Can I add this verse on the wiki?

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Recently a friend recommended the Blue and White Series, which is a series of web novels. I personally want to add it to the wiki but I was doubting whether or not it would be allowed due to how many things from other media pop up in it. The series itself is plenty popular enough with its ebooks millions of listens, its own devoted forum with thousands of people, hundreds of reviews, and its own comic of the third novel in the series and it is not listed under the fanfiction section in Qidian or anything like that.

The issue is that the first book focuses on an MC that randomly transforms into different media characters, like one time he turned into a character from LoL, another a character from Pokemon, and even Sun Wukong. The world itself is not based on any media I'm aware of and the story is originally by the Author though it does have clear inspiration from things like SCP and StarCraft.

Anyway just wanted to know if the series would be allowed since I've already been putting in time making the profiles.

 

[ImmortalDread]

Do you have any sandbox for that? Also, I think it meet our requirements. I am unsure, let's ask Agnaa

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Do you have any sandbox for that? Also, I think it meet our requirements. I am unsure, let's ask Agnaa

I have the sandbox profile saved on my PC but it's being fixed at a shop atm so I've just been collecting feats via gyazo.

 

[ImmortalDread]

I have the sandbox profile saved on my PC but it's being fixed at a shop atm so I've just been collecting feats via gyazo.

Oh alright!

 

[Delta333]

Fyi this series is kinda high into tier 0

 

[ImmortalDread]

Fyi this series is kinda high into tier 0

bro it meet every requirement

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Fyi this series is kinda high into tier 0

My friend told me it does get pretty ridiculous but I didnt know it got that crazy.

 

[Cat275]

Wow tier 0.

 

[Delta333]

My friend told me it does get pretty ridiculous but I didnt know it got that crazy.

Tho the biggest cosmology of this author is from the book called 脑洞大爆炸 (don't know wtf is it in English), the blue and white series alone is prolly just around 1-A+ or lower

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Tho the biggest cosmology of this author is from the book called 脑洞大爆炸 (don't know wtf is it in English), the blue and white series alone is prolly just around 1-A+ or lower

Ya, I think there are four novels atm and one more is being written.

 

[Andika_CL_atmadja]

Recently a friend recommended the Blue and White Series, which is a series of web novels. I personally want to add it to the wiki but I was doubting whether or not it would be allowed due to how many things from other media pop up in it. The series itself is plenty popular enough with its ebooks millions of listens, its own devoted forum with thousands of people, hundreds of reviews, and its own comic of the third novel in the series and it is not listed under the fanfiction section in Qidian or anything like that.

The issue is that the first book focuses on an MC that randomly transforms into different media characters, like one time he turned into a character from LoL, another a character from Pokemon, and even Sun Wukong. The world itself is not based on any media I'm aware of and the story is originally by the Author though it does have clear inspiration from things like SCP and StarCraft.

Anyway just wanted to know if the series would be allowed since I've already been putting in time making the profiles.

Can you add some link or picture for proof of popularity ?

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Can you add some link or picture for proof of popularity ?

4.35 Million overall listeners, 2 Million individual listeners on certain chapters, 100k collections on one of the novels in the series, and an active forum with 1k+ users and 5k+ posts.

 

[ImmortalDread]

I think it meets our reqs.

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Oh and the comic has 900k+ views though in all honesty its pretty bad and webnovel inflates views.

 

[Andika_CL_atmadja]

4.35 Million overall listeners, 2 Million individual listeners on certain chapters, 100k collections on one of the novels in the series, and an active forum with 1k+ users and 5k+ posts.

Ok this looks good. if you want to make CRT, I think would be good to include those link in your CRT.

 

[Mariogoods]

Personally, I'm neutral in this, but I'll address two things regarding this verse.

Appearance of copyrighted characters is likely a disqualification point. It should be noted that copyright law in the origin region of this webnovel is less harsh than those in the United States, but it is still a thing. A further analysis is needed.

