Made In Abyss calc replacement

[ElJoaki5]

These calcs should replace these calcs for the AP of Reg's incinerator.

• There’s really no good reason to use vaporization or melting here. Some earlier uses of the incinerator do show it, but it’s not always the case and there aren’t any signs in these cases to justify using melting or vap.
• I also use better sizing for the first calc, since I use the map of the abyss which is the main reference for the size of things given by the manga. Probably better than using storey height (that calc measures room height as storey height too).

 

[Damage3245]

Replacements seem fine to me.

 

[ElJoaki5]

Replacements seem fine to me.

Is one vote enough?

 

[Damage3245]

I'll ping DMUA and KLOL506 since they commented on the original calc.

@KLOL506 @DMUA

 

[DMUA]

There’s really no good reason to use vaporization or melting here. Some earlier uses of the incinerator do show it, but it’s not always the case and there aren’t any signs in these cases to justify using melting or vap. This is why that calc isn’t accepted in the first place.

Technically it is accepted by people besides me, but I suppose that clarification would tip you off on how I feel about this issue

 

[ElJoaki5]

Technically it is accepted by people besides me, but I suppose that clarification would tip you off on how I feel about this issue

I didn’t know that. The calc should still be replaced for the other reasons tho, I think.