• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Chainsaw Man likely far higher replacement

1,014
587
Introduction
Currently, the God tiers of the Chainsaw Man verse have "far higher" within their stats. This is because of Pochita's multiple statements made by Makima during Chapter 84 "Hero Of Hell" which state that during his peak he was implied to be one who killed all the devils that are in Public Safety and simultaneously fought both 4 Horsemen & the Weapon Devils while in Hell, defeated devils that embodied concepts such as nuclear weapons, an in-universe volcano eruption and starlight that would break children's minds. Due to these feats which were off screen, we are unable to accurately give them a proper rating apart from "likely far higher", however the far higher can be replaced with an actual value, that being his statement of fighting a Devil who has the power of the concept of Nuclear Weapons.

Explanation
To understand what I am trying to present we have to go over the basics of Devil Physiology. All devils are born from a "name" - concepts derived from humanity fears that the devil embodies. These concepts can range anywhere from highly tangible such as guns & spiders to highly abstract such as control & violence. Devils can gain strength and boosts in the effectiveness of their abilities through fear. One core trait of devils that has been repeatedly stated throughout the series is that; the more feared the concept that the devil embodies, the more powerful they become. This doesn't just mean fearing the concept itself, fearing mental imagery related to the concept also counts. For example, a person may not fear a car by itself but fearing being run over and dying by a car would still count, and hence empower the Car Devil. As Devils embodying the fear of a concept, the more feared they are, the more powerful they become even a relatively minor boost in fear can immensely boost a devil's overall strength and effects of their abilities, Due to this once a Devil is more feared than another Devil, their AP and Speed surpasses that said Devil. For more information on Devils please visit the Devil Physiology page which goes over how Devils work & their abilities entirely, however I have listed what is necessary to know for this thread.

So If we are going to scale the Nuclear Weapons Devil we must gauge;
1. How feared they are
2. Compare them to their concept
3. Context of his defeat

1; When the Nuclear Weapons Devil was first mentioned by Makima, other Devil's that could potentially boost its power via its concept existed such as the WW2 Devil & the Nazi Devil meaning this took place back during the period of WW2 & the same period where these Devils would meet the end of their existence to the Chainsaw Devil whom is capable of erasing devils and the concepts they embody from existence across the past, present and from everyone's memories by fully consuming them. The War Devil themselves where at their prime before getting pieces of themselves eaten by the Chainsaw Devil. Support to the Nuclear Weapons Devils power is the War Devil whom is at their weakest & becoming even weaker via becoming a Fiend (whom are Devils who takes over a human corpses & are much weaker in both power and the effectiveness of their abilities) wanted Pochita to puke out the Nuclear Weapons Devil, showing that his power should be enough to make her stronger again.

2; Now that we can gauge how feared he is, how does he compare to his concept. Now lets use the Bat Devil as an example, he takes the physiology of a bat, but due to how feared he is, he is much larger & stronger than any bat alive. Being strong enough to create a City Block level+ level feat with his strongest attack, that alone is enough to grasp how stronger a Devil can be than their concept. Now since weve gone over how feared the Nuclear Weapons Devil was during that period, its only fair to say that he should completely outclass any Nuclear Weapons such as the Tsar Bomba which is the strongest man made bomb is history. Despite it not being created during WW2, it should be inferior to the Nuclear Weapons Devil since it shows how strong nuclear weapons can get, so hypothetically in his prime, he would be at least Mountain level (101.5 Megatons).

3; So now we know how strong he would be, but none of that matters if we don't know the actual context. Since its a statement we don't know how Pochita went about defeating these Devils, as he could erase other Devils before the Nuclear Weapons Devil, such as the WW2 Devil, weakening him. What what we do know is that Makima states that "All of these concepts once existed and were feared every bit as much as the Devils with their names", Makima also references what the Nazis did back in WW2, showing that what happened in the real world also happened in CSM, meaning every Devil would receive the same amount of empowerment by fear of their concepts back during those times. Makima expresses the Chainsaw Devils power by his abilities to manage to fight against these Devils and erase them from existence. But because it is just a statement and the scene is never actually shown, a possibly rating would be necessary.

