- 6,590
- 3,421
While I'll say my opinion on the matter, take this as an invite to discuss this again and, hopefully, wrap this up
As we know, during Cap 153, Forfeit, Silver Fang and Garou finished their fight with an obvious victory for the Hero Hunter, while Bang did put up a good fight. In this case, however, Garou was sleeping, and only really started to wake up during Cap 154, page 16, when he one shot Fuhrer Ugly and made all that Subsonic mess against Platinum Sperm and ENW, and after that, he was awake enough to analyze his surroundings and, on total reflex, dodges one of Flash's attacks. This is basically what gave Bang his Likely Relativistic+ Combat and Reaction speed, the "likely" is thanks to Garou being asleep during the battle
Now, I changed sides on this from agreeing to not agreeing, and eventually, I do not agree
The main point in scaling Awake Garou dodging the attack to Asleep Garou is because he did on instinct/reflex, that being what allows him to fight asleep in the first place, but that also assumes Flash using his max known speed during that kick, which is, for me, rather unlikely
Flash certainly bases his style on speed which he confirms himself, but he does hold back enough to people slower than him dodge. Note that at this moment, Flash didn't knew they were Hellfire and Gale, he just attacked his random opponent before anything else, a similar situation to his kick against Garou. Even after knowing more about his opponents (Ninjas, so likely fast enemies), he still held back for quite a while, only using his current Relativistic+ speed at the very end of the fight, where he had a plan to take both of them with a single slash). His fight against Garou and Platinum showed him pushing himself to the "Flashy" attacks and even the Flowing Shadow Feet, which, certainly, allows us to say he was going all out there (He kinda has those Forbidden Techniques aswell, but anyway), and, against Blast, he indeed started with the Maximum Speed Flashy Kicks, this, however, is no normal situation, as Flash knew that man was Blast, and wanted to test him. The same "non max speed" approach happened against the Demon level Octopus, which after Flash stabbed its eyes, he implied to start using more of his power, until Tatsumaki arrived. Therefore, my conclusion is that saying Flash was using his max known speed (Relativistic+) in that kick is iffy on its own and goes against the overall in character showings from him, but the problems don't end up here
Next I'll be quoting @GreatIskandar14045's logic
This is backed up by the fight, as we see how it goes from a rather one sided match where Darkshine has no problem in keeping up with him to something a little closer, with Garou managing to surprise him, react to him and dodge his attacks, in both situations, Darkshine wasn't going all out, but he has no reason to go slower after Garou woke up, so him actually pushing Darkshine to go all out and reacting to what he couldn't before is a clear indication that his speed is higher, one could say that it is a matter of better skill, but that doesn't make you faster. Also note how this does not come from the later part of the battle, where Garou started to evolve, and it's only to show the difference in speed between awake and Asleep Garou
Lastly, as we saw in his fight against Darkshine and his fight against Platinum Sperm in Cap 156, Garou evolves fast when awake, from keeping up with Flash, to keeping up Platinum (Who's faster) to blitzing him in the end, with a direct statement of him getting faster. The chances of him being faster after he woke up are clear and even hinted by the narrative with the timer and how beings this fast are overall showcased (traces of light, timers, etc)
So, conclusion (again), of what goes against Bang's likely scaling
- Garou might be faster after he woke up by evolving
- Garou is faster after he woke up because he showcased better speed feats after he woke up against Darkshine
- Bang's scaling depends on Flash using his maximum speed during the first kick against Garou, which goes against Flash's in character behavior
Awakening Breath's bang speed should be be changed from Likely Relativistic+ to "At least Massively Hypersonic, likely higher" or similar
What you guys think ?
As we know, during Cap 153, Forfeit, Silver Fang and Garou finished their fight with an obvious victory for the Hero Hunter, while Bang did put up a good fight. In this case, however, Garou was sleeping, and only really started to wake up during Cap 154, page 16, when he one shot Fuhrer Ugly and made all that Subsonic mess against Platinum Sperm and ENW, and after that, he was awake enough to analyze his surroundings and, on total reflex, dodges one of Flash's attacks. This is basically what gave Bang his Likely Relativistic+ Combat and Reaction speed, the "likely" is thanks to Garou being asleep during the battle
Now, I changed sides on this from agreeing to not agreeing, and eventually, I do not agree
The main point in scaling Awake Garou dodging the attack to Asleep Garou is because he did on instinct/reflex, that being what allows him to fight asleep in the first place, but that also assumes Flash using his max known speed during that kick, which is, for me, rather unlikely
Flash certainly bases his style on speed which he confirms himself, but he does hold back enough to people slower than him dodge. Note that at this moment, Flash didn't knew they were Hellfire and Gale, he just attacked his random opponent before anything else, a similar situation to his kick against Garou. Even after knowing more about his opponents (Ninjas, so likely fast enemies), he still held back for quite a while, only using his current Relativistic+ speed at the very end of the fight, where he had a plan to take both of them with a single slash). His fight against Garou and Platinum showed him pushing himself to the "Flashy" attacks and even the Flowing Shadow Feet, which, certainly, allows us to say he was going all out there (He kinda has those Forbidden Techniques aswell, but anyway), and, against Blast, he indeed started with the Maximum Speed Flashy Kicks, this, however, is no normal situation, as Flash knew that man was Blast, and wanted to test him. The same "non max speed" approach happened against the Demon level Octopus, which after Flash stabbed its eyes, he implied to start using more of his power, until Tatsumaki arrived. Therefore, my conclusion is that saying Flash was using his max known speed (Relativistic+) in that kick is iffy on its own and goes against the overall in character showings from him, but the problems don't end up here
Next I'll be quoting @GreatIskandar14045's logic
Not only that Garou was unconscious when he fought Bang and Bomb, at the time when he woke which is obviously... he goes much better than he was at his sleep (like when he was fighting against Darkshine)
This is backed up by the fight, as we see how it goes from a rather one sided match where Darkshine has no problem in keeping up with him to something a little closer, with Garou managing to surprise him, react to him and dodge his attacks, in both situations, Darkshine wasn't going all out, but he has no reason to go slower after Garou woke up, so him actually pushing Darkshine to go all out and reacting to what he couldn't before is a clear indication that his speed is higher, one could say that it is a matter of better skill, but that doesn't make you faster. Also note how this does not come from the later part of the battle, where Garou started to evolve, and it's only to show the difference in speed between awake and Asleep Garou
Lastly, as we saw in his fight against Darkshine and his fight against Platinum Sperm in Cap 156, Garou evolves fast when awake, from keeping up with Flash, to keeping up Platinum (Who's faster) to blitzing him in the end, with a direct statement of him getting faster. The chances of him being faster after he woke up are clear and even hinted by the narrative with the timer and how beings this fast are overall showcased (traces of light, timers, etc)
So, conclusion (again), of what goes against Bang's likely scaling
- Garou might be faster after he woke up by evolving
- Garou is faster after he woke up because he showcased better speed feats after he woke up against Darkshine
- Bang's scaling depends on Flash using his maximum speed during the first kick against Garou, which goes against Flash's in character behavior
Awakening Breath's bang speed should be be changed from Likely Relativistic+ to "At least Massively Hypersonic, likely higher" or similar
What you guys think ?
Last edited: