Here are more:
If we assume thier Super states are relative to each other, then the superiority of Amy's base aresenal should carry over to the fight between thier Super forms, viving her the win. Problem is, I see no reason to assume thier Super states are equal. Blaze is the only one who tapped into the full power of the emeralds. Amy hypothetically could, but she never has.
She only rivaled Sonic back in the Rush games. Sonic was far weaker back than in Frontiers, Murder Of Sonic The Hedgehog, and Dream Team. Amy is equal to Sonic in all of these games and contributed to the squad's victory against the Badnik train more heavily than Blaze did.
I’d hardly call Amy equal to Sonic. She did help in those games, but she doesn’t show many feats and in the case of Frontiers and Dream Team it’s iffy how much she even did canonically. Blaze should be a rival to Sonic even now given she’s the alternate dimension counterpart of him and her super form was the closest match to Super Sonic iirc. It’s just that she’s used less so we can’t really confirm her skill.
She lost in Heroes though (I think, the cutscenes make it hard to tell), and I feel like the only people really equal to Sonic in Battle are Emerl and Shadow. Amy was beaten by Emerl and Rouge who isn’t on his level, so I still don’t think she’s that skilled overall. It seems like this goes to super forms in which case Blaze edges out.
I’d assume since it’s iffy if Super Amy is even canon that we can say she’s less skilled with the form’s power than Blaze. And she has no Chaos Control which further proves that.
Indeed. If we assume Super Amy and Burning Blaze can tap into the same level of power just as easily as one another, Amy wins in much of the same way she wins in a base fight, but with more difficulty. If not, Blaze blitzes and one shots. Should we assume that? In my opinion, no, but I don't think that opinion is unanymous around here.
We don't have much to go off of other than direct showings with thier Super forms, (of which Amy has none). Especially since Sonic can make better use of his Super form than Shadow can despite the latter's superior affinity for Chaos energy.
Yeah, but this is really bringing to my attention how ambigious this is, and I hate how this has to be a stomp when we could've had a far more interesting match by keeping them in thier base forms and maybe just restricting some equipment in fairness to Blaze, who has been in way fewer games.