Why possibly, we haven't seen it so why should we use it?
The premise of possibly is (Quoting from the Attack Potency page) "Should be used to list a statistic for a character with some basis, but inconclusive due to the justification being vague or non-definitive. The probability of the justification in question for being reliable should be notable, but mild. This term should be used sparingly." Basically if the justification or reasoning behind the statistic isn't definitive or fully proven, but the evidence suggests that the statistic is probably true but is vague. As since we don't actually see the feat occur via it being offscreen anything else could have occurred, but what we know points out to my premise.

Scaling
Now with everything else out of the way, we can get to who would scale to likely Mountain level (101.5 Megatons)
Primordial Devils; These devils have been described as "transcendent" compared normal devils and have never experienced death before due to their immerse power, as they possess names that are feared by nearly every human on the Planet, eg; Falling and Darkness. They have been stated to be far stronger than the likes of "some Gun Devil", a weakened Falling Devil with just her appearance on earth caused gravity fluctuations all around the globe causing nations to suffer from damage and become immensely poorer

The Chainsaw Devil; Is known as the devil that devils fears the most which puts him at a comparable level to the Primordial Devils and far above the Nuclear Weapons Devil, Makima considered a proper fight with Pochita "unwinnable" and needed to resort to heavily depowering him, simultaneously fought both 4 Horsemen & the Weapon Devils while in Hell one of the four horsemen being the Death Devil whom is the strongest Devil with the name most feared of all, Makima planned to use the Chainsaw Devil's power to erase her from existence. Defeated devils that embodied concepts such as nuclear weapons, an in-universe volcano eruption and starlight that would break children's minds showing his extreme superiority to the Nuclear Weapons Devil. (So regardless he should be far superior to the Nuclear Weapons Devil regardless of the context)

Makima: Makima is the Control Devil; (The devil that embodies the fear of loosing free will) her fear reaches a greater extent due to countries all around the world having fear for Makima and refused to stand in her way of bringing peace, due to this her AP would scale to this due to being able to draw blood from the Chainsaw Devil.

That's all
Agree: (0:0)

Disagree: (0:
2) @Giannysmag, @Lord_Farquaad69420

Neutral: (0:
0)
 
Last edited:
now point out how devils can be equal to, or even weaker than, the thing they embody
 
now point out how devils can be equal to, or even weaker than, the thing they embody
That's varying on how much the Devil is feared, like the Chicken Devil who is not feared at all to the point that he is weaker than a stray cat. But I don't think its relevant here since the Nuclear Weapons Devil at that time, should be fairly feared if not greatly, and the gap in strength should be much larger than the Bat Devil is to his own concept which is comparing (assuming Bats are like 9-C) to 8-B+ with the Bat Devils strongest attack
 
That's varying on how much the Devil is feared,
Indeed.
like the Chicken Devil who is not feared at all to the point that he is weaker than a stray cat.
That would be a case of a Devil being demonstrably below what it embodies.
But I don't think it's relevant here since the Nuclear Weapons Devil at that time, should be fairly feared if not greatly,
Keyword, should, not is.
You need to prove how feared they are with a statement or something. Like a Nuke Devil in the Cold War or the 40/50s, probably is above nuke lv, it would also mog the **** out of a Modern Day Nuke Devil where the populace has become desensitized or no longer overtly concerned with them to a large degree, even treating them like "yeah whatever".
and the gap in strength should be much larger than the Bat Devil is to his own concept which is comparing (assuming Bats are like 9-C) to 8-B+ with the Bat Devils strongest attack
Why? Bats aren't an uncommon phobia, they can also have diseases, causing greater paranoia and fear of them in some places too, and are far, far, more common place than nukes, thus, often in various group's thoughts first and foremost, compared to a nuke.

