-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Live Action One Piece Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Maverick_Zero_X
- Start date
- 21,522
- 36,093
that was a pretty good showing for him considering she is consistently 9-B~9-B+ maybe even low 9-A
this is definitely solid 9-A around the same range as if not higher than the current value granted its also improvised with the hammer so he'd probably just downscale it IF we even end up saying its valid to scale anyways
- 21,522
- 36,093
also ngl I think the Supersonic for everyone should be axed, Luffy should only be supersonic with his gatling attacks ngl since those are definitely presented as being faster than his normal punches and kicks, literally blitzes arlong who is normally comparable to Luffy when he pulls it out.
I think its best to just have em be Subsonic with Supersonic attack speed with Gatling Attacks especially since at least as far as the live action goes they definitely are not as fast as gunfire and routinely have to duck for cover and run when guns do get brought out especially if there are multiple shooters or rapid fire, not quite there yet the way Mihawk is.
also for some reason Nami is scaled to Luffy pulling the safe out of the ground which like is pretty wild so her class 10 should be axed.
there's some decent support feats for our main guys and obviously our two giants are pretty good too (I'm on ep 5 for now so I'll see what else we get)
I think its best to just have em be Subsonic with Supersonic attack speed with Gatling Attacks especially since at least as far as the live action goes they definitely are not as fast as gunfire and routinely have to duck for cover and run when guns do get brought out especially if there are multiple shooters or rapid fire, not quite there yet the way Mihawk is.
also for some reason Nami is scaled to Luffy pulling the safe out of the ground which like is pretty wild so her class 10 should be axed.
there's some decent support feats for our main guys and obviously our two giants are pretty good too (I'm on ep 5 for now so I'll see what else we get)
- 13,161
- 4,811
Vivi also dodged that Cannonball that was near her and Luffy.
- 21,522
- 36,093
does this happen during drum? I'm not done yet
- 13,161
- 4,811
- 6,883
- 7,184
Yo...maybe this is me downplaying manga Nami...but I ain't gonna lie, if you gave manga Nami a normal staff and equalized her and live action Nami's stats...I feel like live action Nami would whoop manga Nami's ass in terms of combat skill.
Heoj
He/Him- 275
- 353
yeh, live action nami is way more competent imo, the most i remember manga east blue nami was some moments with fodder marines in arlong park, and some fodder buggy pirates in orange and logue town.
tbh, i think live action nami makes more sense since nami should be more ready to throw down and quick on her feet, given the whole being a thief and how much shes traveled and seeing more things.
- 21,522
- 36,093
Nah I'd say for sure Live action is definitely more skilled
Also I finished the season and can do calcs. Lowkey the giants are a Mihawk upscale are they not??? Bro is a swordsman
- 13,161
- 4,811
- 21,522
- 36,093
I'll handle calcs for this season too since I've finished
Can someone make profile for Usopp I'm like suprised he doesn't have one when he actually did do stuff in the first season
Can someone make profile for Usopp I'm like suprised he doesn't have one when he actually did do stuff in the first season
- 13,161
- 4,811
He could get prodigy intelligence?
Heoj
He/Him- 275
- 353
in whiskey peak he does brag about how hes never played darts before and casually pulls an absurd dart throw hitting multiple things before hitting the center
- 21,522
- 36,093
yeah coming up with gadgets like that is his most intelligent stuff, also remember combat skill feats don't count as general intelligence and aren't rated as such normally
- 13,161
- 4,811
Fine, he is still a prodigy?
- 21,522
- 36,093
yeah its still Gifted intelligence since normal goons ain't building things like that
ShockingPsychic
He/Him- 4,228
- 1,998
Just finished Season 2! Never watched the anime, but I'm LOVING it. Haven't read the thread, but I'd love to help with profiles and stuff. Anyone doing Smoker's profile, cuz I'd wanna do that one
- 13,161
- 4,811
If nobody else is going to do it, sure, you can
- 52,674
- 46,921
Someone should make a Garp profile lol
- 21,522
- 36,093
Nope we desperately need profiles, we still don't even have a Usopp one apparently.
I'm working on the S2 calcs tho
ShockingPsychic
He/Him- 4,228
- 1,998
I think the biggest feats are related to Mister Three's wax. It was said to be stronger than steel, and Luffy was able to break a big wall of it. Miss Valentine was also able to crack it
Miss Valentine also has that hundred kilo punch (That Usopp tanks)
The Giants' KE would probably be high into Tier 8, but the only thing that would scale is like, Mister 3's maximum with wax?
Smoker hits a baseball hard enough to leave a burnmark on someone, implying it was going at Mach 5 or so (if that's how friction works idk)
- 13,161
- 4,811
To be specific, Luffy also had to use a big wax hammer that was put on to him (and he lifted that, when it was so heavy that he was having a hard time lifting it)
yeah
Probably yes, but you also forgot about the fact that they still teared through a giant fish.
sure
ShockingPsychic
He/Him- 4,228
- 1,998
- 177,441
- 90,363
- 21,522
- 36,093
This wouldn't directly scale to Luffy himself since he its more of a situation gum gum using the wax attatched to him combined with his rubber body as a means to create a greater force to actually break the wall so its at most applicable to a possibly rating for that
KE is kinda bunk and lame, I'll do their GPE, weight, speed, and their swing against the goldfish.
This I disagree with though
ShockingPsychic
He/Him- 4,228
- 1,998
Zoro gets smashed through a wall during the fight with Mister Nine, but it's probably just 9-B
Sanji damages a t-rex pretty badly
Sanji damages a t-rex pretty badly
- 13,161
- 4,811
Breaking his neck
- 21,522
- 36,093
Yeah both of those are 9-B too
- 13,161
- 4,811
Also, Luffy stated that he broke Dorry out of his Wax prison (off-screen)
- 21,522
- 36,093
Yeah but we don't know by what means or by how many strikes either
- 21,522
- 36,093
This season is mainly just support feats but that said we will need to downgrade everyone a bit too, speed needs to be axed down to either superhuman or subsonic, Nami for some reason scales to Class 10 from Luffy's LS feat which makes 0 sense so thats axed, she's also 9-A from slapping away one of Buggy's limbs which I personally don't think is enough to justify that considering she's more in line with the 9-B stuff instead
Mihawk is probably the only person who has anything upgradable
Mihawk is probably the only person who has anything upgradable
- 177,441
- 90,363
Probably by using the vax "hammers" that had been stuck on his hands at the time, if I remember correctly.
- 13,161
- 4,811
Remember that Vivi and Luffy dodged a Cannonball from Wapol before they got hit by it
- 21,522
- 36,093
They didn't dodge it, they just contained the explosion in his mouth
- 13,161
- 4,811
- 21,522
- 36,093
Ah okay I see, this supports the subsonic
- 52,674
- 46,921
I wonder who has better teeth: Wapol or Luffy
- 13,161
- 4,811
The better question is, who can eat more.
- 21,522
- 36,093
first batch, probably need 2 more to get all the relevant feats out of the way from this season
