• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

DC Comics - Green Lantern Universal Feats Discussion (Continuation)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Emirp sumitpo

VS Battles
Thread Moderator
Messages
25,093
Reaction score
27,267
Continued from here: https://vsbattles.com/threads/dc-comics-the-legendary-dc-heralds-upgrade.147343/

Any derailing will be deleted. You have been warned.

At Firestorm's suggestion, moving the Green Lantern stuff here for cohesion.

3-C​

High 3-A​

Green Lantern

Low 2-C​

Green Lantern

2-C, possibly 2-A​

Hal Jordan
Debunks to the debunks

Next up is Krona scaling. The first thing to note is this refutation:

Krona alone easily stopped all of Hal's willpower, but Hal was able to scratch Krona
Just to keep in mind, at this point, Hal has fought Sinestro, Lobo, Atrocitus, Larfleeze, Predator, and Parallax Flash, with some of these being extended fights where Hal is clearly harmed, so it should be fair to say this isn't Hal at his full power, and this would explain why Hal does so much better later in the arc. As for this:

Krona may have been wearing multiple rings, but the entities are still in the other guardians.
This is quite blatantly not true. We literally see Hal make the plan to contact the entities to remove them from the Guardians, which Hal gets Kyle to do by drawing in Krona's book, with Krona still overriding their usage of the rings. At this point, we see Krona get all the rings, and he seemingly attacks Hal with all the entities on panel. On top of this, the entities are only freed after Hal defeats Krona, so it's pretty clear Krona was still controlling them.

As for Hal being on this level being an Outlier, he harmed Black Lantern Crispus, and normal Crispus has fought the Butcher, a weaker Hal has taken attacks from a possessed GLC power battery, he fought the Predator, multiple GLs fought the Guardians with the Entities, Atrocitus fought the Butcher, Hal survived Krona attacking him with the Entities, etc. It's pretty consistent for them to scale to this level, especially in Geoff John's run.

Now I'll look into two other controversial Hal feats that could be used for this upgrade.

Starting off, we have Hal Jordan knocking off Black Lantern Crispus Allen's jaw in Green Lantern #50. Let's take a look at why this is rejected:

Unknown | Hal escapes (Crispus Allen) Black Lantern Spectre's grasp and knocks out Black Lantern Spectre’s jaw to no effect. Several lanterns attack him to no real effect.
This is kind of hilarious, as obviously it takes lot of power to knock someone's jaw off, and is clearly recoiling as well. Saying that "Lanterns attacked him to no real effect" is also odd, as one of the scans linked has Spectre being stabbed through and yelling. At the very least, Hal does better than the Big Bang level Guardians, who get overpowered pretty quickly and easily. Also, the Lanterns needing Parallax can just be because Crispus was endlessly regenerating, not because he was more powerful than them. Next we have the feat of containing the Universe-threatening U-Bomb in The Green Lantern #6.

High 4-C Contained the U-bomb with the Central Power Battery reserves. "All we know is this -- prior to his disappearance, an energy output was recorded equivalent to ten-to-the-44th-power joules."
The U-Bomb's detonation would cause all matter in the universe to bind to a compressed quark core.
Using the Central Power Battery, Hal stops the detonation, is shot into deep space, and is miniaturized into his ring
Limiting this feat to Large Star level is a bit odd. We know the detonation would've affected all matter in DC's Infinite Universe, so it likely should be a High Universal feat. The recorded output being 10^44 joules doesn't really limit much, as it's phrased as limited information and it's said to be "an energy output" rather than "the energy output", so it could be one of many. And while it is true that Hal used energy from the Central Power Battery, it's unlikely this is much of an amp, considering previously mentioned scaling.

Are all the Green Lanterns together really only Galaxy level? Feat here comes from Green Lantern #25. Let's take a look.