Like a hypothetical "spider devil" would be ******* shredded and high key a god tier, despite spiders being 10-C, solely due to Arachnophobia, in much the same way as something as mundane as "darkness", is a god tier, solely due to it being a common and deeply ingrained fear.

I really don't like this. The whole CRT is based on multiple "maybes", and not "is".

Literal best I can see you getting is a "possibly" ngl.
 
Keyword, should, not is.
You need to prove how feared they are with a statement or something. Like a Nuke Devil in the Cold War or the 40/50s, probably is above nuke lv, it would also mog the **** out of a Modern Day Nuke Devil where the populace has become desensitized or no longer overtly concerned with them to a large degree, even treating them like "yeah whatever".
Fair
Why? Bats aren't an uncommon phobia, they can also have diseases, causing greater paranoia and fear of them in some places too, and are far, far, more common place than nukes, thus, often in various group's thoughts first and foremost, compared to a nuke.

Like a hypothetical "spider devil" would be ******* shredded and high key a god tier, despite spiders being 10-C, solely due to Arachnophobia, in much the same way as something as mundane as "darkness", is a god tier, solely due to it being a common and deeply ingrained fear.
We do already have a Spider Devil, it shows no feats on a level comparable to Denji & just as easily gets folded by the Darkness Devil, but yet again something could have happened to its fear in CSM, we just don't know yet. But my point being, due to the points in the OP the Nuclear Weapons Devil in its prime due to how feared it was, should be superior its concept & the strongest nuclear weapon (the Tsar Bomb) should gauge how strong he likely was.
 
Instead of arguing this you should just argue that the KE of the gun devil should be used as a possible rating. Chariot has very good point about how Devils in the Chainsawman verse work and it's very clearly not always 1 to 1 even if Nuclear weapons is implied to be equal.
 
Fair

We do already have a Spider Devil, it shows no feats on a level comparable to Denji & just as easily gets folded by the Darkness Devil, but yet again something could have happened to its fear in CSM, we just don't know yet.
Man you get my point, the falling devil then given a fall literally can't exceed 9-B if it ain't from orbit, yet it has a High 6-A ass feat.
But my point being, due to the points in the OP the Nuclear Weapons Devil in its prime due to how feared it was, should be superior its concept & the strongest nuclear weapon (the Tsar Bomb) should gauge how strong he likely was.
Your points are conjecture. Like yeah it could be true, but it might not be. We don't even know when Pochita fought it, that alone makes this whole fiasco inherently unquantifable.

Under absolutely no circumstances can we put a solid flat rating based on extrapolation or conjecture, at best, you'd be arguing for a "possibly",
even then, like this
When the Nuclear Weapons Devil was first mentioned by Makima, other Devil's that could potentially boost its power via its concept existed such as the WW2 Devil & the Nazi Devil meaning this took place back during the period of WW2 & the same period where these Devils would meet the end of their existence to the Chainsaw Devil whom is capable of erasing devils and the concepts they embody from existence across the past, present and from everyone's memories by fully consuming them."
This has absolutely nothing to do with the Nuke Devil, she just mentioned they once existed, and that they were as feared as the devils with their name.

This, means nothing though, how feared were they? How feared were the devils? She doesn't say. Like a WW2 Devil 30y after WW2 wouldn't be feared at all, given WW2 isn't feared at all anymore.
And she listing them, doesn't dictate a timeline, we simply don't know when they were eaten, which is critically important.

She doesn't say that at all, nowhere does she say she was at her prime when they fought, only that she's gotten weaker.

Even worse, she flat-out says she killed him numerous times, and the only reason she lost, was because he straight up wouldn't stay dead and he began eating bits of her, snowballing into her loss. He didn't overpower her or anything.

