• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Short Awaited Hazbin Hotel Season 2 Downgrade (Part 1. "The only way I know how… SONG!”)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Eden_Warlock99

She/Her
Messages
13,594
Reaction score
6,648
Previous thread here.

Rn practically 90% of Hazbin Hotel sits at "Low 5-B, possibly 5-B" thanks to the Overlords all joining forces, holding hands, and friendship-beaming a shield around a Tier 5 doomsday gun while it was overloading. Now this is an enormous jump for guys who used to be 8-A (And were supposed to be 9-A for a while), is it consistent?

The Outlier Concern

I'm going to point to our Guidelines for Outliers.

Is it a big jump or drop in power?

Yes, undoubtedly so. The feats and anti-feats of Overlords and those who scale to them really only hover around Tier 9. Here are some of those anti-feats:
And this is just the tip of the iceberg! There's another show to look at.
I’ll admit the scaling between the Overlords and I.M.P. is a bit shakier than I’d like, but there’s still solid evidence.
For one, Kitty is a Robo Fizz (Same size, same proportions, etc) and still managed to pressure Cherri (I’ll explain why she scales to the Overlords later) and even had Husk dodging its attacks. The much stronger evidence, though, comes from Millie. Her Battle Axe could withstand and deflect Striker’s Tier 5 bullets, the very same ones he says can kill Overlords, and Millie herself survived an explosion that destroyed said Battle Axe at close proximity.
Was not expecting the Overlords to rack up more anti-feats than I.M.P lol, that is pretty funny
That said, these aren’t super critical to the argument and could be left out if need be, really just here for support.
This might not seem like a huge number of anti-feats compared to other series, but you have to factor in how little screentime (In regards to combat) the Overlords actually have.
And how, when they do get into fights, the anti-feats listed above tend to make up the conclusions, or at least a major part of said fights, which I’ll go into more below.
I will not be counting split second fights like Zestial's match against Pentious and Baxter or Prick and Hatchet's scuffle.

Season 1​

Husk and Angel vs. Mobsters: The very first fight featuring an Overlord and it’s one where said Overlord has to retreat from gunfire. For what’s supposedly a Tier 5 vs. a bunch of Tier 9s, Husk does fights extremely cautiously, using a street car as cover and dodging their knife swings. One of the mobsters even manages to give Husk trouble by jumping onto his back and Angel had to step in to shoot the loan shark off him. Also don't ask me what happened but Husk walks away from the fight with a visible bruise on his cheek.

Vaggie vs. Carmilla: Carmilla (The Arms Dealer Overlord) "fought" Vaggi, who used to be an Exorcist Angle. Not much can really be gleamed from it, neither cause any destruction and the only reason Carmilla can harm Vaggi is cause she's smacking her with her Angelic Pointe Shoes, as reinforced by Carmilla fully attributing her past kill of another Exorcist Angel to the fact she used an Angelic Weapon.

The Hazbin Hotel vs. The Exorcists: The Overlords here are Husk and Nifty and they really don’t do a whole lot. Niffty spent the entire fight stabbing corpses, while Husk killed a handful of Exorcists with his Angelic Cards (Which everyone else in this fight did) and briefly grappled with one of them. The Exorcists themselves, who are stronger than the Overlords, don't do much beyond being killed in the dozens either. Even Lute, who's stronger than your average Exorcist, was taken out by falling rubble, as mentioned earlier.

Season 2​

The Vees (Vox, Valentino and Velvette) vs. Weakened Alastor (ft. Husk and Nifty): This is where they start actually getting stuff, Vox pulls off two 9-A feats! But the destruction is very much localized to the single street they’re fighting on. Even when Husk and Velvette start tossing explosions around, the surrounding buildings are barely affected. By contrast, the rematch between Vox and Alastor, after Vox became significantly stronger, has them tearing buildings and roads apart.
What I'm saying is that the difference in portrayal feels intentional.
The collateral deaths in this fight are also used to justify the quintillions gap Overlords have over regular Sinners, but looking at them, one was the result of Vox's dura neg "TP inside you" move and another was just Val missing and shooting a random passerby. Really only this one shows a power gap between Overlords and ordinary Sinners, the rest don’t suggest anything close to the absurd gap that’s currently on the profiles.

