• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Ayanokouji Full Strength Contextualized

Oh for the love of god, Housen was stated to be able to overpower BOTH Albert and Manabu with sheer stats, Ayanokouji managed to stop Housen with his hand
This would mean they would all be relative that's my point bro.
Manabu doesn't scale to Albert physically to begin with
Neither does Ayanokouji which is what he said himself due to his genetics. But in a fight Manabu would win, the same way Ayanokouji did. Physically stronger doesn't equal better fighter .
Narrative says otherwise
But that's the premise of my post, the current narrative isn't consistent with what I posted.
No?? If he went all out, Manabu wouldn't be able to catch up to him at all
That's assumption without statements to support it. All we can go off of is that he ran with full effort and at the end said he could go faster, which we can't quantify to a number, so I think it would likely get a "likely higher" for his travel speed
No, there's no statement of that, more over if you look at the context you will see that Ayanokouji that Ayanokouji has no intention of giving his all in this fight at all
But that's what I'm not understanding, I posted dozens of statements and you dismissed the ones I posted?
No 💀, Ayanokouji remained active for 14 days on that same enviroment, there's no peak human or athletic
But every student is also doing this he isn't the only person surviving on the island. I wouldn't say Ichinose has superhuman stamina.

I agree with OP
Thanks bud
 
This would mean they would all be relative that's my point bro.
They are not, Housen massacres Albert in every stat, it literally took the whole Ryuen gang (minus Ibuki) to defeat him

And that was with a well thought out plan

Kouenji as stated in the scans prove he is physically superior in both AP and LS to them and has feats that puts him tied to a supressed and weakened Ayanokouji who out-muscled housen while injured who was stated to be superior in stats compared to Albert and Manabu
Neither does Ayanokouji which is what he said himself due to his genetics. But in a fight Manabu would win, the same way Ayanokouji did. Physically stronger doesn't equal better fighter .
See above
But that's the premise of my post, the current narrative isn't consistent with what I posted.
And we already showed you several scans on why your "thinking" is not correct, more so when you send scans contradicting your own scans
That's assumption without statements to support it. All we can go off of is that he ran with full effort and at the end said he could go faster, which we can't quantify to a number, so I think it would likely get a "likely higher" for his travel speed
Brother in christ, Ayanokouji literally said he could accelerate even further and was going to, how is this an assumption???
But that's what I'm not understanding, I posted dozens of statements and you dismissed the ones I posted?
YOU dismissed the ones disproving your points, let's get that right, this whole CRT is based on your own head canons
But every student is also doing this he isn't the only person surviving on the island. I wouldn't say Ichinose has superhuman stamina.
Yeah but unlike Koji, they aren't being chased after for the entirety of the exam, they are eating, they are drinking, sleeping and not fighting unlike Koji who is just BARELY capable of doing that because he is being chased
 
Last edited:
We can't assume this while also dismissing statements he routinely says himself, that would be inconsistent and only picking what benefits him. When Ayanokouji is in pain he usually states it as my scans show. If his ligaments were destroyed that's definitely something worth noting.
Ok so even if we can't assume that you do realize if his ligaments are not destroyed that only debunks your argument further. If, according to you, Housen and Ayanokouji are relative in strength and Housen stabs Koji through the hand. If Koji's hand hasn't taken damage that would only prove Koji is way more durable. Either way your argument goes out the window.
Housen is above him in terms of fighting ability
This is so wrong it's not even worth elaborating
albert is physically stronger
Proven wrong above
When Ayanokouji caught Albert fist he said he felt pain from his elbow to his torso.
Feeling the impact doesn't mean it hurt him lol. Plus in the Official TL he doesn't say he's in pain, that's your unusable Fan TL again.
However he didn't feel anything from Housen
And yet Housen can manhandle Albert. It's clearly Koji > Housen > Albert as proven more than once to you.
I never seen a statement that said Housen could out strength Albert.
I think this was already shared.


They fight in groups, they always have, just like Albert and Hiyorin restained Ayanokouji, it's not because he needed her help, that's just how Class C standard tactics are. They only held him down because Ryuuen couldn't beat him. That doesn't
I'm not even sure what to say to this. I mean you do realize the two of them, especially Hiyori, didn't actually restrain him right?
 
I agree with OP
Do you mind elaborating how so?

OP has presented a bunch of scans he wants to add to the profile for "increased justifications" but most of them are fan TLs that we can't add anyway because there is an official translation that contradicts them.

Additionally, he is presenting arguments that are not consistent with the narrative and existing feats and trying to adjust the scaling chain of the verse in ways that disregard established facts and which contradict proven scans from the Official TL of the LN.
 
They are not, Housen massacres Albert in every stat, it literally took the whole Ryuen gang (minus Ibuki) to defeat him
No, he massacres Ryuuen in stats which was stated . Albert was actually stated to be superior in a fight with similar body types. Also they never jumped him, they snuck up on him held his arm in place and he couldn't free himself, then Ryuuen beat him unconscious by himself while Ichizaki and Albert held his arm. The subreddit also had this discussion before and everyone also says Albert is stronger than Housen
Kouenji as stated in the scans prove he is physically superior in both AP and LS to them and has feats that puts him tied to a supressed and weakened Ayanokouji who out-muscled housen while injured who was stated to be superior in stats compared to Albert and Manabu
It never said he has stronger punching ability, only that he would defeat them. That's not a stats comparison bro
And we already showed you several scans on why your "thinking" is not correct, more so when you send scans contradicting your own scans
You haven't provided any scans that disprove my scans, you only called them not official while not showing the official versions with different text showing different context, I even included multiple versions. We can't use "trust me bro" as a source when I'm providing the opposite.
Brother in christ, Ayanokouji literally said he could accelerate even further and was going to, how is this an assumption???
I never said it's an assumption I said it's unquantifiable. Saying you go faster only grants you a "higher" at the end of your stat, doesn't change that they are relative like the other characters
YOU dismissed the ones disproving your points, let's get that right, this whole CRT is based on your own head canons
Headcanons don't have scans. I provided a scan for every claim I made. And they haven't been refuted with actual scans, just baseless arguing and hostility
Yeah but unlike Koji, they aren't being chased after for the entirety of the exam, they are eating, they are drinking, sleeping and not fighting unlike Koji who is just BARELY capable of doing that because he is being chased
Based on the Albert stuff this likely isn't true because everything you are saying he scans show opposite. You said houseb was superior to Albert but the scans says Albert is superior.
 
Can someone summarise the arguments for mods?
 
Can someone summarise the arguments for mods?
My argument is basically that the verse is not separated by Attack strength or durability because Ayanokouji says characters can one shot him and he can one shot them and other characters that he attack with full power and it doesn't do much damage. I believe the only stats that have shown separation by tier level is experience, lifting strength and stamina based on the many scans I listed by categories and how it proves Ayanokouji has abnormal lifting strength and stamina but characters can harm him or even one shot him and he can't one shot everyone like the current narrative implies
 
Can someone summarise the arguments for mods?
OP wants to add new scans and justifications to Ayanokouji's profile and implement a revised scaling chain for the verse. His main point is that Ayanokouji is not physically stronger than most top tiers in the verse, but just surpasses them in skill. Also that his WR key should not be above his ANHS key.