Aka, he wouldn't even scale to her concretely, him winning was nuanced, and we know in the past she could flat-out kill him, a lot. Also sheds doubt on the other devils, how do we know he even scales? He could've died a million times and got ohko'd every time by the Nuke Devil, and win solely due to a battle of attrition.
Support to the Nuclear Weapons Devils power is the War Devil whom is at their weakest & becoming even weaker via becoming a Fiend (whom are Devils who takes over a human corpses & are much weaker in both power and the effectiveness of their abilities) wanted Pochita to puke out the Nuclear Weapons Devil, showing that his power should be enough to make her stronger again.
Well, yeah, I'm sure it would make her stronger, especially if she's at her worst.
This, doesn't effect anything though, doesn't tell us if it's above or below nukes in the modern day, or if they even scale given she might just blow him the **** out if she had it.

That's just point 1 of the op, we need more proof, like we have pieces, but not the details, or how they relate, which we need to know.
 
Instead of arguing this you should just argue that the KE of the gun devil should be used as a possible rating. Chariot has very good point about how Devils in the Chainsawman verse work and it's very clearly not always 1 to 1 even if Nuclear weapons is implied to be equal.
that's bad, just use the blatant on screen falling devil feat if ya want an upgrade, at least we KNOW that happened and see it happen
 
I'll attempt the strengthen the OP with more evidence later tomorrow, however I do agree that it's better to argue for a "possibly" than "likely" rating which I will also adjust.
 
that's bad, just use the blatant on screen falling devil feat if ya want an upgrade, at least we KNOW that happened and see it happen
But the feat is just blatantly hax based and would only scale to her gravity manipulation. You yourself stated that Chainsawman doesn't qualify for a universal energy system and there are examples of that being the case in the verse itself.
 
I'll attempt the strengthen the OP with more evidence later tomorrow, however I do agree that it's better to argue for a "possibly" than "likely" rating which I will also adjust.
Man, just like, post a scan

1. The Nuke Devil is as strong, or stronger, than Nukes.
2. When Pochita fought him as timeframe would effect how feared it was.
3. If he was notably feared at the time even then given CSM uni is diff, like a Nuke Devil would be less feared if WW2 Devil didn't exist anymore.
4. That Pochita even scales and wasn't blown the **** out given we know from the War Devil, that Pochita winning, doesn't mean he was stronger or wasn't curbed a fucktillion times. Alternatively, a statement.

You need to prove all of these.
You can justify it all you want, but in the end, it's just guesswork.
But the feat is just blatantly hax based and would only scale to her gravity manipulation. You yourself stated that Chainsawman doesn't qualify for a universal energy system and there are examples of that being the case in the verse itself.
then pray they whip out a new better feat
 
As much as I like to imagine a Nuclear Weapons Devil running around throwing nuke-level attacks, we know far to little to properly gauge its strength and how it scales to Pochita.

The Devil itself could be a glass cannon for all we know, and it would be strange for a demon whose concept is not so feared anymore to be more powerful than other demons that embody "less destructive" concepts but are actually far more feared.

The top tiers of CM simply don't have enough feats to justify that they could more powerful than the strongest nuclear bomb.
 
Damn that late?
Yep
0075-012.png
 
Man, just like, post a scan

1. The Nuke Devil is as strong, or stronger, than Nukes.
2. When Pochita fought him as timeframe would effect how feared it was.
3. If he was notably feared at the time even then given CSM uni is diff, like a Nuke Devil would be less feared if WW2 Devil didn't exist anymore.
4. That Pochita even scales and wasn't blown the **** out given we know from the War Devil, that Pochita winning, doesn't mean he was stronger or wasn't curbed a fucktillion times. Alternatively, a statement.