Nifty (ft. Baxter) vs. Velvette: The only destruction they cause is Velvette breaking a server cabinet. This is the fight that ends with Velvette falling off V Tower and breaking.

Husk and Cherri vs. Valentino: While it was initially Husk solo vs. Val, once Cherri joined and they figured out how to close the distance, they completely beat Val down, with Cherri (Who's not an Overlord) doing the bulk of the beatdown, bruising and even drawing blood from Val. [CHECK CHERRI SECTION FOR MORE INFO]

And that's everything.​
But what of the casual Tier 8 and 7 feats the original thread mentioned?
Both of those originate from Alastor and Adam respectively.
Alastor is the strongest Sinner, remained so even after losing his power source, and was never even slightly challenged prior to his fight with Adam.
Adam is the General of the Exterminations, just his foot soldiers (Exorcists) are seen as untouchable and invincible to Hell’s population, Overlords included. Adam himself steamrolled every single fight he was in, and it took LUCIFER, the undisputed 1# of the verse, to bring him down.

The Overlords have NO scaling to either of these two. So what do they actually scale to?
Frankly, all of this circles back to the fact that, while Overlords are stronger than regular Sinners, they are never portrayed as these invincible and untouchable deities the profiles would led you to believe. This is most evident when we compare them to the one group that is treated that way in Hazbin; the Exorcists.
Just proposing the idea of fighting the angels was seen as laughable back in S1, an entire episode had to be dedicated to secure weapons capable of harming them.

Nothing even remotely similar happens with the Vees. In fact, Vaggi and Charlie, who have no knowledge of Nifty’s former status, assigned her on security duty against Vox.
And nowhere is this clearer than with Cherri Bomb.
I think this scene speaks for itself (Here's a youtube link if the imgur one doesn't work)

After Husk restrains Valentino with his rings, Cherri (Who's currently 9-B) proceeds to wail on him, bruising and even drawing blood from the supposed Tier 5.
The original thread argues she shouldn’t scale because,
Cherri Bomb: Her bomb did no damage to Valentino, and the only damage she did was to a Valentino Husk beat up and was restrained to be unable to do anything. But most damning is the fact Angel Dust is stronger than her, shown not even half a minute later.
First of all, Husk did not "beat up" Valentino. Across the entire fight, Husk lands exactly one hit on Val, a thrown bottle that doesn’t even knock Val’s glasses off. Aside from that, all he really accomplishes is knocking Val’s guns out of his hands. Restraint also doesn’t lower durability, if the gap was truly as astronomical as the profile made it up to be, Cherri shouldn’t be bruising or drawing blood at all.

As for the claim that her bomb “did no damage” to Valentino, that seems entirely based on the lack of visible bruising (If so, Ig none of Husk's attacks did anything to Val). Yet he still groans in pain and Cherri attempts to finish him off by shoving a bomb into his face. The framing makes it pretty clear that her bombs are a legitimate threat to him.

Now regarding "Angel Dust is stronger than her," not really?
Cherri is blindsided by a hypnotized Angel and knocked down by an attack she clearly didn't expect. He then restrains and strangles her using his extra arms, which she breaks free from within seconds. The only reason she fails to immediately retaliate is because Angel’s body proportions give him longer reach.
Even then, so what if Angel scales to Cherri? The issue isn’t whether Overlords are stronger, it's whether the gap is absurdly massive (Which this scene clearly doesn’t support).

Is it a unique or exceptional incident?

Yes, undoubtedly so. Before Might of Lilith (the doomsday weapon) overloads, Carmilla warns Vox that if he fires it again, it will blow and "take you, us and half the Pentagram with it." Vox then attempts to fire it again, fails and causes it to overload. Charlie suggests to evacuate but Carmilla responds with resignation, saying it’s no use.

