-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Reinhard van Astrea Vs. Sasuke Uchiha
- Thread starter YungManzi
- Start date
- 1,690
- 1,327
I don’t see why it wouldn’t, his resistant to mental pollutants and brains washing whereas genjutsu hijacks all your six senses, nervous system, your brain and soul by injecting chakra (soul and mind) into you to show illusions or incap. And it’s layered so even if he resists it doesn’t matter as genjutsu has a higher potency (layers). Rein is not rejecting the mechanics behind genjutsu
Not to mention, Rein resistance is vague while Sasuke genjutsu ranks above the likes of tsykoyomi which creates a pocket dimension (the caster controls all aspects of the dimension like time, matter, substance and vastness) inside the users mind. An example bing that Itachi used tsykoyomi on Izumi, making her live her entire life in a picosecond (not even joking) kill her soul and body in the process
- 1,690
- 1,327
It’s been addressed, in that Rein doesn’t have a planet wide nuke. His range only goes upto thousands of kilometer (on his profile), while his supposed planet nuke (if you can call it that cus the Re0 “planet” is literally flat and not spherical) was dunked due to pucks storm sized being downgraded
- 656
- 111
Thank you
AppleMaker
Username Only- 3,881
- 1,100
Sasuke FRA
- 6,074
- 2,855
Thousands of kilometers is still the radius of the Moon. That's ******* impressive.
- 11,461
- 10,307
Can the guy jump layers in resistance?
Zabazab
Any/All- 6,734
- 10,023
I addressed this here. Layers are merely one means of measuring potency. Reinhard resisted most of the effects of mind/soul hax from an Authority, which functions by bending the rules and concepts of reality, which is why it ignored most resistances. That Authority could completely control people's hearts, their senses, affect people whose awareness were separated from the rest of the world, and even force their body to undergo the same changes as others/the user by linking their souls. It also easily and passively affected over 200,000 people at the same time.
- 6,074
- 2,855
Often, this is a simple formality. There shouldn't be any problems with layering.
- 10,509
- 4,149
yeah Susanoo should block the nuke just like it did the TSOHe blocked the TSO EE with susanoo, so it’s not out side the realm of possibility
- 2,949
- 2,336
Whats the consensus here along with wincons. If any
- 10,509
- 4,149
One side is arguing conceptual based resistance > layers
the other is arguing layers > baseline resistance
some are saying the nuke sword EE should kill sasuke
others are saying Sauce should be able to survive given Susanoo tanked the TSO (it got erased but still saved Naruto)
There is no clear consensus yet
- 10,509
- 4,149
So after reading the thread and the profiles I have to say some things
From what little I know about Re0 Reinhard doesn't open with insta nukes (and the Puck situation was apparently a very dire one), moreover he will likely go close quarters combat with Sasuce.
Sauce for his part is kinda the same but he is more likely to open with genjutsu (something he has a done a lot iirc) but could also go for a fight.
In a fight Sasuke is around at least 3 times weaker so while it will be hard to keep up it won't be the first time he does fight someone magnitudes of times stronger (granted he had a lot of help)
The problem is mostly the hax and the inability to kill Reinhard.
The EE nuke is a wincon if it catches Sasuke outside of the Susanoo which I don't think is likely because he will definitely will be using it to bridge the AP gap so at worst the Susanoo gets EE'd and Sauce summons it again.
The whole debate about numbers, potency and all that is not to my taste since numbers is just range imo. If you can mind hax everyone in a 10km radius it doesn't matter the amount of people someone drops there as they all are within the range of effect.
What matters is if they can focus all that power to **** someone up which is something genjutsu can do iirc.
In this case Reinhard has resistance to mental stuff on that comes from a law/concept but its something that will be overcome if he stays within its effects long enough.
Sasuke for his part scales to 3 or 5 layers of mental stuff depending what you look at in the blog.
idk it could be 50/50, not so sure how we determine this
ON THE OTHER HAND
Sharingan Genjutsu does more than just mind manip, it can do illusions, paralysis and put people to sleep, things that Reinhard's resistance is mid from what I see.