Also, the characters (Sun Wukong, a Pokemon character, a LoL character) should never be scaled to their original appearance counterpart.

Finally, everything which touch the Tier 1 realm should be discussed and approved by admin especially when dealing with non-English works, I suppose.

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Personally, I'm neutral in this, but I'll address two things regarding this verse.

Appearance of copyrighted characters is likely a disqualification point. It should be noted that copyright law in the origin region of this webnovel is less harsh than those in the United States, but it is still a thing. A further analysis is needed.

Not sure if this would help but all of the novels are serialized under Qidian and listed and one is listed to be under CC BY-SA 3.0.

 

[Rabbit2002]

Can it beat SCP and SRE

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

Can it beat SCP and SRE

It can likely measure up to SCP by the first three novels. The remaining two will likely just be icing on the cake.

 

[ImmortalDread]

Dang, @ActuallySpaceMan do you have any sandbox for the verse?

 

[Delta333]

That Rabbit dude has alreay been told most of everything about this series lol

 

[ImmortalDread]

That Rabbit dude has alreay been told most of everything about this series lol

the reqs still meet huh? Did you not see the proof of popurality?

 

[Arceus0x]

scoob and shag has been rejected before so this is probably gonna get disqualified as well. If the transformation was, let's say, based on an SCP that is acknowledged in the lore of the verse then maybe it would be ok but considering it is literally transformations into copyrighted characters then no

 

[ImmortalDread]

Not sure if this would help but all of the novels are serialized under Qidian and listed and one is listed to be under CC BY-SA 3.0.

scoob and shag has been rejected before so this is probably gonna get disqualified as well. If the transformation was, let's say, based on an SCP that is acknowledged in the lore of the verse then maybe it would be ok but considering it is literally transformations into copyrighted characters then no

 

[Arceus0x]

this should be brought up to staff then. Also, being copyrighted itself means nothing. I can write a mario x stranger things fanfic on wattpad and i could copyright it as it is an option.

 

[Delta333]

the reqs still meet huh? Did you not see the proof of popurality?

I have no idea if it meets the standard to be indexed or not, I only know it's strong lol, probably like the second strongest chinese novel according to another debating community that I know

 

[ImmortalDread]

this should be brought up to staff then. Also, being copyrighted itself means nothing. I can write a mario x stranger things fanfic on wattpad and i could copyright it as it is an option.

Complicating won't help either, my brother. Also, elaborate on what the issue is. You talked about copyright issue and now you are saying copyrighted means nothing

I have no idea if it meets the standard to be indexed or not, I only know it's strong lol, probably like the second strongest chinese novel according to another debating community that I know

If you are talking about popularity, I think alone the fact it has 5m listeners is insane. (not passive readers, literally listeners)

If the novel itself is made by a battleboarder idk. I doubt any Chinese would know this wiki exists, lol.

 

[Arceus0x]

Complicating won't help either, my brother. Also, elaborate on what the issue is. You talked about copyright issue and now you are saying copyrighted means nothing

copyright means nothing if the work is copyrighted since copyrighting is possible even for fanfics on wattpad. What matters is if its using copyrighted characters since that is copyright infringement. If it was SCP which has a copyright which lets you use SCPs freely as long as you credit it then it might have been ok but if it uses pokemon and such it's probably not good.

 

[Arceus0x]

I doubt any Chinese would know this wiki exists, lol.

knowing this wiki is not important. Battleboarding isn't just vswiki

 

[ImmortalDread]

copyright means nothing if the work is copyrighted since copyrighting is possible even for fanfics on wattpad. What matters is if its using copyrighted characters since that is copyright infringement. If it was SCP which has a copyright which lets you use SCPs freely as long as you credit it then it might have been ok but if it uses pokemon and such it's probably not good.

Would not the novel actually be flagged if it is true?

 

[ImmortalDread]

knowing this wiki is not important. Battleboarding isn't just vswiki

Ya but this is one of the requirements, that the novel has nothing to do with battleboarding which in this case, it does not.

