- 10,687
- 6,336
Rewatched animations for GBA era Light Magic and I agree on that. They don't really look like light as a whole.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
MFTL - FTL Fire Emblem Aureola.
- Thread starter Miles_Romero12
- Start date
- Status
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #43
How is light supposed to look like, then?Darkanine said:
I see beams of "yellow" illuminating an area. What are those then?
- 10,687
- 6,336
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #45
bump
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #46
bump
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #48
I wouldnt call him NOT proving the manga is canon and NOT proving all people on the game refer to the sky while talking about heaven "debunking"
- 11,444
- 1,998
@Miles
I already explained to you that it's the best possible depiction we have of Aureola and that we've set a precedent for using secondary canon by pixel-scaling from the Pokemon anime.
Secondly, "heaven" is incredibly vague and does not indicate anything. For example, Greek Mythology's "Heaven" was on Mt. Olympus, which on top of a mountain and not in some alternate dimension. Since Fire Emblem does not explain what heaven truly is, you're intentionally distorting statements in order to achieve the results you want.
I already explained to you that it's the best possible depiction we have of Aureola and that we've set a precedent for using secondary canon by pixel-scaling from the Pokemon anime.
Secondly, "heaven" is incredibly vague and does not indicate anything. For example, Greek Mythology's "Heaven" was on Mt. Olympus, which on top of a mountain and not in some alternate dimension. Since Fire Emblem does not explain what heaven truly is, you're intentionally distorting statements in order to achieve the results you want.
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #50
Yeah, but that doesnt change its not the only possible explanation out there, as long as the manga is not canon, it cannot be accepted as factual proof of your claim.
YOU are the one who brought up the whole "Light that descents from the heavens" argument to claim Aureola comes from the clouds, heavely downgrading the results of my calculations. Not to mention your post claiming this is up there for everyone to see.
YOU are the one who brought up the whole "Light that descents from the heavens" argument to claim Aureola comes from the clouds, heavely downgrading the results of my calculations. Not to mention your post claiming this is up there for everyone to see.
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #51
Also, since this is "Magical Light", it can mean it could be slower or way faster than "normal" light.
I dislike how many of your arguments rely on downgrading attacks just because they are "magic" instead of calculating them.
I dislike how many of your arguments rely on downgrading attacks just because they are "magic" instead of calculating them.
- 11,444
- 1,998
@Miles
That literally destroys the point of using secondary canon materials to help visualize a subject due to the limitations of the original source material. The manga is almost entirely accurate to the original game, and it is not different enough to rule it out as a possible source to help analyze information.
I understand that, but you're twisting it to suit yourself. All I used it to say was that it was too vague to say that it came from the sun and the only other depiction shows it coming out of clouds. You're the one who said it was cross-dimensional with conceptual powers because of that statement.
That literally destroys the point of using secondary canon materials to help visualize a subject due to the limitations of the original source material. The manga is almost entirely accurate to the original game, and it is not different enough to rule it out as a possible source to help analyze information.
I understand that, but you're twisting it to suit yourself. All I used it to say was that it was too vague to say that it came from the sun and the only other depiction shows it coming out of clouds. You're the one who said it was cross-dimensional with conceptual powers because of that statement.
- 11,444
- 1,998
@Miles
When "light" doesn't display the properties of real light (i.e. always traveling in a straight line, reflecting off surfaces, bending upon hitting another medium), then we can't instantly assume it moves at the speed of light. Otherwise it's just a beam. This is literally outlined in the Laser/Light Beam Dodging Feats page that we keep showing you but you refuse to read it or comprehend it.
Honestly, it's almost 2:00 a.m. where I live and I don't want to argue this point further. Provide concrete evidence or this thread is closed.
When "light" doesn't display the properties of real light (i.e. always traveling in a straight line, reflecting off surfaces, bending upon hitting another medium), then we can't instantly assume it moves at the speed of light. Otherwise it's just a beam. This is literally outlined in the Laser/Light Beam Dodging Feats page that we keep showing you but you refuse to read it or comprehend it.
Honestly, it's almost 2:00 a.m. where I live and I don't want to argue this point further. Provide concrete evidence or this thread is closed.
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #54
(First comment) Actually, no. There are tons of differences in the overall plot of the Binding Blade manga. For example Al, his mother, Zephiel having both the Exxaccus and the Sword of Seals, etc. It would be more reasonable to make a manga version page for all those who could use this form of Aureola.
Not to mention that it contradicts the games, since it can be used in closed areas, where there are no clouds to be seen.
I have said that it could be cross dimensional to counter your claim that it was a beam of light from the clouds based on a cultural expression. Both have the exact same likelyhood of being true.
(Second comment) I added the actual speed of light to COMPARE Aureola to the speed it takes a regular beam of light to reach earth, 500 seconds.
Its like you didnt read my calc or something.
...
How about you present proof of your claims? Do you think closing the thread will automatically make everyone assume you are right?
Prove that the people were talking about the clouds with "heavens" or that the binding blade manga doesnt contradict the games at all.
Not to mention that it contradicts the games, since it can be used in closed areas, where there are no clouds to be seen.
I have said that it could be cross dimensional to counter your claim that it was a beam of light from the clouds based on a cultural expression. Both have the exact same likelyhood of being true.
(Second comment) I added the actual speed of light to COMPARE Aureola to the speed it takes a regular beam of light to reach earth, 500 seconds.
Its like you didnt read my calc or something.
...
How about you present proof of your claims? Do you think closing the thread will automatically make everyone assume you are right?
Prove that the people were talking about the clouds with "heavens" or that the binding blade manga doesnt contradict the games at all.
- 732
- 28
- Thread starter
- #56
Alright then.
Close the thread.
I dont want to be banned for a personal dispute.
Close the thread.
I dont want to be banned for a personal dispute.
- Status
Similar threads