You need to prove all of these.
You can justify it all you want, but in the end, it's just guesswork.
Starting with this
The Nuke Devil is as strong, or stronger, than Nukes.
Again, there is not much to go about this regarding that we only have a few statements of the Nuclear Weapon Devils existence, but we have to work with what he has.
Your points are conjecture. Like yeah it could be true, but it might not be. We don't even know when Pochita fought it, that alone makes this whole fiasco inherently unquantifiable.
This is true, but due to statements we already know that Pochita would be superior to the likes of the Nuclear Weapons Devil. We even have the Chainsaw Devil comparable to Primordial Devils on this wiki, those who transcend regular Devil's like the Nuclear Weapons Devil, the justification is also in the OP.
The Chainsaw Devil; Is known as the devil that devils fears the most which puts him at a comparable level to the Primordial Devils and far above the Nuclear Weapons Devil, Makima considered a proper fight with Pochita "unwinnable" and needed to resort to heavily depowering him, simultaneously fought both 4 Horsemen & the Weapon Devils while in Hell one of the four horsemen being the Death Devil whom is the strongest Devil with the name most feared of all, Makima planned to use the Chainsaw Devil's power to erase her from existence. Defeated devils that embodied concepts such as nuclear weapons, an in-universe volcano eruption and starlight that would break children's minds showing his extreme superiority to the Nuclear Weapons Devil. (So regardless he should be far superior to the Nuclear Weapons Devil regardless of the context)
Under absolutely no circumstances can we put a solid flat rating based on extrapolation or conjecture, at best, you'd be arguing for a "possibly",
even then, like this
I agree with this one
This has absolutely nothing to do with the Nuke Devil, she just mentioned they once existed, and that they were as feared as the devils with their name.

This, means nothing though, how feared were they? How feared were the devils? She doesn't say. Like a WW2 Devil 30y after WW2 wouldn't be feared at all, given WW2 isn't feared at all anymore.
And she listing them, doesn't dictate a timeline, we simply don't know when they were eaten, which is critically important.
We are aware that other Devil's help empower each other based on their concept & how their fear correlates. An example of this is Yoru (The War Devil) wanting the Chainsaw Devil to puke out the Nuclear Weapons Devil, this is because the once erased nuclear warfare would return, causing Yoru to get stronger via empowerment from the fear of nuclear warfare. This is why I brought up the existence of the WW2 Devil & the Nazi Devil since if they existed during the period of WW2 they would have been extremely feared. The fear of nuclear warfare during those times would also be high due to Hiroshima & Nagasaki atomic bombings. Again tho, like you said, we have no idea how Pochita went about defeating these Devils, but we do know that he is stronger than them.
She doesn't say that at all, nowhere does she say she was at her prime when they fought, only that she's gotten weaker.
True
Even worse, she flat-out says she killed him numerous times, and the only reason she lost, was because he straight up wouldn't stay dead and he began eating bits of her, snowballing into her loss. He didn't overpower her or anything.

Aka, he wouldn't even scale to her concretely, him winning was nuanced, and we know in the past she could flat-out kill him, a lot. Also sheds doubt on the other devils, how do we know he even scales? He could've died a million times and got ohko'd every time by the Nuke Devil, and win solely due to a battle of attrition.
The fact is we don't even know how Yoru went about killing Pochita. Yes we do know that she killed him multiple times, but he was quite literally fighting all the four Horsemen (that Including the Death Devil whom is the strongest Devil in the verse) & all 7 of the Weapon Devils simultaneously. We know she was getting help from multiple other Horsemen & the Weapon Devils, that alone tells us that she probably would not win a 1 on 1 confrontation with him.
Well, yeah, I'm sure it would make her stronger, especially if she's at her worst.
This, doesn't effect anything though, doesn't tell us if it's above or below nukes in the modern day, or if they even scale given she might just blow him the **** out if she had it.

That's just point 1 of the op, we need more proof, like we have pieces, but not the details, or how they relate, which we need to know.
This is fair because that statement alone shouldn't be enough evidence by itself, but regarding the points above, during WW2 the Nuclear Weapons Devil should be feared enough to make him superior to his concept.
2. When Pochita fought him as timeframe would effect how feared it was.
This is what we don't know, but as I've went over above he should be superior to it.
3. If he was notably feared at the time even then given CSM uni is diff, like a Nuke Devil would be less feared if WW2 Devil didn't exist anymore.
This is also very true, that's why I gauged how strong he would be during WW2. This way since we know that Pochita is superior, we could scale him off the Nuclear Weapons Devils hypothetical prime
4. That Pochita even scales and wasn't blown the **** out given we know from the War Devil, that Pochita winning, doesn't mean he was stronger or wasn't curbed a fucktillion times. Alternatively, a statement.
We went over this above, so that query should be solved
You need to prove all of these.
You can justify it all you want, but in the end, it's just guesswork.
Hopefully I did, it may seem like guesswork but the pieces add up imo