First thing to look into is the statement for it being Galactic. This is legit, but it's really questionable if this is the maximum range of it, or at least the maximum potency. Let's take a similar example with Monarch, after Superboy Prime breaches his armor, a Universe destroying explosion comes out, and knocks out the 2-C, possibly 2-A Prime. The wiki reasonably treats this as a 2-C, possibly 2-A feat on Atom's page, showing the Wiki excepts the idea of explosions like these having potency greater than their range. Not only this, but something that envelops the Universe would also cover the Milky Way Galaxy, so while nothing states this to be higher, there's no real reason to say this is the limit to it either.

On top of this, let's look into the Lanterns involved. While there's a lot of big names there, Hal and Kyle are off fighting Sinestro, so it's not like literally every Lantern was there. Not to mention, they're literally in the middle of a war against the Sinestro Corps. Hal and Kyle even approach 0% energy, and the Lanterns that contain it are all seemingly scratched up. On top of this, many of the Green Lanterns still had energy left and continued to fight Prime, so they clearly didn't use all of their energy to do this.

In conclusion, nothing actually caps the bomb at Galaxy level. Its range is never limited, and even if it was only Galactic, its potency could be higher. It's also important to take into consideration the state of the Lanterns performing this feat, as many of them were at low levels, or would at least want to conserve energy, which would be a good reason to have as many contribute as possible. Even with this, some big names like Hal and Kyle were absent from this, and many of the ones who were didn't exhaust all their energy.
 
Last edited:
Aren't you going to add the other GL stuff that you left in separate feat tabs?
 
Aren't you going to add the other GL stuff that you left in separate feat tabs?
I'm pretty sure this is everything GL related? I put tabs in the other posts because it would be too long otherwise.
 
I assumed that you wanted us to read and respond to those paragraphs you wrote.
 
Krona may have been wearing multiple rings, but the entities are still in the other guardians.
This is quite blatantly not true. We literally see Hal make the plan to contact the entities to remove them from the Guardians, which Hal gets Kyle to do by drawing in Krona's book, with Krona still overriding their usage of the rings. At this point, we see Krona get all the rings, and he seemingly attacks Hal with all the entities on panel. On top of this, the entities are only freed after Hal defeats Krona, so it's pretty clear Krona was still controlling them.
Green Lantern Vol 4 #67

I do not see the Entities that possessed the Guardians all attacking Hal. From the comic panel, we only see Krona use the different colored rings to attack Hal.

When Hal blasted Krona through the chest, the Entities were not inside of Krona, they were still inside the Guardians.
 
I do not see the Entities that possessed the Guardians all attacking Hal. From the comic panel, we only see Krona use the different colored rings to attack Hal.

When Hal blasted Krona through the chest, the Entities were not inside of Krona, they were still inside the Guardians.
We covered in the debunk post above.

We literally see Hal make the plan to contact the entities to remove them from the Guardians, which Hal gets Kyle to do by drawing in Krona's book, with Krona still overriding their usage of the rings. At this point, we see Krona get all the rings, and he seemingly attacks Hal with all the entities on panel. On top of this, the entities are only freed after Hal defeats Krona, so it's pretty clear Krona was still controlling them.
 
Are you just proposing scaling Hal to Krona from the Krona VS Hal fight? If so, that is working on the GotU At least 4-B scaling chain.
That's not we're saying. Krona had control over the entities in his fight against Hal, the entities are 2-C, possibly 2-A, and Hal was able to defeat him. Thus Hal scaling.
 
That's not we're saying. Krona had control over the entities in his fight against Hal, the entities are 2-C, possibly 2-A, and Hal was able to defeat him. Thus Hal scaling.
So you are saying that attacking Krona is equivalent to attacking the Entities who are not nearby and on his literal leashes? Attacking the Beast Tamer being equal to attacking the Beast.

Do we have justification that Krona's control over the entities grants him their AP and Durability independently?
 
...

Ain't most of the current profiles dogshit?
The point of the thread is to determine the validity of feats to which the characters scale and their respective chains. Whether the current profiles need to be revised is to be determined.
 
