• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Stewie vs Maggie

Buttersamuri

Buttersamuri

13,314
628
Battle of the babies. Both are 1 n stuff. Both also have guns n stuff. So who beats who?

Speed will be equal

Both get their full arsenal

Both willing to kill

Takes place in an alley way

Who wins and why?

Stewie Griffin: 6

Maggie Simpso: 7

Inconclusive/Draw:
 
Stewies only win option from what I can see myself is his hacks since I made it full arsenal. Cause he isn't physically taking Maggie down
 
He universal equipment would require a self destruct which would either kill himself or remove himself. So technically yes but no. He will have it. He just can't use it cause it would kill him
 
so depending on where it takes place stewie could go to an alternate universe while the other one gets destroyed but it depends the circumstance if maggie is in the family guy verse stewie wouldn't want to destroy his home destroyed and kill everyone or the simpsons verse where he wouldn't care or if it's a mix of the two verses like in the crossover where stewie would also care like in the family guy verse
 
Ehh. You should consider what Stewie would do in character. I seriously doubt he would blow up a universe to kill Maggie. Like in general.
 
So uh

Maggie one-shots super hard, but Stewie has a bunch of abilities. TBH, Maggie's Social Influencing ability + one shot + Stewie isn't a psycho anymore kinda makes me lean towards the Simpson on this one
 
I think I'm going to vote for Maggie. Stewie has the abilities that could allow him to win, but Maggie should be able to deal with it long enough to kill him.
 
Stewie just seems so much smarter and is a way better and more experienced combatant than Maggie is. And his gadgets + inventions are going to make Maggie's life hell. This is a no-brainer. :p
 
Being more experience in combat is useless against someone you can't physically combat doesn't help. Maggie does physically dominate. She doesn't even need to be good at combat. All she needs to do is a single smack.
 
Maggie may be physically superior to Stewie, but given her infrequent experiences in combat (unless I'm missing anything important from more recent Simpsons episodes) throughout the entire show, I don't know why you guys would scale her to the rest of the Simpsons family when their durability feats, high as they are, are often inconsistent. And plus Stewie has tons of equipment that I don't ever remember Maggie dealing with.

Maggie only has a knife, dagger, pacifier, and a few ordinary guns at best. Please explain to me how the hell do any of those even compare to a laser gun, flamethrower, carbonite freeze gun, hypnotic devices, and shrink ray?

In a physical fight, sure Maggie may have the upper hand, I may give you that. But with full arsenal, I don't see how Stewie doesn't stomp. You're comparing someone who's just an above-average thinker to someone who can literally pass for a scientist from a century ahead of our time in terms of tech and intelligence.
 
Because she physically has scaled multiple times. It's linked and brought up way on her page. Physically damaged some of the cast, knocked out homer before, restrained bart, sent someone bolting who physically overpowered homer, and several instances where she most certinalt scale. There isn't going around that. And no. for one, using that argument when the opponent is a family guy character is a really bad idea. Maggie is far more consistent in her levels than stewie. The fact she can hurt and restrain the cast and even is physically strong enough saved homer from drowning. And has sent people stronger than homer flying away with a punch. She scales. There just isn't a way to beat around that. And it scales to her durability as durability almost always scales to AP. And Maggie has taken hits before anyway.

Also. Gotta consider Maggie's abilties: which I haven't seen you bring any up. Not her equipment either

He doesn't stomp because he physically is outlclass and if he gets within hitting range is totally screwed. And his only win factor is by using specific hacks.

Which btw. Have you considered what they would do in character. How fast would stewie even resort to an of his abilities. And would it even be able to happen in time before he dies.
 
Also

Maggie can show survive being vaporized by a laser gun or being stepped on after being shrunk to the size of an ant


Well none of Stweies weapons would physically harm Maggie. Not a chance his laser has the force to even burn her let alone vaporize.

And shrinking her doesn't change the facts she hundreds of times stronger. Much like the ant man. That's gonna be one powerful tiny compared to him

And this results back to my last question. How fast would stewie even resort to an of his abilities. And would it even be able to happen in time before he dies.
 
Stewie is still leagues smarter. If he finds out Maggie's raw strength, that's how he knows which abilities and hax to use and when.
 
How would he figure it out though? Only one way I see that. And that's having tries to attack her physically. Which means he would already be dead. Cause Maggie one shots hard.
 
IIRC stewie doesnt always start out with his ray gun as he also starts out with his mind control ray and i can see him using it if he sees that shooting maggie with the ray gun wont work

im not saying maggie doesnt stand a chance but stewie has wincons too
 
Oh yea. He has win conditions. The idea that his wins were through hacks. It's just the odd of him using them. As well Maggie has range guns. Which she is a really good shot with.
 
Stewie Can win with hacks. But no stomp. Definitely not. Maggie physically dominates him and has range herself.
 
I don't know, Time Travel, Time Manipulation, Spatial Manipulation, Physics Manipulation, Reality Warping, Mind Manipulation, Mind Control, Memory Manipulation, Teleportation, Size Manipulation and precognition seem a step above simple AP.
 
Except like most all of that he isn't gonna even try to use. Definitely not immediately. Some of those things even come from one time situations. Or machines that aren't viable in combat.
 
Stewie is WAY more intelligent. What about his Freezing gun that froze a security guard solid for 10 years? Don't see Maggie dealing with that without firearms herself.
 
She has fire arms. She has a Rifle, shotgun, and Pistol. It's full arsenal. Including hers. So the guns she's had and used through the series are considered.
 
Would Maggie's firearms even harm Stewie with 9-A Durability? or are guns in Simpsons verse 8-C as well? She would have to somehow get past his freeze gun or Stewie scaring the shit out of her with a flame thrower. If she ever gets into CQC then yeah Maggie 1 shots but from range in an Alley which massively limits Maggies reaction advantage. I'm gonna have to say Stewie due to better attacks from range.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Jason_Courne
  • Locked
Family Guy: Stewie's tech/prep-time revision
Replies
12
Views
1K
Jason_Courne
Jason_Courne
Batman vs Peter Griffin
Replies
1
Views
810
Imaginym
Imaginym
Pepsiman25th
jojo vs family guy
Replies
2
Views
2K
Braking
Braking
Kakarot_Prime
Homer Simpson VS. Tom Cat
Replies
8
Views
1K
Propellus
Propellus
Kakarot_Prime
DB Son Goku vs. Homer Simpson
Replies
8
Views
2K
Turtlelord26
Back
Top