• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Mami Tomoe AP revision

Kaltias

VS Battles
Retired
Messages
19,139
Reaction score
6,352
Came up in this thread.

Basically the argument is that Mami's feat of slightly damaging Walpurgisnacht would be enough to rate her (And Candeloro/Elisa who scale from her) as High 7-A.

Thoughts?
 
The feat is of barely penetrating Walpurgis' skin after several minutes of her attacks. Given how small the gap High 7-A is, I would argue she should still remain 7-A.
 
I think I agree with SD, although IMO in this case she should be on a higher end of 7-A or mid-end at worst.
 
Not barely penetrating, actually.

But tbh i'm neutral. I'm mostly making this to avoid derailing.
 
@SD

For reference, Madoka's feat (which scales to Wal) is 5600 megatons, so 5.6 times above baseline High 7-A, and over 10 times above 7-A+.

Personally I think that 7-A+ is the best course of action.

I mean at a certain point even continuous bombardment wouldn't do anything with an AP gap that massive (you can't blow up a tank using a UZI for example)

Mami being over 10 times weaker (aka below 7-A+) feels off
 
Also, Candeloro can probably be High 7-A, given that she is basically "as strong as a witch can be while being below Walpurgisnacht".
 
I mean go ahead with 7-A+. I just think High 7-A is stretching it.

Candeloro can be High 7-A, sure.
 
I wonder what Weekly thinks.

He was the one who thought that High 7-A was the best course of action
 
High 7-A, even baseline High 7-A, would make so much more sense than the 300 Megaton 7-A she's currently rated as when the justification is that she slightly harmed an above baseline 6-C
 
The exact scan is this one btw.

It says that Wal can take several dozens minute straight of Tiro Finale. It doesn't say that she doesn't take damage afterwards (Although obviosly each individual attack is relatively inconsequential)

Also the source is a computer who can monitor the entire multiverse at once, so the statement itself is reliable.
 
Shrugs I'm neutral here, even if i'm slightly leaning towards High 7-A.

But the main reason why i'm neutral is because there isn't actually a set standard for this kind of stuff
 
On the AP itself? 7A+ possibly High 7A?

Chip itself however is honestly dumb as a justification
 
Im still sold on it being High 7-A but the fact that its blatant chip damage bothers me
 
You know I agree, the thing is that if you say that she is 7-B, the feat is basically thrown away because you can throw as many 7-B attacks at Wal as you want and she won't feel them (ask Homura).

If you say that she is 6-C it's just flat out wrong
 
Tbh I find chip damage as a justification somewhat stupid as well

Otherwise, I'm still okay with 7-A+
 
Kaltias said:
You know I agree, the thing is that if you say that she is 7-B, the feat is basically thrown away because you can throw as many 7-B attacks at Wal as you want and she won't feel them (ask Homura).

If you say that she is 6-C it's just flat out wrong
<Damaging something after 12 minutes

<Feat

Even as a fanboy of Mami I admit 7A genuinely feels dumb.
 
She'd be around 7-A still via one shooting really high end 7-B people actually

But yeah I see your point
 
So "At least 7-B, likely 7-A" it is.

Well RIP Mami vs Nui

Btw you should rename the thread to "Mami Tomoe AP Downgrade" ovo
 
Pfft. She'll be upgraded via stomping someone in a new installment like she always does ovo
 
That's the follow up of that bunch of downgrades that turned into upgrades ovo
 
I actually don't mind. The important part is that the rating is accurate.
 
@Kal Look at it this way, now Mami can go on to win even more matches now that she'll be 7-B ovo
 
Back
Top