That response makes no sense for someone who's 1/14th of the power of that explosion, surviving an explosion will always be leagues lower than the AP of the explosion itself, even just being a meter from the epicenter can divide the durability needed to tank it by 16. Yet she treats the blast as something that would unquestionably kill them all.

That and as they keep repeating "Everyone dies if we don't do this!" Hard to have a Season 3 when the entire cast is dead. What's PIS again?
Plot-Induced Stupidity, or PIS for short, is a term used to refer to events in a story that contradict a character's normal capabilities for the purpose of the plot.

Is the event unexplained and unjustified?

Actually.

Why it's NOT an Outlier

In the very first scene of the series, Charlie narrates the history of Hell and states the following.
We’re then told this was significant enough to alarm the angels, prompting them to begin the yearly Exterminations.
Keep in mind, these angels command the Exorcists, beings no one in Hell could even harm. And yet they felt threatened.
That makes it hard to interpret "empowering demonkind" as purely metaphorical, whatever Lilith was doing had a tangible effect.

Note Hazbin is diegetically a musical and singing has already played a narrative role back in S1, with Charlie singing being the thing that gets the Cannibals to join her side.
So is it really far-fetched, to take the creators on their word when they state that the singing in 'Hear My Hope' served a purpose in the plot,
and that it's straight-up them manifesting power (In a very literal way) to achieve a certain goal,
that when they perform something that is a gazillion times over their usual power, it's actually affecting their power?
Especially in this case, the barrier they form doesn't just instantly poof into existence, but gradually builds up the more they sing and outright stagnates when they're not.

A common response to this is, "if this amp exists, why don’t they abuse it constantly in combat?"
It may simply be impractical to sing and fight at the same time, perhaps there's a certain mechanic to it that makes it require multiple singers, maybe they need to be "in perfect harmony" (as the show puts it) or maybe the characters are just dumb, this is the series where a character didn't realize Angels could be harmed, despite being an angel who was.

The intricacies of the mechanics really doesn't matter. We know they're stronger than normal. That's all that matters.

Removal of Low 5-B (Not Lucifer)

The current interpretation for the build up of the barrier, that it’s merely accumulating power over time, doesn’t align with what we see on-screen. As mentioned earlier, the barrier visibly stagnates during Lute’s intermission and even shrinks afterward. This detail was very much intentional.

All in all, I’m completely fine with either treating it as an outlier or listing it under a specific music amp, as long as it doesn't scale to their base.
And to keep things organized, I’d like to avoid discussing the Overlord's new tier here (So no Vox should downscale to Alastor and Shok.wav stuff), I'll make another thread for that after this one. This one is solely about removing the 'Hear My Hope' feat from their base scaling.

That's it.
MdiDluE.gif
 
Last edited:
Do not use Gunfire or falling as an anti-feat if you're not downgrading them to 9-C.
Hopefully I will only have to respond to this once, but "going all the way" in powerscaling is literally impossible. Fiction is not made to be 100% consistent. The anti-feats would still contrast it, but if the Overlords were rated at 9-A, the picture would still be far less inconsistent than what is currently considered the status quo.

Claiming I'm wrong cause by following my logic to its extreme the characters should be 9-C is incorrect not only because because there is a pretty nebulous amount of feats and anti-feats all across 9-B, but because it is not something that should ever be followed to the extreme. Our calcs are already quite a massive oversimplification of reality (Difference between fragmentation and “violent fragmentation” is generally better understood as multiple weak points having the same strength) and ultimately power-scaling is a game of compromises.

It would be one thing if this kind of downgrade reasoning was unprecedented. It isn’t. It's been the case for basically every downgrade of this nature.
But again, this is drifting off-topic. We're not discussing the Overlords new tier here, all of these anti-feats are under 5-B. They're inconsistent with it. They contradict it.
We can argue if the Overlord are 9-C in the next thread.
 
Last edited:
Hopefully I will only have to respond to this one time, but "going all the way" in powerscaling is literally impossible. Fiction is not made to be 100% consistent. The anti-feats would still contrast it, but if the Overlords were rated at 9-A, the picture would still be far less inconsistent than what is currently considered the status quo.