So my take is this.
If the fight drags on (which it will lets be honest) Sasuke will go through his repertoire of powers which includes the aforementioned wincons and he will win but if he tires enough then the EE nuke will eventually catch him and Reinhard will both AP/haxslop win.
So it honestly depends on who reaches the wincon first.
Put me in for incon.
From what little I know about Re0 Reinhard doesn't open with insta nukes (and the Puck situation was apparently a very dire one), moreover he will likely go close quarters combat with Sasuce.
Sauce for his part is kinda the same but he is more likely to open with genjutsu (something he has a done a lot iirc) but could also go for a fight.
In a fight Sasuke is around at least 3 times weaker so while it will be hard to keep up it won't be the first time he does fight someone magnitudes of times stronger (granted he had a lot of help)
The problem is mostly the hax and the inability to kill Reinhard.
The EE nuke is a wincon if it catches Sasuke outside of the Susanoo which I don't think is likely because he will definitely will be using it to bridge the AP gap so at worst the Susanoo gets EE'd and Sauce summons it again.
The whole debate about numbers, potency and all that is not to my taste since numbers is just range imo. If you can mind hax everyone in a 10km radius it doesn't matter the amount of people someone drops there as they all are within the range of effect.
What matters is if they can focus all that power to **** someone up which is something genjutsu can do iirc.
In this case Reinhard has resistance to mental stuff on that comes from a law/concept but its something that will be overcome if he stays within its effects long enough.
Sasuke for his part scales to 3 or 5 layers of mental stuff depending what you look at in the blog.
idk it could be 50/50, not so sure how we determine this
ON THE OTHER HAND
Sharingan Genjutsu does more than just mind manip, it can do illusions, paralysis and put people to sleep, things that Reinhard's resistance is mid from what I see.
So my take is this.
If the fight drags on (which it will lets be honest) Sasuke will go through his repertoire of powers which includes the aforementioned wincons and he will win but if he tires enough then the EE nuke will eventually catch him and Reinhard will both AP/haxslop win.
So it honestly depends on who reaches the wincon first.
Put me in for incon.
- 6,074
- 2,855
From what I read in his profile, Reinhard has a sixth sense that allows him to recognize impending danger, and his RE and adaptation allow him to get out of any situation. Also, if we compare the verses, then using information analysis, Reinhard learns about all of Sasuke's techniques.
- 5,440
- 2,778
Sasuke couldn't kill Reinhard due to Low-Godly regen, layers of genjutsu is useless against law/concept mind resistance-based and Reinhard has several ways to kill or harm Sasuke, plus he's a Extraordinary Genius in combat.
This is stomp.
This is stomp.
- 11,461
- 10,307
nah not a stomp
- 6,074
- 2,855
Go Reinhard vs Deku
- 5,440
- 2,778
Sasuke has no ways to kill or incap Reinhard.
- 11,461
- 10,307
Reinhard boutta get knocked out Garou style
- 11,461
- 10,307
I can't make this shit up, Reinhard has a loss on his profile for being knocked out.
- 6,074
- 2,855
That Garou thread was bullshit.
- 5,440
- 2,778
Wait Reinhard's profile have a loss to Sanji in cooking competition LMFAO
Testarossa002
Username Only- 2,794
- 3,450
Speed should be unequal; they're practically the same value
Anyway, from the profiles, RvA's EE slash speed is FTL
From 4km away, Sasuke, who has FTL shunshin, can just dodge. Unless the EE is like an explosion, unlike what the scan on RvA's stuff depicts.
Genjutsu GG
The only thing here that genjutsu straight up can't do is the transmutation/curse manip. Which has no bearing on the potency of a mind-hax ability. It's like using the genjutsu's ability to astra project as evidence of superiority against someone with resistance to mind hax
Kabuto no diffed an entire stadium with genjutsu that's generally considered inferior to ocular genjutsu
Also, it's not like RvA no diffed the ability.