Counterpoints are that all the scans OP is trying to add are from Fan Translations which don't align with the Official Translations and furthermore are contradictory to feats and statements from throughout the LNs. As for Ayanokouji being physically above everyone else in the verse, this has been established a multitude of times in this thread and many others.

As for the WR vs ANHS key, there are scans in this thread which show in multiple different volumes Ayanokouji directly confirming he is much weaker currently than at his peak in the WR.
 
Counterpoints are that all the scans OP is trying to add are from Fan Translations which don't align with the Official Translations and furthermore are contradictory to feats and statements from throughout the LNs. As for Ayanokouji being physically above everyone else in the verse, this has been established a multitude of times in this thread and many others.
I believe this is where the stalemate lies. I believe the proper thing to do would be to post the official scans to negate each one instead of just saying it's invalid, that doesn't help anyone get the scans their looking for
 
I believe this is where the stalemate lies. I believe the proper thing to do would be to post the official scans to negate each one instead of just saying it's invalid, that doesn't help anyone get the scans their looking for
I'll try and show all of them but there are a ton of Fan TL scans that have been posted in this thread and most don't include the volume and chapter to help find them so bear with me. Myself and Zetsu have already done this for many of them in this thread but I'll present this as best as I can to show the OTL vs Fan TL side by side.

I'll have to make this into multiple posts since VSBW won't let me keep linking back to your previous posts forever in one message.


The OTL says that while Non White Room people can be talented in certain areas the White Room aimed to make someone skilled in all areas. The "talent they could never produce" refers to the kind of people at ANHS like Kouenji and his personality.



This is an OTL scan. In the scan Koji says he is now going to go even faster, showing he wasn't going all out like you claim.



Here we again confirm that your scaling chain of Koji = Kouenji = Albert in physical strength is broken because Koji confirms Kouenji is evenly matched with him and Kouenji is FAR ABOVE Albert.

This argument was that since 9 y/o Koji was weaker than professional adult fighters and attacked their weakpoints, therefore ANHS Koji is physically weaker than Albert despite the evidence to the contrary? Just above we establish that Koji is at least equal to Kouenji who is above Albert. He is also above Housen who is above Albert.

It's worse than that. Ayanokouji overpowered Housen with a knife through his hand. So the muscles and ligaments in his hand are all partly destroyed. Nevertheless he was able to completely overpower Housen's strength with that hand. Since Housen is well above Albert in terms of strength it makes the claim that Albert > Koji totally false.



He can't completely destroy a steel elevator door in one attack but can he make a hole in it. That's textbook wall level.


He coughed...
 
He isn't immune to pain and she stabs him. Idk what the point here is?

That isn't what he said. Ayanokouji never says that he can't take more hits. He says it isn't wise to underestimate someone whose strength he doesn't know.

He was never attacking Ryuuen at full force in this fight.


Not what he said. He didn't say Ryuuen could critically injure him but that he wouldn't take damage by blocking.

Above, he wasn't trying to KO Ryuuen yet.




The problem here is Ayanokouji's goal is to stall Tsukishiro for time without him realizing he is stalling. Plus after several minutes of fighting Tsukishiro says "you will need to catch your breath any minute now" meaning Koji isn't even yet breathing hard but he implies he will be soon.
 
Yes, again not sure what this is trying to prove.







I covered a lot of this now. You can also look at these prior posts where I brought up some of your other specific points
Firstly, I don’t think there are any real proposed changes in this CRT, just changed justifications. I’m not really sure what this is trying to achieve but I’ll respond anyway. There is a lot wrong with this, so I am going to fully disagree from the start. This shows a severe lack of understanding of the verse and the scaling behind it. Zetsu has already commented on much of this so I’ll just focus on some other areas he didn’t cover as in depth.

However based on the below I would request that this thread is closed and that you stop trying to push these changes as they are being repeatedly proven to be false in the context of the verse
or
It's worse than that. Ayanokouji overpowered Housen with a knife through his hand.
or
Ok so even if we can't assume that you do realize if his ligaments are not destroyed that only debunks your argument further. If, according to you, Housen and Ayanokouji are relative in strength and Housen stabs Koji through the hand. If Koji's hand hasn't taken damage that would only prove Koji is way more durable. Either way your argument goes out the window.
 
Every single scan you listed is the same scans i used. Every single one lol

I'll try and show all of them but there are a ton of Fan TL scans that have been posted in this thread and most don't include the volume and chapter to help find them so bear with me. Myself and Zetsu have already done this for many of them in this thread but I'll present this as best as I can to show the OTL vs Fan TL side by side.
I'll have to make this into multiple posts since VSBW won't let me keep linking back to your previous posts forever in one message.



The OTL says that while Non White Room people can be talented in certain areas the White Room aimed to make someone skilled in all areas. The "talent they could never produce" refers to the kind of people at ANHS like Kouenji and his personality.

The first scan you linked says the same thing as the scan i provided so that proves my scans are indeed valid. And he isn't talking about personality. he said "talent" which is physical ability(which I will explain is different than physical strength). He is referring to Koenji having natural gifts. Talent isn't a personality which is why he references sports and academics. not sure where you get personality from.

The albert dura scan you gave also says he dealt minimal damage with his punch validating my point. Just like the first one.
This is an OTL scan. In the scan Koji says he is now going to go even faster, showing he wasn't going all out like you claim.
He says this race is the first time he ran seriously including the white room. If we will get any progress you have to be genuine, he is clearly going all out, going faster doesnt negate the effort he is putting in.


Here we again confirm that your scaling chain of Koji = Kouenji = Albert in physical strength is broken because Koji confirms Kouenji is evenly matched with him and Kouenji is FAR ABOVE Albert.

You still aren't understanding the difference between "physical strength" and "physical ability". He says "the two of us really were evenly matched in PHYSICAL STRENGTH, then mentions Koenji's ENTIRE physical ability. including fighting ability, athleticism, flexibility, coordination, and balance. Which is why he said right after than calling him an "Ultra High School Student" isn't enough to describe how talented he is(which goes back to the first reply i said about the school having talented people with physical abilities the WR cant produce). It also proves my point again that Ayanokouji has non white room comparables like that Tsukishiro point made. You want to downplay Albert by using Koenji but it just further proves that the Ayanokouji is quite even in most aspects with different characters while superior to all in experience.
This argument was that since 9 y/o Koji was weaker than professional adult fighters and attacked their weakpoints, therefore ANHS Koji is physically weaker than Albert despite the evidence to the contrary? Just above we establish that Koji is at least equal to Kouenji who is above Albert. He is also above Housen who is above Albert.
Nothing was established as I just proved this incorrect once again. Physical strength is not the same as physical ability, which is what i keep trying to make you guys understand. Physical strength and Physical Ability is 2 different things.
 

