- 15,181
- 1,535
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Umm... And since when was soul manipulation not considered OHK?ScarletFirefly said:Guts does NOT kill with one scratch. What kind of logic is this? Just because it attacks the soul, it doesn't mean it kills with a single scratch. Show me proof that it does. Until then, it does not, it's just Durability ignoring.
When you cut through their neck, they die. |
Yes, I know that. But all that proves is that the Dragonslayer can reach the soul "dimension". It doesn't prove in any way that it can destroy a person's soul should the blade cut through said person's flesh.XBlackExcellenceX said:He can also attack noncorporeal/intangible entities with this soul manipulation. So I highly doubt it only activates after death. Unless you have proof?
This depends heavily of the nature of said soul attack and also it's potency. For example, the Raging Demon has failed to kill despite it being shown to destroy a person's soul. Heck even F/Z servants or Bleach characters have "soul attacks" that damage the soul and neither of them can kill with a scratch.XBlackExcellenceX said:My fault, I should have been more specific. Since when does someone who actually attacks the soul not considered OHK? Don't bring soul capturing examples next time.
Firstly, its the astral world/plane, not the "soul dimension". Secondly, the burden of proof is on you. I provided a scan of Guts stating that the Dragonslayer can affect the soul. You need evidence that it doesn't OHK like other soul attacking/destroying abilities in fiction. Lastly, soul manipulation is one of the few things that can affect the non-corporeal.ScarletFirefly said:Yes, I know that. But all that proves is that the Dragonslayer can reach the soul "dimension". It doesn't prove in any way that it can destroy a person's soul should the blade cut through said person's flesh.
Look at your first comment... Also that's not how this fallacy works.ScarletFirefly said:No my friend, the burden of proof is on you. You claimed that Guts can kill with one scratch due to soul attacks. I never denied it affects the soul, but your course of logic is erraneous.
Eh, but that's too much work. I've tried it before.ScarletFirefly said:Also an advice Burning. When you count the votes, put the names of the people that have voted. That way you don't accidentally count the same one twice and it's easier to keep track.
So what makes Guts a exception? This is why I'm saying that the burden of proof is on you guys.WeeklyBattles said:@Black Not every character who can attack the soul can OHK...