Completely forgot about this thread just couple of hours later lol
Anyway, will try to respond.
So, I was summoned for some reason or another. Considering there is not debating so far, let's see if I can get it started and it can carry on from there:
AP: Yor is the stronger one as she scales to 5.846 megajoules, whilst Olivia scales to 3.68102 megajoules. Yor does have a feat of briefly knocking out Loid, who is 4.1 megajoules, with a single kick so there that
True, but I don't know much about Yor, however Olivia performed her feat when she was ten, so she's likely vastly superior to that. Also, while unable to control her power. As for knocking out Loid, I don't really know what you want to say by mentioning him ngl.
Speed: Olivia scales to Mach 3.1685 it seems but Yor actually scales far above Mach 3.16 since Fiona was the one that perform that speed feat and she could not even perceive Yor's actions despite standing right in front of her, so Yor has the speed advantage. However, Olivia does have speed amp in the form of Swift Step which would make her comparable, if not superior to Yor
Oh ok, though I'd like to mention that Olivia also scales far above her value considering she was as casual as you can get while performing it. Don't know the circumstance of Yor moving faster than Fiona can perceive, though. So, from my perspective still about equal, while Olivia being faster with Swift Swift (tbh the story implies she could move dozens if not hundreds of km in mere seconds to minutes with it, but so far unquantified)
LS: Yor wins hands down with Class 10 compared to Olivia's Average Human
True.
Stamina: Both has good stamina though I say Yor edges out for being withstanding the pain of a bullet wound for an entire day and staying awake for 3 days during the events on the Princess Lorelei where she had to constantly stay aware of her surroundings to protect two people and fight a whole host of renowned killers.
Don't really know if that's necessarily edging out. Olivia was capable of participating, and essentially carrying 2 full scale battles, moving hundreds of km from one location to another. So, essentially what I'm trying to say is that she casually fought dozens, if not hundreds of soldiers, and then moved to a fortress dozen of KM away (maybe more? idk, the map provided in verse doesn't have hard numbers), and then fighting many soldiers in an entire fortress, while not breaking a sweat. But this doesn't seem like the kind of fight that will boil down to stamina IMO.
Range: Olivia got more range since she has a sword in comparison to Yor's needles unless she throws them.
Yeah, and Olivia can also throw her sword if needed. She has pretty good accuracy.
Other:
- As mentioned before, Yor normally have the speed advantage unless Olivia uses Swift Step. Yor does have options to handle this via her Enhanced Senses, Extrasensory Perception and Instinctive Action. These should help her to survive the Swift Steps and Olivia can't constantly do this move too much since it is said that it drains her stamina at a quicker pace
I don't really see how all those would be too useful against a head on attacks, just being a lot faster. Olivia also has really good skill, and idk the requirements for all those abilities, so might need to check them out, but I don't think it's anything to worry about. Also, Olivia has not yet shown how quick a pace it drains her at but implies moving dozens if not hundreds of km is the only way. (And even then, it's mostly that she would be more tired, not full out)
- Both are characters seems to be equally skilled in combat, making whoever lands the first blow all the more crucial, especially in Yor's case since her needles have poison capable of taking down an elephant so one stab is all Yor needs to secure a win. Just in case if someone is curious, Yor has fought a sword master once, don't about Olivia facing against assassins like Yor unfortunately since I'm not knowledgeable on her
Olivia has faced spy's, she could completely out skill and predict someone who was sent to infiltrate a fortress (and knows how to use faint attacks) and is leagues above people who are also considered legends on the battlefield such as Samuel and is also considered vastly superior to Paul in his youth, who has gained the title of "God of the Battlefield".
- Both have martial arts so if it comes down that both loses their primary weapons, they can fight in hand-to-hand combat although Olivia has to be careful since Yor likes to mix in pressure points in her martial arts to either quickly incapacitate (indeed, it works on people she considered to be strong) or increase the lethality of her strikes, though how effective it will be with Olivia's armor is anyone's guess).
I don't exactly know how skilled Yor is with her hands, mostly seems to be skilled with her needles, at least far better with them, while a lot more emphasis is placed on Olivias martial arts from what I remember. (I have a really terrible memory)
- I believe Yor is the more acrobatic of the two
Don't see how tbh.
- Olivia does have that Fear Inducement which can be something, don't know if it is combat applicable. Yor does have something similar to that in the form of Social Influencing where she can scare not trained and intelligent animals but also highly skilled assassin who she referred to as strong with her aura.
It is combat applicable so far. And it's to the extent of people hallucinating a death scythe instead of a sword.
- Regarding Yor's Standard Tactics, she is usually merciless when fighting, aiming for a person's vital spots like brain, chin, heart, etc to stab in order to end a fight as quickly possible. From looking at Olivia's ST, she uses a similar tactics of finishing fights quickly by decapitating, bisecting, or simply stabbing her opponents
Yep, pretty much both go for 1 shots.
- Olivia does have Fire Manipulation and Yor doesn't have Resistance to Fire Manipulation so it would really hurt if she got hit by it
Yeah, I guess.
For now, I put in a vote for Yor via poisoned weapons strong enough to kill an elephant. Instinctive Reactions + Extrasensory Perception + Enhanced Senses + Acrobatics + Afterimage Creation + Higher Combat Speed will make it difficult to hit her, even with Olivia's Swift Step imo. Not to mention that the Higher AP + LS will allow Yor to overpower Olivia in a clash and perform takedowns on her.
Don't think Yor will have any luck with even landing her poison attack considering Olivia is stated to be able to defend against any attack from any direction, as well as being able to dodge from several soldiers at the same time without looking. For the first 3 powers, I don't see how they will help tbh if Olivia will be likely far faster with swift step. Acrobatics seem to be about the same for the two IMO, afterimage creation is speed based so I don't see it helping, higher combat speed is not as big, maybe even about equal, and also sword strikes are far faster than people can punch (or sum idk, bad memory), at least from what I've heard. And also, better range to begin with. And as for clashes, Olivia isn't one to go for them, and from what I've seen Yor isn't really one to go for them either so I don't think this will matter much.
Anyway, I will probably respond tomorrow after school considering it's late, for now I won't vote and will wait for your counter arguments.