Already debunked this point about physical ability
He can't completely destroy a steel elevator door in one attack but can he make a hole in it. That's textbook wall level.
He never said he can, he said he might be able to. Thats only valid for a "possible". Its not definitive so you can't scale it.
What does this Manabu statement prove? Yes he can go faster but that doesn't negate the fact he said he ran seriously for the first time in his life. He only realized that he could go faster while doing it, which in full context proves he was doing what he told Manabu to do. Go all out. Also and why is this scan valid when you post it but called a fan translation when I use it? i posted this exact same scan and you called it fan made
He coughed...
He isn't immune to pain and she stabs him. Idk what the point here is?
My point is that im showing a consistent theme of characters being able to harm him or cause pain regardless if they use heavy force or slight force, because everyone in this verse is around the same physical scaling and only are seperated by their experience and or physical lifting strength. If Koji was 9-Band Suzuna 9-C she shouldn't be able to harm him with a playful punch and he wouldn't emphasize and highlight it if it didn't really hurt him.
That isn't what he said. Ayanokouji never says that he can't take more hits. He says it isn't wise to underestimate someone whose strength he doesn't know.
He was never attacking Ryuuen at full force in this fight.

Yes he was, and everytime he hit Ryuuen harder than normal he would emphasize by calling it "heavy" or stating how he is by tanking such a hard punch, it would be pointless to highlight it otherwise. You cant ignore parts that make him relative him then highlight others from the same scan.
Not what he said. He didn't say Ryuuen could critically injure him but that he wouldn't take damage by blocking.
Im stating these things verbatim with what's written, we can't say he didn't say it when it's right there. That's headcanon
Above, he wasn't trying to KO Ryuuen yet.
Doesnt deny my point and I already says Koji can one shot Ryuuen but not Albert who Kouji and Albert say is above Ryuuen.



The problem here is Ayanokouji's goal is to stall Tsukishiro for time without him realizing he is stalling. Plus after several minutes of fighting Tsukishiro says "you will need to catch your breath any minute now" meaning Koji isn't even yet breathing hard but he implies he will be soon.

The first scan you provided Ayanokouji is saying if he "trades" with Shiba he would be "stopped" by him then says Shiba has the same power as his own. Which is the same exact scan as mine where I said Shiba has the same AP as Koji. My point was proven again.


Just being honest, every single scan you guys deem as "official" say the exact same things as my scans but was somehow deemed "headcanons". So im even more validated by the response. I will wait for mods to comment and approve of the scaling chain changes.
 
Last edited:
Examples:

1.) He easily dodges an attack and grab from Manabu Horikita, but stated his kick could one shot him.
(Manabu is a 5th dan in karate and 4th dan in judo, which would make him ima high tier, this coupled with the fact Ayanokouji said he could one shot him).
Let's not forget this is the same volume where Kiyotaka introduced himself as a mere normal high schooler with his background even leading to a middle school and was even performing plot deception (a technique where a character deceives the reader).

In reality, Kiyotaka managed to stop Housen who was equipped with a knife at once with a severed hand to the point where Housen couldn't even budge him forward. You are simply proposing an AP =/= Durability here which in fact, is just bad to prove in a verse with characters having human bodies.
LMFAO, why do people still use this after Y2V11?

In Y2V11, Albert compared Kiyotaka to Housen in terms of strength, and that the weight in Housen's attacks was almost the same to that of Kiyotaka, which is correct.
image.png

image.png

Kiyotaka transcends the concept of heaviness or lightness, and even if he's going "all out" and "not holding back", he's possibly still holding back, because the source of his strength is narratively said to be not that simple, and he can go beyond and deliver damage above his weight of the arm allows him to.

So no, this statement is invalid, Albert never really took an attack from a Kiyotaka who was actually not holding back.
3.) Stated that pressure points wouldn't always work on Albert due to his superior genetics.
  • He admits here that he is inferior physically to Albert who never trained but worked out his body get muscular and build endurance, This means depending on how inferior he is physically, even attacking weak points won't work.
Albert possesses crazy amount of muscle mass, yes. But nowhere in the text you have highlighted or the one I can read says that Kiyotaka outright declared Albert as a physically superior individual.

Secondly, he's talking about the nature of pressure points in general, it's not about Albert. Pressure Points use the application of pain and attack the endurance of a character rather than conventional durability. If the character has high endurance, then they can endure a hit to the pressure points as well.
4.) Stated the blow he received from Ryuen was "heavy", but suppressed the pain.
(Ryuuen is a self trained fighter, so he would be considered mid tier as he doesn't have the training someone like Manabu has, yet he was able to hit Ayanokouji hard enough he registered it as "heavy" meaning it likely hurt, he just suppressed the pain of it due to his endurance training.
What? The scan reads that RYUUEN was the one who RECEIVED the blow lmfao. It's just a scan to say that Ryuuen had received a "heavy" blow but still was able to stand up well and not be really disoriented too much. Here's the full one:
image.png

By the way, don't misunderstand, Kiyotaka never used his full strength against Ryuuen, he himself said that he could oneshot him, but that he didn't want to:
image.png

5.) Instantly knew Shiba had the same striking power after dodging a punch from him, and said Shiba can one shot him.
(Directly states Shiba is equal to him in AP and that his own striking power can one shot himself)
"Stop me in my tracks" doesn't mean the same thing as him being able to one shot him.

Plus, Kiyotaka compared Shiba's attack's attacking power to the attack of his own, and the attacks he had delivered weren't at his full strength either.

Crazily, he stated that he needed Kiryuuin to keep Shiba busy only for 1 or 2 seconds, meaning that if she could keep him busy, he would be taking on Tsukishiro in the meantime, the same Tsukishiro who roughly equals Shiba in physical ability, and that means that Shiba/Tsukishiro vs Kiyotaka is a 1/2 second matchup lmfao. THAT is the difference in their true abilities:
image.png

6.) Stated Ibuki and Horikita were equals physically without ever seeing them fight.
(this is further validated by his statements about both of them at different points in the story that they both can heavily damage him if they struck his head due to their athleticism)
Yes, he has incredible Information Analysis ability listed on his profile and he can completely give someone's measure of abilities without seeing them in a fight.

Both are highly irrelevant as statements and only amount to "plot deception" or an improper narrative giving.

In reality, Kiyotaka stopped both Ibuki and Suzune at once while using only a single hand, and Ichika, who was highly weakened in Y2V4 literally took a punch from Ibuki on the face and that only managed to shake her up.
image.png

And a kick from Ibuki couldn't even knock down a weakened Suzune:
image.png


And I don't think I need to mention the difference between Ichika and Kiyotaka. Kiyotaka scales MASSIVELY above Ichika to the point where he toyed with her, blitzed her, knocked the air out of her, opposed her strength with an extreme superiority and literally let her go and proved his levels in Y2V7, and he even DIRECTLY cleared it up with her that the differences between them were big:
image.png


Either way, the Suzune one is an obvious GAG scene so...
7.) Had a stalemate in Tug Of War with Koenji.
(Koenji is not even a white room student and is lazy and he is narratively equals with Ayanokouji)
I don't disagree with the fact that Kouenji isn't a White Room student, but that's literally KOUENJI, a character who's trained on levels which are as crazy as White Room.
8.) Was nearly blitzed by Nanase after she switched personalities and had to use what he calls "emergency evasive action" which means he was being serious.
(Ayanokouji was watching her the entire time to even notice her personality switch but was still nearly blitzed by her and got serious)
(This would also make her a high tier since her experiences are lower but similar to Manabu)
I don't know where it does even state that she nearly blitzed him lmfao. Are we even reading the same novels?