Claiming that I am objectively a hypocrite because by following my logic to its extreme the characters should be 9-C is incorrect not only because because there is a pretty nebulous amount of feats and anti-feats all across 9-B, but because it is not something that should ever be followed to the extreme. Not only cause our own calcs are already quite a massive oversimplification of reality (Difference between fragmentation and “violent fragmentation” is generally better understood as multiple weak points having the same strength) but cause ultimately power-scaling is a game of compromises.

It would be one thing if this kind of downgrade reasoning was unprecedented. It isn’t. It's been the case for basically every downgrade of this nature.
But again, this is drifting off-topic. We're not discussing the Overlords new tier here, all of these anti-feats are under 5-B. They're inconsistent with it. They contradict it.
If you want to argue 9-C Overlords, you're free to do so in the next thread.
oh, so your "anti-feats" Are not actually being used fully! So you don't even really believe in them, gotcha!
 
oh, so your "anti-feats" Are not actually being used fully! So you don't even really believe in them, gotcha!
Do you actually have a problem processing the fact that 9-B anti-feats towards a 9-A character are far less damning than it would be if the character was ****** Tier 5?

It's a smaller gap, and it's in that range of feats that writers simply don't know how much joules goes into "seemingly superhuman" feats.
 
Last edited:
Do you actually have a problem processing the fact that a 9-B anti-feats towards a 9-A character are far less damning than it would be if the character was ****** Tier 5?

It's a smaller gap, and it's in that range of feats that writers simply don't know how much joules goes into "seemingly superhuman" feats.
Eden. When you decide that an anti-feat is to be used, and you are NOT DOWNGRADING THEM BELOW SAID ANTI-FEAT, I will take issues with it. This is something I apply in general. Don't go "But thiiiis is fine!" no if you're not going all the way when using things like this I will call it out if I'm in the thread. Downgrade them to 9-C or don't use those anti-feats with me.
 
The most blunt problem with using anti-feats and not arguing below them is that you are by default conceding that these anti-feats are invalid/dismissible by arguing to scale them higher.

Nor will I ever agree to Sinners scaling to freaking Overlord.

If you want to argue downgrade through mighty author’s statement (which I disagree with since it contradicts the series and creates many issues), then it’s fair, but the two above? Nah, not buying into that at all.
 
I'm in the boat that all WoG should be thrown out for the verse. We want to claim Lilith isn't special? Show me something that isn't Word of God or from a chronic liar.
Would it be wrong to say they were able to inherit the ability from Lilith as time went on? Perhaps her empowering them with her songs enabled them to achieve the ability to do that?
 
How about we say Season 2 was all Vox’s dream because he dreams capturing Alastor and it came true, but in the end Alastor used Dream Manipulation to turn it into a nightmare? Sounds plausible to me, we should totally do that.
 
How about we say Season 2 was all Vox’s dream because he dreams capturing Alastor and it came true, but in the end Alastor used Dream Manipulation to turn it into a nightmare? Sounds plausible to me, we should totally do that.
what if Vox when he used hypontization in his appearence put the audience under a spell and the resrt season 1 and season 2 never happened?
a dream within a dream
 
Waiter, waiter! More headcanons please!
So yes, we'll ignore WoG and just assume Lilith is special despite the statement being there.

Take is as "headcanon" but rejecting something because it's WoG and just going to assume Lilith is special is just pathetic. Even when a big percentage of the verse is reliant on WoG. Just shoot down the 5-B feat because the evidence for it being a planet is WoG or whatever.
How about we say Season 2 was all Vox’s dream because he dreams capturing Alastor and it came true, but in the end Alastor used Dream Manipulation to turn it into a nightmare? Sounds plausible to me, we should totally do that.
Try taking things more seriously would ya? There's a reason this CRT exists and it's definitely not because of the well-made arguments by the supporters
 
So yes, we'll ignore WoG and just assume Lilith is special despite the statement being there.

