Genshin Impact Discussion Thread

[MSahla]

I shared the same birthday as Yunjin

 

[MSahla]

If this is referring to Asmoday, then Asmoday have some kind of Fate Manip that even bypassed Irminsul itself. It would be an amazing foreshadows too.

 

[MSahla]

Since we call Columbina “Bina”, we will also call Anastasya “Ana” for short too.

 

[TWILIGHT-OP]

Since we call Columbina “Bina”, we will also call Anastasya “Ana” for short too.

Or Tsaritsa?

 

[MSahla]

Or Tsaritsa?

I mean, that's not gonna be the display name. It's gonna be Anastasya. Pretty much like Bina who went from The Damselette to Columbina.

 

[TWILIGHT-OP]

I mean, that's not gonna be the display name. It's gonna be Anastasya. Pretty much like Bina who went from The Damselette to Columbina.

Who tf calling her by her real name, we all now used to call her Tsaritsa.

 

[MSahla]

Who tf calling her by her real name, we all now used to call her Tsaritsa.

That's gonna be me. I mean i get that we're used to call her Tsaritsa because we've been calling her so for 6 years. So it's gonna take some times to get used to.

 

[AsterReal]

The markings on the pigeons' wings are beautiful.

 

[MSahla]

Dottore boss defeat animation

 

[MSahla]

Now that we know that our sibling were being trapped within a cage by Asmoday in the Temple of Space (specifically Cage of Suchness), it is make so much sense why our sibling said that their memories were lost at the moment they arrived in Teyvat in the Space and Time For You Archon Quest. Because, whoever wants to leave the Temple of Space, all of their memories have to be erased completely.

 

[Le'garde273]

Since we call Columbina “Bina”, we will also call Anastasya “Ana” for short too.

Lol suddenly i am thinking if this possibility of this would totally debunk tsaritsa being bronya, cause "ana"stasya could be expy of ana shariac (which make sense tbh considering both of them are ice queen)

 

[MSahla]

Lol suddenly i am thinking if this possibility of this would totally debunk tsaritsa being bronya, cause "ana"stasya could be expy of ana shariac (which make sense tbh considering both of them are ice queen)

Like why would she be Bronya expy anyway. The latter would make so much sense than the former, lol.

 

[Le'garde273]

Like why would she be Bronya expy anyway. The latter would make so much sense than the former, lol.

The main reason peoples believe tsaritsa being bronya expy is, iirc due earlier genshin beta childe voiceline is ever called tsaritsa as "bronya"

 

[MSahla]

And there's a headcanon of the Tsaritsa being a lesbian to the first Cryo Archon whom people theorized as Seele. And then boooommm, the first one is turns out to be a Male

The main reason peoples believe tsaritsa being bronya expy is, iirc due earlier genshin beta childe voiceline is ever called tsaritsa as "bronya"

I'm afraid that's not gonna happen in any way possible, since her real name aren't Bronya. I mean there's a possibility of her appeareance, voice and others being similar. But, the chance is too low now.

 

[MSahla]

The only right song to play when we go to Snezhnaya

 

[AsterReal]

 

[AsterReal]

So the rebellion of the angels was what started—or rather, set the stage for—the War of the Funerary Flame and the return of Nibelung.