All that scan means is that Nanase had just improved her abilities to the point where he would need to put at least some effort from that point on, otherwise he was really just toying with no efforts in the entire fight.

Plus, I don't even want to go against the "knock out adult men which would include himself" argument. 😭 It's so wild because it is literally just a general statement and doesn't even apply to him. It's even funnier because he uses the article "an" which even refers to the fact that he's talking about the general adult.

NO, I'M NOT EVEN EXPLAINING WHY IT'S WRONG. 😭
LMFAO, the scan you have attached directly states:
All right, I'm going to go even faster.
This means that he could faster, and that means he still wasn't going all out. Before he could, a student fell into his way.
"Ayanokouji "Hidden Strength"

Many people believe from this statement that Ayanokouji is weaker at ANHS than he is in the White Room, but that's physically impossible genetically. Ayanokouji is talking about his deteriorating stamina from the intense workouts from the white room, it has nothing to do with having superior AP or durability. White Room students were trained to be superior to Olympic athletes, and smarter than the smartest students at Japanese universities. This is because every teacher was hand picked for not being ordinary with their teachings.
Bro what? Kiyotaka in ANHS is far weaker than his self in the White Room. And it is probably common sense, and you don't even need that statement that you grow weaker if you aren't hitting the gym daily. 😭 But yes, that statement is fully correct and you have given ZERO reasoning to prove why it's wrong.
The slight difference between characters that can be argued would be their lifting strength as it was explicitly stated that Ayanokouji didn't want to reveal it. He was capable of catching Albert's fist, although he still took damage, crushed Ichizaki's fist with his grip, could gauge his own score on the grip strength test to 100kg by force, and has stated this is the strength he didn't want to reveal it when he was stuck in an elevator.
Kiyotaka literally equals Kouenji in tug-of-war and stated that if it wasn't for his body weight, then he could have won, meaning that his LS was still a little bit higher than Kouenji's and this means that Kouenji, a character who can swing extremely heavy boars with relative ease would be slightly upscaled by Kiyotaka and thus, Kiyotaka not only goes far beyond 100 kg as his LS but also goes insanely above any other character in COTE.

In fact, a much higher feat than any of the feats you listed is Ichika being able to fracture Kushida's arm which is an accepted feat by the way, and the same Ichika got brutally mogged in LS by Kiyotaka in Y2V7 as well.
Attack Potency/Durability
This is where the scaling chain is mostly confused as many people believe Ayanokouji outscales characters AP and Durability because he is "holding back"(which I debunked above). The only character who has statements which place him above all characters in terms of durability is Albert due to Ayanokouji himself states has genetics that no pure Japanese person has, and has trained and was demonstrated and described in detail during the fight, Ayanokouji did not defeat Albert with brute strength, used weak points specifically because of his durable body, which he still insists wont always work.
Albert is not above Kiyotaka due to the Y2V11 statement supporting the fact that Kiyotaka wasn't at his full power.
White Room Key vs ANHS Key

Ayanokouji ANHS key is his strongest key as it was never stated he gets weaker after leaving the White Room.
NO. ANHS Kiyotaka is getting stronger time by time as he works out in the gym, but yes, he does get weaker and he indirectly confirmed it to Mashima without needing to mention about the White Room and just mentioning it as "where I was before".
This DOESN'T help in establishing superiority of ANHS Kiyotaka over White Room Kiyotaka in any way though?

And where the hell is it written that he couldn't hurt them even when wielding a baton? It's literally nowhere. Instead, he said that he would be hitting the weak points because BROTHER, HE WAS literally fighting 6 FIGHTERS at ONCE. This means that he would need to get it over with quickly, so any way you see it, hitting weak points is the optimal way.

Please interpret the scenes correctly at least.
I went and found multiple versions of scans to prove that there is no errors and that Ayanokōuji doesn't outscale the verse physically, and that its only experience involved with a bit of abnornal lifting strength.

White Room Koji

Talent =/= Abilities. You can have talent of all sorts but it doesn't matter if you are not polishing it.

Plus, this statement doesn't mean crap. White Room gives overall superiority. It doesn't matter if a character is superior in one of two aspects if a White Room subject completely demolishes them.

Plus, you need to actually think this through and know that giving examples of intellect, academics, athletics, durable body, fighting and running, and a general talent statement doesn't make it enough for you to prove your non-difference in physical abilities between White Room subjects and non-White Roomers.
It's just your interpretation and no part of the scan supports. In reality, talking with common sense, repeatedly slamming a part of your body can create microfractures in bones which can lead to re-calcification making them stronger, or exercising creates microtears in muscles, making them stronger.
THIS IS SUCH A HEADCANON OF ALL TIME.

"Ayanokouji views adults such as his white room instructions as superior in "size, strength and skill until he was 9 years old where the upped his training even more" - No, just no, yes they are superior in size but by the age of 9, he defeated all of his instructors in both strength (a 9 y/o btw) and skill:
image.png


(also, a statement showing that pure physical strength was enough to beat the instructors)

Bro. 😭 When you are getting weaker, both striking and lifting strength are affected. And, Kiyotaka's striking strength equals his AP, so yes, his AP is also decreasing. Durability-wise, he's getting weaker too because he would begin to lose the muscle mass and the calcification of his bones would gradually be getting weaker with time.

Kiyotaka is NOT a natural genius; he literally adapts with time and starts with knowledge application. If you don't understand that, then you need to start reading novels.
But yes, here:
image.png



So yes, this thread is almost completely wrong because:
  • It assumes that the White Room/Kouenji's training advantage is due to narratives mainly.
  • It assumes that some areas where non-WR students are superior to WR subjects means total superiority, which is obviously false.
  • A large part of the criticism in the OP comes from statements which are completely proven wrong later on or are plot deception or in a GAG scene.
 
Can someone summarise the arguments for mods?
The OP is basically using arguments from GAG scenes or arguments from scenes which get completely proven otherwise later on in the series in different encounters between characters to establish that the verse doesn't go in an AP = Durability relation (he is doing it unknowingly btw).

But from what I read, he's just trying to establish that the gaps in AP and Durability in the verse are narrow which is obviously wrong too because every statement he used has actually gone completely differently later on in the series and doesn't match the feats and the outcomes of the combat between characters.
 
The OP is basically using arguments from GAG scenes or arguments from scenes which get completely proven otherwise later on in the series in different encounters between characters to establish that the verse doesn't go in an AP = Durability relation (he is doing it unknowingly btw).

But from what I read, he's just trying to establish that the gaps in AP and Durability in the verse are narrow which is obviously wrong too because every statement he used has actually gone completely differently later on in the series and doesn't match the feats and the outcomes of the combat between characters.
Despite making largely the same arguments I did you managed to explain everything much better than I did lol.

