• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Search results for query: *

  1. Phoenks

    Post your personal Tiering System here

    I'll just post the tiers I would make / change / add. Micro level: 0 Joules to 0.2 Joules (Kinetic energy of an adult mouse moving at maximum speed) - Inserted between 10-C and 11-A. Mountain level Large Mountain level Multi-City level: 50 Megatons (Tsar Bomba) to 5 Gigatons (Small island...
  2. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    Different verses treat quantitative gaps in strength differently. Garou has survived gaps in verse before that by our standards would be like thousands or even millions of times. Being "7x" stronger in certain verses doesn't automatically mean the other person gets stomped. Saitama wasn't...
  3. Phoenks

    Nah it's just infinite cause he isn't flying across time or anything. And higher dimensional...

    Nah it's just infinite cause he isn't flying across time or anything. And higher dimensional travel isn't inherently immeasurable.
    • Phoenks
    • Profile post comment
  4. Phoenks

    Wait what? Idk what you are talking about exactly. Show it

    Wait what? Idk what you are talking about exactly. Show it
    • Phoenks
    • Profile post comment
  5. Phoenks

    Notability Standards for Webnovels/Webcomics

    I disagree. I'll give a quick example of why. If you take a look at a lot of power fantasy ("domination fantasy," where the main point is to have a protagonist who succeeds at becoming strong and basically acting as a stand in for the viewer to feel a sense of accomplishment), there are...
  6. Phoenks

    Notability Standards for Webnovels/Webcomics

    This looks like it should preferably be a staff thread. A lot of things to go over that could significantly alter indexing on the wiki.
  7. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

  8. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    I will no longer comment on this thread. I still stand by what I said, but I urge staff to go over it and make a decision for themselves. After all they are the ones that determine standards. For the record, I don't think the series is unpopular enough. But I do think the other stuff also just...
  9. Phoenks

    Top 15 Strongest Characters for Every Tier

    smurf just means higher-dimensional/higher-reality level stuff relative to your physical existence. Has not much to do with the tier. Even a baseline 1-A with 1 layer 1-A hax is a smurf. Same for a 6-D with 7-D hax. Also, just because this list includes smurfs does not mean it is a...
  10. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    Look, you are continually and purposefully missing the point. It isn't just one thing or one genre about it that it that is bad. It is the entire package put together. The writing quality itself is bad. The content of the writing is bad. The genre is power fantasy (A genre that is...
  11. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    I know the actual definition of power fantasy. I'm using it in the correct manner there, that's why I separated it from power scaling in the first place. I understand there are fans of those kinds of domination fantasy-works. Thing is, power fantasy in of itself is a genre that is 90+% of the...
  12. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    I went back through 20+ chapters and they were literally everything I described in my post. There wasn't a single difference. It was all a bunch of power-scaling slop lol. I don't even think it was a different bad guy. Some "Omnifather" had been going on for all that time. If you want me to...
  13. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    I can forgive genuine Chinese cultivation novels because 1. They are translated (Often with MTL and novice translators). So they often have somewhat an excuse for poor (perceived) writing quality. (They are also leagues better than this work even after translation) 2. The Chinese culture and...
  14. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    I will add that this work seems heavily influenced by power scaling on top of what I would say is objectively bad wrting. This is worse than a lot of the worst stuff that FC/OC gets, by an extremely notable degree, IMO. I recommend that every staff member here just take a glance through some...
  15. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    Even if Gojo manages to hit him 1/100+ times with the Domain, it's a stomp. Because he would have a clear win condition while Mori Dan does not. Reacting =/= outrunning. And, literally since forever? When has anyone ever dodged or even reacted to the expansion of a Domain Expansion? It's...
  16. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    But the only time he gets explicitly "8x" stronger/faster is with the actual stimuli, it would seem. And that's over multiple panels. Gojo could quite easily start with Domain Expansion if he wanted to. And if he doesn't, I still don't think he'd allow him to become that fast. Also, it seems...
  17. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    In those panels Mori Dan was given a stimuli to develop. It's not passive in the way you originally phrased it. Also says through "battle" and "training" on the profile. So I'll assume it works in the same way as most AD: they have to actually be pushed to get significantly stronger. Thing is...
  18. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    How fast is domain expansion treated on VSBW? Also, are you saying he grows several times faster without any challenge? Has that happened? The scan on the profile doesn't really tell me much. RIP
  19. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    Doesn't Gojo just open a Domain and end the fight? Seems like a stomp ngl. Also, Mori doesn't resist being pulled into attacks / Domain Expansion range by "Blue." So he won't just be able to escape everything Gojo does, either.
  20. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    Okay, now could you answer the meat of my post? Also, just so you know, the scan linked in the profile doesn't even say that. Might wanna change that fact.
  21. Phoenks

