This trait matters less since Miwa is outranged by Brain, so she'd have to get into his distance first
Brain has the skill advantage here, Miwa doesn't have much going for her in that regard as opposed to Brain's gifted intellegence due to his genius class
Uh, Cocytus literally has a skill that negates melee weapons which Shalltear doesn't have, also that's a bad argument since the anime shows Cocytus attacking through Brain's attack and the light novel stating the attack never even reached him. So there's no reason why an attack that could slightly harm someone a hundred thousand times stronger than him couldn't do at bare minimum decent damage against someone who is only 40x.
Brain has the better range, which is
I meant at which distance from each other do they start the fight..... but ok ig
SBA means they start at the distance of whatever the highest range of either fighter is, which as I said is 3 meters
She can literally stand there and let Brain wail on her until he gets tired and there wouldn't be a scratch on her or her clothes. From Brain's value to the baseline of 8-C, Miwa can at bare minimum one-shot Brain 4. Times. Over.
Classes mean nothing, it's feats that matter.
Same difference, cause equipment damage was a thing in Yggdrasil, aka Cocytus' swords are relative to him and just went through the attack.
I mean, Brain's own page lists him as smarter than Miwa. I just said his class because it's the reason why he's able to break his limits over and over again.
Actually, no it's not. Cocytus's attack power when it comes to physicals surpasses that of Shalltear's defense by a noticeable margin plus the weapon he was using was his strongest blade which would naturally be far more durable than Shalltear's fingernail. Also, Cocytus didn't clash with Brain, the katana was unharmed and Cocytus took it for himself. So yeah, I don't know what your argument is when Brain's attack never even interacted with Cocytus nor his equipment.
Even if we were to assume that her nails are the weakest part of her entire body, that doesn't change the absolutely massive gap that's in place with the nails needing to be well over a hundred thousand times weaker than her normal durability for her to be harmed by Brain and for the amps to not be enough to seriously harm Miwa
No, his main advantages is better range, strength and speed amps to his attacks, and the ability to attack multiple times in a single moveI thought for a sec Brains Resistances were part of his abilities
Miwa's AP > Brain's strength amps (as we don't know how much it amps him). He can't harm her at all, even with the Speed amps with won't do any good.
Don't trust single word descriptors like that
1. Cocytus has natural armor with max shit put into it, AKA, his glass cannon defenses are light-years above Shalltear's nails, AKA they might as well not even be Low 7-C.
This is obviously going to go in circles, but even then, Low 7-C isn't on Brain's profile, and it'd have to be there for this to matter at all. And Brain's profile needs a ******' rework WAAAAAAAY more than it needs an attack that is EXTREMELY debatably Low 7-C, at Low 7-C.
Brain's strength amps are able to barley harm a character that is low 7-C with a lesser version of his strongest move, without any contradictions to lessen it (Still don't know why you'd compare Cocytus' strongest weapons to a fingernail) that should at bare minimum allow him to do decent damage to her.
While she can amp herself, that's not only more situational, but would also still be below Brain's amp since Miwa would need a smaller amp in order to harm 15 finger Sukuna, which is something that is just not happening (15 finger Sukuna upscales from 2.95 kilotons vs Miwa's baseline 0.25 tons as opposed to Brain's 128 megajoules vs Shalltear upscaling from 1.47 kilotons).
I mean fair enough but scaling to Gazef in skill is more than what Miwa has
I don't know what your point is for the first one, considering you just said Cocytus being able to tank a stronger version was the anti-feat that prevented Brain's attack from being Low 7-C, but now you are saying that Cocytus' armor is massively above Shalltear's nails which effectively makes that entire argument moot.
I do agree that Brain needs a rework but if we are going purely by profiles alone, he is listed with an attack capable of harming a Low 7-C. Hell I'm not even trying to argue that Brain's attack is Low 7-C, only that it's able to do decent damage to a baseline 8-C. Plus if we want to go down that route for 'rules as written' then Brain can be put on Miwa's level with it since the 'Higher' could allow him to be put near baseline 8-C since both of the tiers are right next to each other.
