• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Undertale: The prelude of a series of big revisions (Part 0/?)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
19,280
Reaction score
11,978
Hello everyone. It's been a while since my last CRT involving both Undertale and Deltarune, but the results are finally getting released, especially since today is a month since the 10th anniversary.

The following is the prelude to a series of CRTs that will further fix and update both games (especially with the new feats from Chapters 3 and 4, but that's gonna be there, as this CRT is about Undertale after all), and this would have been significantly far more difficult without the help I've received to do this.

So, before continuing, I'll list the invividuals who have been major contributors here: @TheOrangeGuy09, @Eden_Warlock99, @LittleGuy99, @Qurbonboev, @Monsters_fight and @Psychomaster35... and @Arceus0x was there too, somewhere.

The canon status of the 10th anniversary content

I believe that the elephant of the room here is whether to treat the new content of the 10th anniversary livestreams, which can be both seen here in their entirety, but if you want to see just the new stuff, just go here.

These are all just minor additions like new cutscenes, but some are genuine extensions of places that were never explored in the actual game, like the Old and New Ruins, the school, a whole new underwater area, and even the part of the house of the Annoying Dog that was left "unpatched" in the original game.

There is in fact a part which can be problematic, AKA the entire Spamton segment which would imply that he'd be canon in Undertale and also a replacement of Sans, but there are two issues here:
  1. The part is not a real part of the game, it happens after that Spamton A. Spamton injected that big-ass floppy disk in the screen, which effectively caused the game to be hacked. It did not have Spamton as a genuine part of it, it's just a result of actual edit.
  2. Toby Fox says explicitly when he does not want stuff to be canon (like with the livestream of the Spamton Sweespstakes, the kickstarter or the merch), but regarding the 10th anniversary livestream he just said that these areas are just "like a what if" that "was always there, it never wasn't there and never will not be there", which is a reference to how Frisk will never meet everyone in the Underground even if they walk all over it, which is something that is already a fact in the actual game as for example you never engage with all the population of the Underground which is stated to be in thousands, but you can fight with only 104 monsters in total besides bosses, other than the fact you cannot fight people like Alphys or the vendors, or also how New Home is a big city full of homes which we never interact with. Meaning that it's actually the "true" version of the game that is probably more canon than the game we played if anything.
Meaning that if the 10th anniversary stream is accepted as canon, then the next CRT will implement the new feats and info that come from there.

Regarding the Flowey scaling + Mettaton feat upgrade

We currently scale Asgore as above Flowey's 7.28 Tons feat based on this statement from the latter which supposedly means that no matter how much LV he gains.

However, this is wrong, as he only mentions that he could never go past him to get the SOULs, which he specifies as him showing them to him (which only does to Frisk given them being the last human to kill). Him being unable to beat Asgore no matter the LV would also contradict his claim of him having killed everyone in some of his runs.

BUT, Asgore would still be superior to a LV 1 Flowey, due to him being equal in stats with Toriel, who could easily erase Flowey’s bullets and knock him out with a single attack.

However, the evidence for people like Undyne scaling to Asgore is kinda shaky, especially when no character besides Toriel has direct combat showings against base Flowey anyway, and he has no real CHECK STATs for almost all his forms besides the GoH Asriel one. Plus Flowey being on the same level of Asgore and Toriel fits given that he’s still the dust of Asriel combined with some DT, and Asriel, just like his parents, is a Boss Monster, the strongest type.

Regardless, there is a replacement for the current Mettaton’s 0.41 Tons calc, that being this one of 2.42 Tons (so still High 8-C, but lower), which would basically scale to basically everyone whose stats are below 80. The gap between the 2 calcs is barely above x3, and said gap is still fitting with Undyne knocking down Asgore in a casual sparring session, and overwhelming Toriel off-screen. Regarding how this applied to the peak human SOUL scaling, I'll get to it in the next CRT.

LS wise, however, the new calc upgrades the verse (still within Class M though) from the current 3304 Tons to 11730 Tons, and everyone with 18 and above ATK would scale from it (especially when Undyne, the same one who uses LS to flex her strength, still calls Papyrus very strong).

Sans' TK also would scale from Papyrus' LS, given that between the two, Sans' TK is far better, and there's no reason to say that Papyrus' TK is that lower than his ATK (which I'll explain right now in the following section).

