2 Creepypasta Classics, Kind Of (Jeff The Killer vs Ticci-Toby) (GRACE)

[ThePrimalHunter]

Spoiler: This is unrelated to the match

How would you guys feel if I made profiles for the shitty creepypasta fanfictions I wrote when I was in middle school? I think it would be funny to put them on the site

Jeff the Killer (Reboot) vs Ticci-Toby

Ground Rules:

• Speed is equal
• Both have their full arsinal
• Fight takes place in a dense forest
• Neither start with line of sight

Who Wins?

Pale Kid: 5 (TheShape03, Tllmbrg, HonestlyBored24, LeoEpicGamer8910, Volt12121)
Skinny Kid: 0 ()
Composite Jeff: 0 ()

 

[TheShape03]

They both have almost the same physical stats, for now I would say Jeff wins due to his martial arts skill.

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

They both have almost the same physical stats, for now I would say Jeff wins due to his martial arts skill.

I'll count this as a vote, but do keep in mind that Toby has FAR better pain tolerance than Jeff, because he litteraly can't feel pain unlike Jeff, who can still get hurt

 

[Volt12121]

Alright so,

Jeff is more than likely physically stronger than Toby, he's actually trained in combat and can keep up with other martial arts users.

Toby has far more reliable weapons especially sense they give him more range than Jeff's knife.

Stealth wise they should be about the same and both have a weakness that could make it difficult to spot the other if they were to stealth, which are Jeff being blind in one eye and Toby suffering from hallucinations.

Toby does have far better pain tolerance seen as how he can't feel it at all, but that can also be a big disadvantage, since he wouldn't feel his body basically giving up on him.

So question being, how frequent and how severe are Toby's hallucinations? Cause the match entirely relies on who gets the first stab in (yes, even if Toby wouldn't feel the pain, the stab would still prove detrimental to his chance of winning as again, he wouldn't be able to feel his body aching in pain) and Toby's hallucinations seem far more detrimental than Jeff being blind in one eye (especially sense Jeff can still fight and operate quite well despite this disability)

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

So question being, how frequent and how severe are Toby's hallucinations? Cause the match entirely relies on who gets the first stab in (yes, even if Toby wouldn't feel the pain, the stab would still prove detrimental to his chance of winning as again, he wouldn't be able to feel his body aching in pain) and Toby's hallucinations seem far more detrimental than Jeff being blind in one eye (especially sense Jeff can still fight and operate quite well despite this disability)

The hallucinations are typically pretty minor, such as hearing a sound or seeing a figure that isn't there, but usually it's nothing more than that. Now, there was the one hallucination session in the therapists office where he couldn't hear or see anything in the real world and saw an army of eyeless children behind slenderman trying to kill him, but that only happened once and isn't frequent at all. And, it was right before he became a proxy so that just might have been the "initiation process" or something

 

[Volt12121]

Then i'm honestly not too sure, Toby does have the better weapon, range and pain tolerance but Jeff does have more experience in actual combat (especially sense he can take people in 3 vs 1)

 

[LeoEpicGamer8910]

How would you guys feel if I made profiles for the shitty creepypasta fanfictions I wrote when I was in middle school? I think it would be funny to put them on the site

Do it

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

Then i'm honestly not too sure, Toby does have the better weapon, range and pain tolerance but Jeff does have more experience in actual combat (especially sense he can take people in 3 vs 1)

Should I count this as an incon as both are pretty much equal?

 

[Volt12121]

Personally yeah incon works

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

Personally yeah incon works

Vote counted

 

[Volt12121]

Do it

Agreed

 

[Tllmbrg]

Alright having read the original Ticci-Toby story I think I'll side with Jeff

We never actually see how he fights with the hatchets in the story, instead we have the fight with his dad where he uses a knife as our only basis. And frankly, that paints a bad picture of this fight since he was struggling against a weaponless dude while he was fully going for the throat.

While I haven't read Jeff 2015 specifically, off the profile he should be way more skilled than Tobey and more experienced in actual fighting.

Jeff also has better stealth feats, and while he has one blind eye he would just have more time to look for Tobey.

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

We never actually see how he fights with the hatchets in the story, instead we have the fight with his dad where he uses a knife as our only basis. And frankly, that paints a bad picture of this fight since he was struggling against a weaponless dude while he was fully going for the throat.

Well, he did manage to kill 4 teenagers, and I wouldn't say Toby struggled in the fight against his dad as Toby had the advantage pretty much the whole time

Vote counted though

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

How would you guys feel if I made profiles for the shitty creepypasta fanfictions I wrote when I was in middle school? I think it would be funny to put them on the site

I re-read some of my older creepypasta stories

1. They're just as bad as I expected lmao

2. I didn't really think of powerscaling at all back then and it shows. The characters are crazy powerful. Jeff and some of the other humans could be 9-A depending on what I get for a calc, which is obsurd considering how canonically Jeff is just a regular dude

 

[Volt12121]

To be fair, Julia is 9-B and she's supposed to be a regular kid in her universe

 

[Tllmbrg]

Well, he did manage to kill 4 teenagers, and I wouldn't say Toby struggled in the fight against his dad as Toby had the advantage pretty much the whole time

We don't really get any details on that, I would more so attribute it him sneaking on them or something
Also maybe struggle is not the best term but his dad managed to grab him several times, and it took a bit of time to put him down for Tobey.
And Jeff as a more experienced fighter who also has weapons on him and can power through pain should just be able to power through Tobey's attacks and face stab him several times imo

 

[HonestlyBored24]

Jeff FRA

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

Jeff FRA

Vote counted

And that's grace

 

[LeoEpicGamer8910]

There has to be at least 3 vote difference for grace.

Jeff FRA

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

There has to be at least 3 vote difference for grace.

Jeff FRA

Thanks for correcting me

NOW grace can start

 

[Volt12121]

Gonna be changing my vote for Jeff fra

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

And that's a clean sweep for Jeff