CRT Question

[Warren_Valion]

Now that CRTs are allowed back on the wiki. it brings up a good question that I always asked myself whenever making a CRT.

When is there enough acceptance or denial for the CRT to officially be accepted or denied?


I never know, and I feel like it should be an established thing if it isn't already.

Does anyone know?

 

[QuasiYuri]

From what I was able to experience, it's mainly case by case I would say.

Like if a CRT just has 6 people approve and nobody being against it then that's fine.

If you have 15 people agreeing and 15 disagreeing, numbers are pretty much irrelevant.

 

[Warren_Valion]

Obviously, it depends and is case-by-case, but when is it good enough, that is my real question. How do you decide what are the parameters for a specific case?

And what about staff members, are they required for a CRT, and if so, which types and how many?


I feel like it should all vary based on numerous factors.

-Size of the verse

-Severity of the revision

-Agree-to-Disagree ratio

-Etc


But whatever the case, I think this is something that should go beyond just a shoulder shrug and a, "It depends".

 

[Antoniofer]

If I was to compare, I would say that 2 out of 3 of the staff involved, whose number should be proportional to the "popularity" of the verse, should agree in order for the changes to be applied. But I'm only basing myself in real law.