-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Star Wars Discussion Thread Canon/Legends- Episode VI Return of the Threadi
- Thread starter Shadowbokunohero
- Start date
-
- Tags
- star wars
- 9,091
- 5,548
- 4,947
- 1,074
Yeah, I've spoken about the issues with using the calc before for Ezra & Kanan. TLDR: The feat that gave the ship's 8-A [102 Tons] rating caused way more damage than they did combined with multiple asteroids. Even if the feat was fine since two people did it, it'd be 8-B+ for Kanan & Ezra. But since they did way less damage it hard to quantify over 8-B. I'm wondering if anyone has the Grand Inquistor statement comparing him to Ventress
- 9,091
- 5,548
But that's not the point of the calculation. The ship's 8-A durability comes from something different; we're not calculating Erza and Kanan's feat, that calculation doesn't even exist on the verse page. We were only scaling it up based on their ability to damage a ship with 8-A durability.
- 4,947
- 1,074
Is the ship's durability not upscaling from this?
- 9,091
- 5,548
I thought you were talking about using the calculation based on Kanan and Erza's feat. I got confused.
- 4,947
- 1,074
I know which calc you're talking about but, I went to the ships page and found the calc it linked to. The calc is perfectly fine overall for the ship durability. The issue is that the attack that gives ship durability left it pretty damaged but intact. Kanan and Ezra did not inflict anywhere near that level of damage. I think getting an 8-A from the ship damage only works if they actually left major damage. In the imgur scan I looked at they left very little lasting damage. Sorry if I explained that confusingly.
Nonynho
Any/All- 9,199
- 2,878
RotS Yoda > RotS Ani
Oh yeah
- 4,947
- 1,074
Might be able scale the Grand Inquisitor to 8-A off the Ice Cliff Feat. Because he did stomp Barriss. Not sure how to handle the Ventress thing though, because she lost to an Inquisitor, but we also have the statement putting her over him. Not sure if she has any canonical power drop statements. Not sure if context from the SW Tales changes anything?
- 375
- 88
- 52,605
- 46,829
Vader was one-handed. He was EXTREMELY casual there.Shouldn't he be same tier as Vader?
- 4,947
- 1,074
I'm not sure? This canonically pretty close to RoTS, and yet Vader still quickly overwhelmed him in combat. Though I should note depending on how we take Tales of the Underworld, the Ventress scaling might be outdated if we don't consider her as grown weaker. We might be able to use the use the Grand Inquisitor to get a 8-B+ for Kanan at least. He managed to press the Grand Inquisitor more than Barriss did.Shouldn't he be same tier as Vader?
- 9,091
- 5,548
Vader was using one hand (meaning he wasn't taking it seriously) + he then says he was just testing the suit + shortly after, Sidious appears and says that Vader defeated the Grand Inquisitor with little effort.Shouldn't he be same tier as Vader?
Vader wasn't even trying, and when he does, he defeats the guy instantly.
- 8,619
- 1,815
I wonder how Khaleen Hentz would think on Vos partnering with another Nightsister of all things
- 8,619
- 1,815
This is why I reccomend reading the Rise of the Sith and Clone Wars Epic Collection paperbacks, the comics humanize Ki-Adi-Mundi as someone who is honestly just trying their best at being a jedi and father whilst in a turbulent time period of change. Even when he told Anakin about how the he loss his family during the Clone Wars and how he got over it, it was in the context of trying to comfort Anakin over the loss of master (before Obi-Wan came back).
- 8,619
- 1,815
two of them actually
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,217
actually theres a statement that puts anakin> ROTS yoda
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,218
also canon Windu is a fraud compared to his legends counterpart
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,219
i think there is prob avenues to get him to tier 7.
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,220
anyway fraud windu
- 1,044
- 832
this entire thing of palps playing with mace never made sense to me because that boy got fried like chicken the entire fight.anyway fraud windu
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,222
bro got fried three times, i think his lowkey just a *********. or gets off on spunging his lightning everywhere and struggles to "pull back" as they say.
- 9,091
- 5,548
anyway fraud windu
I had already mentioned this here. In any case, @XSOULOFCINDERX had a different opinion.
