Redundant scalings between All Might and All For One's primes.

I just went to check for Boku no Hero Academia's pages (I am scrutinizing them and a few other verses I like in order to downgrade everything where there may be Outlier scaling or other forms of invalid power measuring) and noticedtweo things:

Firstly, All-Might's prime is scaled to All For One's.

Secondly, All For One's prime is scaled to All-Might's.

This made me want to ask "Are we really admitting our position as unfounded headcanon makers here?", but I'll try to put it on a more educated way.

The scaling of the two is redundant. Besides, the ratio between the minimal value for Low 7-C and the maximum value for High 7-C is of 100x.

Could anyone explain what was the scaling that leaded All-Might and All For One's primes to be scaled as High 7-C?

And if it is the fact that All-Might has only 1/60th of his Prime potency, shouldn't then this be made explicit on his page so that All For One's scaling is logically valid?


Besides that, I would like to ask why is the feat of a fodder villain cutting a boat in half not an outlier. Is such a feat even ever seen again? If I remember well, Bakugou and Izuku seemed no stronger than the lowest 9-A or strongest 9-B on their first fight.

All Might Prime is not scaled to anyone. His Prime stats came from the fact that he said that his 300 or so punches against Noumu, if he had done it back in his prime, would've only taken 5.

AFO is scaled from All Might Prime.

EDIT

Likely Large Town level (in his prime, just five of his punches would contain the power of over 300 as he is now)

Oh, I'm sorry. I only saw it now that I was looking onto durability, which looks redundant at a first glance.

I'll now make a post however criticising the 8-C fodder feat.

Very well.

Mand21 said:

"Are we really admitting our position as unfounded headcanon makers here?"

Click to expand...

I'd suggest against putting words like these next time though. It can be taken negatively by many, but I appreciate you try to make sure that our pages are consistent and logical by checking.