SOUL Power is UES

The last part of the CRT is that I do believe that SOUL power as a UES is something that is established in the verse, but the hints aren’t that obvious.

In Undertale, this has been mentioned in the Entries 1 and 2 of the True Lab where it’s stated that the Barrier is locked by SOUL power, and that enough of it is required to break it, with Papyrus mentioning that Asgore needs Frisk’s SOUL to get enough SOUL Power to break the barrier, and that the power of 7 SOULs is needed to destroy the barrier. In fact, the power of the single Human SOUL at peak is stated to be equal to the power of all the monsters’ SOULs at once.

And said power of the SOUL is shown in multiple ways:
Because of all the above, I believe it’s clear that both Magic and DETERMINATION can increase one’s SOUL Power, which is linked to one’s physical stats (AP, Dura, Speed and LS), as well as the potency of the non-physical abilities like Magic and DETERMINATION, meaning that SOUL Power qualifies as being UES, which also means that Frisk and Chara finally stop being featless in LS, but will scale to the characters whose DT makes them comparable/above.

(Yeah Sans is still one of the fastest guys despite his 1 ATK/DEF stats, but he’s literally made to cheat around the rules of the game, so him being a canon outlier in this fits his character).

TLDR:

  • The contents of the 10th anniversary livestream are canon and should be used.
  • Only very few characters will scale to Flowey's feat, rest will be downgraded from High 8-C+ (7.28 Tons) to only High 8-C (2.42 Tons).
  • SOUL Power is a UES that scales to AP, Dura, LS, Speed and Hax potency.
 
Last edited:
Oh, so that's how the 2.42t calculation fits in. Hmmm, that would be an AP downgrade from the current Tier 7s, but it makes sense, I suppose. It's consistent. The only ones we know who are capable of giving Flowey any trouble are Sans via hax and Asgore, with Toriel being able to temporarily overwhelm Flowey early on, and maybe Papyrus if the "Papyrus Never Moves" theory is correct...

Although I do remember that during roughly the end of the Pacifist route, just before Flowey becomes Asriel, the general cast is able to block Flowey's attacks and protect Frisk, so IDK.

Anyway, I agree with everything.
 
Although I do remember that during roughly the end of the Pacifist route, just before Flowey becomes Asriel, the general cast is able to block Flowey's attacks and protect Frisk, so IDK.
The thing is that Flowey was actually in his Omega form there as he had the power of 6 SOULs, and he was clearly holding back in order to gather the remaining SOULs needed to transform in Asriel (unless they're actually Low 2-C lol).
Hmmm, that would be an AP downgrade from the current Tier 7s
As I said, that would be elaborated with more detail in the next CRT given that has more than meets the eye which needs to be proper analyzed.
 
Any upgrade for Sans 🥲? (besides the fact he is able to randomly summon that car i forgot the name in english) and the fact he can make his bones non lethal and tangible?
 
In general this makes sense, however I have to disagree with your take on Undyne. I understand that Asgore is the strongest but downscaling from him shouldn't be an issue since she can consistently clash with him. You also mentioned Undyne banishing Toriel after challenging her which only supports this. Remember, Undyne is quite special, being the only monster to naturally generate determination. I think Undyne and the few people above her should still scale to Flowey.

In short, anyone from 50atk and above should scale imho. Whether anyone else scales...idk.
 
Also Asgore should still scale above Flowey. Obviously he wouldn't beat him on higher levels at some point but base flowey got nuked by a single fireball from Toriel and just generally has no reason to not be outscaled by Asgore.
 
In general this makes sense, however I have to disagree with your take on Undyne. I understand that Asgore is the strongest but downscaling from him shouldn't be an issue since she can consistently clash with him. You also mentioned Undyne banishing Toriel after challenging her which only supports this. Remember, Undyne is quite special, being the only monster to naturally generate determination. I think Undyne and the few people above her should still scale to Flowey.
I am not really saying that she does not scale, just that a x3 gap can already allow her to be able to still contend with Asgore/Toriel.

Plus this wiki has a precedent about this, as we allow 8-C characters to have the ability to minimally harm High 8-C+ ones as part of their AP justification, so this should not have a problem either.
 
