This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
If you ask me for my full opinion, this isn't even Conceptual Manipulation in the first place. But, ignoring that: Yeah, nothing useful here.
Do you have the scans on you?
You can't do that, sorry. If you did, the subsequent replies you're given would just be ignored.
If it's referring to space and time as a whole and not just the particular spacetime structure of the multiverse, then it would have more merit, yeah. The former rules out the possibility that the...
Yeah, looks fine to me. I assume the "Final Wall" is basically supposed to be the blank page of the novel itself, yes? Given the stuff about it dividing reality and fiction, and "recording" the Oldest Dream's imagination through text. If so, 1-A probably starts with it, yeah, and the Oldest...
How exactly am I contradicting myself? What I said and what I quoted from the BDE page are basically the exact same thing.
And I mean. I won't lie, if this is the same evidence used for 1-C, then I'd say even that is unwarranted. But regardless, the type of "transcendence" required of 1-A is...
A necessary condition, not a sufficient one.
Why would it? The "Concept of time is irrelevant" business is something that has already long been addressed as of no worth, so I'm not sure why it keeps being brought up.
I already said as much:
And from the BDE page:
Point me to the WoG...
I mean, yeah, "The mental notion of time" obviously exists, but that doesn't mean anything for the purposes of scaling a character who is the source of everything.
Makes no difference, really.
I said the exact opposite. A realm being non-physical and also being referred to as "higher" in some way doesn't fit the bill. Why would it?
How exactly would "Is aspatial and atemporal + Big AP feats" help prove 1-A? This is just a non-sequitur.
Depends on the exact content of said WoG.
The...
Not particularly, no.
It's not.
It's really something that you'd only get through statements, the vast majority of the time. If the Chaos Force was described as aspatial, atemporal, etc (Which, come to think of it, there aren't any statements of, from what I see. "Outside time-space" is...
Yeah, fair enough. It seems Odin predating time is something that's acknowledged by the profiles and used as justification for abilities (Type 4 Acausality, in this case), so that ought to be changed if this is true.
What is said non-physical form like, if I may ask?
Depends entirely on what the "superiority" in question consists of. All that's been shown so far only indicates that the Chaos Force is more powerful than everything else in the cosmology, which is a necessary condition for 1-A but obviously not a sufficient one. Largely, being 1-A necessitates...
Type 1 BDE also involves being aspatial and atemporal.
Being a Type 1 Concept can get you to 1-A but doesn't inherently do that, so I'd have to look at the actual evidence to see. The rest is just a long-winded way of saying "The Chaos Force is the highest thing in the cosmology," which doesn't...
Source for that claim.
Positing that Odin and Surt were initially spaceless and timeless and afterwards came to be bound by spacetime is just trying to ad hoc away something that poses a contradiction to your argument, seeing as this, to my knowledge, is never mentioned at all, anywhere.
The...
All it says was that there were "no realms," so, no mention of any aspatial nature. All you have in that regard is Ymir's death being stated to be the beginning of time, and yet the universal scope that you want to assign to this is blatantly undercut by beings who are clearly spatial and...
In those cases, the location is already concretely established to have no space and time, and the characters are traveling there through special means. This case is different because we are still in the process of arguing that a certain thing is aspatial and atemporal, and part of that inference...
That's just a non-sequitur. "Other pieces of information tell us that this plane is above something that's the source of time" doesn't lead to what is being argued in the blog. That's just unrelated information.
The Chaos Force binding everything together only tells us about its causal power...
Your entire argument for the cycle being aspatial and atemporal is that it predated time. The point is that this clearly isn't the case, because spatial and temporal beings existed before the event that supposedly originated time. That alone crumbles the entire point of this thread.
That...
So, I went through the positive justifications in the blog, will go through the preemptive responses to anti-feats later if needed or if I feel like it. But, so far:
Yeah, that doesn't really warrant anything. "Concept," our wiki's weird usage of the term notwithstanding, primarily refers to a...
Pretty interesting case. Honestly, I'd say most of this could be interpreted as Beyond not being a literal author entity per se but moreso a vague cosmic being that's metaphorically referred to as the story's author, but given the explicit reference to the book's title (Jorge Joestar) and...
I don't think that's Low 1-A at all. "Essence" here is very vague and seems to be used in the common everyday sense of "A condensed extract of something," especially given the stuff about Prima Materia being "harvested out" of objects.
1-A is fine, though. Being above spatiotemporal...
Yeah.
You can't really become full-blown Tier 0 in a way where you stand as another entity parallel to the first thing, so, no.
Resurrection that's impossible to nullify, I guess.
I mean, depends. If it's a case of "Ontologically unable to be surpassed by anything other than the Tier 0,"...