 

[Arceus0x]

Would not the novel actually be flagged if it is true?

idk man, sometimes copyrighters doesn't have time to read an extremely random chinese novel

 

[Arceus0x]

Ya but this is one of the requirements, that the novel has nothing to do with battleboarding which in this case, it does not.

good

 

[ImmortalDread]

idk man, sometimes copyrighters doesn't have time to read an extremely random chinese novel

You got a point, but we are talking about a popular novel series. And they are lowkey doing money.
Yk copyright is not only about protection...

 

[Arceus0x]

You got a point, but we are talking about a popular novel series. And they are lowkey doing money.
Yk copyright is not only about protection...

Scoob and Shag

Scoob and his best pal Shag are up to their usual hi-jinks, but everything is not as it seems in their latest adventure. Scoob and Shag is a parody and the likeness to any trademarked characters are purely for satirical purposes through fair use and has no association to any existing copyrights.

www.webtoons.com

this has 49 mil views and thousands of likes per chapter. It makes money with patreon and i think merch. Wasn't allowed to be added here even if the cartoon characters were renamed.

 

[ImmortalDread]

Scoob and Shag

Scoob and his best pal Shag are up to their usual hi-jinks, but everything is not as it seems in their latest adventure. Scoob and Shag is a parody and the likeness to any trademarked characters are purely for satirical purposes through fair use and has no association to any existing copyrights.

www.webtoons.com

this has 49 mil views and thousands of likes per chapter. It makes money with patreon and i think merch. Wasn't allowed to be added here even if the cartoon characters were renamed.

What was the reason?

 

[Arceus0x]

What was the reason?

staff called it basically fanfiction.

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

copyright means nothing if the work is copyrighted since copyrighting is possible even for fanfics on wattpad. What matters is if its using copyrighted characters since that is copyright infringement. If it was SCP which has a copyright which lets you use SCPs freely as long as you credit it then it might have been ok but if it uses pokemon and such it's probably not good.

I know this is "Whataboutism" but what about all the other verses on the wiki that do the exact same thing?

Animator vs. Animation

For detailed information about this series, visit the Animator vs. Animation Wiki. Animator vs. Animation is a flash video series created by Alan Becker and first released on Newgrounds June 3, 2006, and released on YouTube on May 14, 2007. The series is about an animator named Alan Becker...

vsbattles.fandom.com

This is a prime example as it features Mario, Pokemon, League of Legends, and specifically Minecraft to such a heavy degree it's an intricate part of the story. And the abilities of sed characters are present in the profiles.

 

[Arceus0x]

I know this is "Whataboutism" but what about all the other verses on the wiki that do the exact same thing?

Animator vs. Animation

For detailed information about this series, visit the Animator vs. Animation Wiki. Animator vs. Animation is a flash video series created by Alan Becker and first released on Newgrounds June 3, 2006, and released on YouTube on May 14, 2007. The series is about an animator named Alan Becker...

vsbattles.fandom.com

This is a prime example as it features Mario, Pokemon, League of Legends, and specifically Minecraft to such a heavy degree it's an intricate part of the story. And the abilities of sed characters are present in the profiles.

that verse's existence is hella sus ngl

 

[ImmortalDread]

staff called it basically fanfiction.

Fanfiction? We have a lot of fanfiction here, as @ActuallySpaceMan mentioned above

I know this is "Whataboutism" but what about all the other verses on the wiki that do the exact same thing?

Animator vs. Animation

For detailed information about this series, visit the Animator vs. Animation Wiki. Animator vs. Animation is a flash video series created by Alan Becker and first released on Newgrounds June 3, 2006, and released on YouTube on May 14, 2007. The series is about an animator named Alan Becker...

vsbattles.fandom.com

This is a prime example as it features Mario, Pokemon, League of Legends, and specifically Minecraft to such a heavy degree it's an intricate part of the story. And the abilities of sed characters are present in the profiles.

Imao, I used to watch it, and it was really entertaining, but I never knew it is listed in vsbattle. Let me check.