Asta vs Reinhard

[Sonicflare9]

Asta (Pre-Timeskip)

Asta (アスタ, Asuta?) was left at an orphanage as an infant on the outskirts of the Clover Kingdom alongside another baby named Yuno. Excitable and outgoing, he dreams of becoming the Magic Emperor, the greatest mage in the kingdom. However, Asta is one of the rare few, if not the only one to be...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Reinhard van Astrea

Reinhard van Astrea (ラインハルト・ヴァン・アストレア, Rainharuto van Asutorea?) is the current Sword Saint (剣聖, Kensei?) and a member of the Lugunican Royal Guard, currently acting as Felt's knight, supporting her in her bid to become the 42nd king of the Dragon Kingdom of Lugunica. He is not only the...

vsbattles.fandom.com

speed equalized

royal knights arc asta

whooooooooooooooo would win

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Both have analytical prediction and instinctive reaction so that cancels out, however Reinhard has reactive evolution which makes him react to any attack he has seen once, with vastly greater speed.

Asta can surpass his limits in battle, however Reinhard will just react at a greater speed, can Asta keep up is the question.

I would argue Reinhard is more skilled as well, so even if Asta could null Reinhard's energy attacks (does he only null magic?), Reinhard could take him in close combat.

Also there is the issue of Reinhard's regen and immortality, don't think Asta can put him down.

Leaning towards Reinhard.

 

[Eganergo]

Does AP matter in this match? Who has the advantage?

 

[Regidian]

Both have analytical prediction and instinctive reaction so that cancels out, however Reinhard has reactive evolution which makes him react to any attack he has seen once, with vastly greater speed.

Asta can surpass his limits in battle, however Reinhard will just react at a greater speed, can Asta keep up is the question.

I would argue Reinhard is more skilled as well, so even if Asta could null Reinhard's energy attacks (does he only null magic?), Reinhard could take him in close combat.

Also there is the issue of Reinhard's regen and immortality, don't think Asta can put him down.

Leaning towards Reinhard.

Reinhard don't have magic apparently so magic null of asta would not help


Reinhardt: “I cannot use any kind of magic, let alone healing magic. It was simply the spirits in the air that came to my aid, hastily healing the wounds on my foot.”

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Asta seems to scale to 197 Megatons, Reinhard is baseline for one shotting ppl very close to 7-A, so doesn't look like much of difference.

I mean bleeding actually makes Reinhard stronger so the gap could be narrowed if there was one, when he gets injured.

 

[Eganergo]

Ok, Golden Beas-- Err... Reinhard FRA.

 

[Epsilon_R]

Asta is 197 Megatons in base and 394 in demon form. But since Reinhard doesn't use magic, Asta doesn't have any advantage. I'm pretty sure Reinhard is more skilled than this version of Asta

 

[Sonicflare9]

should I make it post time skip asta but restrict black form

 

[Epsilon_R]

I mean, it won't really change anything

 

[SatellaTheWoE]

Isnt this a massive stomp in Reinhard favor?

 

[SuperStar]

Necro