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,224
those are pretty conflicting stuff, id argue then just to use the most recent scans then as they take precedence. the storygroup members including people Pablo hildago have mention stuff like the visual dictionaries being "soft canon" in the sense that they take precedent in the context of omissions of information but are subject to change and inferior to those found directly in the media.
a lot of windu's scans also originated from the Legends 2010's book which were beholden to luxas's comments of Windu>palpatine, which canon doesnt have too.
that being said if the WIndu> palps stuff is more consistent, has more statements, including much newer ones then its fine.
a lot of windu's scans also originated from the Legends 2010's book which were beholden to luxas's comments of Windu>palpatine, which canon doesnt have too.
that being said if the WIndu> palps stuff is more consistent, has more statements, including much newer ones then its fine.
- 9,091
- 5,548
Well, I don't know, I haven't gone into it very deeply.
I generally only collect scans of Anakin/Vader.
But the Fanhome Encyclopedia, which mentions this thing about Palpatine toying with Mace Windu, was released in 2020.
I mean, this specific book, the releases of this encyclopedia were from 2020-2022.
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,226
the downside of star wars being how chunky it is lol
Nonynho
Any/All- 9,199
- 2,878
I think we got a couple more stuff countering this idea
- 7,814
- 7,468
Canon can and always has shifted but I feel like these statements paint a comprehensively less reasonable picture than what the scene shows
- 9,091
- 5,548
Give me the scan so I can put it in a certain place.
- 9,091
- 5,548
Let's do a test driver on Vader. Any good vs thread?
Nonynho
Any/All- 9,199
- 2,878
From what weeks-ago-discussion between me and Carvalho told, Vader only surpassed RotS Sidious by +/- the time of Rebels/post-those-events, and another colleague of ours were out here saying it'd be unfair to put Ani against Yoda for a duel, so that'd be the line for y'all:
let's please avoid circular chain
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,232
apparently according to Debrah Chow, Kenobi series vader is prime vader
Nonynho
Any/All- 9,199
- 2,878
Carvalho's the best Vader fan ever lmao
- 9,091
- 5,548
Nonynho
Any/All- 9,199
- 2,878
this is indeed veeeeeeeery nice
i think this justifies incon between RotS Ani and Yoda, what do y'all think of making this thread?
- 9,091
- 5,548
I don't see much need for it, despite the statements; a lot of Star Wars comes from interpretation. We can just put things and statements in the profiles and let the rest be interpreted.
The second thing about Dooku's lightsaber skill is cool, but there's a difference between pure power and lightsaber skill.
The most obvious example is Luke, during the fight against Vader and the Grand Inquisitor.
- 16,968
- 12,949
- Thread starter
- #3,237
I agree with "Anakin (CW) < Anakin (RotS/Pré-Sith) < Anakin (RotS/Post-Sith) < Vader (Post-Suit) < Vader (LotS) < Vader (OWK) < Vader (Rebels) < Vader (ANH) < Vader (ROJ)"
personally, in fact theres prob a few > even between clone wars seasons
is this why you were asking for the anakin scan? @Phsccarvalho
personally, in fact theres prob a few > even between clone wars seasons
is this why you were asking for the anakin scan? @Phsccarvalho
- 9,091
- 5,548
There are still some post-ESB scans from that comic book series of Vader being stronger than ever.
The ANH) is because there's a magazine called "Entertainment Weekly's Ultimate Guide to Rogue One" that says Vader is in his prime during Rogue One.
Unfortunately, I can't find an image or a PDF of that magazine; I only see people talking about it.
Technically, each older version of Vader is his prime, considering the continuous power increases mentioned in that statement that the power of the Sith (referring to Vader and Palpatine) increases over time (besides Vader's meditations on Mustafar).
The way I presented it only shows key moments where there's another statement about his new prime or power increase, so of course, there are more "<"
I asked because I'm collecting scans for this sandbox. So any of our scale scans are welcome.
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 26,466
- 12,373
He scales above TPM Maul but got done in by being nerfed twice and also fighting in an area that ***** his fighting style.
- 9,091
- 5,548
Actually, I did that to contextualize myself with Palpatine's statement. Him saying that RotS Anakin was almost rivaling him in power.
So I was making this "scale" between Anakin and Vader themselves.
Because it would be something like that.
The ">~" signifies that Sidious is stronger, but not by such a large margin, considering his own statement about Anakin in "Secrets of the Sith".
Similar threads
- Locked
