Scrooge McDuck vs. Shovel Knight

[Megamangohan]

Since Death Battle is Doing it, why not it be done here.

Note: Shovel Knight Defeating Kratos is considered a feat here so this is not a Mismatch.

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

Using crossovers as feats aren't generally allowed. And even if they were, Multi-continent level is still well below Planet level. However, if Scrooge was limited to his base form, it will work out.

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

If we're going with Base Scrooge and Base Shovel Knight, than I'd say Scrooge. Shovel Knight may be ranked as a higher tier than Scrooge, but attack potency and durability isn't what only counts. Scrooge is way more experianced and intelligent than Shovel Knight is, keep in mind, from as it seems, Shovel Knight is a young knight, and one who assumed that the one he loved was dead and gone for for good, and still even went on the quest to save her though there wasn't any hope what so ever. Sure, it's heroric and brave, but also very stupid and risky at the same time. For Scrooge on the other hand, when he's on quests, he has prep time and the will to think of what may occur ahead of him.

 

[fandom_12cheeper]

If we're going with Base Scrooge and Base Shovel Knight, than I'd say Scrooge. Shovel Knight may be ranked as a higher tier than Scrooge, but attack potency and durability isn't what only counts. Scrooge is way more experianced and intelligent than Shovel Knight is, keep in mind, from as it seems, Shovel Knight is a young knight, and one who assumed that the one he loved was dead and gone for for good, and still even went on the quest to save her though there wasn't any hope what so ever. Sure, it's heroric and brave, but also very stupid and risky at the same time. For Scrooge on the other hand, when he's on quests, he has prep time and the will to think of what may occur ahead of him.

>inexperienced

Have you even played the game?It's made pretty clear that Shovel and Shield Knight have been doing this for a long time.

Not like it matters because experience and taktikz mean absolutely nothing when you can't even harm the other guy.

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

If we're going with Base Scrooge and Base Shovel Knight, than I'd say Scrooge. Shovel Knight may be ranked as a higher tier than Scrooge, but attack potency and durability isn't what only counts. Scrooge is way more experianced and intelligent than Shovel Knight is, keep in mind, from as it seems, Shovel Knight is a young knight, and one who assumed that the one he loved was dead and gone for for good, and still even went on the quest to save her though there wasn't any hope what so ever. Sure, it's heroric and brave, but also very stupid and risky at the same time. For Scrooge on the other hand, when he's on quests, he has prep time and the will to think of what may occur ahead of him.

>inexperienced
Have you even played the game?It's made pretty clear that Shovel and Shield Knight have been doing this for a long time.

Not like it matters because experience and taktikz mean absolutely nothing when you can't even harm the other guy.

Yes, I have played Shovel Knight before, and I never said he was inexperianced, all I stated was that Scrooge is more experianced than Shovel Knight. Thought Shovel Knight's age is unknown, Scrooge is at the age of 88, and has been on quests and has dealt with danger amongst many occasions in his lifetime.

 

[fandom_12cheeper]

Again,doesn't matter when the stat gap is this wide.

Batman is a really good strategist who's been fighting for decades but that doesn't mean he can take on Beerus.

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

Well man, if you think Shovel Knight beats Scrooge, than that's fine. I think otherwise.

 

[fandom_12cheeper]

Oh I'm not saying who wins I'm just pointing out how experience and tactics are utterly meaningless unless you're relatively close.I don't care how great of a tactician you are,a peak human isn't beating Nyarlathotep.

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

This thread should be closed tbh, Shovel Knight was only Building Level with this thread was first made; and now he's at least Large Town Level. Scrooge is only Room Level in base and Super Scrooge is Planet Level However we set it it's a stomp thread in one way or the other now.

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

Well not to mention, Scrooge was declared victorious against Shovel Knight.

 

[CrackerVolley]

Does this mean we should remove the exact same match mayed by hipper from the two's profiles

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

Does this mean we should remove the exact same match mayed by hipper from the two's profiles

Well, that was the thread that declared Scrooge victorious, so, the deed has been done.