Take is as "headcanon" but rejecting something because it's WoG and just going to assume Lilith is special is just pathetic. Even when a big percentage of the verse is reliant on WoG. Just shoot down the 5-B feat because the evidence for it being a planet is WoG or whatever.

Try taking things more seriously would ya? There's a reason this CRT exists and it's definitely not because of the well-made arguments by the supporters
Says the person who thinks Stolas and Andrealphus>FP Alastor based off of literally nothing but WoG. Where in my upgrade thread did I use WoG, please do show me.
 
I'm in the boat that all WoG should be thrown out for the verse. We want to claim Lilith isn't special? Show me something that isn't Word of God or from a chronic liar.
Wow didn't think you'd just concede on the empowerment being literal, that makes thing incredibly easy.
Well first of all, you have no proof that it's special, in fact you have evidence to the contrary with Hear My Hope.
And do explain why the Exterminations happened, at all, if Lilith (The Problem) was already gone?
Nor will I ever agree to Sinners scaling to freaking Overlord.
Genuinely how do you want to respond to this? You just said "No." and nothing else. Like okay?
Who will not be affected by this?
Anyone who scales to Lucifer is untouched, this just screws over the Overlords and Exorcists.

And please everyone, we have a discussion thread. You don't have to post anything on your mind here.
Unless yall are trying to bloat this thread on purpose lol
 
So yes, we'll ignore WoG and just assume Lilith is special despite the statement being there.

Take is as "headcanon" but rejecting something because it's WoG and just going to assume Lilith is special is just pathetic.
Give me a single explanation to why Sinners just didn’t continue singing on their own or Vox didn’t even try doing that in his “let’s make Hell great again” propaganda and then I’ll concede.

Also you’re straight up proposing something that is never even SUGGESTED, you're just saying “uhh let’s assume they somehow inherited her ability”. Then, by the same logic, let’s say that 1-A being unlocked them powers to stop MoL if it’s deemed an outlier!
 
Previous thread here.

Rn practically 90% of Hazbin Hotel sits at "Low 5-B, possibly 5-B" thanks to the Overlords all joining forces, holding hands, and friendship-beaming a shield around a Tier 5 doomsday gun while it was overloading. Now this is an enormous jump for guys who used to be 8-A (And were supposed to be 9-A for a while), is it consistent?

The Outlier Concern

I'm going to point to our Guidelines for Outliers.

Is it a big jump or drop in power?

Yes, undoubtedly so. The feats and anti-feats of Overlords and those who scale to them really only hover around Tier 9. Here are some of those anti-feats:
And this is just the tip of the iceberg! There's another show to look at.
I’ll admit the scaling between the Overlords and I.M.P. is a bit shakier than I’d like, but there’s still solid evidence.
For one, Kitty is a Robo Fizz (Same size, same proportions, etc) and still managed to pressure Cherri (I’ll explain why she scales to the Overlords later) and even had Husk dodging its attacks. The much stronger evidence, though, comes from Millie. Her Battle Axe could withstand and deflect Striker’s Tier 5 bullets, the very same ones he says can kill Overlords, and Millie herself survived an explosion that destroyed said Battle Axe at close proximity.
Was not expecting the Overlords to rack up more anti-feats than I.M.P lol, that is pretty funny
That said, these aren’t super critical to the argument and could be left out if need be, really just here for support.
This might not seem like a huge number of anti-feats compared to other series, but you have to factor in how little screentime (In regards to combat) the Overlords actually have.
And how, when they do get into fights, the anti-feats listed above tend to make up the conclusions, or at least a major part of said fights, which I’ll go into more below.
I will not be counting split second fights like Zestial's match against Pentious and Baxter or Prick and Hatchet's scuffle.

Season 1​

Husk and Angel vs. Mobsters: The very first fight featuring an Overlord and it’s one where said Overlord has to retreat from gunfire. For what’s supposedly a Tier 5 vs. a bunch of Tier 9s, Husk does fights extremely cautiously, using a street car as cover and dodging their knife swings. One of the mobsters even manages to give Husk trouble by jumping onto his back and Angel had to step in to shoot the loan shark off him. Also don't ask me what happened but Husk walks away from the fight with a visible bruise on his cheek.

