• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

UNDERTALE/DELTARUNE [shiny new] DISCUSSION THEAD

Status update: If nobody else has done so or is planning to, I will make a quick CRT to remove Gerson's teleportation in ~30-40 minutes once I get home.
B46MzMB.png
 
I am tbh,i actually created my vsbw acount to defend the L1c rating when it was first proposed
Before that i would just observe the forum like a ghost
I made mine because I didn't like that the CRT passed lol.
the god tiers are very blatantly at least multiversal
Hard disagree LMAO. I think the problems with multiversal scaling are what allowed the L1-C arguments to exist. The top tiers should be around H3-A to L2-C imo.
 
Actually i just noticed
False r>f got approved which means the player is actually at least 1C (6d)
I am 99.999999999999999999999999999999% certain false R>F is not +1D by default, especially if there is no evidence to suggest there is a legitimate uncountable infinite difference between the player and the rest of the verse.
 
I am 99.999999999999999999999999999999% certain false R>F is not +1D by default, especially if there is no evidence to suggest there is a legitimate uncountable infinite difference between the player and the rest of the verse.
"That said, such cases should be evaluated carefully. A failed Reality-Fiction Transcendence claim should not be upgraded by default. Merely being weaker, smaller, contained within or viewed through a fictional medium, or described as “less real,” is not enough if the work also provides evidence contradicting the premise of that transcendence. Likewise, statements that something is a “higher plane,” “higher world,” “more real,” “outside the story,” or “beyond space-time” are insufficient on their own unless supported by context showing what kind of superiority is actually being described."

So yea just having false R>F by itself doesn't qualify for any sort of upgrade, we would need more evidence for 1-C player.

Edit: Ok my bad I misread sorry that's not what that says at all
 
Assuming the "world" is at least multiversal leads to a couple of issues. One of which is Asriel's hypergoner feat, where "world" >= 2-B is used in a blog to justify Asriel actually erasing the timeline (since the world ending soon after should debunk this). One of the issues with this is that the save file still counts time after the timeline is destroyed. This should've been used as evidence for a downgrade instead of an upscale for the cosmology.

Another is sans dialogue, where the world ending is described as "sudden" or time-like. This is incompatible with the assumption that a temporal structure was erased. This also can't be used as evidence of a hypertimeline. Doing so results in a sudden destruction of a hypertemporal structure, requiring a hyper-hypertimeline, and the scaling becomes circular.

In addition, there are various statements that contradict a 4D "world." For example:

Flowey stating that Chara is no longer in the world. If the world were 4D this makes a simple death appear as EE.

Flowey claiming to be the prince of the world's future. This implies that the world is 3D as it is affected by time. Sans also makes a similar statement regarding the world's future but i don't wanna look for it lol.

If that isn't enough there's also Goner Kid's parallel worlds dialogue which establishes the world as a single universe.

This context implies that the "world" does not refer to the entire cosmology, but rather an H3-A structure. This doesnt contradict sans statements as "everything ends" is vague enough to mean "everything in our 3D universe." This should make Chara, who explicitly destroys the world, H3-A. Asriel can rewrite the timeline and possibly destroy it with hyper goner (if so then Frisk restores it immediately after), so he's L2-C.
 
Assuming the "world" is at least multiversal leads to a couple of issues. One of which is Asriel's hypergoner feat, where "world" >= 2-B is used in a blog to justify Asriel actually erasing the timeline (since the world ending soon after should debunk this). One of the issues with this is that the save file still counts time after the timeline is destroyed. This should've been used as evidence for a downgrade instead of an upscale for the cosmology.

Another is sans dialogue, where the world ending is described as "sudden" or time-like. This is incompatible with the assumption that a temporal structure was erased. This also can't be used as evidence of a hypertimeline. Doing so results in a sudden destruction of a hypertemporal structure, requiring a hyper-hypertimeline, and the scaling becomes circular.

In addition, there are various statements that contradict a 4D "world." For example:

Flowey stating that Chara is no longer in the world. If the world were 4D this makes a simple death appear as EE.

Flowey claiming to be the prince of the world's future. This implies that the world is 3D as it is affected by time. Sans also makes a similar statement regarding the world's future but i don't wanna look for it lol.

If that isn't enough there's also Goner Kid's parallel worlds dialogue which establishes the world as a single universe.

This context implies that the "world" does not refer to the entire cosmology, but rather an H3-A structure. This doesnt contradict sans statements as "everything ends" is vague enough to mean "everything in our 3D universe." This should make Chara, who explicitly destroys the world, H3-A. Asriel can rewrite the timeline and possibly destroy it with hyper goner (if so then Frisk restores it immediately after), so he's L2-C.
Yeah man those arguments aren't it
Don't even know what you're seing in them bro
 
Ok since i didn't argument why i should do it now
One of the issues with this is that the save file still counts time after the timeline is destroyed. This should've been used as evidence for a downgrade instead of an upscale for the cosmology.
That would be if we didn't have a direct statement about the timeline being destroyed or the fact that the save files exist outside of the timeline
Another is sans dialogue, where the world ending is described as "sudden" or time-like. This is incompatible with the assumption that a temporal structure was erased. This also can't be used as evidence of a hypertimeline. Doing so results in a sudden destruction of a hypertemporal structure, requiring a hyper-hypertimeline, and the scaling becomes circular.
I genuinely can't understand what you're trying to say, sorry
In addition, there are various statements that contradict a 4D "world." For example:
Uhhhhh, you do know that the universe is 4d because of time right? Are you trying to argue that undertale lacks a 3rd spatial dimension or that time doesn't exist in undertale?
Flowey stating that Chara is no longer in the world. If the world were 4D this makes a simple death appear as EE.
What? And again L1c is 5d not 4d

