All For One VS FFD Shirou Emiya

[Fray100]

@Fray believe me there are pages on this wiki that would have larger P&A sections then yours.

True but I doubt over 600,000 weapons would all fit on one page.

 

[Darkmon_cns]

That's not the point. It's the abilitys of them. concept manplation, fire manplation,poison user. Those should be in the P&A section if he has them.

 

[Fray100]

That's not the point. It's the abilitys of them. concept manplation, fire manplation,poison user. Those should be in the P&A section if he has them.

Agreed but do to how his magic works It all falls under his Pocket Reality Manipulation and Power Mimicry abilitys.

And that's not counting his Time Manipulation or Soul Manipulation either

 

[Darkmon_cns]

....no it doesn't.... if he keeps those powers you'd just put that power there....linking to the power page for said power... no one on the vs wiki ever did that technically one for all is an example of that not happening. All his abilities were gained vai power mimicry and he doesn't just have power mimcry listed NO he has the powers listed.


So no that doesn't get you out of putting the powers in the P&A section...

 

[Fray100]

....no it doesn't.... if he keeps those powers you'd just put that power there....linking to the power page for said power... no one on the vs wiki ever did that technically one for all is an example of that not happening. All his abilities were gained vai power mimicry and he doesn't just have power mimcry listed NO he has the powers listed.

So no that doesn't get you out of putting the powers in the P&A section...

You do know I'm just the host to this Battle right not the original creator of FFD Shirou's page right?

If you want to make a complaint about that page take it up with the Mod @Xmark12 who created it not me.

 

[Darkmon_cns]

Well sorry i was mistaken i thought you made it

 

[Fray100]

Well sorry i was mistaken i thought you made it

No problem

and trust me the other versions of Shirou listed on Vs wiki have the same problem you pointed out see here andhere so no biggy

 

[Fray100]

Bump

Anyone wish to add their perspective on this topic?

 

[Fray100]

Oh great a troll (haven't had to deal with one of those directly before) and thank you @Colonel Krukov for removing it on behalf of everyone on this thread.

 

[Fray100]

Bump

 

[Fray100]

Bump

 

[Fray100]

Bump

any one wish to add to this topic?

 

[DarkNeon1994]

I never watched Fate/stay night anime before, but I will vote Shirou for BlackDarkness679's Reason

 

[Fray100]

2-1-0

I see good to know

Even though I see them being more evenly matched in my books.

 

[BlackDarkness679]

Maybe you,but not everyone,after all its a debate between fictional characters,people might have different opinions

 

[Fray100]

True

Thats why I came up with VS battle in the first place and it's an interesting topic.

 

[Fray100]

Bump

 

[Fray100]

Bump

 

[Drag-O-Drawgon]

Where did you find that one? (Also, I put that on the wiki)

 

[DMUA]

Can he reinforce his body fast enough to not just get vaporized by All For One Airblasting him?

 

[Xmark12]

He usually unconsciously reinforces himself before battles against people anyways because of his training, sooo.

 

[Fray100]

Can he reinforce his body fast enough to not just get vaporized by All For One Airblasting him?

He usually unconsciously reinforces himself before battles against people anyways because of his training, sooo.

what Xmark12 said and on top of that Shirou has a much greater speed and attack range then All for one however All for one has greater durability and Lifting Strength then Shirou does.

As for versatility both are fairly evenly matched if they are being creative with their abilities (...well at least in my books they are)

So what would you two vote on this topic?

 

[Xmark12]

To be honest I'm going for Shirou because of his slightly more versatile attacks (Conceptual weapons, multiplying attacks) and his habit to be more focused on range and strategy than his canon counterpart.

 

[Fray100]

3-1-0

Good to know

However don't forget All for one does have more combat experience then shirou alltho it is somewhat hampered by his sadistic tendencies and habit of trying to mentally break his opponents.

 

[BlackDarkness679]

3-1-0
Good to know

However don't forget All for one does have more combat experience then shirou alltho it is somewhat hampered by his sadistic tendencies and habit of trying to mentally break his opponents.

More combat experience isnt always helping much if the opponent is better in other stuff,so even unexperienced characters can win against one that has years of that,depending of what each of them have

 

[Fray100]

agreed that's why i pointed out the downsides of his personality

 

[Fray100]

bump

 

[Fray100]

Bump

 

[BlackDarkness679]

You can vote on your thread if it takes a while till a match can be concluded, that way you dont have to wait too much and before you say it, yeah you are allowed to vote on your thread

 

[Fray100]

true and Bump

 

[BlackDarkness679]

Then you know you can vote for shirou and that would make it 4-1,after 24 hours you can add the results unless somebody else votes here,if it will ne anpther one for shirou it can be added immediately,you can end this thread now if you vote,its been going for too long now

 

[Fray100]

4-1-0

Vary well and Shirou does have more versatile attacks then All for one

 

[Fray100]

Anyone wish to add to this because if not im going to taley this up by the end of the day.

 

[Xmark12]

Added to Shirou's profile

 

[Fray100]

thank you