Vaggie vs. Carmilla: Carmilla (The Arms Dealer Overlord) "fought" Vaggi, who used to be an Exorcist Angle. Not much can really be gleamed from it, neither cause any destruction and the only reason Carmilla can harm Vaggi is cause she's smacking her with her Angelic Pointe Shoes, as reinforced by Carmilla fully attributing her past kill of another Exorcist Angel to the fact she used an Angelic Weapon.

The Hazbin Hotel vs. The Exorcists: The Overlords here are Husk and Nifty and they really don’t do a whole lot. Niffty spent the entire fight stabbing corpses, while Husk killed a handful of Exorcists with his Angelic Cards (Which everyone else in this fight did) and briefly grappled with one of them. The Exorcists themselves, who are stronger than the Overlords, don't do much beyond being killed in the dozens either. Even Lute, who's stronger than your average Exorcist, was taken out by falling rubble, as mentioned earlier.

Season 2​

The Vees (Vox, Valentino and Velvette) vs. Weakened Alastor (ft. Husk and Nifty): This is where they start actually getting stuff, Vox pulls off two 9-A feats! But the destruction is very much localized to the single street they’re fighting on. Even when Husk and Velvette start tossing explosions around, the surrounding buildings are barely affected. By contrast, the rematch between Vox and Alastor, after Vox became significantly stronger, has them tearing buildings and roads apart.
What I'm saying is that the difference in portrayal feels intentional.
The collateral deaths in this fight are also used to justify the quintillions gap Overlords have over regular Sinners, but looking at them, one was the result of Vox's dura neg "TP inside you" move and another was just Val missing and shooting a random passerby. Really only this one shows a power gap between Overlords and ordinary Sinners, the rest don’t suggest anything close to the absurd gap that’s currently on the profiles.

Nifty (ft. Baxter) vs. Velvette: The only destruction they cause is Velvette breaking a server cabinet. This is the fight that ends with Velvette falling off V Tower and breaking.

Husk and Cherri vs. Valentino: While it was initially Husk solo vs. Val, once Cherri joined and they figured out how to close the distance, they completely beat Val down, with Cherri (Who's not an Overlord) doing the bulk of the beatdown, bruising and even drawing blood from Val. [CHECK CHERRI SECTION FOR MORE INFO]

And that's everything.​

Both of those originate from Alastor and Adam respectively.
Alastor is the strongest Sinner, remained so even after losing his power source, and was never even slightly challenged prior to his fight with Adam.
Adam is the General of the Exterminations, just his foot soldiers (Exorcists) are seen as untouchable and invincible to Hell’s population, Overlords included. Adam himself steamrolled every single fight he was in, and it took LUCIFER, the undisputed 1# of the verse, to bring him down.

The Overlords have NO scaling to either of these two. So what do they actually scale to?
Frankly, all of this circles back to the fact that, while Overlords are stronger than regular Sinners, they are never portrayed as these invincible and untouchable deities the profiles would led you to believe. This is most evident when we compare them to the one group that is treated that way in Hazbin; the Exorcists.
Just proposing the idea of fighting the angels was seen as laughable back in S1, an entire episode had to be dedicated to secure weapons capable of harming them.

Nothing even remotely similar happens with the Vees. In fact, Vaggi and Charlie, who have no knowledge of Nifty’s former status, assigned her on security duty against Vox.
And nowhere is this clearer than with Cherri Bomb.
I think this scene speaks for itself (Here's a youtube link if the imgur one doesn't work)

After Husk restrains Valentino with his rings, Cherri (Who's currently 9-B) proceeds to wail on him, bruising and even drawing blood from the supposed Tier 5.
The original thread argues she shouldn’t scale because,

First of all, Husk did not "beat up" Valentino. Across the entire fight, Husk lands exactly one hit on Val, a thrown bottle that doesn’t even knock Val’s glasses off. Aside from that, all he really accomplishes is knocking Val’s guns out of his hands. Restraint also doesn’t lower durability, if the gap was truly as astronomical as the profile made it up to be, Cherri shouldn’t be bruising or drawing blood at all.