Flowey claiming to be the prince of the world's future. This implies that the world is 3D as it is affected by time. Sans also makes a similar statement regarding the world's future but i don't wanna look for it lol
Ok there is soooo much wrong with this
1: our world/universe is affected by time and that doesn't make it 3d, the fourth dimension is quite literally time
2: having a higher spatial dimesnion (which is what you seen to have confused the L1c it for) wouldn't make the world not affected by time, time is a whole separate dimension
3: we literally got L1c Via hypertime which is just another temporal dimension
If that isn't enough there's also Goner Kid's parallel worlds dialogue which establishes the world as a single universe.
Yeah and undertale supporters never argued that there are more than one universe, just that the universe has multiple timelines (which is only 2-B) and a higher temporal dimension (the origin of L1c undertale)
Asriel can rewrite the timeline and possibly destroy it with hyper goner (if so then Frisk restores it immediately after), so he's L2-C.
Frisk wasn't even the one who undid everything that Asriel did, it was Asriel himself
 
I am 99.999999999999999999999999999999% certain false R>F is not +1D by default, especially if there is no evidence to suggest there is a legitimate uncountable infinite difference between the player and the rest of the verse.
There kinda one tho due player controling two sets uncountable infinites timelines (player town and the save file that probally arent our due the contract at the beginning tho)
 
That would be if we didn't have a direct statement about the timeline being destroyed or the fact that the save files exist outside of the timeline
That statement should be debunked by time existing and the statement that the world was ending. Best case scenerio Frisk restores the timeline immediately after the hypergoner destroys it.

genuinely can't understand what you're trying to say, sorry
In order for a 4D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. This is the justification used by the wiki to upgrade Chara slash to L1-C. But now Chara's slash suddenly destroys a 5D structure. In order for a 5D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. By upgrading Chara, you lose the justification that upgrades them to begin with. The evidence for 5D now becomes evidence for 6D. If you upgrade Chara slash to 6D, you get evidence for 7D, etc. This mess happens because we initially scaled Chara to 4D, so Chara should not be 4D.


Uhhhhh, you do know that the universe is 4d because of time right? Are you trying to argue that undertale lacks a 3rd spatial dimension or that time doesn't exist in undertale?

No UT is at least 4D.
Destroying a timeline = 4D feat
Destroying a world = 3D feat (THE WORLD IS THE PRESENT, NOT THE ENTIRE COSMOLOGY)

What? And again L1c is 5d not 4d
Doesn't matter. For Flowey's statement to work you have to argue that Chara was removed across the entire cosmology, and any timeline/hypertimeline. This isn't what the statement implies, rather Chara isn't in the world because the world is the present.

Ok there is soooo much wrong with this
1: our world/universe is affected by time and that doesn't make it 3d, the fourth dimension is quite literally time
2: having a higher spatial dimesnion (which is what you seen to have confused the L1c it for) wouldn't make the world not affected by time, time is a whole separate dimension
3: we literally got L1c Via hypertime which is just another temporal dimension

In context of UT, our timeline is 4D, but our world is 3D because it is the present. Our present changes over time, but our timeline should not. Hypertimeline is a potential explanation for this but I don't think it's a good one given the other quote I mentioned. Its more believeable to downgrade a character to 3D rather than upgrade the verse with a hypertimeline.
 
Last edited:
That statement should be debunked by time existing and the statement that the world was ending. Best case scenerio Frisk restores the timeline immediately after the hypergoner destroys it.


In order for a 4D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. This is the justification used by the wiki to upgrade Chara slash to L1-C. But now Chara's slash suddenly destroys a 5D structure. In order for a 5D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. By upgrading Chara, you lose the justification that upgrades them to begin with. The evidence for 5D now becomes evidence for 6D. If you upgrade Chara slash to 6D, you get evidence for 7D, etc. This mess happens because we initially scaled Chara to 4D, so Chara should not be 4D.




No UT is at least 4D.
Destroying a timeline = 4D feat
Destroying a world = 3D feat (the world is the present, not the entire timeline)

EDIT: I HATE ACCIDENTALLY PRESSING SEND
Soo does my thing with two sets of uncountable works ?
 
That statement should be debunked by time existing and the statement that the world was ending. Best case scenerio Frisk restores the timeline immediately after the hypergoner destroys it.


In order for a 4D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. This is the justification used by the wiki to upgrade Chara slash to L1-C. But now Chara's slash suddenly destroys a 5D structure. In order for a 5D time structure to end suddenly, you need +1 time dimension. By upgrading Chara, you lose the justification that upgrades them to begin with. The evidence for 5D now becomes evidence for 6D. If you upgrade Chara slash to 6D, you get evidence for 7D, etc. This mess happens because we initially scaled Chara to 4D, so Chara should not be 4D.




No UT is at least 4D.
Destroying a timeline = 4D feat
Destroying a world = 3D feat (the world is the present, not the entire cosmology)


Doesn't matter. For Flowey's statement to work you have to argue that Chara was removed across the entire cosmology, and any timeline/hypertimeline. This isn't what the statement implies, rather Chara isn't in the world because the world is the present.
Okay but what if there no present ?
 
Back
Top