- 6,108
- 963
Since the least thread kinda turned into a mess, time to remake it.
We agreed in the last thread on these ratings if memory serves me correctly.
At least High 7-A for Fourth Form Tatsumi, scaling from One-Shotting Purge Mode Shikoutazer. At least High 7-A, for Tyrant. And straight up 6-C for Esdeath and Enoodzuno Akame. As the former while weakened One Shotted Tyrant, who is nearly borderline 6-C to begin with
However, there is another case to be made here.
Is it any coincidence that Esdeath's best AP feat (One-Shotting Tyrant) was while under the effects of ISCIC? Said powerup doesn't buff Esdeath to 6-B, but it obviously increases her physical power to an extent
While earlier in the story, Esdeath while not using any amps, has two incidents that challenge the current ratings.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/Akame-ga-Kiru--053----Kill-the-Adversity?id=210800#34
Esdeath should have Danamaku btw
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#11
Tatsumi successfully lands a strike on Esdeath,
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#12
In the very next pannel she lets out a slight grunt of pain, and visibly winces.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga...---Kill-the-Adversity--Part-002-?id=214498#30
Esdeath was threataned enough by a blast from Mine that she decided to use Mahapdama.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#46
Esdeath states she can still feel the impact, and is impressed with Tatsumi's power.
I am aware that Esdeath let her emotions get the better of her, and allowed the blow to land. But she still took slight damage from it regardless.
So what am I suggesting? That Esdeath is only scales above Shikoutazer with ISCIC. With all this in mind, it's not a stretch to imagine that the Ice Storm boosts her physical power as well.
If this makes sense to everyone, I would propose At least 7-B, likely higher for Esdeath in base for being arguably superior to Second-Third Form Tatsumi, and base Shikoutazer, while Esdeath was casually toying with the former 6-C with ISCIC active
Further Reasoning: Before anyone claims that it makes more sense for Esdeath in base to be above Shikoutazer, think about it. Purge Mode was a secret addition to the Shikoutazer Teigu the Minister had created without anyone's knowledge (Likely including Esdeath) So it is not a stretch to imagine that with such a powerup, it could've easily been above Esdeath without the latter having any amps.
Honestly, scaling Esdeath without the Ice Storm above Purge Mode doesn't make any sense, and to claim otherwise has little-to no basis for evidence.
In agreement: Burning Full Fingers TriforcePower1 Graf Thorsdottir Knightofannihilation666 Dark649 RebubleUselet Gargoyle One Veloxt1r0kore Newendigo
Against
Neutral/Undecided.
We agreed in the last thread on these ratings if memory serves me correctly.
At least High 7-A for Fourth Form Tatsumi, scaling from One-Shotting Purge Mode Shikoutazer. At least High 7-A, for Tyrant. And straight up 6-C for Esdeath and Enoodzuno Akame. As the former while weakened One Shotted Tyrant, who is nearly borderline 6-C to begin with
However, there is another case to be made here.
Is it any coincidence that Esdeath's best AP feat (One-Shotting Tyrant) was while under the effects of ISCIC? Said powerup doesn't buff Esdeath to 6-B, but it obviously increases her physical power to an extent
While earlier in the story, Esdeath while not using any amps, has two incidents that challenge the current ratings.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/Akame-ga-Kiru--053----Kill-the-Adversity?id=210800#34
Esdeath should have Danamaku btw
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#11
Tatsumi successfully lands a strike on Esdeath,
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#12
In the very next pannel she lets out a slight grunt of pain, and visibly winces.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga...---Kill-the-Adversity--Part-002-?id=214498#30
Esdeath was threataned enough by a blast from Mine that she decided to use Mahapdama.
http://*********.com/Manga/Akame-ga-Kill/56-Kill-the-Great-General?id=219727#46
Esdeath states she can still feel the impact, and is impressed with Tatsumi's power.
I am aware that Esdeath let her emotions get the better of her, and allowed the blow to land. But she still took slight damage from it regardless.
So what am I suggesting? That Esdeath is only scales above Shikoutazer with ISCIC. With all this in mind, it's not a stretch to imagine that the Ice Storm boosts her physical power as well.
If this makes sense to everyone, I would propose At least 7-B, likely higher for Esdeath in base for being arguably superior to Second-Third Form Tatsumi, and base Shikoutazer, while Esdeath was casually toying with the former 6-C with ISCIC active
Further Reasoning: Before anyone claims that it makes more sense for Esdeath in base to be above Shikoutazer, think about it. Purge Mode was a secret addition to the Shikoutazer Teigu the Minister had created without anyone's knowledge (Likely including Esdeath) So it is not a stretch to imagine that with such a powerup, it could've easily been above Esdeath without the latter having any amps.
Honestly, scaling Esdeath without the Ice Storm above Purge Mode doesn't make any sense, and to claim otherwise has little-to no basis for evidence.
In agreement: Burning Full Fingers TriforcePower1 Graf Thorsdottir Knightofannihilation666 Dark649 RebubleUselet Gargoyle One Veloxt1r0kore Newendigo
Against
Neutral/Undecided.
