Live Action One Piece Discussion Thread

[Dalesean027]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Dalesean027/OPLA_S2_Calc_Compilation_2

WIP here since I've gotta add more calcs as I go but congrats to the two boys for breaching past everything else so far (Mihawk upscale)


Now the goldfish is a little iffy tbh but at worst 100~150m long at least which means the result at its worst is still 8-A+ around 800ish tons to 1.3 kilotons

and actually there may be a way to actually scale Luffy to the improv gum gum hammer after all, once he breaks the wall Mr. 3 created he is shown holding his shoulder and does feel some of the blow back from the impact so if it does end up an upgrade it can be used as a "at most" sorta deal

 

[Alexander]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Dalesean027/OPLA_S2_Calc_Compilation_2

WIP here since I've gotta add more calcs as I go but congrats to the two boys for breaching past everything else so far (Mihawk upscale)


Now the goldfish is a little iffy tbh but at worst 100~150m long at least which means the result at its worst is still 8-A+ around 800ish tons to 1.3 kilotons

and actually there may be a way to actually scale Luffy to the improv gum gum hammer after all, once he breaks the wall Mr. 3 created he is shown holding his shoulder and does feel some of the blow back from the impact so if it does end up an upgrade it can be used as a "at most" sorta deal

How big was the Goldfish in the original version?

 

[Dalesean027]

How big was the Goldfish in the original version?

It had a height of 715m originally

 

[Alexander]

It had a height of 715m originally

What if somewhere, in some place, it is said by one of the showrunners that the fish is the same size has his original version?

 

[Kazuma_kuwabara]

Wapol in the live action>>> Kaido

 

[Alexander]

Wapol in the live action>>> Kaido

based

 

[Dalesean027]

What if somewhere, in some place, it is said by one of the showrunners that the fish is the same size has his original version?

Nope thats I looked for VFX sources for size statements but there was nothing

 

[Alexander]

Nope thats I looked for VFX sources for size statements but there was nothing

****

 

[ShockingPsychic]

Which episode does Garp reveal that Smoker's jitte is tipped with seastone?

Smoker's almost done

 

[Antvasima]

Which episode does Garp reveal that Smoker's jitte is tipped with seastone?

Smoker's almost done

I think that it was the Laboon episode, but may misremember.

 

[Dalesean027]

Which episode does Garp reveal that Smoker's jitte is tipped with seastone?
Smoker's almost done

Tank the speed down to subsonic because once I'm done with the S2 calcs I am downgrading these guys

Otherwise though great work

 

[ShockingPsychic]

Is Smoker good to post?

 

[DaReaperMan]

Is Smoker good to post?

Intelligence is scanless and referenceless, standard tactics is nonexistent, age isn't referenced, summary isn't referenced, quote isn't referenced...

Also are there any full-body shots of him?

 

[ShockingPsychic]

Intelligence is scanless and referenceless, standard tactics is nonexistent, age isn't referenced, summary isn't referenced, quote isn't referenced...

Probably should have phrased it as "are the stats right" lol. Still got a ways to go before I post

Also are there any full-body shots of him?

All are very blurry or from promoshots where he's not in-character

 

[ShockingPsychic]

Updated the page, should be done now

Couldn't find the clip of Garp talking about the jitte, and his age is assumed off his canon counterpart. Added a "likely" in there for clarity. Going off the show alone, he's at least late 20s to early 30s, since he was a child at Gold Roger's execution

 

[ShockingPsychic]

Sooo, am I good to post his profile?

 

[DaReaperMan]

Sooo, am I good to post his profile?

Sure

 

[Kachon123]

 

[Antvasima]

Thank God that the producers of this show are humble and sensible enough to not mess with perfection just to nourish their own egos because they think that their creative visions are superior to the people who truly created and made stories popular in the first place, like the writers and producers of so many other adaptations do (Amazon's "Wheel Of Time" show comes to mind for example).

 

[Alexander]

What matters is the respect, but Oda himself also admires how good some things are, like he mentioned one of his favorite scene is Iñaki singing Binks Brew and dancing to Laboon.

 

[Antvasima]

Yes. It is great that their collaboration gave such an amazing result.

 

[DeadlyMonarchChewstheDirt]

This all is kinda weird that they are stuck in a subsonic small building level hell, which will be made stranger when Luffy pulls a storm on Crocodile, mf gonna jump from 9-A to 7-C real quik. (also, almost everyone's a prototype victim right now)

 

[Dalesean027]

This all is kinda weird that they are stuck in a subsonic small building level hell, which will be made stranger when Luffy pulls a storm on Crocodile, mf gonna jump from 9-A to 7-C real quik. (also, almost everyone's a prototype victim right now)

I don't see how its weird, most live action verses usually aren't that crazy speed and tierwise, some that do end up faster either have super blatant bullet timing feats that are on a higher end rather than not (most bullet feats in live action shit be subsonic tho ngl)


We'll see though how they adapt that when we get to Alabasta, I do expect some upgrades

 

[Alexander]

But we at least still got Dorry and Brogy destroying the big fish

 

[Antvasima]

Iñaki ranking the manga storyarcs.

 

[Antvasima]