• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Solar system luffy

ISL for Whitebeard's Earthquakes are not a bad idea actually. But nah.

First, we don't allow horizon scaling for this very reason.
Second, we have officially maps for the world of one piece where we can calculate the size of the planet using the red line. The planet is much smaller than this horizon.

So unfortunately, not valid.
 
Also there are more luffy scales that get him to uni but uh one will require a lot of time to read
 
Yeah for multi there's a scale that I disagree with and takes so many screenshots to fit the whole scale
 
Wait there is also scale for multi? Damn, this world is crazy
 
Downplay, luffy above boundless, as he scales to the creator himself in real life... Not just any creator but THE Oda/Goda
 
I usually use scaling that i think makes sense but i stay away from calcs because.. i think we all know why, i don't understand math
 
i can use it outside of the wiki?
I mean, if you want to ignore the objectively better method of getting the planet size, go ahead.

But you'll get in a pickle when you're claiming the Red Line is a 1.000.000th of the width of the planet, when pictures show otherwise.
 
This is a hypothetical of if Luffy destroys the planet/scales to its destruction I'm guessing?
 
i think it might be for whitebeards tremors being stated to be capable of destroying the planet
 
i think it might be for whitebeards tremors being stated to be capable of destroying the planet
No one takes that statement as a scaling thing. Even though it's repeated several times in manga, databook and Ace novel. At this point it's embarrassing how we choose to ignore it.
So until that statement gets repeated with more depth (because apparently you need more than 'destroy' for it) then it probably doesn't matter for the scaling.
 
Give me 1 reason not to use it, even if we don't use it in the context of planetary destruction, it can be very well used as "whitebeard can make the world uninhabitable" as he is still destroying the world in that context (remember, world doesn't necessarily equate to planet, it can mean literally anything)

And the issue of whitebeard not destroying marineford can be addressed with :
1- he was sick and weakened
2- he was holding back
We never really saw the full potential of the gura gura no mi

Heck, didn't someone state that they're not safe from the gura gura even while on the other side of the world?

Absolutely no reason not to take the statement, even if we lowball it to a cartoonish degree
 
No one takes that statement as a scaling thing. Even though it's repeated several times in manga, databook and Ace novel. At this point it's embarrassing how we choose to ignore it.
So until that statement gets repeated with more depth (because apparently you need more than 'destroy' for it) then it probably doesn't matter for the scaling.
You can't really calc something vague like that when
  • We don't know how long it would take
  • We don't know in what way it would be destroyed; erased, cracked, fragmented, life wiped etc
  • We don't know if he'd overcome the GBE or not
You'd need to assume all of this which is pretty much equivalent to just fabricating the entire feat
 
You can't really calc something vague like that when
  • We don't know how long it would take
  • We don't know in what way it would be destroyed; erased, cracked, fragmented, life wiped etc
  • We don't know if he'd overcome the GBE or not
You'd need to assume all of this which is pretty much equivalent to just fabricating the entire feat
Its a fruit that causes tsumanies and earthquakes, can't we use surface area to find the energy needed to wipe it?
 
You can't really calc something vague like that when
  • We don't know how long it would take
  • We don't know in what way it would be destroyed; erased, cracked, fragmented, life wiped etc
  • We don't know if he'd overcome the GBE or not
You'd need to assume all of this which is pretty much equivalent to just fabricating the entire feat
Hence the 'more depth'. We'll either need to be shown a feat of the quakes travelling globaly in a certain timeframe or a statement like 'destroy it one shot' type thing.
That or a Boros style 'destroy the surface in one blast' thing. Too vague to calc.
 
Back
Top