Okay so why bring up 4-B?
Because that's the current rating of Guardians, which hasn't been changed. This is all a process.

If Character B is currently Tier 4, there isn't an issue with saying that Character A can scale to Character B.

Before you can say Character A scales to Tier 2 through Character B, you need to finalize that Character B is Tier 2 first.
 
So you are saying that attacking Krona is equivalent to attacking the Entities who are not nearby and on his literal leashes? Attacking the Beast Tamer being equal to attacking the Beast.

Do we have justification that Krona's control over the entities grants him their AP and Durability independently?
In Green Lantern #60, Krona is shown to have control of all entities and even forcefully pulls them out like a leash here and here. Krona also explains how this works further in Green Lantern #62, stating that by controlling Ion, he controls all willpower. Sinestro also states in Green Lantern #63 that Krona had complete control over the entities. We also see in Green Lantern #64 that Krona could seemingly restrain all Entities. And in another example, in Green Lantern Emerald Warriors #8, to show Krona's control of the entities, he could use Parallax's abilities to corrupt the corps.

And we know that in order to forcefully control the entities, you'd need to have at least comparable AP as shown as how Atrocitus could make Butcher submit to him, or how Sinestro was able to tame Parallax and make it submit to him completely.
 
In Green Lantern #60, Krona is shown to have control of all entities and even forcefully pulls them out like a leash here and here. Krona also explains how this works further in Green Lantern #62, stating that by controlling Ion, he controls all willpower. Sinestro also states in Green Lantern #63 that Krona had complete control over the entities. We also see in Green Lantern #64 that Krona could seemingly restrain all Entities. And in another example, in Green Lantern Emerald Warriors #8, to show Krona's control of the entities, he could use Parallax's abilities to corrupt the corps.

And we know that in order to forcefully control the entities, you'd need to have at least comparable AP as shown as how Atrocitus could make Butcher submit to him, or how Sinestro was able to tame Parallax and make it submit to him completely.
To clarify, the proposed scaling here relies less upon Krona getting power from the entities, but that Krona was already as powerful as the entities to begin with.
 
To clarify, the proposed scaling here relies less upon Krona getting power from the entities, but that Krona was already as powerful as the entities to begin with.
I mean, yeah. He kind of needs to be around the level or superior to the entities in order to forcefully control them.
 
I mean, yeah. He kind of needs to be around the level or superior to the entities in order to forcefully control them.
In hindsight, you could have used the currently agreed Atrocitus rating to justify the scaling chain and made it easier to follow.

Atrocitus Tier 2 Peak (Via Butcher Encounter) < Krona (Feels pain from Atrocitus' Napalm breath and bite to his neck) < Peak Hal (Blew through Krona's chest)

I have no issues with this chain.
 
To clarify, are we separating the peaks of high-tier lanterns from low-tier lanterns? I don't think we can say everyone can reach Atrocitus/Hal level.
 
To clarify, are we separating the peaks of high-tier lanterns from low-tier lanterns? I don't think we can say everyone can reach Atrocitus/Hal level.
Definitely not all Lanterns are Hal level. Fodder Lanterns would remain in the 5-C to 5-A ranges.

Only the main dudes like Hal, Kyle and John scale to Tier 2
 
Regarding the universe inside the ring, it's a micro-verse as reverse miniaturization is used to get people out of it, so I don't think this qualifies as Tier 3.
-The Green Lantern Vol 1 #7 July 2019
 
Regarding the universe inside the ring, it's a micro-verse as reverse miniaturization is used to get people out of it, so I don't think this qualifies as Tier 3.
-The Green Lantern Vol 1 #7 July 2019
Hm. Fair point I suppose. Though I'll wait what other think.

What are your opinions on the other feats?
 
What are your opinions on the other feats?
I'll probably have more time to go over things tomorrow.

Regarding Black Lantern Crispus Allen, you probably could insert the Atrocitus scaling chain there too. It was a year before his Butcher incident, but it might count as something. He wasn't doing much against the BL CA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top