• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Holy Grail War! Stelle & Saber (Artoria) Vs Aventurine and Archer (EMIYA) (Honkai: Star Rail X Fate/Stay Night) [8-5-4]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Might work on nasu after I'm finished with block tales (I've taken a recent liking to tsukihime especially the remake)

Anyways following but neutral atm (idk a thing about honkai and only have like basic knowledge on fate)
I wish Lancer was a playable HSR character so we can make a profile for him. Instead he literally went missing 90% of the entire story mode even though his master was right with us.
 
Wait a min...so kirei is in honkai star rail???
No. Lancer killed him


his new master is a cowboy

 
No. Lancer killed him


his new master is a cowboy


Yeah i knew lancer killed him in main cannon I just thought hsr made it to where he's still alive for some reason

Anyway a cowboy is infinitely better than kirei XD
 
Wait what? Block Tales? Like the Roblox game
Yeah...Remember the crappy profile that I thought was valid to publish because I was tired of spending countless all nighters on it only to realize it actually was more half way finished along with some mistakes here or there?

Yup, that's meant to be the profile for the player I was working on although this time I'm actually taking more time on it (currently working on getting stuff calced, fixing minor blog post mistakes and nitpicks, along with just getting stuff accepted)
 
Archer and Adventurine Fra.

With 1km of distance, and Archer knowing he can't 1v1 Saber in CQC, he just gonna snipe them from a distance when he go up a building like the Berseker fight in UBW. Even If Stelle can reduce the demage, she can engate them, so this gonna weaken her or Saber to fight propelly against Aventurine and his 1-B attack.

We have the HA strategy, where Stelle can use the command spell to make Saber go jump to kill Archer or fire Excalibur on him. While this could work, with Aventurine and Archer taking shots at them to stop for her doing so, the chances are really not that high.

And Archer can defend himself using Rho Aias to protect against Excalibur blast, and Aventurine can teleport Archer next to him using a command spell to avoid It.

So yeah, Ikemen duo fra.
 
Archer and Adventurine Fra.

With 1km of distance, and Archer knowing he can't 1v1 Saber in CQC, he just gonna snipe them from a distance when he go up a building like the Berseker fight in UBW. Even If Stelle can reduce the demage, she can engate them, so this gonna weaken her or Saber to fight propelly against Aventurine and his 1-B attack.

We have the HA strategy, where Stelle can use the command spell to make Saber go jump to kill Archer or fire Excalibur on him. While this could work, with Aventurine and Archer taking shots at them to stop for her doing so, the chances are really not that high.

And Archer can defend himself using Rho Aias to protect against Excalibur blast, and Aventurine can teleport Archer next to him using a command spell to avoid It.

So yeah, Ikemen duo fra.
Agree with most of these points although I don't think it's fair to say rio aias is blocking Excalibur

Reason why is because Excalibur is an A++ noble phantasm putting it significantly above the likes of B class noble phantasms like gae bolg which have broken through rio aias before
 
Archer and Adventurine Fra.

With 1km of distance, and Archer knowing he can't 1v1 Saber in CQC, he just gonna snipe them from a distance when he go up a building like the Berseker fight in UBW. Even If Stelle can reduce the demage, she can engate them, so this gonna weaken her or Saber to fight propelly against Aventurine and his 1-B attack.

We have the HA strategy, where Stelle can use the command spell to make Saber go jump to kill Archer or fire Excalibur on him. While this could work, with Aventurine and Archer taking shots at them to stop for her doing so, the chances are really not that high.

And Archer can defend himself using Rho Aias to protect against Excalibur blast, and Aventurine can teleport Archer next to him using a command spell to avoid It.

So yeah, Ikemen duo fra.
The path of the trailblaze allows her to continuously fight as long as she needs to without rest and are comparable to mydei and phainon who can fight nonstomp for 10 days straight. she also has 3 different healing abilities from 3 different path powers. Its very unlikely for her and saber to get weakened due to them targeting Stelle.

Aventurine 1-B is his final attack where he gambles everything he has into 1 attack. Its also not his starting move since his starting move is to launches dices and poker chips. I dont really see him using it anytime soon unless he really needs it.

Stelle can also taunt both of them and force them to both target her so Saber can fire excalibur. Stelle also has abilities from the path of harmony, destruction, and preservation

I dont think Rho aias would be able to block a command spell amped Excalibur either since it was destroyed twice by Sakura and Lancer




Even when Shirou used it against Excalibur Morgan, he was extreme diffing it while Bellophron was offsetting Excalibur greatly
 
Last edited:
The path of the trailblaze allows her to continuously fight as long as she needs to without rest and are comparable to mydei and phainon who can fight nonstomp for 10 days straight. she also has 3 different healing abilities from 3 different path powers. Its very unlikely for her and saber to get weakened due to them targeting Stelle.

