@Zenkai
In regards to AP, I don't really see how Raven is stronger, because both are banking on the same thing; an area that is "endless" in comparison to countless universes. Unless your purpose was just to clarify her AP, but later on in this comment you seem to treat it as if Raven's stronger, which I again do not see the evidence for if these are the statements we're going off of, since both effectively come down to "endlessly greater than countless worlds".
- "Ah, you see. You're once again throwing out there that just becaue The Chaos Gods can't do it to Khorne, that Raven automatically can't either."
This is not at all what I said. I'm suggesting that if Khorne is already capable of resisting and completely shrugging off the influence of abstract conceptual beings who are comparable to himself, you need more proof of Raven being able to affect him on these levels. You can't just say "she can just because". I'm not pulling this out of nowhere, either. Going back to the comment I originally replied to, you said:
"
She can practically set the laws of magic to her favor and reshape laws across existence to her will. If she wanted, she could force Khrone to follow laws that she sets"
You did not provide adequate reasoning for such a thing. You just asserted that this is a thing Raven could do to Khorne. I am not saying "because this Chaos God could not do ____ to Khorne, Raven can not do so either". I am saying "because this Chaos God could not do ____ to Khorne, explain why Raven
could do such a thing without just assuming she can by default".
- "I have seen no evidence to suggest the other chaos gods are more powerful or comparable to Rave"
I have provided you with such evidence. I have explained the nature and size of Shyish, how it and the other mortal planes can fit into a bubble of unaligned magic, and how all of this is just a drop in the Realm of Chaos, which itself can hold things such as a swamp of countless universes within its seemingly endless expanse. I have also provided a quote saying that the Chaos Gods could accidentally destroy all of this in the blink of an eye if they did not actively balance themselves.
- "Balance between Chaos? You mean the Chaos that Grandfather Spider embodies as well, that she was able to, at the same time lock away? A heart of chaos that was the very essence and embodiment of Chaos, that charged the essence of reality and formed it alongside the shadows which she basically considered fodder? Yeah nah mate, that ain't stoping jack of what Raven can do."
I'm assuming this is in response to the law manipulation conversation, so... are you asserting that Raven can affect the entirety of the Realm of Chaos because, in her setting, she sealed away something that is the embodiment of Chaos? This ignores the fact that, again, she has to overwhelm
all the Chaos Gods to do this in its entirety, not just Khorne. This is like me saying, "So Raven's a conceptual abstract across all of creation, right? Like the ones whose power Khorne is completely immune to? Yeah, sorry, she's not gonna be able to do anything to him". It ignores any and all nuance for the sake of "these things are vaguely comparable, thus they are equal". If we treat that as the case, "Khorne is immune to everything Raven has to offer" is as valid as "Khorne can't do shit against Raven". It is much easier to make a case for just conceptually altering/attacking Khorne or something like that than imposing law across the entirety of the Realm of Chaos.
- "That would be assuming the God's Khrone has been power nulling are comparable or stronger than Raven, which neither of us have given evidence to suggest one or the other."
I have given evidence as to the scale of 2-B the Fantasy Chaos Gods occupy. You have given evidence for the scale of 2-B Raven occupies. Neither immediately screams superiority to the other based on the size of the cosmology alone. I am not assuming they are comparable out of nowhere.
- "If we look at AP, from the things above, Raven does seem far stronger."
Based on
what? Nothing that's been provided suggests a larger cosmology.
- "Just because he can nullify Chaos Gods that are above in doesn't automatically make him above Raven's resistance."
Exactly. Which is why I went through the effort of explaining the scale of 2-B he's in and why it is not vastly below Raven, as you suggest.
- "Spider's Power Null logically would be comparable to Raven's which literally made him go from 2-B to High 4-C, possibly 3-A, regardless that would be two infinites weaker."
Unless Spider was naturally at this state, that is not so much power null as it is statistic debuffing, albeit very impressive power null. Which is specifically the kind of thing Khorne is most commonly focused on nullifying and resisting; powers targeted at him. Also, this is the kind of thing where context and video/scans is extremely helpful, as opposed to just automatic power reduction to a level two infinities lower. How was it done? What exactly happened? I have nothing to go by and can't properly gauge the ability. Similarly, Khorne choked Skarbrand, a being powerful enough to put a small crack in his armor, until he was at a level that he now contends with the strongest of mortal champions. However, without the full context, and because we don't see this, I don't want to use this as "Khorne choked two degrees of infinity out of Skarbrand". Likewise, the full context and video (if available) would be extremely helpful, here.