As for the claim that her bomb “did no damage” to Valentino, that seems entirely based on the lack of visible bruising (If so, Ig none of Husk's attacks did anything to Val). Yet he still groans in pain and Cherri attempts to finish him off by shoving a bomb into his face. The framing makes it pretty clear that her bombs are a legitimate threat to him.

Now regarding "Angel Dust is stronger than her," not really?
Cherri is blindsided by a hypnotized Angel and knocked down by an attack she clearly didn't expect. He then restrains and strangles her using his extra arms, which she breaks free from within seconds. The only reason she fails to immediately retaliate is because Angel’s body proportions give him longer reach.
Even then, so what if Angel scales to Cherri? The issue isn’t whether Overlords are stronger, it's whether the gap is absurdly massive (Which this scene clearly doesn’t support).

Is it a unique or exceptional incident?

Yes, undoubtedly so. Before Might of Lilith (the doomsday weapon) overloads, Carmilla warns Vox that if he fires it again, it will blow and "take you, us and half the Pentagram with it." Vox then attempts to fire it again, fails and causes it to overload. Charlie suggests to evacuate but Carmilla responds with resignation, saying it’s no use.

That response makes no sense for someone who's 1/14th of the power of that explosion, surviving an explosion will always be leagues lower than the AP of the explosion itself, even just being a meter from the epicenter can divide the durability needed to tank it by 16. Yet she treats the blast as something that would unquestionably kill them all.

That and as they keep repeating "Everyone dies if we don't do this!" Hard to have a Season 3 when the entire cast is dead. What's PIS again?

Is the event unexplained and unjustified?

Actually.

Why it's NOT an Outlier

In the very first scene of the series, Charlie narrates the history of Hell and states the following.

We’re then told this was significant enough to alarm the angels, prompting them to begin the yearly Exterminations.
Keep in mind, these angels command the Exorcists, beings no one in Hell could even harm. And yet they felt threatened.
That makes it hard to interpret "empowering demonkind" as purely metaphorical, whatever Lilith was doing had a tangible effect.

Note Hazbin is diegetically a musical and singing has already played a narrative role back in S1, with Charlie singing being the thing that gets the Cannibals to join her side.
So is it really far-fetched, to take the creators on their word when they state that the singing in 'Hear My Hope' served a purpose in the plot,


and that it's straight-up them manifesting power (In a very literal way) to achieve a certain goal,



that when they perform something that is a gazillion times over their usual power, it's actually affecting their power?
Especially in this case, the barrier they form doesn't just instantly poof into existence, but gradually builds up the more they sing and outright stagnates when they're not.

A common response to this is, "if this amp exists, why don’t they abuse it constantly in combat?"
It may simply be impractical to sing and fight at the same time, perhaps there's a certain mechanic to it that makes it require multiple singers, maybe they need to be "in perfect harmony" (as the show puts it) or maybe the characters are just dumb, this is the series where a character didn't realize Angels could be harmed, despite being an angel who was.

The intricacies of the mechanics really doesn't matter. We know they're stronger than normal. That's all that matters.

Removal of Low 5-B (Not Lucifer)

The current interpretation for the build up of the barrier, that it’s merely accumulating power over time, doesn’t align with what we see on-screen. As mentioned earlier, the barrier visibly stagnates during Lute’s intermission and even shrinks afterward. This detail was very much intentional.


All in all, I’m completely fine with either treating it as an outlier or listing it under a specific music amp, as long as it doesn't scale to their base.
And to keep things organized, I’d like to avoid discussing the Overlord's new tier here (So no Vox should downscale to Alastor and Shok.wav stuff), I'll make another thread for that after this one. This one is solely about removing the 'Hear My Hope' feat from their base scaling.

That's it.
MdiDluE.gif

Move this to a staff discussion.

