Honkai: Star Rail Discussion Thread

[Mbpoops]

you do know that his profile is based around his REAL self, i mean if you are really into it you can make separate keys for him where hes 4-A

i was planning on doing this anyway but we've like never seen the real skaz he could be a bum lowkey

 

[Mbpoops]

Didn’t TB almost die in 56 seconds and say it was gonna eat them if it survived any longer?

still lasted 56 seconds against a 4-A tb thats a win in my book

 

[Mbpoops]

Honestly we just need DHIL to job an Emanator and we can remove that Emanator > Pathstrider thing

goat heng kill the verse

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

still lasted 56 seconds against a 4-A tb thats a win in my book

I always interpreted that fight as TB just running and dodging while being unable to damage it, but we can’t really prove it cause the fight was gameplay.
Fake Skaz is just bums

 

[Mbpoops]

I always interpreted that fight as TB just running and dodging while being unable to damage it, but we can’t really prove it cause the fight was gameplay.
Fake Skaz is just bums

i mean they had their bat

 

[SuperNova55555]

Like. Dan Heng scaling to Phantylia is prob one of the biggest downscales in this verse lol.

It’s obvious Phantylia was playing around the entire fight and that’s even the reason she lost. But I guess he might’ve “scratched” her body or sum so that’s enough to scale to here lel

 

[SuperNova55555]

By the way, didn’t DHIL attack JY and abused the connection between them or did he attack Phantylia herself cuz I cant remember

 

[Mbpoops]

Like. Dan Heng scaling to Phantylia is prob one of the biggest downscales in this verse lol.

It’s obvious Phantylia was playing around the entire fight and that’s even the reason she lost. But I guess he might’ve “scratched” her body or sum so that’s enough to scale to here lel

i mean phainon scratching nanook is the only reason why low 1-C irontomb cyrene and khaslana are a thing

 

[Mbpoops]

By the way, didn’t DHIL attack JY and abused the connection between them or did he attack Phantylia herself cuz I cant remember

 

[SuperNova55555]

Ohhh, it was LL, yea that makes sense.

I guess DHIL rlly is getting carried by that one ability animation mid fight lol.

 

[Mbpoops]

Ohhh, it was LL, yea that makes sense.

I guess DHIL rlly is getting carried by that one ability animation mid fight lol.

he deadass is

 

[PedjaTarzan]

Dont forget we somehow manage to damage irontomb before bro just locks in and one shots cosmos

 

[Mbpoops]

Dont forget we somehow manage to damage irontomb before bro just locks in and one shots cosmos

cyrene lowkey carried us

 

[SuperNova55555]

he deadass is

Can’t we say that it’s just the Arbor’s body that’s weak or something? Since if we claim that Phantylia was playing around (which she is), we can js say that it’s not an issue of her Emanator powers (since we can claim she wasn’t really using them), but of the Arbor itself. And thus DHIL doesn’t scale to Phantylia.

 

[Mbpoops]

Can’t we say that it’s just the Arbor’s body that’s weak or something? Since if we claim that Phantylia was playing around (which she is), we can js say that it’s not an issue of her Emanator powers (since we can claim she wasn’t really using them), but of the Arbor itself. And thus DHIL doesn’t scale to Phantylia.

what about jingyuan then

 

[SuperNova55555]

what about jingyuan then

Lightning Lord is prob Emanator level anyways. Physically he himself prob isn’t

 

[Mbpoops]

Lightning Lord is prob Emanator level anyways. Physically he himself prob isn’t

4-A, 3-C with lightning lord? fine by me. what about feixiao then?

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

Can’t we say that it’s just the Arbor’s body that’s weak or something? Since if we claim that Phantylia was playing around (which she is), we can js say that it’s not an issue of her Emanator powers (since we can claim she wasn’t really using them), but of the Arbor itself. And thus DHIL doesn’t scale to Phantylia.

Doesn’t that one ability animation DHIL has where JY calls for his help happen when Phantylia is in destruction mode? Isn’t that precisely when she’s using her emanator powers?

 

[SuperNova55555]

4-A, 3-C with lightning lord? fine by me. what about feixiao then?

