Is CM2 dimensioned?

[Arency]

As it's usually tied to a dimensioned structure...

If it's the case, would it work for AE1 being to have CM2 aspect despite AE1 to be dimensionless?

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

The rule with AE1 and HDE not being applicable to a character was specifically for type 1 concepts, so it might be possible, though I'm not entirely sure so you're best off waiting for more input

 

[Vietthai96]

No, it is tied to reality as a whole which could includes some voids which is undimensioned

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

No, it is tied to reality as a whole which could includes some voids which is undimensioned

Then does it depend on the verse or...?

 

[Vietthai96]

Then does it depend on the verse or...?

Depend on verses yes

 

[Arency]

No, it is tied to reality as a whole which could includes some voids which is undimensioned

So CM2 undimensioned if it has void, but if it doesn't, wouldn't it be some smurf/dimensioned CM2? And would AE1 CM2 in that case even be possible?

Also don't our universe actually have voids

 

[Vietthai96]

Concept itself is undimensioned, unless we talking about concept of dimensionality

 

[FriendOfTheTeaParty]

Concept itself is undimensioned, unless we talking about concept of dimensionality

That is undimensioned too

The concept of an apple is not an apple itself.

Same logic applies to dimensionality or else you run into a logical paradox.

 

[Vietthai96]

MGQ jump scare

Anyway i probably wording it very badly and wrongly, but concept can have dimensions if the verse itself decides to establish such weird stuff

Anyway, i think concept of dimensionsality can encompass all extension of dimensions thus having dimensionality too, but well

 

[SuperNova55555]

And if the Ideas and the particulars that share
them have the same Form, there will be something common to these; for why should '2' be one and the same in the perishable 2’s or in those which are many but eternal, and not the same in the '2 itself' as in the particular? But if they have not the same Form, they must have only the name in common, and it is as if one were to call both Callias and a wooden image a 'man', without observing any community between them. (Aristotle’s Metaphysics)

I doubt the wiki is so strict on it though.

 

[Tanin_iver]

The rule with AE1 and HDE not being applicable to a character was specifically for type 1 concepts, so it might be possible, though I'm not entirely sure so you're best off waiting for more input

Is it really just Type 1 AE for Concept Type 1, or for just about all AE1 barring the exceptions that a verse may specify.

I mean if we look at it this way, test an AE1 using Space-Time and Dimension Manip, and see if you can argue to affect it.

Can Space-Time and Dimension Manip Affect Souls?
Can they affect metaphysical mind/memories?
Can they affect any of the Concept Types?
Can they affect Plot?
Can they affect ontological Information?
They can be argued to affect maybe say in some cases due to verse mechanics and that would be the exception and not the norm.

So I'd say in most cases almost all AE1 Types can be argued to be undimensioned.

At least that's the impression I got from the new revisions.

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

Is it really just Type 1 AE for Concept Type 1, or for just about all AE1 barring the exceptions that a verse may specify.

Pretty much this I believe

 

[Tanin_iver]

Pretty much this I believe

Is it really just Type 1 AE for Concept Type 1,

or for just about all AE1 barring the exceptions that a verse may specify.

Which one bro? Which one do you believe?

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

Which one bro? Which one do you believe?

What Viet said above, he's mirroring DT's points made in the CRT that addressed this

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

Best way it can be explained is that the concept itself is abstract and lacks a "physical size", but it has a "range" or rather an area under its own influence.