👍
 
Let's not forget this is the same volume where Kiyotaka introduced himself as a mere normal high schooler with his background even leading to a middle school and was even performing plot deception (a technique where a character deceives the reader).

In reality, Kiyotaka managed to stop Housen who was equipped with a knife at once with a severed hand to the point where Housen couldn't even budge him forward. You are simply proposing an AP =/= Durability here which in fact, is just bad to prove in a verse with characters having human bodies.

LMFAO, why do people still use this after Y2V11?

In Y2V11, Albert compared Kiyotaka to Housen in terms of strength, and that the weight in Housen's attacks was almost the same to that of Kiyotaka, which is correct.
image.png

image.png

Kiyotaka transcends the concept of heaviness or lightness, and even if he's going "all out" and "not holding back", he's possibly still holding back, because the source of his strength is narratively said to be not that simple, and he can go beyond and deliver damage above his weight of the arm allows him to.

So no, this statement is invalid, Albert never really took an attack from a Kiyotaka who was actually not holding back.

Albert possesses crazy amount of muscle mass, yes. But nowhere in the text you have highlighted or the one I can read says that Kiyotaka outright declared Albert as a physically superior individual.

Secondly, he's talking about the nature of pressure points in general, it's not about Albert. Pressure Points use the application of pain and attack the endurance of a character rather than conventional durability. If the character has high endurance, then they can endure a hit to the pressure points as well.

What? The scan reads that RYUUEN was the one who RECEIVED the blow lmfao. It's just a scan to say that Ryuuen had received a "heavy" blow but still was able to stand up well and not be really disoriented too much. Here's the full one:
image.png

By the way, don't misunderstand, Kiyotaka never used his full strength against Ryuuen, he himself said that he could oneshot him, but that he didn't want to:
image.png


"Stop me in my tracks" doesn't mean the same thing as him being able to one shot him.

Plus, Kiyotaka compared Shiba's attack's attacking power to the attack of his own, and the attacks he had delivered weren't at his full strength either.

Crazily, he stated that he needed Kiryuuin to keep Shiba busy only for 1 or 2 seconds, meaning that if she could keep him busy, he would be taking on Tsukishiro in the meantime, the same Tsukishiro who roughly equals Shiba in physical ability, and that means that Shiba/Tsukishiro vs Kiyotaka is a 1/2 second matchup lmfao. THAT is the difference in their true abilities:
image.png


Yes, he has incredible Information Analysis ability listed on his profile and he can completely give someone's measure of abilities without seeing them in a fight.

Both are highly irrelevant as statements and only amount to "plot deception" or an improper narrative giving.

In reality, Kiyotaka stopped both Ibuki and Suzune at once while using only a single hand, and Ichika, who was highly weakened in Y2V4 literally took a punch from Ibuki on the face and that only managed to shake her up.
image.png

And a kick from Ibuki couldn't even knock down a weakened Suzune:
image.png


And I don't think I need to mention the difference between Ichika and Kiyotaka. Kiyotaka scales MASSIVELY above Ichika to the point where he toyed with her, blitzed her, knocked the air out of her, opposed her strength with an extreme superiority and literally let her go and proved his levels in Y2V7, and he even DIRECTLY cleared it up with her that the differences between them were big:
image.png


Either way, the Suzune one is an obvious GAG scene so...

I don't disagree with the fact that Kouenji isn't a White Room student, but that's literally KOUENJI, a character who's trained on levels which are as crazy as White Room.

I don't know where it does even state that she nearly blitzed him lmfao. Are we even reading the same novels?

All that scan means is that Nanase had just improved her abilities to the point where he would need to put at least some effort from that point on, otherwise he was really just toying with no efforts in the entire fight.

Plus, I don't even want to go against the "knock out adult men which would include himself" argument. 😭 It's so wild because it is literally just a general statement and doesn't even apply to him. It's even funnier because he uses the article "an" which even refers to the fact that he's talking about the general adult.

NO, I'M NOT EVEN EXPLAINING WHY IT'S WRONG. 😭

LMFAO, the scan you have attached directly states:

This means that he could faster, and that means he still wasn't going all out. Before he could, a student fell into his way.

Bro what? Kiyotaka in ANHS is far weaker than his self in the White Room. And it is probably common sense, and you don't even need that statement that you grow weaker if you aren't hitting the gym daily. 😭 But yes, that statement is fully correct and you have given ZERO reasoning to prove why it's wrong.

Kiyotaka literally equals Kouenji in tug-of-war and stated that if it wasn't for his body weight, then he could have won, meaning that his LS was still a little bit higher than Kouenji's and this means that Kouenji, a character who can swing extremely heavy boars with relative ease would be slightly upscaled by Kiyotaka and thus, Kiyotaka not only goes far beyond 100 kg as his LS but also goes insanely above any other character in COTE.

In fact, a much higher feat than any of the feats you listed is Ichika being able to fracture Kushida's arm which is an accepted feat by the way, and the same Ichika got brutally mogged in LS by Kiyotaka in Y2V7 as well.

Albert is not above Kiyotaka due to the Y2V11 statement supporting the fact that Kiyotaka wasn't at his full power.

NO. ANHS Kiyotaka is getting stronger time by time as he works out in the gym, but yes, he does get weaker and he indirectly confirmed it to Mashima without needing to mention about the White Room and just mentioning it as "where I was before".

This DOESN'T help in establishing superiority of ANHS Kiyotaka over White Room Kiyotaka in any way though?

And where the hell is it written that he couldn't hurt them even when wielding a baton? It's literally nowhere. Instead, he said that he would be hitting the weak points because BROTHER, HE WAS literally fighting 6 FIGHTERS at ONCE. This means that he would need to get it over with quickly, so any way you see it, hitting weak points is the optimal way.

Please interpret the scenes correctly at least.

Talent =/= Abilities. You can have talent of all sorts but it doesn't matter if you are not polishing it.

Plus, this statement doesn't mean crap. White Room gives overall superiority. It doesn't matter if a character is superior in one of two aspects if a White Room subject completely demolishes them.

Plus, you need to actually think this through and know that giving examples of intellect, academics, athletics, durable body, fighting and running, and a general talent statement doesn't make it enough for you to prove your non-difference in physical abilities between White Room subjects and non-White Roomers.

It's just your interpretation and no part of the scan supports. In reality, talking with common sense, repeatedly slamming a part of your body can create microfractures in bones which can lead to re-calcification making them stronger, or exercising creates microtears in muscles, making them stronger.

THIS IS SUCH A HEADCANON OF ALL TIME.

"Ayanokouji views adults such as his white room instructions as superior in "size, strength and skill until he was 9 years old where the upped his training even more" - No, just no, yes they are superior in size but by the age of 9, he defeated all of his instructors in both strength (a 9 y/o btw) and skill:
image.png


(also, a statement showing that pure physical strength was enough to beat the instructors)


Bro. 😭 When you are getting weaker, both striking and lifting strength are affected. And, Kiyotaka's striking strength equals his AP, so yes, his AP is also decreasing. Durability-wise, he's getting weaker too because he would begin to lose the muscle mass and the calcification of his bones would gradually be getting weaker with time.