Also Asgore should still scale above Flowey. Obviously he wouldn't beat him on higher levels at some point but base flowey got nuked by a single fireball from Toriel and just generally has no reason to not be outscaled by Asgore.
BUT, Asgore would still be superior to a LV 1 Flowey, due to him being equal in stats with Toriel, who could easily erase Flowey’s bullets and knock him out with a single attack.
I already said he does still though.
 
I am not really saying that she does not scale, just that a x3 gap can already allow her to be able to still contend with Asgore/Toriel.

Plus this wiki has a precedent about this, as we allow 8-C characters to have the ability to minimally harm High 8-C+ ones as part of their AP justification, so this should not have a problem either.
I just don't think there's a good enough reason not to scale her. Sure, she is weaker than Asgore by an undefined extent. Doesn't mean she is 3x below either. We know she is very strong, we know she fought off Toriel and can clash with Asgore. There's no real anti-feats that put her below that. Being a boss monster doesn't help either, it's not like it's some law of nature, it is just something common.
 
I already said he does still though.
forgor
sans-pixel-art-face-kcudse1miu845p0c.png
 
I just don't think there's a good enough reason not to scale her. Sure, she is weaker than Asgore by an undefined extent. Doesn't mean she is 3x below either. We know she is very strong, we know she fought off Toriel and can clash with Asgore. There's no real anti-feats that put her below that. Being a boss monster doesn't help either, it's not like it's some law of nature, it is just something common.
Again, you are misunderstanding my argument.

We usually use the "downscale to an undefined degree" if we don't know the real gap, but we do. I am not even saying she cannot downscale, I am in fact using these to support her being relative. The thing you're not addressing is the fact that a x3 gap is enough to do so. Plus these fights happened off-screen, so we don't know if Undyne managed to wrestle with a serious Asgore, especially given that she only fought him in sparing sessions, and she still considers Asgore to be far stronger than herself, as she considers killing Frisk to be mercy compared to what Asgore could do to them.
 
In general this makes sense, however I have to disagree with your take on Undyne. I understand that Asgore is the strongest but downscaling from him shouldn't be an issue since she can consistently clash with him. You also mentioned Undyne banishing Toriel after challenging her which only supports this. Remember, Undyne is quite special, being the only monster to naturally generate determination. I think Undyne and the few people above her should still scale to Flowey.
Undyne overthrew Toriel with the entire Underground backing her during a rebellion.
She never actually beat Toriel in a one-on-one fight, Undyne just forcibly removed Toriel with an entire army along with her, and considering the fact Toriel still ends up leaving on her own accord in the endings without Undyne, it's not like she was clinging to the throne in the first place.

That coupled with Undyne’s line about how killing Frisk being mercy compared to what Asgore could do really shows just how highly she regards his power.

Plus, it’s generally better to scale characters to something we know they're stronger than rather than something slightly higher that they're weaker than.
 
Last edited:
Seems good at a glance

Even with the monster downgrade, Deltarune characters are still fodder to them.
 
For the most part, I agree.
Not sure about the LS feat though, it might be an outlier given this dialogue:
* Undyne is very strong.
* Papyrus made a bet with her that she could not lift everyone here up.
* She could.
* The only trouble is that she did not know how to put everyone down.
Undyne being able to physically lift everyone is considered as a reason for her to be strong and Papyrus made a bet about this as well. So it would be weird if that many characters scaled to 11,730 tons.

Apart from that, I agree.
 
Undyne being able to physically lift everyone is considered as a reason for her to be strong and Papyrus made a bet about this as well. So it would be weird if that many characters scaled to 11,730 tons.
This would just upscale Undyne. The argument is Papyrus downscaling from Mettaton in LS, not Undyne.
 
Agree with (practically) everything

It clearly us/Frisk that slashed her. We pushed the button to attack, and attack does 23k damage(unlike Chara attacks, that always do 999s damage).

Not sure about the LS feat though, it might be an outlier given this dialogue:
Can you give context about this dialogue (who is everyone here referred to)?

Even with the monster downgrade, Deltarune characters are still fodder to them.
 
