Well, I think I can probably give my opinion now, at first I thought 12 had a completely massive advantage but as I learned more it started to feel closer to a 50-50- normally I’d go for the usual “inconclusive”, but this time I’m thinking 12 wins more often than not, but like a, 5.75-4.25- in fact, this opinion might change as I write this
At first encounter, Blade would likely see some kind of hallucination of her getting packed, but once they start fighting that'll probably go away
early on, Blade has the advantage in both AP, and even Skill, so her confidence would probably be regained enough to not be feared up- but 12’s ability to catch-up in stats and skill will close that gap by the time Blade say… cut off an arm or something. As well, the fear manipulation would definitely start creeping up on Blade’s focus when 12 just regens it off.
Blade would probably be smart enough to figure that if amputation doesn't work, try for the head as she likes trying to go for the neck anyways. But at this point I see Blade struggling a lot to land that hit to the neck and then discover the core
- 12 probs knows of its own weakness and therefore would make it easier to defend one point of its body (fact check this tho)
- thanks to its large size, Blade would either have to use her swordwhip or jump up to attack which definitely limits her amount of moves she can pull off
- - both strategies that 12'll adapt to once 12 catches onto her goal (i could even see 12 making their own whips).
However, Blade’s strength would increase with fear, so this'll definitely be something she could do, especially combined with her skill which would take a bit more time to catch up on than strength cuz she's kind of a skill monster.
But notice that this relies on
- an emotional amp, and emotions are pretty inconsistent and in this case would be a double edged sword since it would hamper Blade’s skills for a boost that will be caught up to eventually
- intelligence to deduce that she needs to cut the neck (and our only statement of that being her go-to move is essentially edgy dialogue)- she can easily think “go for the heart” or “go for the brain” instead of “do the edgy thing I said I was gonna do to iX” or “cut specifically the brainstem”. And that’ll take more time to eventually arrive at the correct answer
both of these situations are definitely likely to happen since 12 has fear manip and Blade does have that kind of intelligence, but it’s still not a guarantee way of how things could go- along with the fact that 12 would figure out her goal of cutting the neck
if this was put in a manga or an anime, Blade def would win because these conditions will definitely be fulfilled, but by the time these things would happen in a realistic vs battle, I think Blade would arrive at the answer just a bit too late, and 12 will start to win the melee / whip clashes more often- the battle would end with 12 knocking Blade into a wall or smth and she’s probably Berserk Trigger for the win, which would constitute as a loss for this specific vs battle
however all of this relies on how fast 12’s adaptation really is tbh, in my analysis I gave Blade around 2-3 melee engagements before 12 catches up and I still think Blade would just barely lose, even win because the win conditions are likely to happen
so I might have to do a cop out with an Inconclusive until I get more info on how fast this development is (yeah, I did change my opinion as I wrote this)- this is a pretty cool matchup