The faint alow of the three moons was not enouah to veil the murderous wind stirred up by the falling stars.
Beyond the northern winds, in the old capital, rebels from across the land gathered beneath the giant dome.
The eldest daughter, once hailed as the morning star, now sat enthroned in unforgivable sin.
She raised the blade that once shattered the shackles placed on the people before the ever-growing ranks of her followers. The herald ascended the high tower, preparing to proclaim her blasphemous- words to the heavens,
"The final war is about to begin, and I already know what it is I seek." "I would rather freedom, hard-won though it shall be, over the comfort of shackles."
"Either cast Them down from their throne in the heavens and bring Them before a justice beyond thi s world,.."
"Or be consumed by Their fickle wrath, and perish alongside the eternal fate Thev have decreed."
"1 believe not in everlasting prosperity. Happiness is not a thing that can be designed."
"I believe not in the crown of sevenfold radiance, and nor do I bear any hope that its light truly redeems all.'
"I believe not in songs sung on bended knee, for this world is one that belongs to us."
Wings brushed against wings in a dry, whispering hiss, for never since creation had so many angels gathered in one place As if roused by thunderous war drums, beasts long forgotten by the world caught the scent of blood that tainted the divine. From lightless valleys and the far reaches of the outer seas, the most ancient masters of the earth also came forth to answer the call.
"From the suffering ordained by fate, we have forged our own peace. Our great work has already long surpassed Their grace."
'A pale star burns beyond the false firmament, and its very existence proclaims our victory. 'Even in failure new possibilities will arise, for those yet to come are also watching us." 'Behold... The stars shine ever so bright tonight.'

 

[MSahla]

So the rebellion of the angels was what started—or rather, set the stage for—the War of the Funerary Flame and the return of Nibelung.

Literally Primordial One (and possibly the Shades) against Nibelung, the Sovereigns, Angels, and the Voyager.

 

[AsterReal]

The Artifact Set states that the sun in the firmament is fake.

 

[AsterReal]

The sky had been set ablaze by the blistering embers, which had also mingled with a rain of blood. Night had turned brighter than day, From the heavens fell a stellar spike that stirred the verv stars. its brilliance dimming even the light of the false sun.

I imagine that just as the Moons had goddesses, the sun outside Teyvat must have its own god.

 

[MSahla]

Wings brushed against wings in a dry, whispering hiss, for never since creation had so many angels gathered in one place, as if roused by thunderous war drums, beasts long forgotten by the world caught the scent of blood that tainted the divine. From lightless valleys and the far reaches of the outer seas, the most ancient masters of the earth also came forth to answer the call.

"From the suffering ordained by fate, we have forged our own peace. Our great work has already long surpassed Their grace."
'A pale star burns beyond the false firmament, and its very existence proclaims our victory.

'Even in failure new possibilities will arise, for those yet to come are also watching us." 'Behold... The stars shine ever so bright tonight.'

The Aura coming from these sentences

 

[MSahla]

Koitar's goated speech:
"The final war is about to begin, and I already know what it is I seek."

"I would rather freedom, hard-won though it shall be, over the comfort of shackles."

"Either cast Them down from their throne in the heavens and bring Them before a justice beyond this world,.."

"Or be consumed by Their fickle wrath, and perish alongside the eternal fate They have decreed."

"I believe not in everlasting prosperity. Happiness is not a thing that can be designed."

"I believe not in the crown of sevenfold radiance, and nor do I bear any hope that its light truly redeems all.'

"I believe not in songs sung on bended knee, for this world is one that belongs to us."​

 

[MSahla]

I think Pantalone's JP VA doesn't really fit with the character and appereance tbh. Kinda hope they replace the old with the new one.

 

[Furina003]

Koitar's goated speech:
"The final war is about to begin, and I already know what it is I seek."

"I would rather freedom, hard-won though it shall be, over the comfort of shackles."

"Either cast Them down from their throne in the heavens and bring Them before a justice beyond this world,.."

"Or be consumed by Their fickle wrath, and perish alongside the eternal fate They have decreed."

"I believe not in everlasting prosperity. Happiness is not a thing that can be designed."

"I believe not in the crown of sevenfold radiance, and nor do I bear any hope that its light truly redeems all.'

"I believe not in songs sung on bended knee, for this world is one that belongs to us."​

koitar and voyager are just a form of arrogance, are they stupid?? they feel restrained, but they themselves will not be able to hold back the destruction of the abyss that has destroyed the universe, even the voyagers also know that there is no solution they can do to hold back the abyss, but the primordial one is different, he managed to realize a world without the abyss if not disturbed by the intruder from within.
in essence koitar was only consumed by the voyager's seduction.

So the rebellion of the angels was what started—or rather, set the stage for—the War of the Funerary Flame and the return of Nibelung.