- 6,148
- 4,679
It is...
- 5,440
- 2,778
Reinhard resists.
Testarossa002
Username Only- 2,794
- 3,450
not at the initial stage going by what's on the profile
It kept going in a straight line until it hit something
Sasuke dodges
if you ignore everything i said and what i responded to, yeah he does
- 6,148
- 4,679
Keyword "initial stage"
and what's Sasuke gonna do once that initial stage is over?
- 5,440
- 2,778
Ok so what you said about Reinhard's resistance to Illusion?
- 13,308
- 13,971
Disagree on Reinhard resisting Genjutsu.
Layers > Number of People Affected.
Also, the source of the Sirius' Authority is Concept Manipulation/Law Manipulation, but it is unable to affect spiritual/mental concepts. Mind/Soul in Re: Zero are not conceptual objects. If they were, then the argument that Sirius' authority would overpower layers would make more sense, but just having conceptual manipulation as the source of the ability is not really much of a factor.
Like, if I can use my concept manipulation to do what is otherwise basic mind manipulation, that is not really any more potent than said basic mind manipulation. But if the mind manipulation can affect conceptual constructs (Minds/Souls that are accepted to be Type 2 or 1 Concepts), then yes, that would be a factor here.
Numbers are generally not really as much of a factor for potency since its messy and a lot of the time, certain individuals among a group who have stronger mental resistance would be able to overcome it anyway. Also, being able to affect 200,000 people doesn't automatically translate to you actually being able to focus the potency of your ability onto a single person more effectively. You'd need to prove that in order for it to be substantial evidence for overcoming layered abilities.
With that out of the way, Reinhard also doesn't really open with Reid? Puck was going to destroy the world in the instance he fought him. It made sense in the Garou fight to have him start with it, since Garou was also destroying the world passively, but here I don't think it'd be his first course of action. That seems really out of character.
Layers > Number of People Affected.
Also, the source of the Sirius' Authority is Concept Manipulation/Law Manipulation, but it is unable to affect spiritual/mental concepts. Mind/Soul in Re: Zero are not conceptual objects. If they were, then the argument that Sirius' authority would overpower layers would make more sense, but just having conceptual manipulation as the source of the ability is not really much of a factor.
Like, if I can use my concept manipulation to do what is otherwise basic mind manipulation, that is not really any more potent than said basic mind manipulation. But if the mind manipulation can affect conceptual constructs (Minds/Souls that are accepted to be Type 2 or 1 Concepts), then yes, that would be a factor here.
Numbers are generally not really as much of a factor for potency since its messy and a lot of the time, certain individuals among a group who have stronger mental resistance would be able to overcome it anyway. Also, being able to affect 200,000 people doesn't automatically translate to you actually being able to focus the potency of your ability onto a single person more effectively. You'd need to prove that in order for it to be substantial evidence for overcoming layered abilities.
With that out of the way, Reinhard also doesn't really open with Reid? Puck was going to destroy the world in the instance he fought him. It made sense in the Garou fight to have him start with it, since Garou was also destroying the world passively, but here I don't think it'd be his first course of action. That seems really out of character.
Last edited:
- 6,148
- 4,679
Dawg, all I see in my notifications is you replying in 3 Re Zero threads lol
Testarossa002
Username Only- 2,794
- 3,450
I'm not even sure what the argument is. Is there a certain range it gets to before it automatically explodes?
- 3,570
- 2,298
Voting Sasuke fra
- 1,690
- 1,327
Not that it matters cuz the EE nuke isnt even his first move lol
- 6,074
- 2,855
Information analysis + instinctive actions + sixth sense can very well make this the first move
- 170
- 74
Astrea FRA
- 6,148
- 4,679
bro just started watching and is already way into him
- 1,690
- 1,327
Freakybro just started watching and is already way into him
Similar threads