This would just upscale Undyne. The argument is Papyrus downscaling from Mettaton in LS, not Undyne.
The point is that Undyne being able to lift Alphys, Asgore, Sans, Papyrus and Toriel at once is something that is means she's strong and is something that Papyrus bet Undyne couldn't do. Which she was able to do, but I doubt Papyrus would assume she wouldn't be able to if a good chunk of the Underground including him can lift 11.7k tons
 
The point is that Undyne being able to lift Alphys, Asgore, Sans, Papyrus and Toriel at once is something that is means she's strong and is something that Papyrus bet Undyne couldn't do. Which she was able to do, but I doubt Papyrus would assume she wouldn't be able to if a good chunk of the Underground including him can lift 11.7k tons
Do be an anti-feat that Papyrus goes "I bet you can't lift an ant!"
Well, this would mean that no-one scales to Class M, as Toriel, who is equal to Asgore, said that Undyne is strong via that too. It would also imply Undyne is above Asgore as well... weird.
 
Hello everyone. It's been a while since my last CRT involving both Undertale and Deltarune, but the results are finally getting released, especially since today is a month since the 10th anniversary.

The following is the prelude to a series of CRTs that will further fix and update both games (especially with the new feats from Chapters 3 and 4, but that's gonna be there, as this CRT is about Undertale after all), and this would have been significantly far more difficult without the help I've received to do this.

So, before continuing, I'll list the invividuals who have been major contributors here: @TheOrangeGuy09, @Eden_Warlock99, @LittleGuy99, @Qurbonboev, @Monsters_fight and @Psychomaster35... and @Arceus0x was there too, somewhere.

The canon status of the 10th anniversary content

I believe that the elephant of the room here is whether to treat the new content of the 10th anniversary livestreams, which can be both seen here in their entirety, but if you want to see just the new stuff, just go here.

These are all just minor additions like new cutscenes, but some are genuine extensions of places that were never explored in the actual game, like the Old and New Ruins, the school, a whole new underwater area, and even the part of the house of the Annoying Dog that was left "unpatched" in the original game.

There is in fact a part which can be problematic, AKA the entire Spamton segment which would imply that he'd be canon in Undertale and also a replacement of Sans, but there are two issues here:
  1. The part is not a real part of the game, it happens after that Spamton A. Spamton injected that big-ass floppy disk in the screen, which effectively caused the game to be hacked. It did not have Spamton as a genuine part of it, it's just a result of actual edit.
  2. Toby Fox says explicitly when he does not want stuff to be canon (like with the livestream of the Spamton Sweespstakes, the kickstarter or the merch), but regarding the 10th anniversary livestream he just said that these areas are just "like a what if" that "was always there, it never wasn't there and never will not be there", which is a reference to how Frisk will never meet everyone in the Underground even if they walk all over it, which is something that is already a fact in the actual game as for example you never engage with all the population of the Underground which is stated to be in thousands, but you can fight with only 104 monsters in total besides bosses, other than the fact you cannot fight people like Alphys or the vendors, or also how New Home is a big city full of homes which we never interact with. Meaning that it's actually the "true" version of the game that is probably more canon than the game we played if anything.
Meaning that if the 10th anniversary stream is accepted as canon, then the next CRT will implement the new feats and info that come from there.

Regarding the Flowey scaling + Mettaton feat upgrade

We currently scale Asgore as above Flowey's 7.28 Tons feat based on this statement from the latter which supposedly means that no matter how much LV he gains.

However, this is wrong, as he only mentions that he could never go past him to get the SOULs, which he specifies as him showing them to him (which only does to Frisk given them being the last human to kill). Him being unable to beat Asgore no matter the LV would also contradict his claim of him having killed everyone in some of his runs.

BUT, Asgore would still be superior to a LV 1 Flowey, due to him being equal in stats with Toriel, who could easily erase Flowey’s bullets and knock him out with a single attack.

However, the evidence for people like Undyne scaling to Asgore is kinda shaky, especially when no character besides Toriel has direct combat showings against base Flowey anyway, and he has no real CHECK STATs for almost all his forms besides the GoH Asriel one. Plus Flowey being on the same level of Asgore and Toriel fits given that he’s still the dust of Asriel combined with some DT, and Asriel, just like his parents, is a Boss Monster, the strongest type.