We can say the same for all generals. But generals pretty much fuse their attacks with their spirits (especially Feixiao) so it’s functionally a superficial difference

 

[ExcelsisBerny]

Aigh, so we have another statement. I believe it’s fine then. No need for jobbing the entire verse

Bro.... I'm starting to believe Yog is just a SoQ level being, because her domain is also called "Sea of Stars". Maybe you should add that to the cosmology blog.

 

[Mbpoops]

We can say the same for all generals. But generals pretty much fuse their attacks with their spirits (especially Feixiao) so it’s functionally a superficial difference

im fine with this

 

[Mbpoops]

Bro.... I'm starting to believe Yog is just a SoQ level being, because her domain is also called "Sea of Stars". Maybe you should add that to the cosmology blog.

pretty sure the soq doesnt have stars since it destroys everything that enters it except for some exceptions but what do i know

 

[SuperNova55555]

Doesn’t that one ability animation DHIL has where JY calls for his help happen when Phantylia is in destruction mode? Isn’t that precisely when she’s using her emanator powers?

It’s her second phase. And she was also playing around, like testing us whether we can survive a star.

 

[SuperNova55555]

I think the main thing here is that Phantylia makes it pretty clear that there’s a difference between her and the Arbor’s body. Which is prob how we are to resolve the scaling issues I’d argue.

Bro.... I'm starting to believe Yog is just a SoQ level being, because her domain is also called "Sea of Stars". Maybe you should add that to the cosmology blog.

Nah, that wouldn’t be SoQ, since it wouldn’t have stars like that. “Sea of stars” is colloquially used to js refer to the normal universe, especially in Genshin

 

[Mbpoops]

3-C: Evernight, acheron (white hair), zephyro, welt, phantylia, jingyuan, feixiao, (with stands) dominicus sunday's first key? argenti's second key (blame firefly), irontomb, demiurge, REAL skaz, Lygus, Herta

4-A: trailblazer (post argenti quest till cyrene amp), march 7th (every key except evernight), himeko, yanqing, yunli, PomPom (the express), dormancy, saber/archer..?, skaz, aventurine, topaz, and jade (all except the qlipoth hammer ofc), argenti first key, black swan, the galaxy rangers, hoolay, literally every chrysos heir and titan except the ones mentioned above and cyrene amps, mem/cyrene (NOT DEMIURGE), acheron (purple), blade, kafka, silverwolf..? firefly, sparkle (until her clones get nuked), jingliu, dhil, permanser terrae, Flame reaver, Khaslana

in a rush so if anythings wrong lmk

 

[ExcelsisBerny]

I think the main thing here is that Phantylia makes it pretty clear that there’s a difference between her and the Arbor’s body. Which is prob how we are to resolve the scaling issues I’d argue.


Nah, that wouldn’t be SoQ, since it wouldn’t have stars like that. “Sea of stars” is colloquially used to js refer to the normal universe, especially in Genshin

Alright then. Yog below Cyrene when?

 

[SuperNova55555]

3-C: Evernight, acheron (white hair), zephyro, welt, phantylia, jingyuan, feixiao, (with stands) dominicus sunday's first key? argenti's second key (blame firefly), irontomb, demiurge, REAL skaz, Lygus, Herta

4-A: trailblazer (post argenti quest till cyrene amp), march 7th (every key except evernight), himeko, yanqing, yunli, PomPom (the express), dormancy, saber/archer..?, skaz, aventurine, topaz, and jade (all except the qlipoth hammer ofc), argenti first key, black swan, the galaxy rangers, hoolay, literally every chrysos heir and titan except the ones mentioned above and cyrene amps, mem/cyrene (NOT DEMIURGE), acheron (purple), blade, kafka, silverwolf..? firefly, sparkle (until her clones get nuked), jingliu, dhil, permanser terrae, Flame reaver, Khaslana

in a rush so if anythings wrong lmk

Argenti…?