- "I don't see how that is NLF in the slightest. If a core purpose of an ability is to bypass resistances and immunaties to a specfic ability, then it is going to do just that."
Again,
in universe. In universe, Khorne is entirely immune to magic and its effects due to his unbridled rage. This includes magic from beings comparable to himself. It would still be NLF to say he's immune to all magic
period when in a battle with someone not from his franchise. It just means his resistance is incredibly good. In this case, we would similarly say that shadow magic is better at overcoming resistances to magic, not that it bypasses all resistances to magic
period. You cannot make such absolute statements outside the confines of a single fictional franchise. That's the point I'm getting at.
- "Which I am willing to bet it is, as an conceptual force of Grandfather Spider that forms the essence of reality, with it easily being able to reshape the threads of reality."
Similar question to before; why is Grandfather Spider superior? Khorne has resisted the powers of several other entities comparable to him who are also conceptual forces that make up fundamental parts of reality, and can create, change, and destroy it at will. The reality that Grandfather Spider controls does not seem to be more impressive. Does this mean these powers won't work on Khorne at all? No, because there's zero way to say that for certain. However, it means you need an extremely good reason to just say "it bypasses Khorne's resistances".
- "The big three exist to perfectly counterbalance each other, the mere fact of this keeps existence safe. They can stop each other's action via sheer force of will"
Doesn't the mere fact that Raven stopped Grandfather Spider in the first place disprove this as a completely literal statement? I'm genuinely curious, since she seemed to pretty objectively "defeat" him, not to mention
Bartleby's page uses him being able to destroy Raven as an AP justification.
- "Godly Regen or not, I don't see how it would be relevant if Khorne is stopped before anything happens. Is Khorne going to casually nuke the multiverse and the concept of light and order to make sure Raven can't come back."
Quite possibly? Chaos has the power to destroy creation, but what it really desires is to rule over the mortal realms, as it represents a great game. If that's not a problem in this fight, or if Khorne has genuine need to worry about an entity that is a threat to him, then I don't see what issues the god of bloodshed and slaughter would have pressing the nuke button if it was required to win.
- "Where did that even derive from? Her sealing is that she binded The Chaos Heart to the original 6 schools of magic, each chains of Magic which none of Spider's resistances/immunaties, nor his reason of counterbalancing her existence could stop."
Again, I'm not saying "nothing Raven has would work on Khorne at all", as that's a ludicrous statement to make in matches as vague as this. What I am saying is, without the reasoning of "it overrode Spider's resistances, so it'll automatically override Khorne", why is
this the most likely outcome? What makes this more likely than Khorne nuking everything to get rid of a legitimately dangerous enemy? What makes his resistances more likely to break before hers?
On top of that, do you have further context for this sealing? Did it just happen automatically or did Spider and Raven actually fight? This is
extremely important if the sealing itself is a major win condition, and I was under the assumption they actually battled before Spider was sealed away.
- "Grandfather Spider in that regard isn't a singular person either. He is the Shadow and Chaos that is molded across reality"
I was more under the assumption these things were created from him as opposed to literally being him, but if not, cool. Do you perhaps have anything that explains this a bit better, as a lot of info about him seems quite vague.
- "Most of it is banking on assumption that just because he stopped a few Chaos Gods that are "Similar to Raven/stronger than him" (Debatable in the first place) he can stop Raven herself."
No, it's banking on "greater evidence is needed due to the fact Khorne has fought against and affected other beings of his level". The entire point of the first post was that you need better evidence specifically because of the beings Khorne has fought, not that he can stomp Raven or something like that. This is compounded by the fact that, again, his survivability is actually superior, which is a major factor in fights like these.
- "For now, it seems Raven is far stronger to The Chaos Gods, and that's ignoring the fact that she can stat amp herself continiously."
1. I still have zero idea what you're basing this on going by what you've actually provided. Being endless compared to already countless universes is not far above the Realm of Chaos.
2. Khorne grows in power from conflict, and stat amping is one of the powers he'd actually be
likely to use. I don't see how that makes a difference, here.