• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Wiki Page Deletion Requests Thread (New forum)

Is it really necessary with a staff forum thread for this particular issue though, given that I understand our current rules in the manner stated below? Maybe some minor further clarification regarding alternative continuity characters, to avoid misunderstandings? 🙏
Also, as far as I understand our rules in the manner they are currently written, we do have general policy points about a minimum of 20 appearances for Marvel Comics characters in general, and about that alternative continuity characters need to have prominently been the main characters in their own comicbooks.

 
Is it really necessary with a staff forum thread for this particular issue though, given that I understand our current rules in the manner stated below? Maybe some minor further clarification regarding alternative continuity characters, to avoid misunderstandings? 🙏
I agree with Empress's point only in the notion that the character in question has enough detail within those two appearances to be fleshed out. Inconsistency isn't a bother, its a given and we can bend those rules a bit.
 
We already have 662 Marvel Comics pages with mostly incoherent scaling despite that it is largely well-established characters that are much easier to figure out the statistics for.


It seems extremely unwise to open the floodgates for tens of thousands more far more obscure characters with extremely few appearances from this verse. 🙏
 
We already have 662 Marvel Comics pages with mostly incoherent scaling despite that it is largely well-established characters that are much easier to figure out the statistics for.


It seems extremely unwise to open the floodgates for tens of thousands more far more obscure characters with extremely few appearances from this verse. 🙏
As long as we don't let them mess up the scaling (by not letting the scale to their mainline counterparts, which is already a rule), I don't think that would be much of an issue. Yeah, it would be great if people helped out more with that scaling instead of creating new pages, but if you don't let them create new pages for Marvel, most people would just do that for other verses instead.

I can understand some concern about making revisions more difficult, by DPLs finding characters of a certain tier who shouldn't actually be revised due to them scaling to their own AU stuff instead of mainline things, but I'd think a better solution to that would be creating a category for Marvel characters that are part of the main universe.
 
Well, beyond the scaling problems, Marvel Comics has tens of thousands of characters, and I want us to focus on the more prominent ones, and we already have around 660 of them featured in our wiki, which likely is a lot more than for any other verse there, rather than drown in irrelevant extremely obscure characters with extremely few appearances. 🙏
 
If this is a divisive enough matter to have made up this many posts with this many varied perspectives and opinions, then it should preferably be discussed in a dedicated thread, and not here. I don't have much to say on it; I don't tend to interact with the Marvel Comics profiles. But whatever you settle on, it would just be good for everyone else who might need this thread if it is not sidetracked.
 
Okay. I am not sure what I should mention in its first post though. Ask for us to somewhat clarify the rule text regarding unofficial canon/alternatice timelines characters? 🙏
 
Yeah, I think the main points of order are "Can these characters simply be significant parts of these alt-canon runs, or do they have to be the main protagonists of them?" and "Can these characters scale to others from within those alt-canon runs, or do they need their own direct feats?"
 
Thank you. I am still very tired though, but will try to handle it after a while. 🙏
 
 
Shouldn't all these be blogs? Many of these are straight up calcs, and almost all of them were initially blogs that GarrixianXD, a now banned user, stole and posted as profiles.






 
Many explanation blogs were moved to full pages as part of some initiative or another. Garrixian as a content mod was involved in that. It's debateable whether everything flagged ought to be kept as proper pages, but it wasn't that Garrixian "stole" the content.
 
Many explanation blogs were moved to full pages as part of some initiative or another. Garrixian as a content mod was involved in that. It's debateable whether everything flagged ought to be kept as proper pages, but it wasn't that Garrixian "stole" the content.
Oh. He was banned essentially for stealing content, so I assumed the same for these pages.
 
Shouldn't all these be blogs? Many of these are straight up calcs, and almost all of them were initially blogs that GarrixianXD, a now banned user, stole and posted as profiles.






IIRC, there are plenty of Digimon supporters who worked hard on the verse, with Executor N0 being the biggest expert to me knowledge; Garrixian didn't strike me as being anything to do with the lot of these. And they were banned for something else entirely as Agnaa pointed out more importantly.
 
IIRC, there are plenty of Digimon supporters who worked hard on the verse, with Executor N0 being the biggest expert to me knowledge; Garrixian didn't strike me as being anything to do with the lot of these. And they were banned for something else entirely as Agnaa pointed out more importantly.
I'm not sure if you're arguing for all the profiles to stay, especially since that would include the calcs, but I've worked just as hard to make similar profiles for Pokemon, and my CRTs to upload them have received little to no support. It doesn't really matter how hard they've worked if they're not something that fits the site. He didn't write or steal the pages, but he did turn them from blog posts into real pages.
 
I do not remember the specifics, but if some of our blog posts were inappropriately converted into regular wiki explanation pages (in order to more easily allow longterm community collaborations to improve on and update their contents, and also make them more official), you should probably create a staff forum thread about it. 🙏
 
 

Sorry, I'm late. The pages that I mentioned have been deleted. These pages were minimalistic and lacked polish. I am mentioning this in case someone inquires about the source of the deleted pages, or if there is an issue with the deletion.
should we fix the pages than deleting it.
 
IIRC, there are plenty of Digimon supporters who worked hard on the verse, with Executor N0 being the biggest expert to me knowledge; Garrixian didn't strike me as being anything to do with the lot of these. And they were banned for something else entirely as Agnaa pointed out more importantly.
We are still working on it.

Just we can't do any major updates till Time Stranger comes out later this year. Since it might have some important info that changes our view since it takes place in Iliad.
 

Incomplete and sounds like and FC/OC.
 
 
 
🫡.
 


Two profiles for the same character. The Boiled One seems to be the original, but the Invader profile seems to have existed for a few months uninhibited. I don't know if there's a difference between them, but going off what I remember from TBOPH I think it's the same entity.
 


Two profiles for the same character. The Boiled One seems to be the original, but the Invader profile seems to have existed for a few months uninhibited. I don't know if there's a difference between them, but going off what I remember from TBOPH I think it's the same entity.
Yah I accidentally got both of them up after I saw that they were deleted for bogus reasoning
I nuked the top one as it was of worse quality
 


Two profiles for the same character. The Boiled One seems to be the original, but the Invader profile seems to have existed for a few months uninhibited. I don't know if there's a difference between them, but going off what I remember from TBOPH I think it's the same entity.
Hold on a second, Phen-228 is Mao Zedong?!
UH?!
 
Back
Top