Regardless, there is a replacement for the current Mettaton’s 0.41 Tons calc, that being this one of 2.42 Tons (so still High 8-C, but lower), which would basically scale to basically everyone whose stats are below 80. The gap between the 2 calcs is barely above x3, and said gap is still fitting with Undyne knocking down Asgore in a casual sparring session, and overwhelming Toriel off-screen. Regarding how this applied to the peak human SOUL scaling, I'll get to it in the next CRT.

LS wise, however, the new calc upgrades the verse (still within Class M though) from the current 3304 Tons to 11730 Tons, and everyone with 18 and above ATK would scale from it (especially when Undyne, the same one who uses LS to flex her strength, still calls Papyrus very strong).

Sans' TK also would scale from Papyrus' LS, given that between the two, Sans' TK is far better, and there's no reason to say that Papyrus' TK is that lower than his ATK (which I'll explain right now in the following section).

SOUL Power is UES

The last part of the CRT is that I do believe that SOUL power as a UES is something that is established in the verse, but the hints aren’t that obvious.

In Undertale, this has been mentioned in the Entries 1 and 2 of the True Lab where it’s stated that the Barrier is locked by SOUL power, and that enough of it is required to break it, with Papyrus mentioning that Asgore needs Frisk’s SOUL to get enough SOUL Power to break the barrier, and that the power of 7 SOULs is needed to destroy the barrier. In fact, the power of the single Human SOUL at peak is stated to be equal to the power of all the monsters’ SOULs at once.

And said power of the SOUL is shown in multiple ways:
Because of all the above, I believe it’s clear that both Magic and DETERMINATION can increase one’s SOUL Power, which is linked to one’s physical stats (AP, Dura, Speed and LS), as well as the potency of the non-physical abilities like Magic and DETERMINATION, meaning that SOUL Power qualifies as being UES, which also means that Frisk and Chara finally stop being featless in LS, but will scale to the characters whose DT makes them comparable/above.

(Yeah Sans is still one of the fastest guys despite his 1 ATK/DEF stats, but he’s literally made to cheat around the rules of the game, so him being a canon outlier in this fits his character).

TLDR:

  • The contents of the 10th anniversary livestream are canon and should be used.
  • Only very few characters will scale to Flowey's feat, rest will be downgraded from High 8-C+ (7.28 Tons) to only High 8-C (2.42 Tons).
  • SOUL Power is a UES that scales to AP, Dura, LS, Speed and Hax potency.
The proposals look reasonable.
 
The point is that Undyne being able to lift Alphys, Asgore, Sans, Papyrus and Toriel at once is something that is means she's strong and is something that Papyrus bet Undyne couldn't do. Which she was able to do, but I doubt Papyrus would assume she wouldn't be able to if a good chunk of the Underground including him can lift 11.7k tons
This would mean that any LS feat is invalid, which would include also the Ice Dog feat, the Papyrus bones feat, or Flowey's feat.

This is literally why we apply the logic of feats > statements, as we cannot deny all of the former just because of a one-off statement, especially given that in the Valentine card entries Undyne is stated to be capable of moving 2 tons.
 
The point is that Undyne being able to lift Alphys, Asgore, Sans, Papyrus and Toriel at once is something that is means she's strong and is something that Papyrus bet Undyne couldn't do
To consider this as proper anti-feat, we would need to assume that 1) Papyrus has accurate estimate of how strong he and Undyne is(yes, but only to some degree) 2) Papyrus knows how strong you need to lift them all at once(he may easily severely overestimate this value).
And consider the possibility that main challenge is not to have enough force to lift them all, but to able to lift them all an once(which adds difficulty of maintaining them all in balance and not letting them fall accidentally). Second part of dialogue hints at second variant
 

Regarding the Flowey scaling + Mettaton feat upgrade

We currently scale Asgore as above Flowey's 7.28 Tons feat based on this statement from the latter which supposedly means that no matter how much LV he gains.

However, this is wrong, as he only mentions that he could never go past him to get the SOULs, which he specifies as him showing them to him (which only does to Frisk given them being the last human to kill). Him being unable to beat Asgore no matter the LV would also contradict his claim of him having killed everyone in some of his runs.

BUT, Asgore would still be superior to a LV 1 Flowey, due to him being equal in stats with Toriel, who could easily erase Flowey’s bullets and knock him out with a single attack.
How it feels when you see someone say something you've agreed with but kept silent on
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top