[Chainsaw Man] Minor Asa addition

[Saqphire]

Asa should get Spatial Manipulation with her Weapon Creation

Why? Here are the scans with explanations but in short; she is stated to able to warp space to create weapons and has directly done so before in the Eternity Devil Arc

Would she have Infinite range via warping an endless space though? Maybe, that's up to yall.

Edit: Here are the raws for the space warp statements if that helps

Agree: Pearly0nsams (Infinite Range), Acertainbcplayer (Spatial Manipulation), VoidGoji (Spatial Manipulation), GodEarh026 (Infinite Range), GunshyFever, Apex_Predator_GX (Spatial Manipulation), M2u12
Disagree: Pearly0nsams (Spatial Manipulation)
Neutral: VoidGoji (Infinite Range), GodEarh026 (Spatial Manipulation), Apex_Predator_GX (Infinite Range)

 

[Pearly0nsams]

Range? Yea. Spatial hax? Nah.

 

[ElajRuengies]

Asa should get Spatial Manipulation with her Weapon Creation

Why? Here are the scans with explanations but in short; she is stated to able to warp space to create weapons and has directly done so before in the Eternity Devil Arc

Space can also mean a place or location, not just literal spacetime. Asa "owned" it by buying the aquarium thanks to how buildings can be bought. The Room 606 Sword is thanks to Asa percieving a space as her own.

Would she have Infinite range via warping an endless space though? Maybe, that's up to yall.

We don't know if it's actually Infinite, just that it's at least over a kilometer long given the stated length of 20 meters before stuff started repeating, the amount of money in each hallway, and the million yen they got in total.

 

[Saqphire]

Space can also mean a place or location, not just literal spacetime. Asa "owned" it by buying the aquarium thanks to how buildings can be bought. The Room 606 Sword is thanks to Asa percieving a space as her own.

That is very true tbh, it can be a place/location and also a immaterial space that contains material objects like the Room 606 Sword (it can be both or one of em). The raws I saw after making the CRT used Kuukan which meant literal space/airspace if that helps. I also put them in the OP now aswell

We don't know if it's actually Infinite, just that it's at least over a kilometer long given the stated length of 20 meters before stuff started repeating, the amount of money in each hallway, and the million yen they got in total.

I mean, that kinda would contradict how Eternity Devil functions by making a space that never ends if it was a total size of simply one kilometer, and the one million yen wouldn't really mean much since there can be an infinite amount of more yen in the spaces Denji didn't cover, just that he collected merely one million and went back to her.

I feel like it makes more sense if it's either just an infinitely regenerating space or an infinite sized space that that Asa would've had to warp which would mean she had to warp the metaphysical infinity of the space regardless (otherwise they wouldn't have been free from it) but the overall proposal for infinite range isn't something I fully agree with but still is a possible interpretation which is why I put it up anyway as a maybe option

Range? Yea. Spatial hax? Nah.

Added your vote on the tally

 

[Acertainbcplayer]

Asa turned not only the physical matter that is the structure itself, but the physical space which is the dimension itself that is containing the structure into her weapon (since that's would be the only logical way to explain why she could escape the pocket dimension), would be spatial manip regardless of the dimension being infinite or not.

Count my vote as yes for spatial manip via weapon creation, might change my opinion later.

 

[Saqphire]

Asa turned not only the physical matter that is the structure itself, but the physical space which is the dimension itself that is containing the structure into her weapon (since that's would be the only logical way to explain why she could escape the pocket dimension), would be spatial manip regardless of the dimension being infinite or not.

Count my vote as yes for spatial manip via weapon creation, might change my opinion later.

Adding your vote

 

[VoidGoji]

Agree with spatial hax, neutral on infinite range

 

[GodEarh206]

Agree Infinite range, neutral Space hax

 

[GunshyFever]

Agree with everything

 

[Saqphire]

Agree with spatial hax, neutral on infinite range

Agree with everything

Agree Infinite range, neutral Space hax

Added on op

 

[Arkenis]

Non mod votes don’t matter. Range wise doesn’t make sense and spatial seems unlikely even with the raw using kuukan. This may be a case of how her power works rather than her power working on space itself.

 

[Saqphire]

Non mod votes don’t matter. Range wise doesn’t make sense and spatial seems unlikely even with the raw using kuukan. This may be a case of how her power works rather than her power working on space itself.

Why do you believe so? Bump btw

 

[Arkenis]

Why do you believe so? Bump btw

Feels more like a way of speaking than specifically talking about space.

 

[Apex_Predator_GX]

Agree with spatial hax, neutral on infinite range

 

[M2u12]

I read Chainsaw Man up to this arc before I stopped reading it, so I should be able to give my opinion on this.

Even now, I’m still wondering why Asa doesn’t have Infinite/High Universal range, So I agree with this.

And for Spatial Manipulation, I don’t see any problem with it, so I agree with that as well.

 

[Saqphire]

Feels more like a way of speaking than specifically talking about space.

It makes more sense for it to be literal given the feat on the Eternity Devil; if she didn't warp the space itself then the weapon creation wouldn't work as she'd just warp the physical parts of it (that she sees) but still be trapped in it

Agree with spatial hax, neutral on infinite range

I read Chainsaw Man up to this arc before I stopped reading it, so I should be able to give my opinion on this.

Even now, I’m still wondering why Asa doesn’t have Infinite/High Universal range, So I agree with this.

And for Spatial Manipulation, I don’t see any problem with it, so I agree with that as well.

Added

 

[Arkenis]

It makes more sense for it to be literal given the feat on the Eternity Devil; if she didn't warp the space itself then the weapon creation wouldn't work as she'd just warp the physical parts of it (that she sees) but still be trapped in it

Doubt that's how it works. Just feels like reading into it's function than just a cool example of the power.

 

[Acertainbcplayer]

I feel like I should mention this. Asa tried to turn Aging's world into a weapon to escape and Yoru didn't refute the idea, but tried to confirm again that she can't use devil power inside that world instead.

This case is completely different than Eternity's case, where in Eternity's case you could argue that Asa didn't need to convert the dimension itself into the weapon but just the physical space, Aging's world is literally a completely separate world with it's own environment, light source and stuff. Of course this is iffy but again, I think this supports Asa having spatial hax.

 

[Ser_Hakim_Dayne]

Agree with both.