(STAFF APPROVAL NEEDED) Soul Eater Profile Issue

[Cielsea]

I can't really speak on what happened in the previous CRTs but if no reason was given for the stats being downgraded in those prior ones then I don't why this shouldn't be fine but I'd suggest adding all the scaling evidence to the OP regardless

@Nierre

okay i will do so.

 

[Nierre]

I've lost interest in scaling this verse any more, so if majority thinks it's okay to scale them then I have no qualms about it.

 

[Cielsea]

I've lost interest in scaling this verse any more, so if majority thinks it's okay to scale them then I have no qualms about it.

thank you for your cooperation, may I ask why you lost your interest in the verse though?

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

The OP looks kind of a bit simple; though the draft pages looks pretty well done aside from punctuation issues. I can't really comment on scaling and what not.

 

[Cielsea]

The OP looks kind of a bit simple; though the draft pages looks pretty well done aside from punctuation issues. I can't really comment on scaling and what not.

what should i do regarding the op? as for the scaling the proof is in the draft pages as well.

 

[MintyBoi1]

I believe all three should scale pretty blatantly. For one Maka, Black Star, and Kid were iirc the only people besides Crona and Lord Death to be able to do anything to Asura. Maka cutting him open with Kishin Hunt. Black Star is commended by Asura multiple times and Kid is directly stated to be just a little below him at worst. Plus they all took several direct hits, Black Star swallowing a blast which Asura himself is surprised he survived. They weren’t strong enough to outright kill Asura, just sealing him away, but they could at least do damage and survive several hits that would kill people as far below him as Tier 6.

 

[Random-Helper323]

I'll help put together that OP in a bit. Basically all you need is the evidence for the scaling, and then to include the things I listed above about how the downgrade was poorly handled back when it was done.

 

[Cielsea]

I believe all three should scale pretty blatantly. For one Maka, Black Star, and Kid were iirc the only people besides Crona and Lord Death to be able to do anything to Asura. Maka cutting him open with Kishin Hunt. Black Star is commended by Asura multiple times and Kid is directly stated to be just a little below him at worst. Plus they all took several direct hits, Black Star swallowing a blast which Asura himself is surprised he survived. They weren’t strong enough to outright kill Asura, just sealing him away, but they could at least do damage and survive several hits that would kill people as far below him as Tier 6.

yup these are all the exact same points i put in the profiles, anyway for the reason why they can't kill asura it's mostly because of the abstract existence and immortality he has from being the concept of fear anyway and is not due to a lack of ap or scaling.

 

[Cielsea]

I'll help put together that OP in a bit. Basically all you need is the evidence for the scaling, and then to include the things I listed above about how the downgrade was poorly handled back when it was done.

okay thanks but what other evidence is there as i'm pretty sure I have it all listed in the profile

 

[Random-Helper323]

okay thanks but what other evidence is there as i'm pretty sure I have it all listed in the profile

I just saw you updated the OP. Technically the edits that removed 2-C did link a CRT, it's just that the CRT said nothing about Fire Force scaling.

 

[Cielsea]

I just saw you updated the OP. Technically the edits that removed 2-C did link a CRT, it's just that the CRT said nothing about Fire Force scaling.

right i will clarify this.

 

[Cielsea]

we just need an admin to approve the scaling and we're done or do we already have enough approvals?

 

[MintyBoi1]

yup these are all the exact same points i put in the profiles, anyway for the reason why they can't kill asura it's mostly because of the abstract existence and immortality he has from being the concept of fear anyway and is not due to a lack of ap or scaling.

You can add my scans to the OP to you want, it’s definitely make things easier for this to get accepted.

 

[Cielsea]

You can add my scans to the OP to you want, it’s definitely make things easier for this to get accepted.

should i spoiler tag and say it's additional scans from you?

 

[MintyBoi1]

should i spoiler tag and say it's additional scans from you?

Sure, credit me

 

[Cielsea]

Sure, credit me

added, anyway do you know an admin that could approve this?

 

[MintyBoi1]

added, anyway do you know an admin that could approve this?

Maybe reply to the ones who already commented

 

[Cielsea]

Maybe reply to the ones who already commented

most of them already said yes the only that hasn't responded is damage. actually wait how many approvals do we even need?

 

[Random-Helper323]

most of them already said yes the only that hasn't responded is damage. actually wait how many approvals do we even need?

You typically need two or three approvals from thread mods, admins or bureaucrats.

From what I can see you seem to have the approval of King Tempest.

Nierre and Medeus appear to be neutral, and Antvasima is being a referee here.

 

[Cielsea]

You typically need two or three approvals from thread mods, admins or bureaucrats.

From what I can see you seem to have the approval of King Tempest.

Nierre and Medeus appear to be neutral, and Antvasima is being a referee here.

Dalesean seems to agree although i'm unsure if he counts as an admin.

 

[Random-Helper323]

Dalesean seems to agree although i'm unsure if he counts as an admin.

Dalesean is calc group. Only thread mods, admins and bureaucrats have voting rights.

 

[Cielsea]

I believe all three should scale pretty blatantly. For one Maka, Black Star, and Kid were iirc the only people besides Crona and Lord Death to be able to do anything to Asura. Maka cutting him open with Kishin Hunt. Black Star is commended by Asura multiple times and Kid is directly stated to be just a little below him at worst. Plus they all took several direct hits, Black Star swallowing a blast which Asura himself is surprised he survived. They weren’t strong enough to outright kill Asura, just sealing him away, but they could at least do damage and survive several hits that would kill people as far below him as Tier 6.

actually it just came to my mind now but I remember kilik using azusa to snipe asura and he suffered abit of knockback from the attack, this is considered an outlier though right?

 

[MintyBoi1]

actually it just came to my mind now but I remember kilik using azusa to snipe asura and he suffered abit of knockback from the attack, this is considered an outlier though right?

Not sure, it looks more like he was just distracted and he easily blocked the next shot. But if we do say he took damage, it could just mean Asuza is one of the stronger Death Scythes among Spirit.

 

[Cielsea]

Not sure, it looks more like he was just distracted and he easily blocked the next shot. But if we do say he took damage, it could just mean Asuza is one of the stronger Death Scythes among Spirit.

if he took damage would that mean the death scythes scale to Asura? this seems somewhat inconsistent though from what I know since Spirit said himself that he could not do anything to Asura.

 

[MintyBoi1]

if he took damage would that mean the death scythes scale to Asura? this seems somewhat inconsistent though from what I know since Spirit said himself that he could not do anything to Asura.

Yeah, I don’t think they scale. It probably did no damage and Asura right after makes them move to a new location to not be killed by him.

 

[Cielsea]

Yeah, I don’t think they scale. It probably did no damage and Asura right after makes them move to a new location to not be killed by him.

fair enough, just brought it up since i wanted to see what others thought about it.

 

[Cielsea]

bump

 

[MintyBoi1]

Your OP is lacking in any links, any scans, any arguments.

Scale them

The OP looks kind of a bit simple; though the draft pages looks pretty well done aside from punctuation issues. I can't really comment on scaling and what not.

Do any of you have opinions here now that scans for scaling have been added to the OP?

 

[Cielsea]

i've already tried contacting some admins but there have been no responses, what happened to this site? it wasn't this dead and inactive before