- 4,735
- 4,307
Yeah thats because they completely match them/pass the requirements.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Chainsaw Man discussion thread
- Thread starter Rez
- Start date
- 814
- 786
- 4,735
- 4,307
I'm pretty sure even the one's Saphire mentioned are enough regardless.
- 814
- 786
As stated in the post:
Couldn't elaborate more since I'm at work rn
So yeah, being in the production team & author opinion (such as Oda examples in the post) are not enough, you need explicit quotes of that being part of the Manga timeline, or at least, being an discarded idea from the first release (this being along with to that specific scene instead the whole Anime)
Couldn't elaborate more since I'm at work rn
- 4,735
- 4,307
The Oda example was bare minimum supervision. That is not the same as Fujimotos involvement.
Movie cannonocity sounding way more prominent though
- 814
- 786
Yeah and none of these examples have a explicit confirmation of being part of the original continuity. Y'all should look for that, unless it's in the blog which I did not see atm.
- 4,735
- 4,307
I believe that the blog does tackle that, you can skim through it and see for yourself when you find some time.
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 13,595
- 6,650
Actually Chariot worked on this, right? He did say the canon blog wasn't enough
- 4,735
- 4,307
No he didn't, and I doubt he actually read through the blog considering how much he was discrediting it.
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 13,595
- 6,650
- 814
- 786
If you mean the general canon CRT, as said in the JJK thread, yeah, he did work on this.
If you mean something about Chainsaw Man idk I'm not active on this verse
- 4,735
- 4,307
I thought you were mentioning CSM canon thread involvement. That was solely a CowHeadGod project.
- 19,727
- 21,178
I didn't write any of it as it exists currently
Did and did.
Just because people don't agree with you doesn't mean they "didn't read it". If anything it's exactly that type of thinking that gets you stuck in a rut and causes issues on your own end if you don't take the issues at hand at face value when pointed out.
Also who said this was about CSM? Don't be presumptuous; whether or not it effects CSM is besides the point, the bigger concern is it's gotten out of hand in general and actual ground rules need to be placed to avoid extrapolation or faulty usage.
- 4,735
- 4,307
I assumed you did not properly read through it due to your vague and discrediting input on it. That is what I took from your sentiment, not me being upset with you because we did not come to an agreement, so do not get it confused. And regarding the premise of the thread in general, I would actually come into agreement with you based on my own beliefs that align with what was mentioned in that thread.
- 19,727
- 21,178
Don't assume anything, especially when I literally said I read it anyway even then?
Like think for a second, why would I derail a completely unrelated thread by systematic pruning of every single quote in a blog? You're evidently talking about the Link match right? Why in the world would I write a 100000 byte explanation for that when it ultimately wasn't topical and needed a CRT of it's own, which I said we'd do later?
You can deal with it when the time comes, don't assume people didn't read through a mixmatch of disconnected lines tho just because they didn't decide to give you a wall of text explaining why each one is suspect in a vs match of all things.
- 1,993
- 1,202
what did I stumble upon
- 4,735
- 4,307
I like to assume, that is a preference, but I guess in this scenario I should have taken you more literally. I do not believe you would purposely derail something without proper cause. Apologies.
Saqphire
She/Her- 1,573
- 1,884
Considering the thread starter conceded that an extensive supervision is sufficient, yes it does. Also, the blog even adds further on it, it's advised to read something before discrediting it
- 19,727
- 21,178
Damn ya'll really can't go 5 seconds without yapping about people "discrediting it, they mustve not read it", as if people can just think it isn't good enough.
- 13,530
- 10,269
Anybody have an interest in this, I need some debatingPEOPLE, I HAVE MADE A REZE MATCH!
To Disarm a Bomb | Beyond the Grave vs Reze
AAAAYYYYYY I'm back to making matches, time to make one that'll die fast since I love using niche characters.... womp womp CONDITIONS Reze starts in her Hybrid form, scaling to [9.14 Tons of TNT] Beyond the Grave scales to [2.8 Tons of TNT] (I think? I cant check the comments on fandom)...vsbattles.com
Saqphire
She/Her- 1,573
- 1,884
Seeing as he was only referring to my examples in the thread and not the blog, that's a valid assumption here lol
- 4,735
- 4,307
Praying that we have stuff for the movie. Even if we don't I hope we can make movie profiles.
- 814
- 786
I explicitly only referencing your examples and lil bro thinks I'm tackling the whole thing
- 814
- 786
And as I said, disagree with those examples meet the new requirements. Not elaborating since I'm busy.
Machmatej
He/Him- 1,642
- 1,583
if we need to make an anime/movie profile for the verse, we're so fried
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 13,595
- 6,650
There's definitely not enough stuff that's different for a movie profile.
So if it ain't canon, it can't get anything.
- 19,727
- 21,178
Stop assuming. Obviously people are going to read the blog if topical, but they don't need to break down EVERY blog example to comment on the examples posted in a specific context.
That shit be like pointing out a flawed calc and then acting because they didn't comment on these 30 other calcs they must not know they exist.
If something has enough differences, you can make sep profiles for anything, see DBZ with Toei. That isn't a new rule fyi, the only caveat is there has to be enough different to warrant a new profile, stats being diff isn't enough, you'd need at least a few notable additions, or in some cases, removals even to justify its existence.
Edit: For example; a anime DIO profile might have enough to warrant its existence (different stats, ranges, abilities function differently like he has dust lv regen, has new abilities that are anime only like being able to turn into shadows and darkness, teleportation, etc), he has not just diff stats, but diff abilities too that are notable enough, and it's not one or two abilities either it's a handful. But someone like uh, literally every single other character in the JoJo anime, doesn't have remotely enough, they might have slightly diff stats, or maybe one extra ability, that shit isn't enough to justify a profile for Anime Jotaro for example.
- 4,735
- 4,307
I'm the scaling guy @CowHeadGod save us
- 1,020
- 574
All that does is serve as a support statement for Rel feats, nothing special
- 14,878
- 16,613
You're a fool. The kanji means "near light speed", the standard is to assume 75%. Just check tatsumaki profile
- 1,020
- 574
- 21,511
- 36,033
Bad for them because it only scales to dabora and a modern day maho post adaptation, they specifcally that no human could achieve his speed and that its unprecedented in history
They also hard cap and say SoL physicals is impossible
Its actually the anti-Gojo and Sukuna Rel statement
- 14,878
- 16,613
I was arguing that on the general discussion, until I saw that the kanji means "near light speed". The current value for rela is 20%, which is 5x slower, so idk
Dabura without amps was also keeping up with Maho who was dodging his light CT, which would give 2 to 5% SoL, so again, idk
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 13,595
- 6,650
We all know Yuji's coming in eventually so
- 21,511
- 36,033
Near light speed irl is anything 10% SoL or higher but moreso basically anything with a "c" so I mean any of it works but yeah basically just nukes that for Sukuna and Gojo regardless
- 14,878
- 16,613
We are changing things only for JJK. OPM have been using near SoL statement as 75% for over 5 years lmfao I'm crying
Similar threads