Perhaps, from this text we are told a little that at that time, Phanes was alone with his 4 shades (although the shades were Phanes himself), fighting all the dragons, Nibelungs, Voyager Koitar and all the angels. In essence, Phanes vs. everybody (the real aura)

 

[Furina003]

I imagine that just as the Moons had goddesses, the sun outside Teyvat must have its own god.

The sun god did exist, if I remember correctly, this was discussed in the Liyue Bamboo Forest book, where it was explained that the three moon goddesses always took turns meeting the sun god and during the revenge war, there was a sun chariot that had crashed in Liyue, but returned to outer space.

 

[PedjaTarzan]

The sun god did exist, if I remember correctly, this was discussed in the Liyue Bamboo Forest book, where it was explained that the three moon goddesses always took turns meeting the sun god and during the revenge war, there was a sun chariot that had crashed in Liyue, but returned to outer space.

Didnt he also create a chasm crater

 

[Furina003]

Didnt he also create a chasm crater

Yes, right

 

[MSahla]

We are bout to witness a generational special program in 10 days

 

[Puppet43]

If it is not reliable, why would they recommended it?

I could litterally recommend you a not safe for work story about Traveler and Skirk, does this mean is reliable?

You're asking this, either you're loreskipper or just ignored the scan that i gave to you from Josephus' statements, cause them knowing the true secrets about Celestia has always been a common knowledge.

No? Im just asking u to pass the scan how does this proof im a loreskipper?
I could say the same about you if u once didnt know about a statment that said Traveler is like 100 times stronger than his previous base

Her note is in the book at the very end of each prayers. I don't even think you read the whole book, or not even read the book atp.

Man u dont have to be aggresive, i just asked you where i could the statment because i dont have a photographic memory

Puppet, we've been through this. You're admitted yourself that you're being headcanoned and wanted that statement to be referred to the Shades so bad, while the devs themselves never directly mentioned the shades.

But this HOLYSHIT how in the world you interpreted this as level of shades rather the moon GODdess themselves!? Are the moon sister aren't god to begin with!?!

He is stated to be on par with Gods

• Couldnt be random (Archon War) Gods, because thats bassicly his base
• Couldnt be Archons because a lot of characters by this point were Archon lvl (Varka) or beyond (Flins, Nefer, Traveler, Durin) yet still have to group against him
• Shouldnt be Moon Goddess because he was capable of clashing with a Moon Goddess worth of 3 Moon Goddess (Authorities)

That litterally leaves us with 1 group of Gods, Shades.
Unless Dr Data is stated stronger than Heretic and its low diffed by a Shade im not changing my mind
You guys are capable of glazing a statement where a developer mentions we should read the book, but when the same person talks about power scaling and how our next fight will be against a man with a god complex who wants to reach Phanes' levels, you'll say it's simply "headcanon + 67 + gg + ez + womp womp".
"But the Shades beat him, dude, that's why they can't be in the same tier," and I never said otherwise. You think that within the same "level" all characters have to have a 50% chance of beating each other, when we have Signora and Electro Traveler in the same tier, one of whom beat the other with medium difficulty, and let's not even get into the haxs.

while the meaning of it is not that literally and it's just a flowery words.

I could say the same about Istaroth being time

 

[Puppet43]

So, Mini Durin size?

Most likely gonna be a fungi

The only right song to play when we go to Snezhnaya

 

[MSahla]

I could litterally recommend you a not safe for work story about Traveler and Skirk, does this mean is reliable

??
First thing first, you ignored who is doing the recommending and in what context. So your analogy doesn't work and you're doing false equivalance. A random NSFW shit about Traveler and Skirk has no authority, no verification, and no intent to inform canon. It’s purely fanmade.

The Hymns of the Far North being recommended by the devs is a completely different situation. It gives evidentiary weight.

No? Im just asking u to pass the scan how does this proof im a loreskipper?
I could say the same about you if u once didnt know about a statment that said Traveler is like 100 times stronger than his previous base

I already gave you Josephus' statements and even a statement from Tiara artifact description which is basically saya the same thing. The people of the unified civilization lived among the Angels. And those angels were basically telling them the secrets of everything, including Celestia.

