Genshin Impact Discussion Thread

[PedjaTarzan]

I either would do that or low key just wait for top tier to put up a on screen feat or we made Rerir scaling (x10) and we get up to 10 Yottatons shi

its probably going to be done by sinner or shade at fp so it would scale exclusively to them
just how 5-A is only for bina and dottore

 

[MSahla]

One of the best written characters in Genshin, and you're not ready for that Conversation.

 

[RoninSlayer200]

Biggest cap ever (I skipped all dialogues).

 

[Tsubasa16]

Dude what are you talking about? Paralogism is listed as pre-natlan but post-fontaine.

I mentioned already why i said that in another comment... (essentially i didn't get to check it myself but i had seen people saying that was the case for some reason).

Still it doesn't change the fact Skirk's quest for instance has dialogue in it that doesn't make sense if it doesn't take place either during or after Natlan.

 

[Giannysmag]

One of the best written characters in Genshin, and you're not ready for that Conversation.

She's a pretty well written but she's tiers below the best written character in Nod Krai (and Genshin)

 

[Voidnether]

One of the best written characters in Genshin, and you're not ready for that Conversation.

Below Furina

 

[Giannysmag]

 

[AsterReal]

I just realized that technically, Teyvat before the creation of the Three Moons should be larger than it is now. Given that Nibelung created the three moons from Teyvat's planetary crust, and given the size of the Eternal Moon, I don't think it would have taken very little crust from the planet to create the moons.

So, was Teyvat larger before the creation of the moons? I suppose large enough so that the loss of the crust needed to create the moons would not reduce their size so much.

 

[Le'garde273]

Can anyone tell me which moon calc currently will be used, cause depend on which calc i wanted to ask cgm to evaluate this

 

[Le'garde273]

https://vsbattles.com/threads/genshin-impact-discussion-thread.153890/post-7500831

Yeah i am aware there's two calc, but is there already decided which one will be used?

My calc currently use puppet calc as base, since he made first

 

[MSahla]

Can anyone tell me which moon calc currently will be used, cause depend on which calc i wanted to ask cgm to evaluate this

We're gonna discuss that later, but maybe i'm leaning towards Gianny's LS, both Class E for Dottore and Bina. But idk bout yours tho, maybe just ask cgm first.

 

[MSahla]

 

[IReallyLoveRilysse]

@Sahlwrld

 

[Voidnether]

@Sahlwrld

Knew it was 5-A

 

[MSahla]

@Sahlwrld

The dome is infinitely bigger than that.

 

[MSahla]

 

[Voidnether]

 

[MSahla]

Yeah i am aware there's two calc, but is there already decided which one will be used?

My calc currently use puppet calc as base, since he made first

Not really, we'll probably decide it on Gianny's new Dottore CRT.

 

[MSahla]

Escoffier will rerun in next patch but theres this woman, feels so hard to skip her. Like theres no way i skip Istaroth's daughter that i have been waiting since 2-3 years ago.

 

[IReallyLoveRilysse]

Knew it was 5-A

It's just an fan interpretation

 

[MSahla]

They're just husband and wife.

 

[MSahla]

Today was Alain's funeral. Heavy rain fell throughout the ceremony, as if someone was crying in the sky. Ugh. Annoying! Holding an umbrella in the rain is so inconvenient! Alain was laid to rest, and everything proceeded smoothly. I was the one who stepped forward to bid him farewell, while Pulonia stayed behind to look after the house.
The weather didn't clear up until midnight. I sat by the grave for a while, keeping Alain company, with the moon in the sky keeping me company in turn.

 

[Puppet43]

One of the best written characters in Genshin, and you're not ready for that Conversation.

Durin and Rerir better

They're just husband and wife.

Sun and Moon ship
.
I found some intersting about Rerir. He says this before exploting the cannon

炮中汲取的力量将会是上次的好几倍

The characters 几倍 mean double
This means that if the cannon had hit, Rerir would be twice as strong, but since it missed, it only reached 10% of its power. Therefore, we could assume that Shadow Rerir was between 6-9%, and that double percentage could be between 12-18%. And since Shadow Rerir could go toe-to-toe with Traveler using Moon Marrow, that would mean that the supposed double percentage would be equal to two Moon Marrows. And if we go back to Dottore, before he created the Third Marrow, Arle and Varka already mentioned him as a Nod Krai-level threat. The same thing happens in Acts 3 and 4 of Nod Krai; they portray Rerir as a Nod Krai-level threat.
.
So the scaling would go as this

Columbina Trilune > Dottore Trilune > Dain >= Lumine >= Rerir act 3 & 4/Dottore 2 Marrow >= Durin > Rerir 10% >= Trav and Arle with Marrows >= Rerir Shadow

This would mean that Sinners, Sovereings and Shade (which are portrey as narratively equal forces) would be like between 5.55 and 8 times the strength of 2 Marrows

 

[PedjaTarzan]

Traveler above rerir

 

[Puppet43]

Traveler above rerir

Shadow Rerir, the one who we press against the ropes
Yeah

 

[Giannysmag]

So the scaling would go as this

Trilunar Bina and Dottore are equal, Moon Traveler and Arle are weaker than shadow Rerir and how tf are Dain and Lumine stronger than Luna 2 Rerir?