Now moving on to non Chariot queries
Stronger than the nuke or the explosion of the nuke

Think about that
You can use the Gun Devil to answer this question. It is stronger than a gun & stronger than the firepower of a gun.
As much as I like to imagine a Nuclear Weapons Devil running around throwing nuke-level attacks, we know far to little to properly gauge its strength and how it scales to Pochita.

The Devil itself could be a glass cannon for all we know
and it would be strange for a demon whose concept is not so feared anymore to be more powerful than other demons that embody "less destructive" concepts but are actually far more feared.

The top tiers of CM simply don't have enough feats to justify that they could more powerful than the strongest nuclear bomb
Not really, I don't believe Devil's in general can be glass cannons because how much they are feared affects their physical stats like strength, dura, speed etc...
As Devils embodying the fear of a concept, the more feared they are, the more powerful they become even a relatively minor boost in fear can immensely boost a devil's overall strength and effects of their abilities, Due to this once a Devil is more feared than another Devil, their AP and Speed surpasses that said Devil
Feats wise, we have Primordial Devil's whom Pochita is comparable to performing High 6-A feats while weakened. That shows that the top tiers have potential to be or already are stronger than the strongest nuclear weapons, even if it doesn't scale to them physically it shows the gap between regular Devils & Primordial Devils. This is also why I'm arguing for a "possibly" rating

I will change up to OP for a possibly rating in a moment
 
Again, there is not much to go about this regarding that we only have a few statements of the Nuclear Weapon Devils existence, but we have to work with what he has.
Literally the issue, we don't know shit. If we don't know, let's not pretend we do.
We don't have to work with anything.
This is true, but due to statements we already know that Pochita would be superior to the likes of the Nuclear Weapons Devil.
We know he beat them, we don't know how.
We even have the Chainsaw Devil comparable to Primordial Devils on this wiki, those who transcend regular Devil's like the Nuclear Weapons Devil, the justification is also in the OP.
We don't even know how strong the Nuke Devil is in the first place, this means nothing.
The Chainsaw Devil; Is known as the devil that devils fears the most which puts him at a comparable level to the Primordial Devils and far above the Nuclear Weapons Devil,
That's kinda bad, he's feared because he can literally delete them from existence, it has nothing to do with power or strength, but the fact if he gets ya, ya cooked. like that's quite literally what the scan is saying.
Makima considered a proper fight with Pochita "unwinnable" and needed to resort to heavily depowering him,
This is true, but has no evidence that he's above the Nuke Devil here, or that she is, let alone a prime Nuke Devil. qk
I'm like 99% sure that fight ended with him dipping, and he's immortal, he could have died 100 times for all we know. All we know is that they fought, what that entails, who knows, at the least we know his ass didn't win, a vague fight that could've been him just getting ganked, ain't good evidence. Hell maybe the Death Devil showed up and curbed his ass and that's why he dipped?
There's way to many unknowns.
Makima planned to use the Chainsaw Devil's power to erase her from existence.
Via weird conceptual EE eating hax yes.
Defeated devils that embodied concepts such as nuclear weapons, an in-universe volcano eruption and starlight that would break children's minds showing his extreme superiority to the Nuclear Weapons Devil. (So regardless he should be far superior to the Nuclear Weapons Devil regardless of the context)
No, this is LITERALLY what we're arguing about. How did he win? Was he killed a fucktillion times doing it? When did it take place? How strong was the Nuke Devil at the time? Was it before or after various other devils got eaten? There's so many unknowns that affect this, that even attempting to use it, is a self-fulfilling argument.
We are aware that other Devil's help empower each other based on their concept & how their fear correlates.
Exactly, another x-factor that we don't know that complicates scaling, was the WW2 Devil eaten before or after the Nuke Devil? Etc.
An example of this is Yoru (The War Devil) wanting the Chainsaw Devil to puke out the Nuclear Weapons Devil, this is because the once erased nuclear warfare would return, causing Yoru to get stronger via empowerment from the fear of nuclear warfare.
That isn't what the scans says.
You're extrapolating here.