Like buddy, we've been through Enkanomiya already, and that's the obvious blatant evidence we have. You got the author of of the Byakuyakoku Collections telling us about Istaroth, and even the history about the Shades and Primordial One itself. How do you not even think that the people of the unified civilization doesn't know anything?

Man u dont have to be aggresive, i just asked you where i could the statment because i dont have a photographic memory

At the end of each prayers.

That litterally leaves us with 1 group of Gods, Shades.

Puppet, you know that's headcanon. The words “Onpar with the gods” is vague statement by design alone and doesn’t specify which level. If you're treating it as if it must refer to the highest possible tier (like the Shades), then it's an assumption, not evidence. This is all just false dilemma, where you’re just forcing a narrow set of options, then picking the only one left.

If you want to claim Dottore is on the level of the Shades, you need direct or strongly implied evidence tying him to that tier (e.g the Sovereigns vs Shades + Phanes for example).

I could say the same about Istaroth being time

If it's just flowery, then it would be just one vague line and then no supporting behavior. While in this case, the essence of her being time is always being consistently demonstrated over the years.

 

[Le'garde273]

That litterally leaves us with 1 group of Gods, Shades.

Ah yessss.... Stealing the moons power aren't moons level anymore

The moon goddess suddenly wasn't GODdess anymore

Mf couldn't comprehend if they can strongers than without giving gazzilions time gap to next level.

Beside, aren't you exactly aware if the moons sister are stated divided their authority into three so no sister would have dominant power. The "god" Aren't even close to shade to begin with, it refer exactly to this lol

 

[Le'garde273]

@MSahla

 

[MSahla]

@MSahla

 

[Le'garde273]

The shades level singular moon goddess in the question

• Didn't participated war, two times
• didn't even try
• not even close to nibelung original light sovereign authority as it only exist as mere extension of his will when nibelung leave teyvat
• didn't even called by corrupted nibelung to assists the war unlike the entire sovereigns
• got their selves and moon vessel seperated by nibelung in moons reflection, then empty husk moons got modified as weapon by nibelung, meaning the moons pre modified aren't even that powerful
• Got their followers begging to istaroth to protect their own moon goddess
• got blatantly stated by nicole them three are nowhere near their level
• died for nothing
• the dragons kin actually and ironically cheering for their death

Oh yeah their power in singular three obviously shades level cause it's mention "god"

 

[MSahla]

The shades level singular moon goddess in the question

• Didn't participated war, two times
• didn't even try
• not even close to nibelung original light sovereign authority as it only exist as mere extension of his will when nibelung leave teyvat
• didn't even called by corrupted nibelung to assists the war unlike the entire sovereigns
• got their selves and moon vessel seperated by nibelung in moons reflection, then empty husk moons got modified as weapon by nibelung, meaning the moons pre modified aren't even that powerful
• Got their followers begging to istaroth to protect their own moon goddess
• got blatantly stated by nicole them three are nowhere near their level
• died for nothing
• the dragons kin actually and ironically cheering for their death

Oh yeah their power in singular three obviously shades level cause it's mention "god"

 

[MSahla]

Maybe i should change the Traveler's age to thousands of years.

 

[PedjaTarzan]

Maybe i should change the Traveler's age to thousands of years.

I mean it landed on the planet like at the age of dragons when PO first came, and then it moved the ship on the moon iirc. bro may be tens of thousands years old too

 

[MSahla]

I mean it landed on the planet like at the age of dragons when PO first came, and then it moved the ship on the moon iirc. bro may be tens of thousands years old too

I don't think they were landed for the first time during the age of the Dragons. The most likely case here is that at least up to 6000 years ago, somehow. We can just assume that the spaceship has FTL or even MFTL travel speed atp. Because, if not then they wouldn't be landed at Nod-Krai again in anytime soon.

But, this is really depends of when they landed or arrived at Teyvat for the first time.

 

[Mbpoops]