Kiyotaka is NOT a natural genius; he literally adapts with time and starts with knowledge application. If you don't understand that, then you need to start reading novels.
But yes, here:
image.png



So yes, this thread is almost completely wrong because:
  • It assumes that the White Room/Kouenji's training advantage is due to narratives mainly.
  • It assumes that some areas where non-WR students are superior to WR subjects means total superiority, which is obviously false.
  • A large part of the criticism in the OP comes from statements which are completely proven wrong later on or are plot deception or in a GAG scene.


I went and found multiple versions of scans to prove that there is no errors and that Ayanokōuji doesn't outscale the verse physically, and that its only experience involved with a bit of abnornal lifting strength.

White Room Koji



ANHS Koji

As you can see there is a consistent theme with the verse as nobody besides Albert his statements that would put their durability above every other character due to his superior genetics being half black. Which is something he was likely taught when learning about USA.

Superior Lifting Strength

As I mentioned before this is where Ayanokouji mostly stands apart from the verse as this, his stamina, his kinetic vision, and his White Room Experience are his best physical attributes apart from his intelligence. The only people shown comparably to Ayanokouji here is Albert and possibly Housen.

Upgrades

' Note: Now I didn't only find things for the scaling chain, i also found more stataments to contextualize that the strength gap in the verse comes from experience, not physical capability as Ayanokouji and Tsukishiro stated there are non white room people as talented as White Room members, and some the WR cant even produce. like Albert.


Fighting tactics


This would mean they would all be relative that's my point bro.

Neither does Ayanokouji which is what he said himself due to his genetics. But in a fight Manabu would win, the same way Ayanokouji did. Physically stronger doesn't equal better fighter .

But that's the premise of my post, the current narrative isn't consistent with what I posted.

That's assumption without statements to support it. All we can go off of is that he ran with full effort and at the end said he could go faster, which we can't quantify to a number, so I think it would likely get a "likely higher" for his travel speed

But that's what I'm not understanding, I posted dozens of statements and you dismissed the ones I posted?

But every student is also doing this he isn't the only person surviving on the island. I wouldn't say Ichinose has superhuman stamina.


Thanks bud
Already debunked this point about physical ability

He never said he can, he said he might be able to. Thats only valid for a "possible". Its not definitive so you can't scale it.

What does this Manabu statement prove? Yes he can go faster but that doesn't negate the fact he said he ran seriously for the first time in his life. He only realized that he could go faster while doing it, which in full context proves he was doing what he told Manabu to do. Go all out. Also and why is this scan valid when you post it but called a fan translation when I use it? i posted this exact same scan and you called it fan made


My point is that im showing a consistent theme of characters being able to harm him or cause pain regardless if they use heavy force or slight force, because everyone in this verse is around the same physical scaling and only are seperated by their experience and or physical lifting strength. If Koji was 9-Band Suzuna 9-C she shouldn't be able to harm him with a playful punch and he wouldn't emphasize and highlight it if it didn't really hurt him.


Yes he was, and everytime he hit Ryuuen harder than normal he would emphasize by calling it "heavy" or stating how he is by tanking such a hard punch, it would be pointless to highlight it otherwise. You cant ignore parts that make him relative him then highlight others from the same scan.

Im stating these things verbatim with what's written, we can't say he didn't say it when it's right there. That's headcanon

Doesnt deny my point and I already says Koji can one shot Ryuuen but not Albert who Kouji and Albert say is above Ryuuen.

The first scan you provided Ayanokouji is saying if he "trades" with Shiba he would be "stopped" by him then says Shiba has the same power as his own. Which is the same exact scan as mine where I said Shiba has the same AP as Koji. My point was proven again.


Just being honest, every single scan you guys deem as "official" say the exact same things as my scans but was somehow deemed "headcanons". So im even more validated by the response. I will wait for mods to comment and approve of the scaling chain changes.

I responded to all of these points already. The overall disconnect is people think physical strength is the same as physical ability when it is not as the definition and breakdown of both state. The only difference by tiering is their lifting strength, stamina and experience or talent level, which Tuskishiro and Ayanokouji state can be equal or superior to White Room in certain aspects as academics, sports or natural talent.

Ayanokouji hiding his true self from regular students in regular classes doesn't mean he is hiding himself in combat when he is explicitly stating the opposite every time he does it, even in the scans being sent by you guys, which is where I'm confused because I'm proving more than context I'm basically expaining the entire character with proof and it's being dismissed
 
Despite making largely the same arguments I did you managed to explain everything much better than I did lol.

👍
😭 Brooo...

I responded to all of these points already. The overall disconnect is people think physical strength is the same as physical ability when it is not as the definition and breakdown of both state. The only difference by tiering is their lifting strength, stamina and experience or talent level, which Tuskishiro and Ayanokouji state can be equal or superior to White Room in certain aspects as academics, sports or natural talent.

Ayanokouji hiding his true self from regular students in regular classes doesn't mean he is hiding himself in combat when he is explicitly stating the opposite every time he does it, even in the scans being sent by you guys, which is where I'm confused because I'm proving more than context I'm basically expaining the entire character with proof and it's being dismissed
I can't care lesser about what Google definition says about physical strength or ability. I have already gone on these things many times that COTE, or for that matter, any series doesn't go with the exact terminologies. They can use the term "force" to describe AP which is mainly energy or work. Authors aren't meant to be pro-scaling.

And no, I already gave enough feats to prove the massive AP difference between characters and already gave counter proofs to all the stuff which you regarded as AP similarities.

I already mentioned why I think that Kiyotaka wasn't giving it his all against Albert using the Y2V11 scan, and in fact, even Albert himself agreed with that afterwards, so yes, all this thread brings is mostly nothing. A lot of these points are something I used to see daily in literal YT comments and most of them original from a non-scaler perspective.

As of this point, Kinugasa-sensei has managed to indirectly retcon or directly go against almost every scaling incoherence which could somehow be made out in COTE scaling some years ago, that's what he actually started doing after the interview where he stated that he would actually focus on COTE combat aspects more.
 
any series doesn't go with the exact terminologies. They can use the term "force" to describe AP which is mainly energy or work. Authors aren't meant to be pro-scaling.
AP is measured in joules, because it's simplified (even to the point where some people just take the total energy and think that it's usable as it is - one example is in this thread, no offense meant towards anyone). The actual stuff that determines the damage is impact force and pressure.
I can't care lesser about what Google definition says about physical strength or ability.
You definitely should, unless you want to get a character as high as possible based on misinterpreted terms.
 
AP is measured in joules, because it's simplified (even to the point where some people just take the total energy and think that it's usable as it is - one example is in this thread, no offense meant towards anyone). The actual stuff that determines the damage is impact force and pressure.

You definitely should, unless you want to get a character as high as possible based on misinterpreted terms.
You are trying to push realism when the wiki doesn't work that way, can you please stop trying to insist on that?

Zefra among others have explained to you why that doesn't work
 
You are trying to push realism when the wiki doesn't work that way, can you please stop trying to insist on that?
If you don't like realism then maybe don't use the Potential Energy formula to calculate the energy in the first place. You're using a value that's based on a character jumping down an object. It results in humans being Street Level (thousands of joules) according to the same logic.