 

[Puppet43]

Trilunar Bina and Dottore are equal, Moon Traveler and Arle are weaker than shadow Rerir and how tf are Dain and Lumine stronger than Luna 2 Rerir?

Trav was putting belt to bro
Even they are equals Bina was clearly stronger
i explain this in my wiki

 

[Giannysmag]

Trav was putting belt to bro

He absolutely wasn't lmao, what fight did you watch?

Even they are equals Bina was clearly stronger

No? They were going blow for blow and Bina had help from the Traveler too. She only started being clearly stronger when they stole one of the marrows

 

[AsterReal]

Even before removing the Moon Marrow from the Iridescent Moon, Dottore couldn't contain an attack from Columbina.

 

[AsterReal]

The traveler was even able to break his shield to take the Moon Marrow from the Iridescent Moon.

 

[MSahla]

Trilunar Bina and Dottore are equal

I don't think so. I mean, you can pretty much see Columbina is superior, like how she can amped or blessed Traveler until the Traveler manage to onpar with him with Trilunar, even though the Traveler was getting no diffed before. And Dottore's shield can't hold Bina's power.

Yes, the Traveler was getting buffed by Bina, hence why we got that cool ass burst animation with Lunar power and bypass his shield.

 

[Giannysmag]

 

[MSahla]

 

[The_Tetromino_King]

columbina => Dottore

 

[Giannysmag]

I don't think so. I mean, you can pretty much see Columbina is superior, like how she can amped or blessed Traveler until the Traveler manage to onpar with him with Trilunar, even though the Traveler was getting no diffed before. And Dottore's shield can't hold Bina's power.

Yes, the Traveler was getting buffed by Bina, hence why we got that cool ass burst animation with Lunar power and bypass his shield.

I rewatched the cutscenes of them fighting and it's definately more like Bina >= Dottore but they are still very relative, especially since he is reacting to both ehr and the amped Traveler

 

[MSahla]

I rewatched the cutscenes of them fighting and it's definately more like Bina >= Dottore but they are still very relative, especially since he is reacting to both ehr and the amped Traveler

If Bina can amped the Traveler to the point that the Traveler can matched him with 3 marrows and its authority, then Bina is just simply can do much much better than Traveler because she casually buffing Traveler until the Traveler were equal or even slightly stronger to Dottore.

 

[Giannysmag]

If Bina can amped the Traveler to the point that the Traveler can matched him with 3 marrows and its authority, then Bina is just simply can do much much better than Traveler because she casually buffing Traveler until the Traveler were equal to Dottore.

Not really, she is just making the Traveler strong enough to match Dottore. Even if you say that she split her power 50/50 between her and the Traveler for that to happen, Dottore is still keeping up with both at the same time

 

[MSahla]

Not really, she is just making the Traveler strong enough to match Dottore. Even if you say that she split her power 50/50 between her and the Traveler for that to happen, Dottore is still keeping up with both at the same time

I don't say she split her powers to the Traveler like 50/50, theres not really proof to say that, she already said it was just a blessing.

I mean yeah he can keeping up with them, but he's the one who will eventually be defeated since Columbina is stronger. Even those 3 layers shield by Dottore can't hold Bina's power even tho they got 3 Trilunar Power.

 

[Giannysmag]

I don't say she split her powers to the Traveler like 50/50, theres not really proof to say that, she already said it was just a blessing.

I know that's not what you meant, I'm just pointing out that without that interpretation her amping the Traveler doesn't mean anything by itself

I mean yeah he can keeping up with them, but he's the one who will eventually be defeated since Columbina is stronger.

He was defeated after losing 2 of moon marrows and with Flins, Nefer and Lauma jumping him

Even those 3 layers shield by Dottore can't hold Bina's power even tho they got 3 Trilunar Power.

That's fair tho even after he lost 2 of the marrows his shield could briefly hold back Bina's full power

 

[MSahla]

That's fair tho even after he lost 2 of the marrows his shield could briefly hold back Bina's full power

A usual dramatic scene.