 

[Mbpoops]

Argenti…?

forgot to remove it lol

3-C: Evernight, acheron (white hair), zephyro, welt, phantylia, jingyuan, feixiao, (with stands) dominicus sunday's first key? irontomb, demiurge, REAL skaz, Lygus, Herta

4-A: trailblazer (post argenti quest till cyrene amp), march 7th (every key except evernight), himeko, yanqing, yunli, PomPom (the express), dormancy, saber/archer..?, skaz, aventurine, topaz, and jade (all except the qlipoth hammer ofc), argenti, black swan, the galaxy rangers, hoolay, literally every chrysos heir and titan except the ones mentioned above and cyrene amps, mem/cyrene (NOT DEMIURGE), acheron (purple), blade, kafka, silverwolf..? firefly, sparkle (until her clones get nuked), jingliu, dhil, permanser terrae, Flame reaver, Khaslana,

 

[SuperNova55555]

forgot to remove it lol

3-C: Evernight, acheron (white hair), zephyro, welt, phantylia, jingyuan, feixiao, (with stands) dominicus sunday's first key? irontomb, demiurge, REAL skaz, Lygus, Herta

4-A: trailblazer (post argenti quest till cyrene amp), march 7th (every key except evernight), himeko, yanqing, yunli, PomPom (the express), dormancy, saber/archer..?, skaz, aventurine, topaz, and jade (all except the qlipoth hammer ofc), argenti, black swan, the galaxy rangers, hoolay, literally every chrysos heir and titan except the ones mentioned above and cyrene amps, mem/cyrene (NOT DEMIURGE), acheron (purple), blade, kafka, silverwolf..? firefly, sparkle (until her clones get nuked), jingliu, dhil, permanser terrae, Flame reaver, Khaslana,

If no Pathstriders are 3-C then Emanators like Herta will fall as well since there aren’t others to upscale from.

And again. Why. Is. Gramps. In. There.

 

[Mbpoops]

If no Pathstriders are 3-C then Emanators like Herta will fall as well since there aren’t others to upscale from.

And again. Why. Is. Gramps. In. There.

It slipped my mind cus i was in a rush but im pretty sure hes considered stronger than evernight? I gotta look at his profile again should at least leep 3-C woth star of eden tho. Herta is there cus lygus mutual destruction

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

And again. Why. Is. Gramps. In. There

Varies up to 3-C with Star of Eden prob?

 

[SuperNova55555]

It slipped my mind cus i was in a rush but im pretty sure hes considered stronger than evernight?

Gramps is stronger than Evernight??

Herta is there cus lygus mutual destruction

This is very likely not physical (prob via technology and stuff) but ig its a pretty superficial difference so I dont rlly mind

Varies up to 3-C with Star of Eden prob?

Yea. Why would we grant this.

 

[CastoriceTheFifth]

PleasehavesexwithmePleasehavesexwithmePleasehavesexwithmePleasehavesexwithmePleasehavesexwithmePleasehavesexwithme

 

[Natsuki012]

Gramps is stronger than Evernight??

likely talking about this

 

[Mbpoops]

Gramps is stronger than Evernight??

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Welt_Yang?so=search#:~:text=and%20the%20Star%20of%20Eden%20(He%20is%20repeatedly%20regarded%20as%20the%20strongest%20by%20his%20fellow%20Astral%20Express%20Members%2C%5B64%5D%20which%20includes%20Evernight%2C%5B65

I didnt write the profile

 

[SuperNova55555]

likely talking about this

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Welt_Yang?so=search#:~:text=and%20the%20Star%20of%20Eden%20(He%20is%20repeatedly%20regarded%20as%20the%20strongest%20by%20his%20fellow%20Astral%20Express%20Members%2C%5B64%5D%20which%20includes%20Evernight%2C%5B65

I didnt write the profile

That’s the stupidest reason ever oh my god

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

Yea. Why would we grant this

For the clash Welt has vs Zephyro and Welt being the last man standing against the guy (he’s still inferior).
You don’t see no “Permansor Terrae” or “Evernight” fighting Zephyro

Varies cause Singularity Rebuild and Zeroth Power are much stronger than the random little energy blasts star of Eden can fire.

 

[SuperNova55555]

You don’t see no “Permansor Terrae” or “Evernight” fighting Zephyro

They wouldn’t be there… cuz they didn’t go to Amphoreus.

 

[Ezalipaz]

Welt is possibly the strongest AE pre-Amphoreus but post-Amphoreus not likely, unless MHY just drop more direct glaze for him again

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

They wouldn’t be there… cuz they didn’t go to Amphoreus.

…
Well there isn’t any Imbibitor Lunae there either but he got booted out of Phantylia downscaling land ig.

So is Zephyro and Welt’s clash taken as a unique reaction or being mostly Zephyro’s power then?