• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Cross continuity scaling that don't make a spec of sense. And also a very irrelevant character in the overall event. (Almost 90% of future end characters are irrelevant and just... there). Also a really bad file in general.
 

Cross continuity scaling that don't make a spec of sense. And also a very irrelevant character in the overall event. (Almost 90% of future end characters are irrelevant and just... there). Also a really bad file in general.
Ovens took care of it. The following pages need to have their links to the delted page removed though.

 

This profile seems to be based off guesswork statistics. Plus I’m pretty sure Kibito was a lot weaker than Gohan at the time since he failed to lift the z sword while Gohan did with some difficulty IIRC
 
I mean if they have consistent feats across the board, I don't see an issue with keeping them. Yeah, not all song series (?) do that, but there are a few that are consistent across the board and each new entry adds more feats and lore to the character.
 
One of our Editing Rules explicitly bans profiles for characters from music videos

Yet some of our Music Characters flaunt this rule, such as Cool-T, Crazy Frog, The Yellow Submarine (Verse), and Ilona Mitrecey.

From checking the logs, the Crazy Frog page was deleted before, and I seem to distinctly remember The Yellow Submarine pages getting deleted for for exactly that reason.
That's a dumb, probably outdated rule, at least in regards to music videos which are ultimately pieces of animation/video/whatever like any other, if they have feats they're fine to keep. "Music video = joke profile" is a stupid conception
 
Last edited:
Sounds like it's contentious enough to probably need its own thread (._.)
 
One of our Editing Rules explicitly bans profiles for characters from music videos

Yet some of our Music Characters flaunt this rule, such as Cool-T, Crazy Frog, The Yellow Submarine (Verse), and Ilona Mitrecey.

From checking the logs, the Crazy Frog page was deleted before, and I seem to distinctly remember The Yellow Submarine pages getting deleted for for exactly that reason.

What should be done about this?
@AKM sama @DarkDragonMedeus @Damage3245 @Elizhaa

What do you think about this?
 
Okay. Perhaps Eficiente can use that instead then?

Edit: Never mind. I do not think that he plans to update those blog posts, so my suggestion likely works better in this case.
 

This profile seems to be based off guesswork statistics. Plus I’m pretty sure Kibito was a lot weaker than Gohan at the time since he failed to lift the z sword while Gohan did with some difficulty IIRC
So, about this?
 
I'm not entirely certain, but I feel like it might be another case by case thing. I obviously agree that celebrity music videos and what not are not allowed here since there's no real continuity and it's mostly just a song performance; and not being very combat heavy. But It seems to me as if Steam Powered Giraffe is an exception. Because it definitely has a lot of lore just from looking at the page, the videos are like episodes of a continuity, and there's a lot of combat between both giant robots and gods. Though, I'm not sure why Cool-T or Crazy From have profiles and could agree with those deletion unless other defense is brought up. As for Yellow Submarine, I feel like Ogurtsow's input might be appreciated since I do recall a time when he worked on them. Plus he is an excellent page editor/creator with a fairly good sense if judgement iirc.
 
I mean something like Disturbed's Land of Confusion music video has clear feats, combat and even a small storyline, I really don't see why it shouldn't be profiled.
 
Okay, and what do you think about Kibito, Medeus?
 
I'm not entirely certain, but I feel like it might be another case by case thing. I obviously agree that celebrity music videos and what not are not allowed here since there's no real continuity and it's mostly just a song performance; and not being very combat heavy. But It seems to me as if Steam Powered Giraffe is an exception. Because it definitely has a lot of lore just from looking at the page, the videos are like episodes of a continuity, and there's a lot of combat between both giant robots and gods. Though, I'm not sure why Cool-T or Crazy From have profiles and could agree with those deletion unless other defense is brought up. As for Yellow Submarine, I feel like Ogurtsow's input might be appreciated since I do recall a time when he worked on them. Plus he is an excellent page editor/creator with a fairly good sense if judgement iirc.
Medeus makes sense to me above btw.

Ogurtsow lives in Siberia, and has not been available for around two months, so I do not know if the Russian authorities allow him access to this forum currently.
 
A lot of music video can be really abstract and not have a clear storyline but that's no reason to disallow music video profiles in general. Even individual music videos can be fine imo but it will obviously be case by case
 
As for Kibito, being Shin's body guard in itself really isn't a feat per say. And while he did confront Gohan in his base form, I don't think his power level was directly compared to his. And it's hard to tell how strong Gohan's base form was at that point in time aside from the obvious fact that he's roughly equal to Teen Gohan's base form who is a lot stronger than Base Goku during Frieza saga. This was before the zenkai that made Gohan as strong as Goku and Vegeta or better yet the Z Sword training that made him surpass Goku initially. Or better yet, grow so strong to the point where even his base form was above Shin and Piccolo's.

So Kibito's exact power level does seem to have too much unknown tbh. So I wouldn't really mind a deletion. His best feat is just that merging with Shin makes him Kibitoshin, but that says nothing about his PL when seperated.
 
Kibito really is a non-character in terms of fights for Dragon Ball. No really notable combat feats.
 
Again this should just have a staff thread. Even if you agree with music video files, I think you'd want a difference between say, Siames' Wolves and Katy Perry in the Dark Horse music video.

I'll make a thread on this in abit
 
Unless I’m mistaken, I thought we needed Despero up for scaling
The only pages which link to Despero, are other versions of Despero, and Starro, which has scaling to Despero as its justification, but is a completely different tier.
 
more like bizarro world lmao
On the topic of Despero and scaling- wasn't the deletion of Starro also discussed? If my memory is just hazy and there wasn't any, the profile should still be deleted or at least reworked because it's just a massive mess with no scans and barely any explanations.
 
Back
Top