- 21,534
- 36,143
The px scaling is important to that hence why im judging your calcs for using that myself and saying "nope don't do that the art kinda bad and doesn't line up with the statements" so again I'd say no one was doing that to begin with
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Uraume's Ice Block
- Thread starter Arkenis
- Start date
- Status
- 21,534
- 36,143
That all aside let me know when changes are made and we can compare versions
OjeTheArcher15
He/Him- 1,266
- 755
Thanks Dale
- 21,534
- 36,143
Also don't forget that like shmeaty's all versions of the calc need to take into account the timeframe aince Uraume didn't just insta spawn this in and it took time
- 3,212
- 3,300
She kinda did insta spawn it in tho
- 21,534
- 36,143
This is what the blog says
So I'd say no it didn't it just cut to it already being made
- 3,212
- 3,300
And the blog is wrong, she had to create the ice block mid air, or did she create it on the ground then chunked it into the sky? it sure didnt look like that. neither can she fly or levitate mid air in order to spent like a minute or so, slowly creating it
she also would have no reason to create it that soon, up until Gojo is defeated at least, as interfering between them would just kill her
- 21,534
- 36,143
She can't fly but the domains also don't fall down as far as I can tell so the falling part wouldn't be a problem, im just going off what I'm getting from the stuff here but that said if she was in freefall before making it then sure I'd agree with you since it wouldn't take long for her to hit the ground if she was at freefall height at 635m in the air.
To figure this out, we'll use the formula for distance under constant acceleration:
distance = (1/2) * acceleration * time²
1. Rearrange the formula to solve for time:
2 * distance = acceleration * time²
time² = (2 * distance) / acceleration
time = sqrt((2 * distance) / acceleration)
2. Plug in the values:
time = sqrt((2 * 635.777657m) / 9.81m/s²)
3. Calculate the value inside the square root:
(2 * 635.777657) / 9.81 = 1271.555314 / 9.81 = 129.6182787
4. Take the square root of that number:
time = sqrt(129.6182787)
5. Calculate the final time:
time = 11.3850021s
It would take approximately 11.3850021 seconds to fall 635.777657m.
So yeah if she was in freefall then I'd say she made it instantly but if was being cooked while she was in the domain floating I'd say its probably best to use the timeframe but that's up to yall I don't have the scans or know so I'm going by whats here
Last edited:
- 24,320
- 37,752
Whole time the discrepancy can be accounted for by saying that Kashimo was already falling
- 3,212
- 3,300
She was not in the domain (doesnt even have it), she just came in falling down on the ice structure
So i think its fair to say she just jumped real high into the air - made the structure under herself, then continued to fall along with it
It also says "appeared" in the first panel, like she just did it
- 34,591
- 35,024
Do we know the size of Hakari's Domain Expansion?
Rodriiogo
He/Him- 1,313
- 1,661
If you mean canon size, no ; px scaling got it to like 9m?
- 21,534
- 36,143
Then it should be fineShe was not in the domain (doesnt even have it), she just came in falling down on the ice structure
So i think its fair to say she just jumped real high into the air - made the structure under herself, then continued to fall along with it
It also says "appeared" in the first panel, like she just did it
Arkenis
They/Them- 25,438
- 13,144
- Thread starter
- #94
- 24,320
- 37,752
calculated size due to inference and panels, not that big
canon size, unknown
- 34,591
- 35,024
Aye, I was just thinking that we could potentially compare his Domain Expansion to the ice block for its size. While the Domain is slightly more in the background compared to the block, it's not by a very drastic amount.
- 24,320
- 37,752
I did this in my blog already, that's the black sphere I calculated
- 34,591
- 35,024
Oh yeah, I forgot about that. Still seems best method to me.
- 3,212
- 3,300
We know that from what? and you're saying she jumped above the clouds?
OjeTheArcher15
He/Him- 1,266
- 755
Probably had
But the framing seems like she made it immediately seeing that the ice had condensation fog coming out of it that appears when Uraume does her technique
- 21,534
- 36,143
Im fine with either someone taking into account what I did or with KTs version
- 2,951
- 2,343
Which height of KT's? Second height?
- 12,767
- 15,298
I believe Tempest’s version is preferable because it relies on fewer assumptions, clearer panels, and does not require the ice structure to exceed 100 meters in width, which is not supported by the manga visuals.
For comparison, Rodrii’s calc results in a mass of ~1.07×10⁹kg of ice. Since the ice nearly fully melts before reaching the ground, this would correspond to over 1 billion liters of water falling in a relatively small area. Even as rainfall, this volume would necessarily result in extreme flooding, severe erosion, and widespread environmental damage, none of which is shown in the aftermath panels.
By contrast, Tempest’s upper end of 1,785,674.1kg corresponds to less than one Olympic swimming pool of water. This amount is consistent with the brief rainfall shown during the Kashimo vs Sukuna scene and aligns much better with the apparent scale of the ice structure, which visually appears to be well below 100 meters in width.
For comparison, Rodrii’s calc results in a mass of ~1.07×10⁹kg of ice. Since the ice nearly fully melts before reaching the ground, this would correspond to over 1 billion liters of water falling in a relatively small area. Even as rainfall, this volume would necessarily result in extreme flooding, severe erosion, and widespread environmental damage, none of which is shown in the aftermath panels.
By contrast, Tempest’s upper end of 1,785,674.1kg corresponds to less than one Olympic swimming pool of water. This amount is consistent with the brief rainfall shown during the Kashimo vs Sukuna scene and aligns much better with the apparent scale of the ice structure, which visually appears to be well below 100 meters in width.
- 12,767
- 15,298
Yes, and there a few more panels like this one. If we see the circumference and Uraume together like that it clearly indicates the ice structure is not 100m+ wide.
- 3,212
- 3,300
I thought its like, aftereffect of her ct right after she makes ice
That's parts of the cloud being dragged from the edges.
- 24,320
- 37,752
Damage3245, SunDaGamer, and Dalesean027 agree that my calculation is better, and those same 3 + M3X agree that the other calculations shouldn't be used.
With my calculation being the accepted one, the other thread should be removed. A scaling thread will likely be made soon in order to implement the changes.
With my calculation being the accepted one, the other thread should be removed. A scaling thread will likely be made soon in order to implement the changes.
- Status
