- 5
- 0
Here is the calc for those that are wondering
This exact calculation was accepted here before at 1.2 Teratons, then it was shown that he used the wrong height on the graph and it was increased to around 1.2 Petatons. It was accepted on the OBD, but wasn't accepted here. The main argument If I remeber correctly was that it was an outlier. I am trying to show why it wasn't an outlier.
My first point: Sengoku's statement
-Sengoku is an extremely intelligent man and was alive when Whitebeard was fighting in his Prime. Why would he give an account to Whitebeard's power if it were untrue? Sengoku clearly states that WB has the power to destroy the world. Now, I'm not suggesting that Prime WB should be upgraded to Planet Level, but this should be a solid testament to the actual energy yields that WB's attacks carry.
My Second Point: Why the Damage didn't reflect the Energy
-Real Earthquakes obviously don't do as much damage as the energy they produce. Stronger Earthquakes can barely topple buildings, yet there energy yields are much higher than buidling level. The Gura Gura No Mi literally concentrates the power of an earthquake into WB's attacks. WB must concentrate the power of his tremors, otherwise Marineford would've been obliterated. WB has had the fruit for likely 20+ years, and it would be ludicrous to assume he can't control his quakes. The point is the Hypocenter of a real quake experiences a vastly greater amount of energy transfer than is what is what actually experienced here on earth. Just like the actual energy in WB's quakes is much greater than the Environmental damage they produce. The point is, the initial energies of WB attacks where potent enough to cause level 4.5 damage tremors thousands of kMs away. The formula he uses takes this into account as this means the energy of the mechanical tremor waves is quite high. For Waves to have enough energy to be able to cause level 4.5 damage earthquakes on the richter scale, the initial surge of energy had to be massive. It was just heavily concentrated. Also, why wouldn't WB concentrate his attacks? it is alot more efficient, especially when all of your allies on the same island you're on.
My Third Point: Why it isnt an Outlier
-Every feat thus far in the series performed by a Top Tier has been relatively cdasual. Every feat by a Top Tier besides this one has been Island Level, yes, I grant you this. But I'd be remiss to not mention that all of those feats were father casual. Also, WB is the strongest attacks in the series, and he stated to have the power to destroy the world, so I don't see why it is an outlier. Also Small Country (what WB was listed at before) to Country+ isn't that crazy of a jump, especially for the strongest characters in the series. Characters in Naruto jumped from like Island level to Multi Continent level in like 1 or 2 arcs.
Tell me what you guys think.
This exact calculation was accepted here before at 1.2 Teratons, then it was shown that he used the wrong height on the graph and it was increased to around 1.2 Petatons. It was accepted on the OBD, but wasn't accepted here. The main argument If I remeber correctly was that it was an outlier. I am trying to show why it wasn't an outlier.
My first point: Sengoku's statement
-Sengoku is an extremely intelligent man and was alive when Whitebeard was fighting in his Prime. Why would he give an account to Whitebeard's power if it were untrue? Sengoku clearly states that WB has the power to destroy the world. Now, I'm not suggesting that Prime WB should be upgraded to Planet Level, but this should be a solid testament to the actual energy yields that WB's attacks carry.
My Second Point: Why the Damage didn't reflect the Energy
-Real Earthquakes obviously don't do as much damage as the energy they produce. Stronger Earthquakes can barely topple buildings, yet there energy yields are much higher than buidling level. The Gura Gura No Mi literally concentrates the power of an earthquake into WB's attacks. WB must concentrate the power of his tremors, otherwise Marineford would've been obliterated. WB has had the fruit for likely 20+ years, and it would be ludicrous to assume he can't control his quakes. The point is the Hypocenter of a real quake experiences a vastly greater amount of energy transfer than is what is what actually experienced here on earth. Just like the actual energy in WB's quakes is much greater than the Environmental damage they produce. The point is, the initial energies of WB attacks where potent enough to cause level 4.5 damage tremors thousands of kMs away. The formula he uses takes this into account as this means the energy of the mechanical tremor waves is quite high. For Waves to have enough energy to be able to cause level 4.5 damage earthquakes on the richter scale, the initial surge of energy had to be massive. It was just heavily concentrated. Also, why wouldn't WB concentrate his attacks? it is alot more efficient, especially when all of your allies on the same island you're on.
My Third Point: Why it isnt an Outlier
-Every feat thus far in the series performed by a Top Tier has been relatively cdasual. Every feat by a Top Tier besides this one has been Island Level, yes, I grant you this. But I'd be remiss to not mention that all of those feats were father casual. Also, WB is the strongest attacks in the series, and he stated to have the power to destroy the world, so I don't see why it is an outlier. Also Small Country (what WB was listed at before) to Country+ isn't that crazy of a jump, especially for the strongest characters in the series. Characters in Naruto jumped from like Island level to Multi Continent level in like 1 or 2 arcs.
Tell me what you guys think.