This same CRT was created a few weeks ago and nothing was resolved in 10 pages. @LephyrTheRevanchist said they would moderate the CRT.
 
Wow didn't think you'd just concede on the empowerment being literal, that makes thing incredibly easy.
Well first of all, you have no proof that it's special, in fact you have evidence to the contrary with Hear My Hope.
"The singing is empowering us!"

Who said that, Eden?
And do explain why the Exterminations happened, at all, if Lilith (The Problem) was already gone?
Notice how the moment Sinners start being hostile to the Angels, they run away like little googoo gaga *******? That's because they're damned cowards.
 
Move this to a staff discussion.

This same CRT was created a few weeks ago
Not same. That CRT proposed MoL is outlier overall based on the overhaul destroying only a city and arguing that DC = AP in that case, that Lucifer & those scaling to him shouldn’t scale to 5-B because it is invalid in the first place, and wanted to replace it with Tier 6 calc. This one seeks to nuke Tier 5 scaling to Overlords and Exorcists based on alleged outliers (Sinner vs. Overlords fights, Overlords not nuking planets every time they appear and instead just destroying walls/buildings).

These are not the same.
 
Both of those originate from Alastor and Adam respectively.
Alastor is the strongest Sinner, remained so even after losing his power source, and was never even slightly challenged prior to his fight with Adam.
Adam is the General of the Exterminations, just his foot soldiers (Exorcists) are seen as untouchable and invincible to Hell’s population, Overlords included. Adam himself steamrolled every single fight he was in, and it took LUCIFER, the undisputed 1# of the verse, to bring him down.
Don't forget the best robot shark in the franchise.
 
Give me a single explanation to why Sinners just didn’t continue singing on their own or Vox didn’t even try doing that in his “let’s make Hell great again” propaganda and then I’ll concede.

Also you’re straight up proposing something that is never even SUGGESTED, you're just saying “uhh let’s assume they somehow inherited her ability”. Then, by the same logic, let’s say that 1-A being unlocked them powers to stop MoL if it’s deemed an outlier!
We had many rounds of debate in other threads and my arguments about that are well-known to you, come on.
I literally address both of these in my CRT, this is why you should READ THE CRT.

I'm just going to ignore posts that don't even address anything in the CRT.
 
Says the person who thinks Stolas and Andrealphus>FP Alastor based off of literally nothing but WoG.
...? You do realize I'm supporting using WoG right?
Where in my upgrade thread did I use WoG, please do show me.
You do realize the whole 5-B feat is dependent on WoG stating Heaven is a planet?
Give me a single explanation to why Sinners just didn’t continue singing on their own or Vox didn’t even try doing that in his “let’s make Hell great again” propaganda and then I’ll concede.
 
I literally address both of these in my CRT, this is why you should READ THE CRT.
Not sure what you’re referring to you. You are just repeating what you said in previous threads and not really linking or addressing our past arguments. Just saying.
I'm just going to ignore posts that don't even address anything in the CRT.
Maybe will copy-paste my old arguments and put them as reply if I find them later.
 
I fully agree with the idea of nuking Tier 5 for the Song Amp thing but downgrading the Overlords anywhere below City Block is preposterous to me.
 
Last edited:
I called Lep. Please don't clog the thread.

@Eden_Warlock99 I do want to ask, what would you think about using the Carmilla's statement only and assuming this is weaker than the beam to scale them at like Mountain to Island level (as far as I remember). That would make the jump in power MUCH more believable right?

Otherwise I do believe this makes sense, I will hold off my vote as neutral but leaning towards agreeing right now... not that it matters lol.
 
2 Pages in 30 minutes, I'm going to go out on a limb and say yall are doing this on purpose lol
Pages are only 40 posts, Eden. 5 people debating getting to 40 isn't hard, especially with other posts from other people.
...? You do realize I'm supporting using WoG right?
You realize that I don't like Word of God in general, right?
You do realize the whole 5-B feat is dependent on WoG stating Heaven is a planet?
Thanks for the concession I never used Word of God in my CRT.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top