This, also literally doesn't mean anything, she's weak, extremely weak here. ANY facet of her that was eaten, would power her back up, and like, yea I'm sure the Nuke Devil would go a way into making her not complete fodder. But this again doesn't tell us anything we actually need to know beyond
"her getting back a part of her power, would give her back some power", which yeah?
This is why I brought up the existence of the WW2 Devil & the Nazi Devil since if they existed during the period of WW2 they would have been extremely feared.
"If".
This is the issue dude, EVERYTHING is "if", "maybe", "could", but never "is".
For all we know Pochita ate them in the 90s when that stuff was desensitized to hell and back.

If we don't know, it isn't an argument.
The fear of nuclear warfare during those times would also be high due to Hiroshima & Nagasaki atomic bombings.
Yeah, maybe. unfortunately, we have no idea when Pochita fought it, how the fight went, how it functions, or anything of the sort.
Hell maybe Pochita ate it a week before it met Denji, we don't know.
Again tho, like you said, we have no idea how Pochita went about defeating these Devils, but we do know that he is stronger than them.
No, we don't. They never say "Pochita is, physically, stronger than [list of dudes]", hell his fear seems to come from his hax and unkillability, enabling him to beat any devil eventually.
Hell, the fact the War Devil literally only lost because of a nuanced snowball effect where she killed him a bunch and again and again and he kept coming back and slowly ate facets of her, weakening her down until she was beatable, says a lot. And is also 100% objective proof he doesn't scale concretely to a lot of these things without evidence.
The fact is we don't even know how Yoru went about killing Pochita. Yes we do know that she killed him multiple times, but he was quite literally fighting all the four Horsemen (that Including the Death Devil whom is the strongest Devil in the verse) & all 7 of the Weapon Devils simultaneously. We know she was getting help from multiple other Horsemen & the Weapon Devils, that alone tells us that she probably would not win a 1 on 1 confrontation with him.
This is conjecture.
She killed him, lots, and we know how she went about killing him, via war shit.
Also she says "I killed him", her killing him a bunch, was on her, because she states it was. The Deat Devil didn't roll up and kill if that's what ya getting at, she says "no matter how many times I killed him".

Also, do we even know if that's the same fight? also it sounds like Pochita got his ass kicked given it's what lead to him meeting Denji and being half dead if I'm not wrong?

Finally, Death Devil in that very panel is stated strongest, it's > Pochita.

Yeah nah, this is mostly extrapolation, and doesn't tell us how strong the Nuke Devil was.
This is fair because that statement alone shouldn't be enough evidence by itself, but regarding the points above, during WW2 the Nuclear Weapons Devil should be feared enough to make him superior to his concept.
So? When did Pochita fight him? Secondly, the strongest nukes weren't common knowledge in WW2. Like we know nowadays but back then? Which is another problem, was he eaten before or after the big boys were invented and became known?
Nuh uh.
This is what we don't know, but as I've went over above he should be superior to it.
Except the very reasons you give, still don't justify anything, because the timeframe affects if THEY'RE stronger than it too.
We don't know, you're just guessing and ASSUMING it has to be the case.
This is also very true, that's why I gauged how strong he would be during WW2. This way since we know that Pochita is superior, we could scale him off the Nuclear Weapons Devils hypothetical prime
No. How do we know, say, Makima, is stronger than a Nuke Devil at its peak? We don't, they don't state that anywhere.
For all we know the Nuke Devil could blow the **** outta Makima back in the 50s.