I have genuinely no idea why you wouldn't want to get some other durability feat (for example taking the 29.4 kilojoule and using the Dura = AP).

You don't even need to go too much in detail. It's literally only one more step to make it more accurate and you're making tons of excuses only to justify the 49.3 kilojoules when you know very well that it's just incorrect to use it.

The original claim was this:
Not to mention Nanase scales to 4.6 KJ AP while Koji is 49,3 KJ in durability which would make no sense that she would've made dmg to him
You're straight up taking the entire 49.3 kJ value and assuming that he'd be able to withstand it in a punch despite almost no part of his body neccesarily being tough enough to withstand that kind of energy only due to the fact that the energy is handled differently when you fall compared to when you're punched.
 
Last edited:
If you don't like realism then maybe don't use the Potential Energy formula to calculate the energy in the first place. You're using a value that's based on a character jumping down an object. It results in humans being Street Level (thousands of joules) according to the same logic.

I have genuinely no idea why you wouldn't want to get some other durability feat (for example taking the 29.4 kilojoule and using the Dura = AP).

You don't even need to go too much in detail. It's literally only one more step to make it more accurate and you're making tons of excuses only to justify the 49.3 kilojoules when you know very well that it's just incorrect to use it.

The original claim was this:

You're straight up taking the entire 49.3 kJ value and assuming that he'd be able to withstand it in a punch despite almost no part of his body neccesarily being tough enough to withstand that kind of energy only due to the fact that the energy is handled differently when you fall compared to when you're punched.
The. wiki. does. not. work. the. way. you. are. saying

Give up
 
The. wiki. does. not. work. the. way. you. are. saying

Give up
In that case you're abusing the fact that this wiki doesn't explicitly state "energy density matters in cases like falling from a high place" to the point where you incorrectly take the 49.3 kilojoules just to get him that high then. If you know that it's completely wrong then why do you keep using it?

The wiki only says something like this:

"For example, if a character withstands an explosion as their primary durability justification than the energy of the explosion that they tanked has hit them over a large surface area of their body. However if all of that energy were focused in an extremely narrow area of effect such as the width of a blade or the point of a needle - then the energy would more than likely pass through the character's body much easier. Even a weaker attack than the aforementioned explosion could do more visible damage by being concentrated.
This can also be an issue with giant-sized characters being harmed by somebody much smaller than them. A bee can inflict pain on a human without possessing attack potency anywhere comparable to a human's durability.
"

A bee attacks lower surface area than a fist is.

A punch has lower surface area than the surface area which you use to land from a high place.
 
I am not indulging you any further, it's getting annoying atp since you can't get it through your head
 
I am not indulging you any further, it's getting annoying atp since you can't get it through your head
Look at what I said for a moment, please. You are genuinely wrong and as incorrect as much as you can be in this case. Even in the "the wiki does not work like this part". The only problem is that it's not explicitly stated. It's stated as a general example.

Like... what am I wrong in at this point? I checked both the physics and the rules to make sure I didn't say anything wrong.

In that case you're abusing the fact that this wiki doesn't explicitly state "energy density matters in cases like falling from a high place" to the point where you incorrectly take the 49.3 kilojoules just to get him that high then. If you know that it's completely wrong then why do you keep using it?

The wiki only says something like this:

"For example, if a character withstands an explosion as their primary durability justification than the energy of the explosion that they tanked has hit them over a large surface area of their body. However if all of that energy were focused in an extremely narrow area of effect such as the width of a blade or the point of a needle - then the energy would more than likely pass through the character's body much easier. Even a weaker attack than the aforementioned explosion could do more visible damage by being concentrated.
This can also be an issue with giant-sized characters being harmed by somebody much smaller than them. A bee can inflict pain on a human without possessing attack potency anywhere comparable to a human's durability.
"

A bee attacks lower surface area than a fist is.

A punch has lower surface area than the surface area which you use to land from a high place.
 
Last edited:
If you don't like realism then maybe don't use the Potential Energy formula to calculate the energy in the first place. You're using a value that's based on a character jumping down an object. It results in humans being Street Level (thousands of joules) according to the same logic.
We geniuely consider bones to be able to tank up to 9 kj, so yeah, we treat human to be capable to, in some circumnstances, tank (at least survive without massive damage) up to thousands of joules.
 
We geniuely consider bones to be able to tank up to 9 kj, so yeah, we treat human to be capable to, in some circumnstances, tank (at least survive without massive damage) up to thousands of joules.
I don't deny that, but you wouldn't scale all parts to 9 kj. Those 9 kJ would only apply for one bone and it would still damage it to some extent.

I was replying to this the whole time:

"Not to mention Nanase scales to 4.6 KJ AP while Koji is 49,3 KJ in durability which would make no sense that she would've made dmg to him"

And that was using energy from falling and scaled it to the 49.3 kilojoules as if it's regular durability that applies to all parts of his body.
 
I can't care lesser about what Google definition says about physical strength or ability.
Dismissal of a fact doesn't make it any less correct. The fact of the matter is you confused physical strength with physical ability which is why you don't seem to understand that these characters are not superior by strength even after it's repeatedly listed. You can be physically stronger than somebody while being inferior in physical ability, that's the fact of the matter. Example. In wrestling. Big Show is physically stronger than Roman Reigns, but Roman Reigns overall is the better wrestler when you add all factors which is why he would have a higher overall on the wrestling game
I have already gone on these things many times that COTE, or for that matter, any series doesn't go with the exact terminologies. They can use the term "force" to describe AP which is mainly energy or work. Authors aren't meant to be pro-scaling.
That doesn't apply to this verse. This is not a fantasy verse with verse specific concepts, and we cannot simply create a headcanons for the verse because you "could care less" that's an even bigger problem if you're willing to purposely midscale the verse even after proven incorrect
And no, I already gave enough feats to prove the massive AP difference between characters and already gave counter proofs to all the stuff which you regarded as AP similarities.
And I gave quadruple that debunks it proving the opposite yet you want to dismiss them and even in the scales you sent which I said multiple times it literally says what im saying after being told my scans were "fan made" so that was a lie told by the zesty guy. That's not helping anyone.
I already mentioned why I think that Kiyotaka wasn't giving it his all against Albert using the Y2V11 scan, and in fact, even Albert himself agreed with that afterwards, so yes, all this thread brings is mostly nothing.
And that's the problem what you think is actually different than whats being told and described over and over and over and over again. Simply going through them 1 by 1 dismissing source material is not helping and even when you guys send scales it's the exact same scales I already sent making the conversation go in circles.
A lot of these points are something I used to see daily in literal YT comments and most of them original from a non-scaler perspective.
The source of where it comes from doesn't change the validity of it. YouTube has videos about every anime. Not just cote.
As of this point, Kinugasa-sensei has managed to indirectly retcon or directly go against almost every scaling incoherence which could somehow be made out in COTE scaling some years ago, that's what he actually started doing after the interview where he stated that he would actually focus on COTE combat aspects more.
This isn't true at all as shown you are purposely dismissing statements that prove he's human then using the ones that you think upgrade him just for the scans to be proven in favor of my point being physical strength and physical ability are not the same things. There are characters in the verse physically stronger than others while being inferior in total physical ability. That won't change and dismissing it when it's said over 20 times is bad faith.
 
