• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Attack on Titan Colossal Titan Feat

I'm not gonna lie we don't even need a cgm when I tell you this is an absurd stance from weekly I mean it.

What is a shockwave?

A shockwave is a sharp change of pressure in a narrow region travelling through a medium, especially air, caused by explosion or by a body moving faster than sound. A shockwave must generate force on the basis of it's definition, something, with mass must be able to move faster than the speed of sound creating a change in the pressure in a region travelling through a medium. The pressure generated in that medium creates a force, that force is called an oblique shock. At minimum, a shockwave generates an oblique shock. As the Mach number of the upstream flow becomes increasingly hypersonic (faster), the equations for the pressure, density, and temperature after the oblique shock wave reach a mathematical limit. However, speed isn't the only thing that increases a shockwaves force, mass also increases it.

Mass, how does it increase a shockwaves force? No- This isn't important, but we do know mass increases a shockwaves force. The greater mass the more it provides more inertia and in turn a greater force to the medium during the impact that creates the shockwave. Now the object creating this shockwave is clearly an object with a large mass, in turn, making the shockwave more powerful, let's assume for a second this object created a force of 2.3612759889 Kilotons of TNT, at a distance of 721 meters away, the force would still be felt at strengths of (roughly) 1.51 megajoules. I calculated this using basic math - Energy per square meters = Energy total / (4 * 3.1416 * r^2) - 2.36 / (4 * 3.1416 * 721^2 = 3.61268914e-7 Kilotons per square meter, that force would be felt by people standing at a distance of 720 meters away, not only would that cause severe movement of sand, but also severe movement of hair.

I consider this case closed.
 
It seems apparent that using the shockwave at distance to find the energy of this feat is invalid
I will say tho there's still a blast from the impact considering we see all the scouts flung, the giant dust cloud created, and the bones fragments being flung
 
It seems apparent that using the shockwave at distance to find the energy of this feat is invalid
I will say tho there's still a blast from the impact considering we see all the scouts flung, the giant dust cloud created, and the bones fragments being flung
I'm fine with using whatever the appropriate overpressure would be at that distance. I don't think any overpressure in the given scale is applicable at the full distance based on observable effects.
 
I'm fine with using whatever the appropriate overpressure would be at that distance. I don't think any overpressure in the given scale is applicable at the full distance based on observable effects.
Is there even a way to quantify the accurate overpressure from that distance if it's shown not even effecting civilians?

I think calculating the dust cloud KE like how it's done in this would be better https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Shmeatywerbenmanjenson/Aang_Nukes_the_Desert
with the dust density found in here
I was thinking about doing a similar thing with the cloud dust created by the beast titan's throw in the anime, tho that one would be done differently
 
I think calculating the dust cloud KE like how it's done in this would be better
I guess that could work but you'd have to use some other density that accounts for the air gaps that would exist in the cloud. The calc uses compact sand density meaning it's treating it like a solid pillar of sand rather than a cloud. The comments mention another end but I can't find it in the blog.
 
I guess that could work but you'd have to use some other density that accounts for the air gaps that would exist in the cloud. The calc uses compact sand density meaning it's treating it like a solid pillar of sand rather than a cloud. The comments mention another end but I can't find it in the blog.
that's why I linked one that has dust density
also it isn't a solid pillar of sand in the avatar calc, they put 99% hollowness to account for air gaps
 
I want to add, the og calc uses the explosion formula despite it being a shockwave

The formula used should've been this instead, the ideal bomb blast formula
E = (ρ/t^2)*(r/c)^5

this still doesn't solve the problem of it doing nothing to the civilians though. I plan on doing the suggested recalc of measuring the dust cloud KE instead soon-ish
 
Basically yes, it does not need to do that as it expands. Shockwaves get weaker as they travel, so the force displayed kilometers from the epicenter will be significantly weaker. All explosions work like this.
Yes, but 4 psi is the power at the distance from the impact, not at the epicenter.
 
Back
Top