Let's Re-Do This: Tier 3 Taizai?

[Kaydee1648]

which supports the fact that it's a seperate dimension(also implied in this scan)

This scan doesn’t prove its spatio temporally separate, even purgatory is referred to as another world, and tmk this lake has similar properties. Also, time dilation isn’t proof of an isolated time axis.
The high 3-A is straightforward so there’s no issue with it

Chaos itself would still be L2C for creating a spacetime.

A certain spatial size is needed to be low 2-C

 

[Majinere566]

This scan doesn’t prove its spatio temporally separate, even purgatory is referred to as another world, and tmk this lake has similar properties. Also, time dilation isn’t proof of an isolated time axis.
The high 3-A is straightforward so there’s no issue with it

Purgatory is another dimension…

 

[Kaydee1648]

I didn’t say it’s not a dimension.

 

[Majinere566]

Then im failing to understand the relevance your comparison with purgatory is to this

 

[Shigeonnt]

If there are some additional statements I don't know about please enlighten me and drop the scans. All the scans I see in the op all day "infinite magic force" , "stores infinite magic" . Those refer to potency of the magic there and not the size of the river itself. And yeah it does matter, if the magic doesn't literally extend to infinity then the dimension doesn't have a size quantifiable enough to be low2c

It’s not about potential, potential is anything that can or can’t come to exist. The magic is already infinite in act. The argument’s so simple it honestly feels like you’re just denying it to yourself. There are a few ways infinite magic could apply here: first, every point of the lake could hold an infinite amount of magic, but there’s no evidence for that, so that option’s completely off the table. The second one is that the magic is the lake itself, since it’s infinite, the lake would necessarily have to be infinite too. That’s the most solid option, especially since we’ve got statements saying the lake is infinite in size. Even if those statements come from Jericho, it could still count as a form of indirect authorial voice, where the author passes info to the audience through a character. Be more objective next time, the feat isn’t Low 2-C, it’s just High 3-A.

 

[Majinere566]

Hey man we can open up a different thread about the Low 2-C shit

 

[Shigeonnt]

Hey man we can open up a different thread about the Low 2-C shit

But I’m pretty sure it’s not gonna get accepted as low 2-C level power

 

[Celest_Void]

If there are some additional statements I don't know about please enlighten me and drop the scans. All the scans I see in the op all day "infinite magic force" , "stores infinite magic" . Those refer to potency of the magic there and not the size of the river itself.

The Lady of the Lake says that the lake is, in fact, magic. And if magic is infinite, then the lake is too. This is the most logical reasoning here, since in the same chapter it's stated that the lake expands infinitely.

 

[karo_senpaii]

It’s not about potential, potential is anything that can or can’t come to exist. The magic is already infinite in act. The argument’s so simple it honestly feels like you’re just denying it to yourself. There are a few ways infinite magic could apply here: first, every point of the lake could hold an infinite amount of magic, but there’s no evidence for that, so that option’s completely off the table. The second one is that the magic is the lake itself, since it’s infinite, the lake would necessarily have to be infinite too. That’s the most solid option, especially since we’ve got statements saying the lake is infinite in size. Even if those statements come from Jericho, it could still count as a form of indirect authorial voice, where the author passes info to the audience through a character. Be more objective next time, the feat isn’t Low 2-C, it’s just High 3-A.

What are you on about? I said potency and not potential

The Lady of the Lake says that the lake is, in fact, magic. And if magic is infinite, then the lake is too. This is the most logical reasoning here, since in the same chapter it's stated that the lake expands infinitely.

The magic holds infinite power ≠ magic covers an infinite space

 

[Celest_Void]

What are you on about? I said potency and not potential

The magic holds infinite power ≠ magic covers an infinite space

Magic has density. If it has density, it occupies space. So... it's pretty obvious here.

Lancelot says, “An infinite store?”

The Lady of the Lake replies, “Yes...” and then states that the water is magic.

Space is infinite. I don't know how you can still keep denying it.

 

[karo_senpaii]

Magic has density. If it has density, it occupies space. So... it's pretty obvious here.

Lancelot says, “An infinite store?”

The Lady of the Lake replies, “Yes...” and then states that the water is magic.

Space is infinite. I don't know how you can still keep denying it.

Of course I know it occupies space, it's a damn lake.

It's an infinite store of magic, as in power itself not extension.
The water it magic, said water which is magic is potent enough to have infinite power .
Don't bother replying to me again, We've said all we could

 

[Demon_Lord18]

 

[Majinere566]

Post in thread 'Official Translation Requests Thread (New forum)'
https://vsbattles.com/threads/official-translation-requests-thread-new-forum.107531/post-7337056

 

[Majinere566]

Can this get added now?

Also for people this would affect

Chaos

Lady of the lake*

Arthur with a “possibly” or “likely” or “up to”

 

[Demon_Lord18]

Can this get added now?

Also for people this would affect

Chaos

Lady of the lake*

Arthur with a “possibly” or “likely” or “up to”

Add it only for Chaos; the Lady of the Lake and Arthur could be left for another CRT

 

[Demon_Lord18]

Can this get added now?

17:46

 

[Damage3245]

Add it only for Chaos; the Lady of the Lake and Arthur could be left for another CRT

I don't think there's any disputes for the Lady of the Lake and possibly Arthur at this time.

Although the Lady of the Lake doesn't really exercise the full power of the Lake as AP if that's what you mean.

 

[Demon_Lord18]

I don't think there's any disputes for the Lady of the Lake and possibly Arthur at this time.

Although the Lady of the Lake doesn't really exercise the full power of the Lake as AP if that's what you mean.

Arthur has the full power of Chaos, so I think a “possibly” or “likely” would work for him.
The Lady of the Lake could get it due to her Large size, since she is the lake itself.

 

[Shigeonnt]

Arthur has the full power of Chaos, so I think a “possibly” or “likely” would work for him.
The Lady of the Lake could get it due to her Large size, since she is the lake itself.

Why not lance?

 

[Bossbrosish]

Why not lance?

That's going to be discussed in a separate thread

 

[Demon_Lord18]

48 hours have passed; since the CRT was approved, I’ll apply this to Chaos.

 

[Cursed_Copycat]

I don't think there's any disputes for the Lady of the Lake and possibly Arthur at this time.

Although the Lady of the Lake doesn't really exercise the full power of the Lake as AP if that's what you mean.

For the lady, you could put ‘Unknown’ for ap, and ‘up to’ h3a as we don’t know if she can utilize the magic like Lancelot seemingly could, is my suggestion.

 

[Cursed_Copycat]

Of course I know it occupies space, it's a damn lake.

It's an infinite store of magic, as in power itself not extension.
The water it magic, said water which is magic is potent enough to have infinite power .
Don't bother replying to me again, We've said all we could

Could you actually give some evidence from the manga that supports the Lake being finite in size? All you’ve done thus far is ignore manga statements with absolutely 0 basis for doing so and it’s getting us nowhere

 

[Demon_Lord18]

This can be closed.

 

[Majinere566]

Yeah can any mods close this?