AP is measured in joules, because it's simplified (even to the point where some people just take the total energy and think that it's usable as it is - one example is in this thread, no offense meant towards anyone). The actual stuff that determines the damage is impact force and pressure.

You definitely should, unless you want to get a character as high as possible based on misinterpreted terms.
This is what I believe is happening, they are just repeating the same arguments as the last person while not addressing that the stuff they're sending is also proving my point while trying to dismiss my points
 
I don't deny that, but you wouldn't scale all parts to 9 kj. Those 9 kJ would only apply for one bone and it would still damage it to some extent.

I was replying to this the whole time:

"Not to mention Nanase scales to 4.6 KJ AP while Koji is 49,3 KJ in durability which would make no sense that she would've made dmg to him"

And that was using energy from falling and scaled it to the 49.3 kilojoules as if it's regular durability that applies to all parts of his body.
I'm not sure, but I think the bones absorb most damage from a fall. Can't say for sure.
 
I'm not sure, but I think the bones absorb most damage from a fall. Can't say for sure.
They probably absorb most of it (unless you bend them to lower the impact force). It's just that my point was that this:
(imgur stuff not working, so here's the entire blog)
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...enji_jumps_a_mountain:_Classroom_of_the_Elite
Is very much comparable to a regular human jumping off of something (except for the height of course). And since we know that regular humans get hurt with hundred joule punches, despite being able to survive kilojoule falls, it shouldn't even apply in the case of those 49.3 kilojoules (and therefore we shouldn't use it as a durability value to begin with).

Another annoying thing to point out is the fact that it would be your legs absorbing most of the energy and the upper body barely gets affected, so it's impossible to say that your durability is equal to the energy you gain from falling.

(I was really just trying to put the value into some sort of context, so it wouldn't be used incorrectly. Didn't mean to start some sort of argument, but looks like I already did, so I'm sorry for that).

The fact that it's used as "at least Wall Level" with the 49.3 kilojoules on the profile is already not a really good look, because that's probably one of the highest values and it's both used as a lower bound and based on a questionable assumption. There must be other feats that are far more reliable, so why not use those instead?
 
Last edited:
This is what I believe is happening, they are just repeating the same arguments as the last person while not addressing that the stuff they're sending is also proving my point while trying to dismiss my points
I feel like a lot of this has been bad faith arguing (I'm not saying this randomly. This is based on a pattern that's way too repetitive). The only response I kept getting for my point was "this wiki doesn't work like this" (which is btw incorrect, because there's a paragraph on the durability page talking about surface area) which still doesn't justify using incorrect values and assumptions just to put a character even higher.

And in your case I can see how they're not even hiding the fact that they're dismissing it.
This is literally the average response you got:
"All of this can be resumed to you just taking everything at face value without taking narrative, statements and feats into consideration"
That's almost an insult and it doesn't even engage in the provided evidence and arguments. It just labels you as "taking everything at face value" and even that claim isn't backed up.

I also don't see any good response to your question (which should also tell you something): "Where are you getting "official translations" because the scans I'm using come from the exact same sites. I'm not sure why you believe there is some secret translation that isn't available to all readers."
 
I finally fixed the full scaling chain and the statement below will be used as the benchmark statement for my entire premise that the verse is mainly separated by experience, and that Ayanokouji is not physically superior to every single character, he is only more skilled, smarter with better pain tolerance, physical ability and lifting strength. Not Attack Potency and Durability. The only time Ayanokouji has ever mentioning holding back was during a written test. People misconstrued him hiding his "real identity" as him "holding back" in every fight, when he explicitly states when he is going all out. Also another big reason for this problem is people confuse physical capabilities and physical strength.

I split the tiers and feats that apply by each characters tier which prove a consistent scaling chain in the verse

Here is the statement: Ayanokouji and Tsukishiro agree that there are Non white room people as talented as white room members. Tsukishiro even says there is talent the white room cant even produce

Scaling Chain I recreated the scaling chain with direct statements and feats underneath to further contextualize how the characters are scaled.

Skill level God: Ayanokouji >>

High: Tsukishiro > Shiba > Shiro > Takuya > Amasawa > Koenji > Housen > Manabu > Nagumo > Utomiya > Kiryuin > Nanase >

Mid: Kanzaki > Albert > Sudo > Ryuuen = Kito > Ibuki ≥ Horikita = Kushida

Lifting Strength

God: White Room Ayanokouji > Current Ayanokouji = Koenji = Tsukishiro = Shiba = Albert = Housen = Takuya = Sudo (possibly Shiro)

High: > Manabu > Nagumo > Ryuuen = Kito > Ichizaki > Amasawa >

Mid: Kiryuin > Nanase > Ibuki ≥ Horikita = Kushida

Speed (Reaction) God: Ayanokouji

High: Shiro > Takuya > Amasawa > Koenji > Tsukishiro > Shiba > Housen > Manabu > Nagumo > Sudo > Kiryuin > Nanase > Utomiya

Mid: Ryuuen = Kito > Hashimoto = Ibuki ≥ Horikita > Kushida > Albert > Ichizaki > Akito

Ayanokouji is the only person with multiple statements about having abnormal reaction time meaning everyone elses reaction time should be relative

Speed (Travel)

God: Ayanokouji ≥ Koenji = Manabu = Albert = Takuya = Amasawa > Tsukishiro > Shiba (possibly Shiro)

High: Serious Nanase > Housen > Nagumo > Utomiya > Kiryuin > Sudo

Mid: Ryuuen = Kito > Hashimoto > Ibuki ≥ Horikita > Kushida > Ichizaki

Attack Potency God: Tsukishiro = Shiba > Albert > Ayanokouji = Koenji = Manabu = Housen (unknown: Takuya, likely atleast ANHS Ayanokouji)

High: 9yo WR Ayanokouji with and without weapons = Shiro > Amasawa > Utomiya > Kiryuin > Nanase > Sudo > Ryuuen = Kito

Mid: Hashimoto > Ibuki > Ichizaki > Hirata > Horikita > Kushida

Durability: Albert >> Housen > Koenji = Ayanokouji > Tsukishiro > Shiba > Takuya > Manabu

High: Ryuuen > Sudo > Kito > Utomiya > Ichizaki > Amasawa > Kiryuin

Mid: Nagumo > Nanase > Hashimoto > Ibuki > Horikita > Kushida

As you can see there is a consistent theme with the verse as nobody besides Albert has statements that would put their durability above every other character due to his superior genetics being half black. Which is something he was likely taught when learning about USA.

Performance Stamina/Ability + Endurance:

God: WR Ayanokouji > Current Ayanokouji >> Takuya > Amasawa > Koenji

 
It always baffles me how the profiles for Ayano and the content threads made on him make it seem like his pinky finger alone upscales from the whole verse. Like, Ayano needs 0.001 percent of his full capabilities to annihilate everybody else. It's hilarious to me
 
Back
Top