Dowgrade Loid Forger (Spy x Family)

[Tie]

Old Calc:​

• Twilight shatters wood of a table: 9-B (95 KiloJoules)

Recalc:​

• Recalculation Loid Yorger punched table: 9-B (58.78 Kilojoules)

I did this because the old calc used compressive strength but my calc used shear strength which actually happened at the cross-section of the beam until the table was torn off.

 

[TioKill]

So I looked at the page, and I think Loid scales off Yor's feat, no? Or at least downscales from it.

 

[Kisaragi_Megumi]

Yeah he is, so i don't think he need to be downgraded

 

[Dalesean027]

yeah this is just a support feat really

 

[TioKill]

However, if the new calculation is more accurate, it should substitute the one on the profile and verse page.

 

[Kisaragi_Megumi]

However, if the new calculation is more accurate, it should substitute the one on the profile and verse page.

Don't have a problem with that, so yeah you can change the old one with the renewal version of it
Is the calc has been accepted, however?

 

[Mr_Sugabz]

However, if the new calculation is more accurate, it should substitute the one on the profile and verse page.

Should be

 

[Rendynoc0unter]

@Fikriskps

 

[TioKill]

Don't have a problem with that, so yeah you can change the old one with the renewal version of it
Is the calc has been accepted, however?

It was.
How many staffs does it take to approve a thread?

 

[Kisaragi_Megumi]

Getcha
One or two staffs should be enough to approve this thread, but just in case i'll call @KobsterHope07 , one of the more knowledgeable SxP supporter for double check

 

[KobsterHope07]

I’ve been summoned and I have no opinion since I’m no calc geek. Loid isn’t downgraded because he downscales from Mommy Assassin as stated in the profile.

Usually when there are multiple versions of a Calc based on a particular feat, we call Calc Group Members to pick and choose which one is correct. Since KLOL506 evaluated both calc, it would be nice to hear their opinion on which of the calc is appropriated.

 

[Tie]

Should I do something?

 

[Chariot190]

Tbh I don't like how he bloodied his own hand doing that
If it were me I'd do "At least [his feat], at most [70% yor's feat]" to compensate
But I also don't care enough to argue that

 

[KLOL506]

Seems fine at a glance as a replacement for the old calcs. The downscaling part can stay tho.