Problems with yorozu high 3a

[Rolgoat]

Before getting into the topic, I would like to point out that there may be mistakes due to my lack of knowledge about JJK. Anyways, the reason for Yorozu's High 3A ranking and the relevant scans are those: "with True Sphere (A true sphere has no contact area and generates infinite pressure as a result, making it untouchable. Infinite pressure functions as infinite damage on a 3D scale)" and this link.

Now, I'll move on to my objection. In classical physics, if something has infinite pressure, its gravitational pull should also be infinite. As a result, it should pull everything around it like a black hole. However, the scan shows no such effect; instead, it can't pull anything towards itself. I don't understand why it's still accepted despite this obvious anti-feat.



Besides that, there's another point I'd like to make, but I want to emphasize that this is just an additional objection and what I'm saying here could be completely wrong because I don't fully understand the balance of cursed energy in JJK. However, in this link, it's clearly stated that Yorozu's cursed energy is insufficient compared to Sukuna's. Logically, to create a sphere with infinite density, an infinite energy output and, therefore, infinite cursed energy should be required. But Yorozu's cursed energy is not infinite.

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

this feels incredulous IMO

 

[Rolgoat]

this feels incredulous IMO

Wdym?

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

Wdym?

fiction being fiction doesnt have to adhere to physics 1:1 and the infinite pressure is more like a byproduct of the perfect sphere created by the cursed energy rather than cursed energy directly creating infinite pressure.

 

[Duedate8898]

To restate what MGQ just did:
I would argue that a series not portraying something scientifically accurate should rarely be considered an anti-feat as generally there are many real world physics principals fiction will ignore for the sake of the story, for instance, FTL or Lightspeed characters in general typically violate the laws of physics in some manner (Shinra from Fire Force is canonically FTL as are the servants Dioscuri in Fate, yet neither achieves Infinite Energy in relation to exceeding lightspeed).

And in regards to output, as MGQ said, the infinite pressure is not coming directly from Yoruzu using her cursed energy to create it, but as byproduct of the shape of her construct.

 

[Livinmeme]

This isn't a Hard SCIFI novel, this is a shonen of dubious quality, to apply such physics into a series where people can punch hard enough to destroy buildings is kinda...Stupid

 

[Planck69]

This is just incredulity with a mix of taking physics too far. Hard disagree.

 

[ReaperAndBlues]

This is anime bruh, physics are a footnote to power systems not a backbone.

Hard disagree for reasons above

 

[Noes]

According to the laws of physics, it is generally not possible to exceed the speed of light. According to the theory of special relativity, as the speed of an object approaches the speed of light, the mass of that object increases and infinite energy is required to increase that speed even further. Therefore, it is considered impossible for any object with mass to exceed the speed of light, but this may change in fiction, it is unnecessary to get caught up in such details and this topic should have been in the question and answer section.
I disagree

 

[Hypertornado099]

Agree with the CRT

 

[AyeZ2]

Disagree

 

[Robo432343]

agree FRA

 

[SunDaGamer]

Yorozu's sphere exerts infinite pressure on whatever comes into contact with it because every point of contact is infinitely small due to it being a perfect sphere (the more sides you add to a shape, the more points it will have and the more circular it will appear as all the possible contact areas become smaller). It's physically impossible for an object like it to exist in real life but that's just how Gege likes his top-tier hax abilities. Gojo's Infinity for example brings Zeno's paradox that motion is impossible into reality, according to it there is an infinite number of fractions between 2 distances which Gojo directly references in the series by mentioning the paradox of achilles and the tortoise, it'd be ridiculous to just discard Gojo's Infinity despite its well established abilities in the story on the basis that it would be physically impossible for it to exist in real life.

 

[Sus]

while the reason in the OP is bad

it's listed as H3A for the mere mention of the word infinite once? could easily be a hyperbole without further evidence

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

while the reason in the OP is bad

it's listed as H3A for the mere mention of the word infinite once? could easily be a hyperbole without further evidence

It's as pretty direct as it can be here.

 

[Planck69]

while the reason in the OP is bad

it's listed as H3A for the mere mention of the word infinite once? could easily be a hyperbole without further evidence

It is an incredibly direct statement, so you would have to explain why we would discard it in the first place.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Before getting into the topic, I would like to point out that there may be mistakes due to my lack of knowledge about JJK. Anyways, the reason for Yorozu's High 3A ranking and the relevant scans are those: "with True Sphere (A true sphere has no contact area and generates infinite pressure as a result, making it untouchable. Infinite pressure functions as infinite damage on a 3D scale)" and this link.

Now, I'll move on to my objection. In classical physics, if something has infinite pressure, its gravitational pull should also be infinite. As a result, it should pull everything around it like a black hole. However, the scan shows no such effect; instead, it can't pull anything towards itself. I don't understand why it's still accepted despite this obvious anti-feat.

Well this point was already addressed by others above so I don't care.

Besides that, there's another point I'd like to make, but I want to emphasize that this is just an additional objection and what I'm saying here could be completely wrong because I don't fully understand the balance of cursed energy in JJK. However, in this link, it's clearly stated that Yorozu's cursed energy is insufficient compared to Sukuna's. Logically, to create a sphere with infinite density, an infinite energy output and, therefore, infinite cursed energy should be required. But Yorozu's cursed energy is not infinite.

Yorozu is not creating infinite pressure with her own CE. She creates the sphere that generates infinite pressure. It doesn't scale physically at all. You don't need infinite CE to create an object that can produce infinite pressure.

If we follow your logic, we should downgrade all fictional characters with universe-busting feats but finite stamina to below High 3-A, lmao.

 

[Floxy178]

Now, I'll move on to my objection. In classical physics, if something has infinite pressure, its gravitational pull should also be infinite. As a result, it should pull everything around it like a black hole. However, the scan shows no such effect; instead, it can't pull anything towards itself. I don't understand why it's still accepted despite this obvious anti-feat.

As far as I know pressure of object's surface has nothing to do with its gravitational pull.

Besides that, there's another point I'd like to make, but I want to emphasize that this is just an additional objection and what I'm saying here could be completely wrong because I don't fully understand the balance of cursed energy in JJK. However, in this link, it's clearly stated that Yorozu's cursed energy is insufficient compared to Sukuna's. Logically, to create a sphere with infinite density, an infinite energy output and, therefore, infinite cursed energy should be required. But Yorozu's cursed energy is not infinite.

Yorozu's sphere doesn't have infinite density.