We went over this above, so that query should be solved
It isn't.
Hopefully I did, it may seem like guesswork but the pieces add up imo

Now moving on to non Chariot queries
It got even worse dog...

You're now assuming they all scale off a peak hypothetical Nuke Devil, when we don't know if they even do, because, again, we don't know the timeframe for any of this. Except when they fought Pochita, which would be well after the hypothetical Nuke Devil prime.
Coupled that with us not even knowing how the fight went, if it's a glass cannon, if pochita died a million times, and a billion other unknowns.
You can use the Gun Devil to answer this question. It is stronger than a gun & stronger than the firepower of a gun.
Guns also way, way, more commonplace than nukes, like goddamn I own a gun.
Not really, I don't believe Devil's in general can be glass cannons because how much they are feared affects their physical stats like strength, dura, speed etc...
You don't believe? But is that a fact?
And whatever the case, it's 100% not linear or 1:1 relative among stats.
If it was the Gun Devil's attack speed would be like MFTL+ or some shit given it's AP is like 8-A/7-C.
Feats wise, we have Primordial Devil's whom Pochita is comparable to performing High 6-A feats while weakened. That shows that the top tiers have potential to be or already are stronger than the strongest nuclear weapons, even if it doesn't scale to them physically it shows the gap between regular Devils & Primordial Devils. This is also why I'm arguing for a "possibly" rating
The existence of higher feats, doesn't justify conjecture feats.
Pochita next chapter could kick the moon in half, it wouldn't make the Nuke Devil any less vague, unknown, and conjecture-based.
 
Already said this before, but there's an Mountain's eruption Devil, eruption tend to be 7-B to 6-C iirc. There's a nuke devil, the biggest at the time was Tsar Bomb a yield of 58mt, CSM killed those. Then there's GD ke.

How is tier 7-B not yet been accepted?
 
This is needless skepticism, we know how he fights, we know what he does, we know the devils all fear him. Why imply the way he did beat them wasn't done through power?
No, it isn't needless. We already know from the War Devil, she beat his ass and killed him a bunch. He won not through power, but nuance.
If that was the case for her, it sets precedence, and given we know LITERALLY nothing on how he did it, yeah nuh uh, it's completely guesswork in a verse that has established he can, and has, beat dudes who can blow him the **** out and simply won due to his nature.
we know what he does, we know the devils all fear him
Yeah and it ain't because he's the strongest.

If we do not know, let's stop acting like we do.
 
Already said this before, but there's an Mountain's eruption Devil, eruption tend to be 7-B to 6-C iirc.
Tend to be, not always, this very line shows there's a huge gap in just the usual. We also don't know how feared it was at the time, how he won, etc.
There's a nuke devil, the biggest at the time was Tsar Bomb a yield of 58mt, CSM killed those.
of all time, maybe he fought it before that was invented or common knowledge? how did he beat it anyway? maybe he fought it when nuke stigma and paranoia ceased? We don't know.
Then there's GD ke.
KE rules say no.
How is tier 7-B not yet been accepted?
Unknown and vague and could be anywhere from 8-A to like 6-C, unknown and vague with a bunch of caveats, bordering on breaking KE rules without any actual corroboration given the support is "idk maybe?".

Basing your upgrade on a thing, where you need like, a dozen unknown factors to be a specific way and multiple assumptions based off that, that in turn only work if a few assumptions and unknown factors fall in place, in a very specific way. Is like the last thing ya want for your verse upgrade CRT.

Just wait till the manga gives more info man. Kinda jumping the gun here.
 
Most of these are fair, I do disagree with some of your points but I don't think its worth mentioning them since that's not the point of this CRT. But I'm bought, might as well actually wait for more info on these Devils. As a resort I'm wondering if an NPES would work for the verse tho, since I find it weird that a mid tier can generate Low 7-B levels of energy, & DD as well as Makima are inferior to that with their telekinetic attacks (given the fact that the Typhoon Devil is completely inferior to them)
 
Back
Top