    Mori Dan vs Satoru Gojo

    I actually disagree with this. The "space bending" property of that kick doesn't even seem genuine. Looks like a visual effect. But sure, I'll give it the benefit of the doubt. Is there any other time that happens? Is it ever use for dura negation or distance negation? If not, then I...
  22. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Going to clarify a few things, because I realized people might not understand the current process. 1. Evaluation is not being done on here anymore. In the beginning of the thread, it was done that way, but we decided to instead bring it onto the Discord for more privacy and less clutter on...
  23. Phoenks

    Yes ...

    Yes ...
    • Phoenks
    • Profile post comment
  24. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    New interface is so mid
  25. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    This is a stretch. It's fast, but blatantly not instantaneous because we see the panels aligned with certain collisions in the fight.
  26. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    Been saying this for a while. Saitama's growth rate is so fast that even with Garou copying him at every punch he's still getting left behind. It's some of the fastest on panel development I've seen.
  27. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    @Antvasima please clarify your stance on notability standards. They are extremely vague. I'm also curious if the actual quality of writing is of any factor.
  28. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    Combining those insane standards with the very questionable writing, it isn't a very good look. And the profile here too is not really that great, if I'm honest. Respect to all the work put into it, and it's definitely salvageable, but there's a lot of missing information / context. Some things...
  29. Phoenks

    Adding Infinite Mana In The Apocalypse To VSBW Part 1

    There are a lot of problems with the profile. High 3-A isn't justified. Infinite speed isn't justified. Extraordinary Genius isn't justified. There are a lot of weird terminologies that aren't explained. Like if ",worlds" mean "galaxies." Since not the page you link to stuff about worlds but...
  30. Phoenks

    Apologies, but this topic in particular annoys the hell out of me. So no.

    Apologies, but this topic in particular annoys the hell out of me. So no.
    • Phoenks
    • Profile post comment
  31. Phoenks

    Arcane Discussion Thread

    Can't wait to see the Viktor profile
  32. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Okay so, for one, if there was only Twitter statements for this stuff, it would've never been accepted on here regardless. That basically just auto-fails the narrative reasoning requirement, because that stuff wasn't even directly involved in the narrative in the first place. As for 2-B /...
  33. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Please just tell me once you have everything. Link it to the blog.
  34. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Since this appears to be an actual game, do you have scans?
  35. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    I don't even know what is Tier 1 about this.
  36. Phoenks

    That's in the requirements to have something accepted. It has nothing to do with that being...

    That's in the requirements to have something accepted. It has nothing to do with that being present on the cosmology blog itself. You must have misunderstood my post.
    • Phoenks
    • Profile post comment
  37. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Narrative importance does not need to be in the cosmology blog. In fact, typically it only serves to make the blog more cluttered and confusing. This is fine since the whole point of our review over discord is to go over the actual reasons this stuff is in the story. Tanz was very willing to...
  38. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    ??? L = Loss. As in, he took a loss.
  39. Phoenks

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    After our review, Tanz's Imaginary Tavern has been accepted. Up to 1-A. Congratulations. I was very shocked by this submission. A completely new user just came in and delivered. Just goes to show this really isn't as hard as people think. Don't be afraid, guys!
  40. Phoenks

    STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

    Forgot. That's another L. Needed help from his Interdimensional friends to hold a single collision between Garou and Saitama.
Back
Top