- 244
- 69
Size of Clover Kingdom
vsbattles.fandom.com
Why is this calc for the size of the Clover Kingdom not being currently used? It seems pretty simple and I'm really not seeing any problem with it.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Black clover- Clover Kingdom Size
- Thread starter Azevedo128
- Start date
vsbattles.fandom.com
Why is this calc for the size of the Clover Kingdom not being currently used? It seems pretty simple and I'm really not seeing any problem with it.
Theendzero13
He/Him- 2,786
- 1,328
I actually don't ?
maybe because it came from anime canon and not from the manga or because the context makes the statement a little iffy?
You should ask epsilon and dragongamerz913 about it though
maybe because it came from anime canon and not from the manga or because the context makes the statement a little iffy?
You should ask epsilon and dragongamerz913 about it though
- 10,086
- 8,217
Simply because the method is bad.
You assume that Asta will just run in a straight line without any kind of curved
Assume that Asta will run at a constant speed without changing for a single second and that he will run at the speed of a runner the whole time
Assume that what Noelle said was accurate like a GPS
Assumes an FTL character will run at human speed
You assume that Asta will just run in a straight line without any kind of curved
Assume that Asta will run at a constant speed without changing for a single second and that he will run at the speed of a runner the whole time
Assume that what Noelle said was accurate like a GPS
Assumes an FTL character will run at human speed
- 244
- 69
- Thread starter
- #4
Most of the variables you mentioned would make the number go up and the only meaningful criticism can be countered by the fact that most of the images of the Clover Kingdom show it to be pretty flat so there's no reason to have many curves in the road.
- 244
- 69
- Thread starter
- #5
Bump
- 1,822
- 2,009
It uses a timeframe from a filler episode, even if it's anime canon, it doesn't hold any basis for the manga. It also assumes that Asta will have an average human running speed and if you argued that Asta only has FTL reactions/combat speed and can fight at that level with Average Human travel speed, it would be heavily inconsistent with the rest of the manga. It's inconsistent even in that anime canon episode as the next scene shows Asta running fast enough to form a dust cloud behind him.
Also, Noelle doesn't say it would take days for Asta to run there, she asks "How many days would that take?" in a reply to Asta saying that he could run there during a gag scene.
Also, Noelle doesn't say it would take days for Asta to run there, she asks "How many days would that take?" in a reply to Asta saying that he could run there during a gag scene.
- 244
- 69
- Thread starter
- #7
-It uses a timeframe from a filler episode, even if it's anime canon, it doesn't hold any basis for the manga.
The fillers were all supervised by Tabata.
-It also assumes that Asta will have an average human running speed and if you argued that Asta only has FTL reactions/combat speed and can fight at that level with Average Human travel speed, it would be heavily inconsistent with the rest of the manga. It's inconsistent even in that anime canon episode as the next scene shows Asta running fast enough to form a dust cloud behind him.
That would only make the size of the kingdom bigger so arguing that as a problem with the answer being the current calc where the kingdom is far smaller doesn't make sense. Also even if Noelle was really wrong about Asta's speed her guess should probably still apply to the average person who should still be faster and stronger than normal humans.
-Also, Noelle doesn't say it would take days for Asta to run there, she asks "How many days would that take?" in a reply to Asta saying that he could run there during a gag scene.
I don't understand how that makes a difference.
The fillers were all supervised by Tabata.
-It also assumes that Asta will have an average human running speed and if you argued that Asta only has FTL reactions/combat speed and can fight at that level with Average Human travel speed, it would be heavily inconsistent with the rest of the manga. It's inconsistent even in that anime canon episode as the next scene shows Asta running fast enough to form a dust cloud behind him.
That would only make the size of the kingdom bigger so arguing that as a problem with the answer being the current calc where the kingdom is far smaller doesn't make sense. Also even if Noelle was really wrong about Asta's speed her guess should probably still apply to the average person who should still be faster and stronger than normal humans.
-Also, Noelle doesn't say it would take days for Asta to run there, she asks "How many days would that take?" in a reply to Asta saying that he could run there during a gag scene.
I don't understand how that makes a difference.
- 1,822
- 2,009
That doesn't mean he directly wrote the episodes, they're applicable to the anime's canon only if they're not in the manga then they're irrelevant to that continuity.
Hell, one of these episodes "supervised" by Tabata had Leopold using mana method runes 20+ episodes before he even sets foot in Heart Kingdom
1. That wasn't my argument at all "it would be heavily inconsistent with the rest of the manga. It's inconsistent even in that anime canon episode as the next scene shows Asta running fast enough to form a dust cloud behind him."
2. Calculations are not accepted based on how much they inflate a verse
3. Anyone can travel from one end to the other of a country, we don't calculate the length of China based on someone travelling from one end to the other in 30 days, and if we did find their average speed throughout the whole journey then it would be calculated based on how long it actually takes them not based on average human running speed (using average human running speeds and applying them over a long distance journey is not a good idea mathematically)
4. People in Black Clover use brooms to travel and don't really flex their running speeds so idk what you mean by "her guess should probably still apply to the average person who should still be faster and stronger than normal humans"
Two characters having a gag argument in an anime filler episode, the credibility is already diminished
Last edited:
- 1,822
- 2,009
The current Clover Kingdom calc actually uses a statement from the manga rather than a statement from a gag argument in a filler episode with questionable canonicity and credibility
Similar threads
