Wind is only for gale zone which will projectile spam him with multiple at once, for the Black hole when any of thr black appears that's it, its literally already expanding and sucking stuff into it so there is no tell there its judt boom a black hole that's already drawing shit in and it expands rapidly and if she doesn't decide to use a smaller one to EE him then she could just use a larger one covering a few kilometers and sealing him for good, he has no way to dodge that or the LS or speed to escape any black holes she does at all regardless.
The idea that the black hole "just appears and starts pulling things in instantly" feels like an oversimplification. Black holes typically take some amount of time to reach full effect unless explicitly stated otherwise, no? So, the formation of such an attack isn’t a completely instant and unavoidable—especially since Headmaster is a master martial artist with EP. Even without outright precognition, recognizing environmental clues such as distortions, visual changes, or the sheer buildup of energy would be enough for him to react accordingly. (e.g. even simple flight magic disrupts the mana in the air, which then can be used to track people. so a black hole forming would definitely do that and let him create a hologram in time.) It might seem too fast, but you have to remember the hologram could be used in such a way that Boichiro literally didn't even see it activated as he was bringing down his final attack on Akuto, and Headmaster is comparable if not superior. She uses black hole thinking it's not dodge able, just to realize she'd never landed it, and now he's back behind her with barrage of attacks.
Well your perception is wrong unfortunately when using any kind of LS even if its grappling or trying to like rip someone apart with your bare hands and trying to argue a lower tier character with higher LS can tear off the limbs of a higher tier guy again a example I gave earlier a 9-B who is Class G isn't harming a 6-B Class M off LS alone because he also doesn't have the relative AP to actually do any significant damage even he could outwrestle them the 6-B is just too durable to harm or jus swapping that with TK for a similar example, if I try throwing, applying some kind of pushing or crushing force on someone when I'm 9-B, Class G with my TK AP yet soomeone else is 6-B Class M, I could restrain or hold them successfully nut my AP is not significant enough to harm them doing anything like crushing, throwing, pushing against them or whatever else so yes we do treat this kind of thing be it physical or TK as having an Attack Potency aspect to it as well so yes when Kat is using her stasis field to pull him and throw him, near completely stop his movements with the force of her grav manip, crushing or whatever else have you with anything she uses it will all also be applying the force of her AP not just her LS, hell if AP didn't matter to these feats then people wouldn't get AP ratings for using TK to do whatever feats they could perform.
Now obviously if you're just holding someone in place (and like aren't actively applying any force when holding them at least not enough to harm them with any pushing or crushing force or even just letting them float around that isn't applying your ap or any lethal force) that isn't going to really harm them but you're not getting that if she is even trying to push, hold, or throw him back with the force of her Gravity Manip he is actively trying to fight through to get to her that would apply AP as well because in this case you're not just doing enough force to try and keep someone from moving you're actively trying to harm them and apply blunt TK force to someone.
I think there might be a small conflation between LS and AP here due to trying to tie it into TK. While AP determines how much raw damage a character can deal, LS is about the ability to restrain, lift, or move objects, which is an entirely separate category of strength. I think the idea that TK inherently scales to AP assumes that just because an ability is "strong," it must also be capable of dealing damage. However, I don't think this is how telekinesis is universally treated?
For example, a 9-B character with Class G LS could hold down a 6-B character, as LS here determines the strength required to immobilize, not to harm. The 9-B would not be able to crush or tear the 6-B apart due to the massive durability diff, but the 6-B would still be physically restrained because LS does not require AP to function. (Unless you're arguing there's some correlation between them, even though we have Low 2-C characters with finite LS) In contrast, AP only comes into play when telekinesis is used in a way that directly applies kinetic energy—such as launching debris. Simply holding someone still or redirecting them does not necessarily scale to AP, meaning that a LS advantage is still a significant factor in the battle.
That's fine overtime, nothing says this battle is going to be lasting like days on end to something where she would obviously be exhausted, this just isn't applicable here at all since he has the means to harm him or bypass his guard or overwhelm him with projectiles while also speed gapping him to a blitz speed degree stuff he could not deal with all at once, even just her movements alone in Jupiter style alone would harm him or deal some kind of AoE force, just gravity sliding on a surface into him or flying or fighting will deal significant damage or aoe just even trying to redirect or block her let alone for any of the shockwaves of her big attack which could still be supplemented with her spamming projectiles or spamming her stasis field to slow or harm him with any of the force of trying to throw him around or him getting caught in like the formation of a debris ball when she's compressing material in the area. Worse even he isn't escaping her black hole if he is even remotely close as it forms near instantly right away expanding quickly immediately pulling shit into it and also existence erasing it or just opting for sealing by becoming a singularity herself another thing he couldn't escape from considering its range.
I feel like this just dismisses the stamina difference because the battle wouldn’t last long enough for it to matter. However, the fact remains that peak human stamina is still just that—peak human. While Kat has good stamina, Headmaster has a century worth of stamina, and since 3x lesser AP difference would still let him get good hits in, I think it's worth considering the sheer stamina difference, especially since everything you've mention here, I think I've responded to. Like, you haven't mentioned anything Hua Jin, mana projectiles, or holograms couldn't deal with.
I feel she has way more options of dealing with him than he has for her here outside of his EP which still is very dubious if it could even work on her as its still a mana sense based thing and from what you said isn't precog, analytical prediction, or any kind of info analysis so I fail to see how it would work on Kat.
Don't worry, never thought she doesn't have a lot of options—just that nothing she has couldn't be answered by Headmasters limited kit. Also, EP isn't about "working on kat", it's more so "it works for him". Like, I've already addressed that EP gives strong intuition to characters where they can act even without knowing what or from where something is coming, they just get it and act on it.
That's all I'll have for my arguments as of right now so I'll leave it to others to decide who they think wins best here
Fair enough, I guess.
By the way, it might be a silly question, but just to be safe, should I count you as a vote for Kat? Usually, I like to get 100% confirmation.
)