Aventurine 1-B is his final attack where he gambles everything he has into 1 attack. Its also not his starting move since his starting move is to launches dices and poker chips. I dont really see him using it anytime soon unless he really needs it.

Stelle can also taunt both of them and force them to both target her so Saber can fire excalibur. Stelle also has abilities from the path of harmony, destruction, and preservation

I dont think Rho aias would be able to block a command spell amped Excalibur either since it was destroyed twice




Even when Shirou used it against Excalibur Morgan, he was extreme diffing it while Bellophron was offsetting Excalibur greatly

I'd also like to add that heavens feel shirou is WAY stronger than archer since his enhancements and projection are both strong enough to one shot beserker. For reference archer needed his strongest weapons to harm him

This means his overall magecraft should be objectively above archer
 
I dont think Rho aias would be able to block a command spell amped Excalibur either since it was destroyed twice
Reason why is because Excalibur is an A++ noble phantasm putting it significantly above the likes of B class noble phantasms like gae
I meant more like, Rho Aias can stall the Excalibur blast until Aventurine teleport Archer with a Command spell. Not that he can block It completely.
 
I'd also like to add that heavens feel shirou is WAY stronger than archer since his enhancements and projection are both strong enough to one shot beserker. For reference archer needed his strongest weapons to harm him

This means his overall magecraft should be objectively above archer
Also in HSR, Saber's excalibur was the only thing capable of destroying the temu skaracabaz and the holy grail out of everyone in that group.

Basically I dont see stelle and saber getting weakened due to them jumping stelle via the strong stamina and several healing/defense abilities. Theyd probably be too occupied getting taunted and targeting stelle for Saber to launch Excalibur.

Theres also this one scene about Aventurine not liking using command spells so theres that

image.png

image.png
 
Changing my vote to Saber and Stelle because they out-heal and out-last the damage Archer and Aventurine can do before sending their ***es to the shadow realm with Excalibur.
 
Taiyo vs Sukuna
Taiyo should fold pretty easily. Taiyo previously stomped when TSB was allowed and sukuna scaled to 500KT. Now Sukuna's around 160KT while Taiyo's at 318KT (assuming you restrict TSB for obvious reasons) has durability upscaling via hardening and has speed amps. So cleave and dismantle struggles to deal lasting damage while Taiyo just beats him down or chops off his head (not even sure if Sukuna's domain kills or deals notable enough damage). Sukuna's forms of precog relying on fighting cursed energy manipulators while Taiyo's doesn't only makes it worse for him.

Asa vs Makima sound near the guy's ship?
This could honestly work cause of how much of a hax merchant Makima is. As usual her regen level specified in such a thread is important since Asa's copy of void (something he never starts with though) would be able to kill high-mid characters.
Edit: So does whether it is original body or Taiyo's body Asa. Since The latter key would be able to resist Makima's long distance bio attacks
 
Last edited:
Taiyo should fold pretty easily. Taiyo previously stomped when TSB was allowed and sukuna scaled to 500KT. Now Sukuna's around 160KT while Taiyo's at 318KT (assuming you restrict TSB for obvious reasons) has durability upscaling via hardening and has speed amps. So cleave and dismantle struggles to deal lasting damage while Taiyo just beats him down or chops off his head (not even sure if Sukuna's domain kills or deals notable enough damage). Sukuna's forms of precog relying on fighting cursed energy manipulators while Taiyo's doesn't only makes it worse for him.
I just might ship this fight
This could honestly work cause of how much of a hax merchant Makima is. As usual her regen level specified in such a thread is important since Asa's copy of void (something he never starts with though) would be able to kill high-mid characters.
Edit: So does whether it is original body or Taiyo's body Asa. Since The latter key would be able to resist Makima's long distance bio attacks
Original Body Asa
 
What if I gave him this dude's body?
Further convo can occur on my Wall or in my DM's since this is an unrelated VS thread if you have more to ask
But Asa can't use the body of Momo Yozakura since Asa bisected him, took his arms and stuffed in a tube inside the Behemoth before he performed the heart procedure on Momo that allows him to possess that guy with Division. His other form of possession, Conquest which is layered, he saved for Taiyo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top